Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-k7p5g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T13:32:00.943Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“George II and All That Stuff”: On the Value of the Neglected

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 July 2014

Jeremy Black
Get access

Extract

A valedictory article is a piece of sadness, but it is also an opportunity to shout at the wind. This piece is doubly written in that sense, first because it focuses on a king, and secondly because it discusses sources and emphasizes the need for archival research. Readers who are enthralled in modishness, and in the multiple mirrors of post-modernism, will proceed no further, but that simply reflects the peculiar and self-serving nature of the dominant approach to eighteenth-century British political history, with its fascination for the rhetorical strategies of discourse and its lack of interest in the contents and contours of politics, and in the hard work required to re-create them.

In part this reflects a sense that somehow all this high politics has been done, but that is deeply misleading. It is particularly so for the reign of George II (1727–60), for that monarch, a king in deed as well as name, still lacks a scholarly biography. This is an important omission, for, without such a study, the monarch appears as a figure of episodic importance, distinctly secondary to his ministers, and as a restraint on them, rather than as an initiator of issues. To understand the king and his role, it is necessary to consider him not thus from the outside but rather on the basis of a thorough study that makes full use of the surviving sources. Secondly, without a focus on the king, it is difficult to understand the Anglo-Hanoverian monarchy, and the problems this created for British ministers. Thirdly, the failure to give due weight to George II ensures that Britain appears more different from Continental states than it should, and certainly removes a possible way to offer a comparative study.

Type
Research Article
Information
Albion , Volume 36 , Issue 4 , Winter 2004 , pp. 581 - 607
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference on British Studies 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I would like to thank Grayson Ditchfield and Mike Moore for their comments on an earlier draft.

References

1 Trench, C. C., George II (1973), pp. 298–99Google Scholar.

2 Plumb, J. H., The First Four Georges (2000), pp. 64–91 Google Scholar.

3 Owen, J., “George II reconsidered,” in Whiteman, A., Bromley, J. S. and Dickson, P. G. M., eds., Statesmen, Scholars and Merchants. Essays in Eighteenth Century History presented to Dame Lucy Sutherland (Oxford, 1973), p. 129 Google Scholar.

4 Black, J., “George II Reconsidered. A Consideration of George's Influence in the Conduct of Foreign Policy, in the first years of his reign,” Mitteilungen des Österreichischen Staatsarchivs 35 (1982): 35–56 Google Scholar.

5 Lodge, R., Studies in Eighteenth-Century Diplomacy 1740–48 (1930), p. 13 Google Scholar.

6 Brooke, J., ed., Horace Walpole. Memoirs of King George II 3 vols. (New Haven, 1985) 1: 63 Google Scholar.

7 For a fire in Hanover destroying government archives see the manuscript newsletter, 17 April 1741, Turin, Archivio di Stato, Lettere Ministri Inghilterra 47. There was more serious destruction with the end of the personal union in 1837.

8 Niemeyer, J., Die Revue bei Bemerode, 1735. Eine kulturgeschichtliche und heereskundliche Betrachtung zu einem Gemälde von J. F. Lüders (Beckum, 1985)Google Scholar.

9 E.g., Ossorio, Sardinian envoy, to Charles Emmanuel III, 12 Aug. 1733, Perrone, Sardinian envoy, to Sardinian foreign minister, 6 Ap. 1752, Perrone to Charles Emmanuel III, 25 Jan. 1753, Turin, Archivio di Stato, Lettere Ministri Inghilterra (hereafter cited as AST. LM. Ing.) 40, 57.

10 Justus Alt, envoy of Hesse-Cassel, to the Landgrave, 22 Feb. 1737, Marburg, Staatsarchiv, 4f Britain (hereafter cited as Marburg) 221; George Tilson, Under Secretary, to Edward Weston, Under Secretary, 20 May (os) 1737, Farmington, Connecticut, Lewis Walpole Library, Weston papers, vol. 2.

11 De Löss to Augustus III of Saxony-Poland, 16 Aug., 2 Sept. 1736, Dresden, Hauptstaatsarchiv, Geheimes Kabinett, Gesandschaften (hereafter Dresden) 638, IV b fols. 130, 180–83.

12 Memoire by Diemar, 28 Feb. 1737, Marburg 221.

13 Colley, Linda J., In Defiance of Oligarchy: The Tory Party, 1714–1760 (Cambridge, 1982)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Clark, J. C. D., English Society 1688–1832: Ideology, Social Structure and Political Practice during the Ancien Regime (Cambridge, 1985)Google Scholar.

15 Hatton, R., George I, Elector and King (1978), Georg I. Ein deutscher Kurfurst auf Englands Thron (Frankfurt, 1982)Google Scholar.

16 Newcastle to Hardwicke, 22 July 1743, London, British Library (BL.), Additional Manuscripts, vol. 32700 fol. 314.

17 E.g. Old England, 4 April 12 Nov. 1752.

18 Zamboni to Count Kaunitz, 31 Mar. 1752, Vienna, Haus-, Hof-, und Staatsarchiv, State Chancellery, England, Varia 10.

19 De Löss, Saxon envoy, to Augustus III, 14 July 1735, Dresden, 638 III b fol. 19. For troop reviews, Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 18 July 1732, AST. LM. Ing. 39; Daily Post Boy 18 June (os) 1735; Tilson to Waldegrave, 20 June, 5 Sept. 1735, Chewton Hall, Chewton Mendip, Waldegrave papers, papers of 1st Earl (hereafter cited as Chewton); Harrington to Newcastle, 26 June 1735, London, Public Record Office (PRO), State Papers 43/86.

20 Daily Post Boy, 16 Aug. (os) 1735.

21 Harrington to Thomas Robinson, envoy in Vienna, 21 July 1735, PRO. 80/116; Münchhausen and Steinberg to Newcastle, 23 Sept. 1752, Hanover, Hauptstaatsarchiv, Calenberg Brief Archiv 2282 fol. 302.

22 Guy, A., Oeconomy and Discipline. Officership and Administration in the British Army 1714–63 (Manchester, 1985)Google Scholar; Justus Alt, Hesse-Cassel envoy, to Hesse-Cassel minister Heim, 2 July 1754, Marburg, 255.

23 Newcastle to Robert, 4th Earl of Holdernesse, 26 July 1752, PRO. 36/119 fol. 143.

24 Harrington to Horatio Walpole, 19 June 1735, PRO. 84/343 fol. 168.

25 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 29 July 1746, AST. LM. Ing. 52.

26 St. James's Evening Post, 19 June (os) 1735.

27 Lyttelton to Sarah, Duchess of Marlborough, (Aug. 1737), BL. Add. Mss. 61467 fol. 9.

28 Dann, U., Hannover und England 1740–1760. Diplomatie und Selbstbehauptung (Hildesheim, 1986)Google Scholar.

29 Thom, Wolfenbüttel envoy, to Duke of Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel, 22 Jan. 1726, Wolfenbüttel, Staatsarchiv, 1 Alt. 6 Nr. 86 fol. 46.

30 Black, J. M., “International Relations in the Eighteenth Century: Britain and Poland Compared,” Diplomacy and Statecraft 13 (2002): 83–112 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Horatio Walpole to Robert Trevor, 26 April (os) 1737, Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire Record Office, Trevor papers, vol. 8.

32 Reporting conversation with Münchhausen, Lascaris, Sardinian envoy in Hanover, to Sardinian foreign minister, 8 Oct. 1752, AST. LM. Ing. 57.

33 Newcastle to Robert Keith, envoy in Vienna, 9 Mar. 1753, PRO. 80/191.

34 Newcastle to Hardwicke, 1 Sept., 15 Oct. 1759, BL. Add. Mss. 35418 fol. 246, 35419 fol. 9.

35 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 7 Oct. 1732, AST. LM. Ing. 39.

36 Newcastle to Hardwicke, 19 Sept. 1757, BL. Add. Mss. 35417 fol. 73.

37 George II to Frederick II, 20 Sept. 1757, BL. Egerton Manuscripts (hereafter cited as Eg.) vol. 3425 fol. 86.

38 Rouillé, French foreign minister, to Folard, envoy to Bavaria, 14 Nov. 1756, Paris, Ministère des Relations Extérieures, Correspondance Politique (hereafter cited as AE. CP.) Bavière 134 fols. 384–92.

39 Anon. to Waldegrave, 30 May 1738, Chewton Hall, Chewton.

40 Tyrawly to Newcastle, 19 May 1735, PRO. 89/38 fol. 32.

41 Old England, 29 Aug. 1752.

42 Carteret's instructions, tenth article, PRO. 63/389 fol. 72.

43 Sarah Marlborough to John, 2nd Earl of Stair, 6 June (os) 1737, New Haven, Connecticut, Beinecke Library, Osborn Shelves, Stair Letters, no. 6.

44 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 23 April 1733, AST. LM. Ing. 40.

45 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 27 April 1733, AST. LM. Ing. 40.

46 Newcastle to Henry Pelham, 26 July, Newcastle to Hardwicke, 26 July 1752, BL. Add. Mss. 35412 fols. 209, 184.

47 Hardwicke to Newcastle, 7 Aug. 1752, BL. Add. Mss. 35412 fol. 250.

48 Thomas, P. D. G., George III. King and politicians 1760–1770 (Manchester, 2002), p. 2 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

49 Edmund Gibson, Bishop of London, to Robert Walpole, 25 June (os) 1735, Cambridge, Cholmon-deley Houghton papers, correspondence, no. 2440.

50 Sarah Marlborough to Stair, 19 Mar. (os) 1738, Beinecke, Stair Letters, no. 22.

51 Albemarle to Newcastle, 30 April (os) 1734, BL. Add. Mss. 32689 fol. 212.

52 Horatio Walpole to Newcastle, 26 Aug. 1735, BL. Add. Mss. 32788 fol. 343.

53 Chavigny, French envoy in London, to Chauvelin, French foreign minister, 13 July 1733, AE. CP. Angleterre 381 fol. 95.

54 Townshend to Baron Diescau, Hanoverian envoy in Sweden, 16 Jan. (os) 1728, PRO. 95/50 fols. 17–18.

55 Harrington to Newcastle, 7 Aug. 1735, PRO. 43/87.

56 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 16 Aug. 1746, AST. LM. Ing. 52.

57 Ossorio to Charles Emmanuel III, 30 Sept., 14 Oct. 1746, AST. LM. Ing. 52.

58 Mirepox to St. Contest, French foreign minister, 14 Mar. 1754, AE. CP. Ang. 437 fol. 85.

59 Perrone to Charles Emmanuel III, 14 Mar. 1754, AST. LM. Ing. 58; Pilcher, G. W., ed., The Reverend Samuel Davies Abroad. The Diary of a Journey to England and Scotland, 1753–55 (Urbana, 1968), p. 84 Google Scholar.

60 Horatio Walpole to Trevor, 22 Mar. (os) 1737, Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire Record Office, Trevor papers, vol. 7.

61 Hardwicke's account of audience on 5 January (os) 1744, Yorke, P. C., ed., The Life and Correspondence of Philip Yorke, Earl of Hardwicke 3 vols. (Cambridge), 1: 383 Google Scholar.

62 John Couraud, Under Secretary, to Waldegrave, 31 Jan. (os) 1737, Chewton. For an account suggesting that the situation was more serious, Colonel Charles Howard MP to 3rd Earl of Carlisle, 1 Feb. 1737, Historical Manuscripts Commission, Manuscripts of the Earl of Carlisle (1897), p. 176 Google Scholar.

63 Sarah Marlborough to Stair, 29 Jan. (os) 1738, Beinecke, Stair Letters, no. 18.

64 Ryder to Newcastle, 16 Oct. (os) 1749, PRO. 36/111 fol. 115.

65 Alt to Landgrave of Hesse-Cassel, 11 Jan. 1737, Marburg 221.

66 Hatton, , George I, pp. 67–68 Google Scholar.

67 Newcastle to Holdernesse, 11 June 1752, PRO. 36/118 fol. 343; cf. William Murray to Charles, 2nd Marquess of Rockingham, 21 July 1752, Sheffield, Archives, Wentworth Woodhouse papers, R1–15.

68 “Journal du voyage de M. le Comte de Gisors en Angleterre,” AE. Mémoires et Documents, Angleterre 1 fols. 30, 39–40, 100–01.

69 Perrone to Charles Emmanuel III, 2 May 1754, AST. LM. Ing. 58.

70 Lady Irwin to Carlisle, 1 Mar. 1737, Carlisle, p. 178.

71 Lord Lovell to Lord Malton, 26 Feb. (os) 1737, Sheffield, Public Library, Wentworth Woodhouse Mss. M3.

72 Weston to Walter Titley, envoy in Copenhagen, 25 Feb. (os) 1737, BL. Eg. 2684 fol. 72; Robert Walpole to Waldegrave, 7 Mar. (os) 1737, Chewton.

73 London Journal, 12 June (os) 1736.

74 Newcastle to Holdernesse, 26 May 1752, PRO. 36/118 fol. 299.

75 Newcastle to Keith, 2 Feb. 1753, PRO. 80/191.

76 Harrington to Newcastle, 12 June 1735, PRO. 43/86.

77 Eg. Harrington to Horatio Walpole, 12, 29 June 1735, PRO. 84/343 fol. 117, 84/344 fol. 97; Harrington to Newcastle, 13, 20, 27 July 1735, PRO. 43/86–7; Newcastle to Holdernesse, 11 June 1752, PRO. 36/118 fol. 343; Wrede, Palatine envoy, to Palatine foreign minister, Baron Wachtendonck, 11 June 1752, Munich, Bayerisches Hauptstaatsarchiv, Kasten blau 9/11.

78 See also, e.g, General Evening Post 8, 17 July (os) 1735.

79 Baron Seckendorf to Ferdinand Albrecht of Brunswick-Bevern, 20 June, 1 July 1735, Wolfenbüttel, Staatsarchiv 1 Alt 22 Nr. 588 fols. 164–65, 179; Guy Dickens, envoy in Berlin, to Tilson, 12 July 1735, PRO. 90/40; De Löss to Augustus III, 14, 17 July 1735, Dresden III b fols. 21–22, 27–29.

80 Morton to Lord Aberdour, 12 Jan. (os) 1734, Edinburgh, National Archives of Scotland, GD 150/3476/41.

81 Lascaris, Sardinian envoy, to foreign minister, 6 July 1752, AST. LM. Ing. 57.

82 Newcastle to Pelham, 14 June 1752, BL. Add. Mss. 35412 fol. 132.

83 Black, J. M., King's, Nobles and Commoners: Slates and Societies in Early Modern Europe (London, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar

84 See, in particular, Clark, , English Society 1688–1832: Ideology, Social Structure and Political Practice during the Ancien Regime (2nd ed.; Cambridge, 2000)Google Scholar, and Langford, Paul, A Polite and Commercial People. England 1727–1783 (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar.