Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-fwgfc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T10:22:48.284Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The WHO European Program of Health Legislation and the Health for All Policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2021

Geneviève Pinet
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive review of the work of the World Health Organization (WHO), begun a decade ago in Europe, in the field of health legislation. This program is the result of the interaction between two important factors: the trends in national health policy and legislation at the country level, and the implementation of the Health for All policy, which has been collectively adopted by the European Member States in various WHO fora.

Health legislation has proved to be a valuable tool in supporting National Health Policies in European countries and a key element in international health activities. The paper will be presented in three main parts. The first examines the legislative implications of the Health for All policy and strategy. The second gives an overview of developments in health legislation in Europe, focusing on national achievements in three areas in which change is necessary to achieve Health for All: health care systems, the environment, and lifestyles. The third part gives an account of activities carried out by the Regional Office for Europe of WHO in the health legislation field, recalls the organization of the first WHO medium-term program in this field, and summarizes its four current subprograms on health policy, health situation, exchange of information, and training. The conclusion briefly outlines the prospects for further developments in Europe.

Type
Articles
Information
American Journal of Law & Medicine , Volume 12 , Issue 3-4: Public Health & The Law , 1986 , pp. 441 - 460
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics and Boston University 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, The Work of WHO in the European Region 1986: Annual Report of the Regional Director (1987).

2 CONSTITUTION OF THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION.

3 World Health Assembly Resolution, WHA 30.43 (1977).

4 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, European Strategy for Attaining Health for All by the Year 2,000, Doc. EUR/RC30/R8 Rev. 2 (1982).

5 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Targets for Health for All (1985).

6 Id.

7 Id.

8 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Strategies for Health for All by the Year 2000: Regional Evaluation, Doc. EUR/RC35/6 (1985).

9 H.J.J. LEENEN, G. PINET & A.V. PRIMS, TRENDS IN HEALTH LEGISLATION IN EUROPE (1985); WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Health Legislation in Europe—Country Profiles, EURO Doc. ICP/HLE 101 E (1985) (unpublished manuscript, available through WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen).

10 Declaration of the Rights of Disabled Persons, G.A. Res. 3447, 15 U.N. GAOR Supp. (No. 34) at 528, U.N. Doc. A/10034 (1975).

11 The United Nations General Assembly declared in Resolution 37/52 of December 3, 1982 that the period from 1983 to 1992 should be the United Nations Decade of the Disabled Persons. G.A. Res. 37/52, 21 U.N. GAOR Supp. (No. 51) at 407, U.N. Doc. A/37/51 (1982) [hereinafter cited as Resolution].

12 G.A. Res. 38/28, 22 U.N. GAOR Supp. (No. 27) at 408, U.N. Doc. A/38/27 (1983).

13 H.J.J. LEENEN, G. PINET & A.V. PRIMS, supra note 9.

14 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Legislation Concerning Nursing Midwifery Services and Education, Report on a WHO Working Group, EURO Reports & Studies No. 45 (1981).

15 Regulations relating to the statutory nursing services in the municipal health services, issued by the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, Norway, on November 23, 1983 pursuant to the fifth paragraph of Par. 1-3; cf. Par. 8-1 of Act No. 66 of November 19, 1982 relating to the municipal health services, and to Par. 7 of Act No. 68 of November 19, 1982 relating to planning and trial projects in municipal social and health services.

16 H.J.J. LEENEN, G. PINET & A.V. PRIMS, supra note 9.

17 Primary Health Act, January 28, 1972, Helsinki, Finland.

18 Ga. Uff., Part 1, Dec. 28, 1978, Ordway Supp. to No. 360, at 1-48, Italy.

19 Law 56/79 of September 15, 1979, Portugal (repealed in 1982).

20 Law No. 1397 of October 1983, Greece.

21 Health Provisions Act, September 8, 1982; Bill on Health Professions; Health Care Charges Act, November 20, 1980, No. 646, Netherlands.

22 In Belgium, under the institutional reform of 1980, health care administration is within the competence of the Flemish, French and German Communities, subject to the regulations of national laws which, for instance, lay down national rules for the financing of health care.

23 Health and Medical Services Act, Statutory Instrument (SFS-1982-763), enacted June 30, 1982, effective January 1, 1983, superseding the Medical Care Act (1962:242), Sweden.

24 Health and Medical Services Act, No. 59 of June 1, 1983, Iceland.

25 Act No. 33 of March 30, 1984, modifying Act No. 66 of November 19, 1982, Norway (regulating state supervision of health services run by counties, municipalities and private enterprise).

26 General Law on Health, No. 14/1986 of April 25, 1986, Spain.

27 The United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, held in Stockholm in 1972, was a powerful force for increasing public awareness and understanding of the fragility of the human environment. The principles of the Stockholm Declaration are still valid and provide a basic code for environmental protection. An Action Plan was also adopted and has been partially implemented.

28 H.J.J. LEENEN, G. PINET & A.V. PRIMS, supra note 9; Health Legislation in Europe—Country Profiles, supra note 9.

29 Pinet, Analysis of Laws and Regulations Related to Caries Prevention in Europe, in STRATEGY FOR DENTAL CARIES PREVENTION IN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES ACCORDING TO THEIR LAWS AND REGULATIONS (1987).

30 Health and Medical Services Act, Statutory Instrument (SFS-1982-763), enacted June 30, 1982, effective January 1, 1983, superseding the Medical Care Act (1962:242).

31 R. ROEMER, LEGISLATIVE ACTION TO COMBAT THE WORLD SMOKING EPIDEMIC (Geneva, WHO) (1982); R. ROEMER, RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN LEGISLATION TO COMBAT THE WORK SMOKING EPIDEMIC (Geneva, WHO) (1986); WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, European Action Plan on Tobacco EUR/RC37/7 (1987) (background document prepared for the Regional Committee meeting, September 15-19, 1987).

32 Health Legislation, European Program, Advisory Committee, Dresden, June 24-26, 1981, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 002, 9418B.

33 Health Legislation, European Program, Advisory Committee Summary Report, Lyon, June 11-13, 1985, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 199 m01, 5908V [hereinafter cited as Legislation].

34 H.J.J. LEENEN, G. PINET & A.V. PRIMS, supra note 9.

35 Id.

36 WHO, Geneva, Report of the Technical Discussions on the Role of Intersectoral Cooperation in National Strategies for Health for All, Thirty-ninth World Health Assembly A39/Technical Discussions/4, May 15, 1986.

37 Health Legislation in Europe—Country Profiles, supra note 9.

38 Vellas, Le role de la legislation sanitaire dans une approche intersectorielle des besoins de santé, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 199 m01/12, 9745L (1985).

39 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Social Justice and Equity and Health, A Report on a WHO Meeting, Leeds, July 22-26, 1985, U.N. Doc. ICP/HSR 804/m02, 37034.

40 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, The Health Burden of Social Inequities, A Report on a WHO Meeting, Copenhagen, December 5-7, 1984, U.N. Doc. ICP/HSR 801/m04, 1789V, 1631V, 1583V, 3814V, 4069V.

41 Pinet & Jardel, Study on Trends in National Policies and Legislation for Data Protection in the Health Field, in DATA PROTECTION IN HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS—Where Do We Stand? (1983).

42 Pinet, Strategies Legislatives et Evolution Medico-Sociale, LES CAHIERS MEDICO-SOCIAUX, 29ème année, No. 4, at 267 (1985).

43 General Law No. 14/1986, April 25, 1986, Spain.

44 International Conference on Health System Organization in Relation to the Spanish General Health Law, Madrid, May 28-June 1, 1984, Ministry of Health and Consumer Affairs, Madrid, Spain.

45 Working Group on Health and Social Legislation for the Disabled, Summary Report, Dresden, November 26-28, 1985, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 102/m01, 8680.

46 Resolution, supra note 11.

47 Pinet, Health and Social Legislation for the Disabled in Europe, Preliminary Findings of a WHO-Study, prepared for the International Expert Meeting on Legislation on Equalization of Opportunities for Disabled Persons, Vienna, June 2-6, 1986, to be published by UNCSDHA and Rehabilitation International, in press; Pinet, Health and Equity for the Disabled—Legislation for Action, EURO Doc. ICP/HLE 113 (1986).

48 Report of the WHO, Health Policy Aspects of Aging, United Nations World Assembly on Aging, Vienna, July 26-August 6, 1982, U.N. Doc. A/CONF. 113/19, v. 82-23752 (1982).

49 L. CHAMBERS, QUALITY ASSURANCE IN LONG-TERM CARE: POLICY, RESEARCH AND MEASUREMENT (1986) (published on behalf of WHO Regional Office for Europe by the International Center of Social Gerontology).

50 Roemer, Basic Principles and Legislative Strategies to Promote the Health of the Elderly, U.N. Doc. WHO/AGE/82.2, 9181B (1982).

51 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Targets for Health for All (1985).

52 Legislation, supra note 33.

53 Fourth Joint Meeting of the European Health Policy Forum and the WHO on “Legislative Approaches with Respect to Health Care Technology,” Brussels, October 17-18, 1984, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 102/m02.

54 G. Pinet, “L'interrogation ethique dans la recherche biomedicale et la recherche en santé, le rôle de coordination de l'OMS,” (1984) (background document).

55 M. Manciaux, “Problems ethiques liés à la recherche à l'appûi de la strategic en vue de la santé pour tout d'ici l'an 2000,” (1986) (background document).

56 “Ethique et promotion de la santé,” rapport d'un atelier OMS réuni a Nancy (France), du 28 au 30 Octobre 1985, par le Bureau régional de l'Europe de l'Organisation Mondial de la Santé.

57 Pinet, Ethical Aspects of Public Health Legislation and the Role of the State, in ETHICAL ISSUES IN PREVENTIVE MEDICINE (1985).

58 Pinet, AIDS, Legislative Measures and Ethical Issues, U.N. Doc. ICP/CDS 026, EUR/HFA target 4 (1987).

59 WHO, Regional Office for Europe, Meeting on “AIDS Diagnosis and Control: Current Situation,” Munich, March 16-18, 1987, U.N. Doc. ICP/CDS 026/16, 1960G.

60 Health Legislation in Europe—What is New in 1984? Our Computer Tells You, EURO Doc. ICP/HLE 104g02; Health Legislation in Europe—What is New in 1985? Our Computer Tells You, EURO Doc. ICP/HLE 115.

61 ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR THE COORDINATION OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS (ACCIS), U.N. DIRECTORY OF UNITED NATIONS DATABASES AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS (1985).

62 Working Group on Health Legislation Information System, Summary Report, Uppsala, November 8-10, 1983, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 003(l)(s) 3947L.

63 Auby, Legislation Sanitaire, Programmes et Moyens de Formation en Europe, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 005 (1984).

64 First WHO International Course on Health Legislation, A report with teaching modules and content of course, Leuven, July 2-3, 1984, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 105 c02.

65 “First National Seminar on Health Legislation” with international participation, Hangzhou, China, April 14-25, 1986, organized jointly by the Health Committee of the National People's Congress and the Ministry of Health, China.

66 OMS, Bureau Régional de l'Europe, Législation Sanitaire, Second Seminare International OMS en Législation Sanitaire, Montpellier, Aug. 25-Sept. 5, 1986, U.N. Doc. ICP/HLE 118.