Patterns of leaf colonization by Chironomidae were compared on three leaf substrates differing in rate of processing and palatability for detritivores. Each leaf species was colonized by a similar number of taxa, with Orthocladiinae and Tanytarsini comprising the dominant groups. However, the chironomid assemblage, categorized by functional feeding groups, differed greatly between the three leaf types. Black cherry leaves supported a much higher proportion of shredders (e.g. Brillia flavifrons) than either red maple or American beech packs. In contrast, beech and maple leaf packs were colonized by distinctly higher proportions of gathering-collectors (e.g. Corynoneura spp., Parametriocnemus sp., Stilocladius spp., Constempellina spp., Micropsectra spp.). Overall, the cherry packs supported a significantly higher shredder and gathering-collector biomass per g leaf pack than either the maple or beech leaves. We conclude that (1) shredders were preferentially associated with cherry leaf packs due to its higher palatability compared to the maple and beech leaves, and (2) similar colonization patterns exhibited by gathering-collectors on all three leaf species were the result of a supply of similar-quality fine detritus.