Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-x5cpj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-01T16:45:08.790Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Nigra crux mala crux: a comparative perspective on urban conflict in Gdansk in 1411 and 1416

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 January 2014

CORDELIA HESS
CORDELIA HESS*
Affiliation:
The Royal Academy of Letters, History and Antiquities, Department of History, Stockholm University, SE-10691 Stockholm, Sweden
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Between 1411 and 1416, Gdansk was the scene for a complex conflict between town population, council and landlord, eventually resulting in violent riots. The peculiar character of these riots becomes apparent when the Gdansk chronicles are compared to the historical accounts from other, better-known conflicts, particularly sources depicting the Lübeck Knochenhauer rebellion, the Hamburg brewer's rebellion of 1481 and the 1449–53 Gentse opstand. A key difference is the extent to which chroniclers understood and portrayed the ritualized action that occurred in the urban uprisings. Comparing the contemporary chronicles of the Gdansk events with the town's urban historiography 100 years later also shows that this early conflict with the landlord later played a significant role in urban self-definition.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 41 , Issue 4 , November 2014 , pp. 565 - 581
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Rechtsstadt of Gdansk took part in the diets of the Hanseatic League beginning in 1361. Occasionally, the Teutonic Order exercised control over the town's foreign policy, such as when they forced the town to remain neutral during the war between the Hanseatic League and Eric of Pomerania in the 1420s. See Cieślak, E. (ed.), Historia Gdańska: Opracowanie zbiorowe, vol. I: Do roku 1454 (Gdańsk, 1978)Google Scholar.

2 See for example Rotz, R.A., ‘Investigating urban uprisings with examples from Hanseatic towns, 1374–1416’, in Jordan, W.C. (ed.), Order and Innovation in the Middle Ages: Essays in Honor of Joseph R. Strayer (Princeton, 1976), 215–33Google Scholar.

3 For an overview of interregional communication during urban uprisings, see Cohn, S.K., Lust for Liberty: The Politics of Social Revolt in Medieval Europe, 1200–1425; Italy, France and Flanders (Cambridge, 2008), 161–9Google Scholar.

4 Arnold, U., ‘Geschichtsschreibung im Preußenland bis zum Ausgang des 16. Jahrhunderts’, Jahrbuch für die Geschichte Mittel- und Ostdeutschlands, 19 (1970), 74–126, at 94–5Google Scholar.

5 Strohm, P., Hochon's Arrow: The Social Imagination of Fourteenth-Century Texts (Princeton, 1992), 51Google Scholar.

6 The Knochenhauer rebellion led by the impoverished merchant Hinrik Paternostermaker was an attempt to overthrow the Lübeck city council. The major source is the Detmar chronicle, which is biased in favour of the council. The most comprehensive overview of the sources and events is Brandt, A. v., ‘Die Lübecker Knochenhaueraufstände von 1380/84 und ihre Voraussetzungen: Studien zur Sozialgeschichte Lübecks in der zweiten Hälfte des 14. Jahrhunderts’, in Friedland, K. and Sprandel, R. (eds.), Lübeck, Hanse, Nordeuropa: Gedächtnisschrift für Ahasver von Brandt (Cologne, 1979), 129–208Google Scholar.

7 With further references: Heß, C., ‘Skirts and politics: the Cistercian monastery of Harvestehude and the Hamburg city council’, Medieval Feminist Forum, 47 (2011), 57–92Google Scholar.

8 This conflict united the city council of Ghent and many of the guilds against Philip the Good of Burgundy. Haemers, J., De Gentse opstand (1449–1453): De strijd tussen rivaliserende netwerken om het stedelijke kapitaal (Heule, 2004)Google Scholar.

9 Grautoff, F.H. and Kock, R. (eds.), Chronik des Franciscaner Lesemeisters Detmar, nach der Urschrift und mit Ergänzungen aus andern Chroniken (Hamburg, 1830)Google Scholar. On the relationship between the Annales Torunenses and Detmar, as well as regarding other chronicles relying on the Annales Torunenses, see Boockmann, H., ‘Geschichtsschreibung des Deutschen Ordens im Mittelalter und Geschichtsschreibung im mittelalterlichen Preußen. Entstehungsbedingungen und Funktion’, in Grenzmann, L. and Stackmann, K. (eds.), Literatur und Laienbildung im Spätmittelalter und in der Reformationszeit: Symposion Wolfenbüttel 1981 (Stuttgart, 1984), 80–93, at 86–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 The so-called Rufuschronik is an anonymous text likely dating c. 1400–30. ‘Der sogenannten Rufus-Chronik erster Teil von 1105–1395’, ed. Koppmann, K., in Die Chroniken der niedersächsischen Städte: Lübeck, vol. II, 2nd edn (Göttingen 1967) (ChrondtSt 26)Google Scholar; ‘Der sogenannten Rufus-Chronik zweiter Teil von 1395–1430’, ed. Koppmann, K., in Die Chroniken der niedersächsischen Städte: Lübeck, vol. III, 2nd edn (Göttingen, 1968)Google Scholar.

11 There is also an anonymous independent report about the Knochenhauer rebellion that circulated in two different versions: ‘Bericht über den Knochenhauer-Aufstand im Jahre 1384’, in ChrondtSt 26, 337–54. This account is handed down as it was copied in seventeenth-century collections.

12 ‘Des Bürgermeisters Herman Langebek Bericht über den Aufstand zu Hamburg im Jahre 1483’, in Lappenberg, J.M. (ed.), Hamburgische Chroniken in nierdersächsischer Sprache (Hamburg, 1861), 340–75Google Scholar; Krantz, A., Wandalia: in qua de Wandalorum populis, et eorum patrio solo, ac in Italiam . . . migratione (Coloniae, 1519)Google Scholar. 80 years later, a German translation was printed: Des Fürtrefflichen Hochgelahrten Herrn Alberti Krantzii Wandalia Oder: Beschreibung Wendischer Geschicht (Lübeck, 1600).

13 Serrure, C.P. and Blommaert, P. (eds.), Kronyk van Vlaenderen van 580 tot 1467 (Gent, 1840)Google Scholar; Fris, V. (ed.), Dagboek van Gent van 1447 tot 1470 met een vervolg van 1477 tot 1515 (Gent, 1901–04)Google Scholar; Schayes, A. (ed.), Dagboek der Gentsche Collatie van de Gebeurtenissen te Gent, en elders in Vlaenderen voorgevallen van 1446 tot 1515 (Gent, 1842)Google Scholar. Information about the texts and authors is available in M. Gypen, Dagboek van Gent, www.narrative-sources.be/naso_detail_en.php; M. Gypen, Cronike van Vlaenderen 580–1440/1467 en continuaties, www.narrative-sources.be/naso_link_en.php?link=243.

14 Scholars dealing with the historiography of medieval Prussia have noted a shift that occurred around 1400; from the historiography of the Teutonic Order to Prussian historiography and from Order-centred to regional historiography. See Päsler, R.G., Deutschsprachige Sachliteratur im Preussenland bis 1500: Untersuchungen zu ihrer Überlieferung (Cologne, 2003), 273–4Google Scholar, with a discussion of the work of Boockmann.

15 Danziger Ordenschronik, SRP, vol. IV, 366–83. It is not the only chronicle from an urban perspective, but it is the only one that not only deals with the immediate history of the Thirteen Year War, but also addresses the earlier events of interest for this study. See Heckmann, M., ‘Krieg und historische Erinnerung im landesherrlichen und im städtischen Milieu des Hanseraums’, in Czaja, R. (ed.), Das Bild und die Wahrnehmung der Stadt und der städtischen Gesellschaft im Hanseraum im Mittelalter und in der Frühen Neuzeit (Toruń, 2004), 115–62, at 145–6Google Scholar. Danziger Ordenschronik is said to have been a major source for the chronicle by the Dominican Simon Grunau, who tells the story of the 1411 and 1416 riots in a version closely resembling the one in the later chronicles from Gdansk, particularly the Wartzmann chronicle. Simon Grunau's Preussische Chronik; Bd. 2: Tractat 15/22, ed. M. Perlbach et al. (Leipzig, 1889), 10–13, at 42–4.

16 The SRP, vol. IV, edition includes only parts of the text, which has survived in six manuscripts. See Arnold, U., Studien zur preußischen Historiographie des 16. Jahrhunderts (Bonn, 1967)Google Scholar; further references can also be found in Heckmann, ‘Krieg’, 145.

17 Heinrich von Reden (also: Rheden), Preußische Chronik, Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Berlin (Stabi), MS boruss., fol. 176; see Arnold, Studien, 87–150, about the relationship between the Reden chronicle and a now lost version from the library of Oberlandesgericht Celle.

18 Stabi, MS boruss., fol. 255, no author or date are given in the catalogue.

19 Stabi, MS boruss., fol. 175. The older version of the Wartzmann chronicle from around 1543 is included in MS boruss., fol. 691, in a seventeenth-century edition. MS boruss., fol. 175, also includes a copy of the Eberhart Ferber-Buch.

20 See a typologization of sixteenth-century urban historiography in Mentzel-Reuters, A., ‘Danziger Historiographie des 16. Jahrhunderts’, in Beckmann, S. and Garber, K. (eds.), Kulturgeschichte Preußens königlich polnischen Anteils in der Frühen Neuzeit (Tübingen, 2005), 99–128Google Scholar; criticism of the SRP edition and of the assignment of the chronicles to Wartzmann and Ferber, ibid., 107–9.

21 All of the chronicles mentioned are different versions of a complex of interconnected texts; both the entire chronicles and their single elements reappear in other manuscripts, mainly in the collections in the Staatsbibliothek Berlin and the Biblioteka Gdańska Polskiej Akademii Nauk (earlier: Stadtbibliothek Danzig). Their mutual relationship has not been the subject of research.

22 ‘Die Chronik des Johann von Posilge’, ed. M. Toeppen, SRP, vol. III, 326–7 (1410–11) and 361–2 (1416).

23 The Ältere Hochmeisterchronik has an extremely complicated tradition. 10 pre-1500 manuscripts have survived, in six different classes. Only one manuscript from Gdansk includes a description of the uprising. See the list of manuscripts in Päsler, Sachliteratur, 292–3.

24 Geheimes Staatsarchiv Preußischer Kulturbesitz Berlin (GSTA), XX. HA, OBA 1522 [Apr. 1411?].

25 GSTA, XX. HA, OBA 239, 28 Aug. 1416.

26 Dumolyn, J. and Haemers, J., ‘“A bad chicken was brooding”: subversive speech in late medieval Flanders’, Past and Present, 214 (2012), 45–86, at 54 and 58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Justice, S., Writing and Rebellion: England in 1381 (Berkeley, 1996), 208Google Scholar.

28 Eberhart Ferber-Buch, fol. 9r–9v.

29 ‘Bericht über den Knochenhauer-Aufstand im Jahre 1384’, ChrondtSt 26, 353.

30 Schayes (ed.), Dagboek der Gentsche Collatie, 66.

31 The descriptions of the events include details about the victims being lured to the castle, the number of wounds inflicted when they were killed and the wine and food sent to the castle, by the families who believed the men to be imprisoned there. Danziger Ordenschronik, SRP, vol. IV, 377; Wartzmann-Chronik, fol. 71r; Eberhart Ferber-Buch, fol. 9r–9v.

32 Czaja, R., ‘Der Handel des Deutschen Ordens und der Städte’, in Nowak, (ed.), Ritterorden und Region – politische, soziale und wirtschaftliche Verbindungen im Mittelalter (Toruń, 1995), 111–23, at 115Google Scholar.

33 M. Biskup, ‘Rewolta pospólstwa gdańskiego w 1416 r. Nowe elementy w stosunkach społecznych i ustrojowych miasta’, in Cieślak (ed.), Historia Gdańska, vol. I, 554–65, at 555.

34 Heinrich von Reden, Preußische Chronik, fol. 105v.

35 ‘Ihr sollet die müntze nemen, vnd soltet ihr euch auch zum ersten hindter den ohren krawen.’ Wartzmann-Chronik, fols. 70v–71r.

36 Krantz, Wandalia, liber 13, cap. 29, p. 468.

37 ‘Dosulves stund up ein grot vordreet in der stad to Dantzke in Prutzen tusschenn deme rade und der menheit. Dat orsakede sick van der munte.’ Rufuschronik, SRP, vol. III, 407.

38 SRP, vol. III, 361.

39 Hoffmann, E., ‘Lübeck im Hoch- und Spätmittelalter: Die groBe Zeit Lübecks’ in GraBmann, A. (ed.), Lübeckische Geschichte (Lübeck, 2008), 81–339, at 244–9Google Scholar.

40 Raape, H., ‘Der Hamburger Aufstand im Jahre 1483’, Zeitschrift des Vereins für Hamburgische Geschichte, 45 (1959), 1–64Google Scholar. Lorenzen-Schmidt, K. presents the same basic information, with a focus on the latter part of the conflict, in ‘Von “bösen” und “frommen” Leuten. Der Hamburger Aufstand von 1483’, in Berlin, J., Das andere Hamburg. Freiheitliche Bestrebungen in der Hansestadt seit dem Spätmittelalter (Cologne, 1982), 24–35Google Scholar.

41 ‘Des Bürgermeisters Herman Langebek Bericht’.

42 Schayes (ed.), Dagboek der Gentsche collatie, 66; Serrure and Blommaert (eds.), Kronyke van Vlaenderen, 115.

43 ‘. . . eyn gros rumor und offlouff zcu Danczk zcwoschin der gemeyne und dem rate . . . und das commune liff off das rathus, und underwand sich, was do was, und das povel liff vor Gerkin hus van der Beke, und nomen dorus, was si fundin, und begingin grosin frebil’. SRP, vol. III, 326–7.

44 Watts, J., ‘Public or plebs: the changing meaning of “the Commons”, 1381–1549’, in Pryce, H. and Watts, J., Power and Identity in the Middle Ages: Essays in Memory of Rees Davies (Oxford, 2007), 242–60, at 259CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 ‘. . . folgeden vele fruwen unde mannen ut der stat, de een deel weldiglich mede int kloster drungenden, een deel auer de muren stegen und vor dem kapitelhuse grot ungestum dreuen mit worden und werken . . . des heren bisschoffes capellan . . . wart . . . van velen und sundriges van Catharinen Arends ser unduchtigen mit höneliken, schändlichen worden afgerichtet und dorch lichting der kleder int achterdeel gewiset’. ‘Des Bürgermeisters Herman Langebek Bericht’, 342.

46 Haemers, Gentse opstand, 195–204.

47 ‘Den vorseiden ledichganc gheduerde iij weeken, ende up den xxj ten dach, welc was den xvjten dach van Novembre, doen ghinc men in de wapenen ter marct met den banieren, omtrent den xj hueren voer der noenen, ende ‘s achternoens omtrent den iiij hueren schieden sy van der marct, ende ginc elc sijns weghs. Up den selven dach soe wordden ter marct ghecoren iiij personen, omme daer uut te makene eenen rechtere in de steede van den bailli.’ Serrure and Blommaert (eds.), Kronyke van Vlaenderen, 115.

48 Hergemöller, B., Uplop – Seditio: Innerstädtische Unruhen des 14. und 15. Jahrhunderts im engeren Reichsgebiet; schematisierte vergleichende Konfliktanalyse (Hamburg, 2012), 101, 107, 206Google Scholar.

49 Trexler, R., Public Life in Renaissance Florence (New York, 1980), 335Google Scholar.

50 Eberhart Ferber-Buch, fol. 9v.

51 Schiller, K. and Lübben, A. (eds.), Mittelniederdeutsches Wörterbuch, vol. V (Bremen, 1880), 344–5Google Scholar.

52 Arnade, P.J., Beggars, Iconoclasts, and Civic Patriots: The Political Culture of the Dutch Revolt (Ithaca, 2008), 331–2Google Scholar.