Skip to main content Accessibility help

Design and optimisation of an aerofoil with active continuous trailing-edge flap

  • Jinwei Shen (a1), Yi Liu (a1), Robert P. Thornburgh (a2), Andrew R. Kreshock (a2) and Matthew L. Wilbur (a2)...


This paper presents the design and optimisation of an aerofoil with active continuous trailing-edge flap (CTEF) investigated as a potential rotorcraft active control device. Several structural cross-section models are developed: high-fidelity NASA STRucture ANalysis (NASTRAN) and University of Michigan/Variational Asymptotic Beam Section Code (UM/VABS) models and a reduced-order analysis model. The validation of the reduced-order model is established by comparing its predictions of CTEF deformations with those of NASTRAN and UM/VABS analyses, which both show good agreement. The 2D aerodynamic characteristics of the CTEF aerofoil are evaluated using XFOIL and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analyses: FUN3D and Overset Transonic Unsteady Rotor Navier-Stokes (OVERTURNS). XFOIL, coupled with the reduced-order structure model, is adopted for optimisation study. The accuracy of XFOIL in predicting the aerodynamic pressure of the CTEF aerofoil is verified using CFD simulations, which shows sufficient fidelity. The predicted variations of aerodynamic coefficients with a CTEF angle are compared among the aerodynamic analyses. The optimisation process is developed and applied to two bimorph bender configurations: a Macro-Fibre Composite (MFC) solid bender and an MFC stack bender. The solid bender is used to confirm the functioning of the optimisation procedure and to use its optimal layout as a reference to the stack design, the primary design object. A linear tapered shape is found to be the optimum for a MFC solid bender, which generates an average of 63% more CTEF angles than those of an optimal rectangular bender. An optimised MFC stack bender is shown to resemble the shape of the solid bender. A four-ply bimorph is considered the best choice among the stack layouts because of its large output of CTEF angles and relatively less plies required. The CTEF angle produced by the four-ply optimal layout ranges from 7.6° to 5.3° with speeds from 0 to 200m/s at an angle of attack (AoA) of 6°. The reduction in the CTEF angle with AoA is less steep than that with speed, ranging from 6.5° to 5.8° with AoA from 0 to 8° at speed of 166m/s. An average of 14% increase in CTEF angles is achieved through optimisation for the four-ply bimorph.


Corresponding author


Hide All
1. Maucher, C.K., Grohmann, B.A., Janker, P., Altmikus, A., Jensen, F. and Baier, H. Actuator design for the active trailing edge of a helicopter rotor blade, Innovation, 2007, p 12.
2. Grohmann, B., Muller, F., Achci, E., Pfaller, R., Bauer, M., Maucher, C., Dieterich, O., Storm, S. and Janker, P. Design, evaluation and test of active trailing edge, American Helicopter Society 67th Annual Forum Proceedings, 3-5 May 2011, Virginia Beach, Virginia, US.
3. Shen, J., Thornburgh, R.P., Kreshock, A.R., Wilbur, M.L. and Liu, Y. Preliminary design and evaluation of an airfoil with active continuous trailing-edge flap, American Helicopter Society Future Vertical Lift Aircraft Design Conference, January 2012, San Francisco, California, US, p 10.
4. Shen, J., Yang, M. and Chopra, I. Swashplateless helicopter rotor system with trailing-edge flaps for flight and vibration controls, J Aircraft, April-May 2006, 43, (2), pp 346352.
5. Fogarty, D.E., Wilbur, M.L. and Sekula, M.K. The effect of non-harmonic active twist actuation on BVI noise, American Helicopter Society 67th Annual Forum Proceedings, 3-5 May 2011, Virginia Beach, Virginia, US.
6. Thornburgh, R.P., Kreshock, A.R. and Wilbur, M.L. Structural optimization of active-twist rotor blades, American Helicopter Society 67th Annual Forum Proceedings, 3-5 May 2011, Virginia Beach, Virginia, US.
7. Sekula, M.K. and Wilbur, M.L. Analysis of a multiflap control system for a swashplateless rotor, J American Helicopter Society, July 2012, 57, (3), p 12.
8. Wilbur, M.L., Mirick, P.H., William, T., Yeager, J., Langston, C.W., Cesnik, C.E.S. and Shin, S. Vibratory loads reduction testing of the NASA/Army/MIT active twist rotor, American Helicopter Society 57th Annual Forum Proceedings, 9-11 May 2001, Washington, DC, US, p 19.
9. Wilkie, W.K., Bryant, R.G., High, J.W., Fox, R.L., Hellbaum, R.F., Anthony Jalink, J., Little, B.D. and Mirick, P.H. Low-cost piezocomposite actuator for structural control applications, Proc. SPIE 3991, Smart Structures and Materials 2000: Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures Technologies, 323, June 2000, Newport Beach, California, US.
10. NASTRAN Quick Reference Guide , The MacNeal Schwendler Corporation, 2013, p 3626.
11. Palacios, R. and Cesnik, C. Cross-aectional analysis of nonhomogeneous anisotropic active slender structures, AIAA J, 2005, 43, (12), pp 26242638.
12. Kim, K.C. Analytical calculation of helicopter main rotor blade flight loads in hover and forward flight, Tech Rep, ARL-TR-3180, January 2004, U.S. Army Research Laboratory AMSRD-ARL-SL-BD Aberdeen Proving Ground, Maryland, US.
13. Patran User’s Mannual , The MacNeal Schwendler Corporation, 2016, p 228.
14. Reaves, M.C. and Horta, L.G. Piezoelectric actuator modeling using MSC/NASTRAN and MATLAB, Tech Rep, NASA/TM-2003-212651, October 2003, Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia, US.
15. FUN3D website,
16. Jose, A.I., Sitaraman, J. and Baeder, J.D. An investigation into the aerodynamics of trailing edge flap and flap-tab airfoils using CFD and analytical methods, American Helicopter Society 63rd Annual Forum Proceedings, 1-3 May 2007, Virginia Beach, Virginia, US, p 21.
17. Drela, M. XFOIL: An analysis and design system for low Reynolds number airfoils, Conference on Low Reynolds Number Airfoil Aerodynamics, June 1989, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana, US.
18. Anderson, W.K. and Bonhaus, D.L. An implicit up-wind algorithm for computing turbulent flows on un-structured grids, Computers and Fluids, 1994, 23, (1), pp 122.
19. Biedron, R. and Lee-Rausch, E. An examination of unsteady airloads on a UH-60A Rotor: Computation versus measurement, American Helicopter Society 68th Annual Forum Proceedings, May 2012, Fort Worth, Texas, US.
20. Marcum, D.L. and P., N. Unstructured grid generation using iterative point insertion and local reconnection, AIAA J, September 1995, 33, (9), pp 16191625.



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed