Skip to main content Accessibility help

Responses to selection for lean growth in sheep

  • G. Simm (a1), R.M. Lewis (a1), B. Grundy (a1) and W.S. Dingwall (a1)


This paper reports the selection responses achieved, and related results, following 9 years of index selection for lean growth in Suffolk sheep. The breeding goal of the index used comprised carcass lean weight and carcass fat weight at a constant age, with relative economic values of + 3 and –1 per kg. The selection criteria were live weight (LWT), ultrasonic fat depth (UFD) and ultrasonic muscle depth (UMD) adjusted to a constant age of 150 days. By year 9, responses in LWT, UFD and UMD in both sexes, as judged by the divergence between selection and control line performance, amounted to 4·88 kg, -1·1 mm and 2·8 mm respectively; these responses are between 7 and 15% of the overall means of the traits concerned. Although selection was originally on index scores based on phenotypic records, the retrospective analyses reported here used the mixed model applications of residual maximum likelihood to estimate parameters and best linear unbiased prediction to predict breeding values. The statistical model comprised fixed effects plus random effects accounting for direct additive, maternal additive and temporary environmental variation. Estimated genetic trends obtained by regressing estimated breeding values on year of birth were similar to annual responses estimated by comparing selection and control line means. Estimates of direct heritabilities were 0·054, 0·177, 0·286, 0·561 and 0·410 for birth weight (BWT), weaning weight (WWT), LWT, UFD and UMD respectively. Corresponding estimates of maternal heritabilities were 0·287, 0·205, 0·160, 0·083 and 0·164. Phenotypic correlations between all pairs of traits were positive and usually moderately high. There were low negative direct additive correlations between BWT and WWT, and between BWT and LWT, but higher positive maternal additive correlations between all other pairs of weight traits.


Corresponding author



Hide All
Banks, R. G. 1999. Genetics of lamb and meat production. In The genetics of sheep (ed. Piper, L. and Ruvinsky, A.), pp. 505522. CAB International, Wallingford.
Bennett, G. L. 1990. Selection for growth and carcass composition in sheep. Proceedings of the fourth world congress on genetics applied to livestock production, Edinburgh, vol. XV, pp. 2736.
Bennett, G. L., Meyer, H. H. and Kirton, A. H. 1988. Effects of selection for divergent ultrasonic fat depth in rams on progeny fatness. Animal Production 47: 379386.
Bishop, S. C. 1993. Selection for predicted carcass lean content in Scottish Blackface sheep. Animal Production 56: 379386.
Cameron, N. D. and Bracken, J. 1992. Selection for carcass lean content in a terminal sire breed of sheep. Animal Production 54: 367377.
Conington, J., Bishop, S. C., Waterhouse, A. and Simm, G. 1998. A comparison of growth and carcass traits in Scottish Blackface lambs sired by genetically lean or fat rams. Animal Science 67: 299309.
Dingwall, W. S., McKelvey, W. A. C., Mylne, M. J. A. and Simm, G. 1994. A protocol for MOET in Suffolk sheep. Programme and abstracts of the 45th annual meeting of the European Association for Animal Production, Edinburgh, p. 256 (abstr. ).
Dingwall, W. S., McKelvey, W. A. C., Mylne, J. and Simm, G. 1993. An evaluation of MOET in Suffolk sheep. Animal Production 56: 444 (abstr. ).
Fogarty, N. M. 1995. Genetic parameters for liveweight, fat and muscle measurements, wool production and reproduction in sheep: a review. Animal Breeding Abstracts 63: 101143. $$(Also, see Erratum preceding p. 935, vol. 63. )
Genstat 5 Committee. 1993. Genstat 5 release 3 reference manual. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Gilmour, A. R. 1996. ASREML, a spatial REML program. NSW Agriculture, Orange, Australia.
Gilmour, A. R., Thompson, R. and Cullis, B. R. 1995. Average information REML, an efficient algorithm for variance estimation in linear mixed models. Biometrics 51: 14401450.
Henderson, C. R. 1988. Theoretical basis and computational methods for a number of different animal models. Journal of Dairy Science 71: (suppl. ) 116.
Kadim, I. T., Purchas, R. W., Rae, A. L. and Barton, R. A. 1989. Carcass characteristics of Southdown rams from high and low backfat selection lines. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 32: 181191.
Kempster, A.J. 1983. Carcass quality and its measurement in sheep. In Sheep production (ed. Haresign, W.), pp. 5974. Butterworths, London.
Kempster, A. J., Croston, D., Guy, D. R. and Jones, D. W. 1987. Growth and carcass characteristics of crossbred lambs by ten sire breeds, compared at the same estimated subcutaneous fat proportion. Animal Production 44: 8398.
Lewis, R.-M. and Beatson, P. R. 1999. Choosing maternal-effect models to estimate (co)variances for live and fleece weight in New Zealand Coopworth sheep. Livestock Production Science 58: 137150.
Lewis, R. M., Emmans, G. C., Simm, G., Dingwall, W. S., FitzSimons, J., Fraser, J. C. and Donbavand, J. E. 1999. The consequences of index selection on carcass composition in Suffolk sheep. Proceedings of the British Society of Animal Science, 1999, p. 46.
Lewis, R. M., Simm, G., Dingwall, W. S. and Murphy, S. V. 1996. Selection for lean growth in terminal sire sheep to produce leaner crossbred progeny. Animal Science 63: 133142.
Leymaster, K. A. and Jenkins, T. G. 1993. Comparison of Texel-and Suffolk-sired crossbred lambs for survival, growth and compositional traits. Journal of Animal Science 71: 859869.
Lord, E. A., Fennessy, P. F. and Littlejohn, R. P. 1988. Comparison of genotype and nutritional effects on body and carcass characteristics of lambs. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 31: 1319.
McClelland, T. H., Bonaiti, B. and Taylor, St C.S. 1976. Breed differences in body composition of equally mature sheep. Animal Production 23: 281293.
McEwan, J. C., Fennessy, P. F., Greer, G. J., Bain, W. E. and Bruce, G. D. 1990. Effects of selection for ultrasonic backfat depth on carcass growth and composition in sheep. Proceedings of the Australian Association of Animal Breeding and Genetics 8: 323326.
McEwan, J. C., Fennessy, P. F., Greer, G. J., Bruce, G. D. and Bain, W. E. 1989. Selection for carcass composition: effects on the development of subcutaneous and internal fat depots. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society of New Zealand 14: 163164.
Meat and Livestock Commission. 1999. Sheep yearbook 1999. Meat and Livestock Commission, PO Box 44, Winterhill House, Snowdon Drive, Milton Keynes, MK6 1AX.
Mercer, J. T., Brotherstone, S., Bradfield, M. J. and Guy, D. R. 1994. Estimation of genetic parameters for use in sheep sire referencing schemes. Proceedings of the fifth world congress on genetics applied to livestock production, Guelph, vol. 18, pp. 3942.
More O’Ferrall, G. J. and Timon, Y. M. 1977. A comparison of eight sire breeds for lamb production. 1. Lamb growth and carcass measurements. Irish Journal of Agricultural Research 16: 267275.
Morris, C. A., McEwan, J. C., Fennessy, P. F., Bain, W. E., Greer, G. J. and Hickey, S. M. 1997. Selection for high or low backfat depth in Coopworth sheep: juvenile traits. Animal Science 65: 93103.
Nsoso, S. J. 1995. Genetic control of lean tissue growth rate in sheep: genetic parameters and responses to selection. Ph.D. thesis, Lincoln University, New Zealand.
Patterson, H. D. and Thompson, R. 1971. Recovery of interblock information when block sizes are unequal. Biometrica 58: 454544.
Simm, G. 1987. Carcass evaluation in sheep breeding programmes. In New techniques in sheep production (ed. Marai, I.F.M. and Owen, J. B.), pp. 125144. Butterworths, London.
Simm, G. 1992. Selection for lean meat production in sheep. In Progress in sheep and goat research (ed. Speedy, A. W.), pp. 193215. CAB International, Wallingford.
Simm, G. 1994. Developments in improvement of meat sheep. Proceedings of the fifth world congress on genetics applied to livestock production, Guelph, vol. 18, pp. 310.
Simm, G. and Dingwall, W. S. 1989. Selection indices for lean meat production in sheep. Livestock Production Science 21: 223233.
Simm, G., Lewis, R. M., Collins, J. E. and Nieuwhof, G. J. 2001. Use of sire referencing schemes to select for improved carcass composition in sheep. Journal of Animal Science In press.
Simm, G. and Murphy, S. V. 1996. The effects of selection for lean growth in Suffolk sires on the saleable meat yield of their crossbred progeny. Animal Science 62: 255263.
Simm, G., Young, M. J. and Beatson, P. R. 1987. An economic selection index for lean meat production in New Zealand sheep. Animal Production 45: 465475.
Solis-Ramirez, J., Blair, H. T. and Purchas, R. W. 1993. Direct and correlated responses to selection for high or low ultrasonic backfat depth in Southdown sheep. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 36: 133141.
Taylor, St C. S. 1980. Genetic size-scaling rules in animal growth. Animal Production 30: 161165.
Wolf, B. T., Smith, C., King, J. W. B. and Nicholson, D. 1981. Genetic parameters of growth and carcass composition in crossbred lambs. Animal Production 32: 17.
Wolf, B. T., Smith, C. and Sales, D. I. 1980. Growth and carcass composition in the crossbred progeny of six terminal sire breeds of sheep. Animal Production 31: 307313.
Woodward, J. and Wheelock, V. 1990. Consumer attitudes to fat in meat. In Reducing fat in meat animals (ed. Wood, J. D. and Fisher, A. V.), pp. 66100. Elsevier, London.


Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Responses to selection for lean growth in sheep

  • G. Simm (a1), R.M. Lewis (a1), B. Grundy (a1) and W.S. Dingwall (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.