Skip to main content Accessibility help

Profitability of controlled traffic in grass silage production – economic modelling and machinery systems

  • H. Alvemar (a1), H. Andersson (a2) and H. H. Pedersen (a3)


Controlled traffic farming (CTF) systems aim to reduce soil compaction by restricting machinery field traffic to permanent traffic lanes. Grass-clover silage production is generally associated with intensive field traffic, resulting in reduced silage clover content. If CTF can increase yield and clover content in grass-clover leys, this would reduce the need for grain and expensive protein concentrate in dairy cow feed rations. A mixed integer programming model was developed to evaluate the potential profitability of CTF in a dairy farm context. Existing field trial data were used to calculate the expected yield outcome of CTF, based on reductions in trafficked area. The results revealed that CTF increased profitability by up to €50/ha. Total machinery costs are likely to increase on converting to CTF, but variable machinery costs are likely to decrease.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Alvemar, H 2014. Controlled traffic for grass silage production - An economic evaluation for dairy farmers (D-level Thesis). Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden.
Douglas, JT, Campbell, DJ and Crawford, CE 1992. Soil and crop responses to conventional, reduced ground pressure and zero traffic systems for grass silage production. Soil Tillage Research 24, 421439.
Douglas, JT and Crawford, CE 1991. Wheel-induced soil compaction effects on ryegrass production and nitrogen uptake. Grass and Forage Science 46, 405416.
Elonen, P 1986. Reports from the Division of Soil Management: Jordpackning - ett problem i Finsk åkerodling (Rapporter från jordbearbetningsavdelningen No. 71). Department of Soil Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden.
European Environmental Agency (EEA) 2015. www.eea.europa.euMean precipitation, 2016-09-05.
Frame, J 1982. The Effect of Wheel Tracking on Red Clover (Trifolium Pratense) Swards, in: Efficient Grassland Farming. British Grassland Society, Reading, UK. pp 313–315.
Frost, JP 1988. Effects on Crop Yields of Machinery Traffic and Soil Loosening Part 1. Effects on Grass Yield of Traffic Frequency and Date of Looseing. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 39, 301312.
Håkansson, I, McAfee, M and Gunnarsson, S 1990. Verkan av körning med traktor och vagn vid vallskörd. Resultat från 24 försöksplatser. (No. 78). Department of Soil Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden.
Hansen, S 1996. Effects of manure treatment and soil compaction on plant production of a dairy farm system converting to organic farming practice. Agricultural Ecosystems and Environment 56, 173186.
Jorajuria, D, Draghi, L and Aragon, A 1997. The effect of vehicle weight on the distribution of compation with depth and the yield of Lolium/Trifolium grassland. Soil Tillage Research 41, 112.
Jørgensen, RN, Green, O, Swain, KC, Kristensen, R, Bochtis, D and Sørensen, CG 2009. Impact on Clover-Grass Yield Casued by Different Traffic Intensities, International Agricultural Engineering Conference. Bangkok, Thailand.
Kroulik, Mi, Paula, M, Chyba, J and White, D 2014. Field traffic intensity for forage harvesting in the UK (HAU Project Report No. 099). Harper Adams University, Newport, UK.
McDonald, P, Edwards, RA, Greenhalgh, JFD, Morgan, CA, Sinclair, LA and Wilkinson, RG 2011. Animal Nutrition, Seventh Edition Pearson Education Ltd, Harlow, UK.
Pedersen, HH and Novak, G 2013. Beregning af overkørt areal. AgroTech.
Rasmussen, KJ and Møller, E 1981. Genvækst efter fortørring af græsmarksafgrøder. II. Jordpakning i forbindelse med høst og transport. Tidskr Plateavl 85, 5971.
Tullberg, J, Yule, D and McGarry, D 2003. On track’ to sustainable cropping systems in Australia. In Proceedings of the International. Soil Tillage Research Organisation 16th Triennial Conference Brisbane, July 13–18. pp. 1271–1285.



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed