Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-9pm4c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T09:12:23.738Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Debates on Autochthonous and Allochthonous Origin of Coal: Empirical Science versus the Diluvialists

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 July 2017

Robert A. Gastaldo
Robert A. Gastaldo*
Affiliation:
Department of Geology, Colby College, 5820 Mayflower Hill, Waterville, ME 04901
Get access

Abstract

Coal is the most abundant fossil fuel resource, acting as a terrestrial carbon sink since the evolution of forests in the Late Devonian. Debate concerning its accumulation began centuries ago when naturalists ascribed its formation to catastrophism associated with the Genesis Flood. With empirical data derived from both modern peat accumulations and ancient coal deposits in the mid-to-late 19th Century, the general scientific community developed a set of criteria upon which to demonstrate the autochthonous (in situ) nature of most peat accumulations. At the same time, adherents to the teachings of Ellen G. White, the Seventh Day Adventist leader, and George McCready Price continued to propagate the idea that our global coal (and oil) reserves were the result of the Noachian Flood. In Price's model, adapted and changed by recent creationists, all continents were denuded by strong tidal activity inherent in the Flood waters. Rafts of floating vegetation were transported to ocean basins where they sank en masse, forming coal deposits, with subsequent burial by siliciclastics and limestones derived from the erosion of alternative source areas. The alternation of vegetation mats derived from one source area and sediments derived from another throughout the year of the Flood accounted for the stratigraphic sequence in coal-bearing strata.

Type
Creationism and Flood Geology
Information
The Paleontological Society Papers , Volume 5: The Evolution-Creation Controversy II: Perspectives on Science, Religion, and Geological Education , October 1999 , pp. 135 - 167
Copyright
Copyright © 1999 by The Paleontological Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Allen, B.J. 1942. The geologic age of the Mississippi River with a presentation of basic factors pertaining to age-estimates of river deltas. The Bulletin of Deluge Geology and Related Sciences, 2:49–63.Google Scholar
Austin, S.A. 1979. Depositional environment of the Kentucky No. 12 coal bed (Middle Pennsylvanian) of western Kentucky, with special reference to the origin of coal lithotype. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, The Pennsylvania State University, College Park, 411 p.Google Scholar
Austin, S.A. 1980. Depositional environment of mummified bark sheets in the Kentucky No. 12 coal bed. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Program, 12(7):380.Google Scholar
Austin, S.A. 1986. Mount St. Helens and Catastrophism. Vital Articles on Science/Creation. ICR Impact No. 57. (http://www.icr.org/pubs/imp/imp-157.htm)Google Scholar
Austin, S.A. 1991. Floating logs and log deposits of Spirit Lake, Mount St. Helens Volcano National Monument, Washington. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Program, 23(5):85.Google Scholar
Bischof, G. 1837. Die Wärmelehre des Innern unsers Erdkörpers microform: ein Inbegriff aller mit der Wärme in Beziehung stehender Erscheinungen in und auf der Erde / nach physikalischen, chemischen und geologischen Untersuchungen von Gustav Bischof. J.A. Barth, Leipzig, 512 p.Google Scholar
Breyer, J.A. 1997. Sequence stratigraphy of Gulf Coast lignite, Wilcox Group (Paleogene), South Texas. Journal of Sedimentary Research, 67A:1018–1029.Google Scholar
Buckland, W. 1820. Vindiciæ geologicæ, or The connexion of geology with religion explained in an inaugural lecture delivered before University of Oxford, May 15, 1819, on the endowment of readership in geology. University Press for the author, 38 p.Google Scholar
de Buffon, L. 1798. Histoire naturelle, generate et particuliére: théorie de la terre et époque de la nature, Dufart, Paris.Google Scholar
Cairncross, B., Stanistreet, I.G., McCarthy, T.S., Ellery, W.N., Ellery, K. and Grobicki, T.S.A. Palaeochannels (stone-rolls) in coal seams; modern analogues from fluvial deposits of the Okavango Delta, Botswana, Southern Africa. Sedimentary Geology. 57:107–118.Google Scholar
Calder, J.H. 1998. The Carboniferous evolution of Nova Scotia, p. 261–302. In Blundell, D.J. and Scott, A.C., (eds.), Lyell: the Past is the Key to the Present. Geological Society (London) Special Publication 143.Google Scholar
Clark, H.W. 1946. The New Diluvialism. Science Publications, Angwin, California, 222 p.Google Scholar
Coffin, H.G. 1987. Sonar and scuba survey of a submerged allochthonous “forest” in Spirit Lake, Washington. PALAIOS, 2:178–180.Google Scholar
Cohen, A.D. 1984. The Okefenokee Swamp. A low sulfur end-member of a shoreline-related depositional model for coastal plain coals, p. 231–240. In Rahmani, R.A. and Flores, R.M., (eds.), Sedimentology of Coal and Coal-bearing Sequences. Special Publication of the International Association of Sedimentologists, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.Google Scholar
Covington, D. and Raymond, A. 1988. Taxonomic uniformitarianism: The problem with shoot/root ratios of peats. Review of Paleobotany and Palynology, 58:85–94.Google Scholar
Cross, A.T. 1971. The Geology of the Pittsburgh Coal. West Virginia Geological and Economic Survey, Report of Investigations, No. 10, 80 p.Google Scholar
Dawson, J.W. 1859. On the vegetable structure in coal. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 15:626–641.Google Scholar
Dawson, J.W. 1866. On conditions of the deposition of coal, more especially as illustrated by the coal formations of Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 22:95–104.Google Scholar
Dawson, J.W. 1868. Acadian Geology. The Geologic Structure, Organic Remains, and Mineral Resources of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island, 2nd edition, MacMillan and Co. London, 694 p.Google Scholar
Dean, W.E., and Arthur, M.A., eds., 1998. Stratigraphy and Paleoenvironments of the Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, USA. SEPM Concepts in Sedimentology and Paleontology No. 6, 255 p.Google Scholar
Demko, T.M. and Gastaldo, R.A. 1992. Paludal environments of the Lower Mary Lee coal zone, Pottsville Formation, Alabama: Stacked clastic swamps and peat mires. International Journal of Coal Geology, 20:23–47.Google Scholar
DiMichele, W.A. and DeMaris, P.J. 1987. Structure and dynamics of a Pennsylvanian-age Lepidodendron forest: Colonizers of a disturbed swam habitat in the Herrin (No. 6) coal of Illinois. PALAIOS, 2:146–157.Google Scholar
DiMichele, W.A., Eble, C.F., and Chaney, D.S. 1996. A drowned lycopsid forest above the Mahoning coal (Conemaugh Group, Upper Pennsylvanian) in eastern Ohio, U.S.A. International Journal of Coal Geology, 31:249–276.Google Scholar
Eble, C.F. 1996. Paleoecology of Pennsylvanian Coal Beds in the Appalachian Basin, 3:1143–1156. In Jansonius, J. and McGregor, D.C., (eds.), Palynology: Principles, and Applications. American Association of Stratigraphic Palynologists Foundation, Houston, Texas.Google Scholar
Eble, C.F., Gastaldo, R.A., Demko, T.M., and Liu, Y. 1994. Coal compositional changes along a swamp interior to swamp margin transect in the Mary Lee Coal bed, Warrior Basin, Alabama, U.S.A. International Journal of Coal Geology, 26:43–62.Google Scholar
Einsele, G., Ricken, W., and Seilacher, A., (eds.), 1991. Cycles and Events in Stratigraphy. Springer Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 955 p.Google Scholar
Elsik, W.C. 1978. Palynology of Gulf Coast lignites, the stratigraphic framework and depositional environments, p. 21–32. In Kaiser, W.R., (ed.), Proceedings of the Gulf Coast Lignite Conference. Geology, Utilization and Environmental Aspects. Austin, TX, University of Texas Bureau of Economic Geology, Report of Investigations, No. 90.Google Scholar
Fayol, H. 1887. Études sur le terrain houille de Commentry. Bulletin Geologié Societé France, 3me Ser. 16:968–978.Google Scholar
Ferguson, A.B. 1975. Plant Dormancy. A key to the past. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 12:108, 127.Google Scholar
Finkelman, R.B., and Casagrande, D.J., (eds.) 1986. Geology of Gulf Coast lignites. Environmental and Coal Associates, Houston, TX, 224 p.Google Scholar
Frederiksen, N.O. 1985. Review of Early Tertiary Sporomorph Paleoecology. American Association of Stratigraphic Palynologists Contribution Series, No. 12, 109 p.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1984. A case against pelagochthony. The untenability of Carboniferous arborescent lycopod-dominated floating peat mats, p. 97–116. In Walker, K.R., (ed.), The Evolution-Creation Controversy. Perspectives on Religion, Philosophy, Science and Education. The Paleontological Society, Special Publication No. 1.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1986a. Implications on the paleoecology of autochthonous Carboniferous lycopods in clastic sedimentary environments. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology and Palaeoecology, 53:191–212.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1986b. An explanation for lycopod configuration, ‘Fossil Grove’ Victoria Park, Glasgow. Scottish Journal of Geology, 22:77–83.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1990. Early Pennsylvanian swamp forests in the Mary Lee coal zone, Warrior Basin, Alabama, p. 41–54. In Gastaldo, R.A., Demko, T.M., and Liu, Y., (eds.), Carboniferous coastal environments and paleocommunities of the Mary Lee coal zone, Marion and Walker Counties, Alabama. A Guidebook for Field Trip VI, 39th Annual Meeting Southeastern Section of the Geological Society of America, Tuscaloosa, Alabama. Geological Survey of Alabama.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1992. Regenerative growth in fossil horsetails (Calamites) following burial by Alluvium. Historical Biology, 6:203–220.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A. 1994. The genesis and sedimentation of phytoclasts with examples from coastal environments, p. 103–127. In Traverse, A., (ed.), Sedimentation of Organic Particles. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A., Allen, G.P., and Huc, A.Y. 1993. Detrital peat formation in the tropical Mahakam River delta, Kalimantan, eastern Borneo: Formation, plant composition, and geochemistry, In Cobb, J.C. and Cecil, C. B., (eds.), Modern and Ancient Coal-forming Environments, Geological Society of America Special Paper 286:107–118.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A., Demko, T.M., and Liu, Y. 1993. The application of sequence and genetic stratigraphic concepts to Carboniferous coal-bearing strata: An example from the Black Warrior basin, USA. Geologische Rundschau, 82:212–226.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A., Pfefferkorn, H.W. and DiMichele, W.A. 1995. Taphonomic and Sedimentologic Characterization of “Roof-Shale” floras, In Lyons, P., Wagner, R.H., and Morey, E., (eds.), Historical Perspective of Early Twentieth Century Carboniferous Paleobotany in North America, Geological Society of America Memoir 185:341–352.Google Scholar
Gastaldo, R.A., Demko, T.M., Liu, Y., Keefer, W.D., and Abston, S.L. 1989. Biostratinomic processes for the development of of mud-cast logs in Carboniferous and Holocene swamps. PALAIOS, 4:356–365.Google Scholar
Grand 'Eury, G. 1882. Memoire sur la formation de la houille. Annales des Mines, 8:101–122.Google Scholar
Gümbel, C.W.V. 1883. Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Texturverhältnisse der Mineralkohlen. Sitz.-Ber. K. bayer Akademie Wissenschaften, München, p. 111–121.Google Scholar
Kidd, J. 1815. A Geological Essay on the Imperfect Evidences in Support of a Theory of the Earth, Oxford, 269 p.Google Scholar
Kosters, E.C. and Bailey, A. 1983. Characteristics of peat deposits in the Mississippi River deltaic plain. Transactions of the Gulf Coast Geological Societies, 33:311–325.Google Scholar
Kuntze, O. 1895. Geogenetische Beitrage. Sind Carbonkohlen autochthon, allochthon oder pelagochthon?. Leipzig, Germany, 77 p.Google Scholar
Le Bel, P.G. 1995. Energy Economics and Technology. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 573 p.Google Scholar
Lemiére, L. 1905. Formation et recherches companies des divers combustibles fossiles. Bulletin Societé de l'Industrial Minereaux, 4me, Ser. IV, 5:70–142.Google Scholar
MacRae, A. 1997. “Polystrate” Tree Fossils. The Talk. Origins Archive (http://www.ics.uci.edu/faqs/polystrate/trees.html)Google Scholar
McCabe, P.J. 1984. Depositional Environments of Coal, p. 13–42. In Rahmani, R.A. and Flores, R.M., (eds.), Sedimentology of Coal and Coal-hearing Sequences. Special Publication of the International Association of Sedimentologists, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.Google Scholar
McCall, E. 1984. Conquering the Rivers, Henry Mill Shreve and the Navigation of America's Inland Waterways Louisiana State University Press, Baton Rouge, 253 p.Google Scholar
McCall, E. 1988. The attack on the great raft. American Heritage of Invention and Technology, Winter 1988, p. 10–16.Google Scholar
McCarthy, T.S., Stanistreet, I.B., and Cairncross, B. 1991. The sedimentary dynamics of active fluvial channels on the Okavango Fan, Botswana. Sedimentology. 38:471–487.Google Scholar
Moore, L.R. 1968. Cannel coals, bogtheads and oil shales, p. 19–29, In Murchison, D.G. and Westoll, T.S., (eds.), Coal and Coal-bearing Strata, Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Morris, H.M. 1974. Scientific Creationism. Creation-Life Publishers, San Diego, California, 217 p.Google Scholar
Morris, H.M. 1995. What are “Polystrate” Fossils?. Vital Articles on Science/Creation, ICR BTG No 81b. (http://www.icr.org/pubs/btg-b/btg-081b.htm)Google Scholar
Morris, H.M. and Parker, G.E. 1982. What is Creation Science?. Creation-Life Publishers, Inc. San Diego, California, 306 p.Google Scholar
Mosbrugger, V, Gee, C.T., Belz, G., and Ashraf, A.R. 1994. Three-dimensional reconstruction of an in-situ Miocene peat forest from the Lower Rhine Embayment, northwestern Germany; new methods in palaeovegetation analysis. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 110: 295–317.Google Scholar
Nelson, B.C. 1927. After Its Kind. The First and Last Word on Evolution. Augsburg Publishing House, Minneapolis, Minnesota, 190 p.Google Scholar
Nevins, S.E. 1971. Stratigraphic evidence of the Flood. Symposium on Creation #III. Baker Book Company, Grand Rapids, p. 44–46.Google Scholar
Nevins, S.E. 1976. The Origin of Coal. Vital Articles on Science/Creation, ICR Impact No. 41. (http://www.icr.org/pubs/imp/imp-041.htm)Google Scholar
Numbers, R.L. 1992. The Creationists. Alfred A. Knopf, New York, New York, 458 p.Google Scholar
Panshin, A.J. and De Zeeuw, C. 1970. Textbook of Wood Technology, Vol. 1, McGraw Hill, New York, New York, 643 p.Google Scholar
Pashin, J.C. 1994. Cycles and stacking patterns in Carboniferous rocks of the Black Warrior foreland basin, In Major, R.P., (ed.), Transactions of the Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies, 44:555–563.Google Scholar
Petzholdt, A. 1845. Geologie. Leipzig, 645 p.Google Scholar
Petzholdt, A. 1882. Beitrag zur Kenntniss der Steinkohlenbildung Nebst Kritik des Werkes. Leipzig, Germany.Google Scholar
Potonié, H. 1895. Über Autochthonie von Carbonkohlen-Flötzen und des Senftenberger Braunkohlen-Flötzes. Jahrbuch d. k. preuss. Geologie Landesanstalt für 1895, 31 p.Google Scholar
Potonié, H. 1899. Die Merkmale alllochthoner palaeozoischeer Pflanzen-Ablagerungen. Naturwissenschaft Wochenschrift, 14:81–82.Google Scholar
Potonié, H. 1909. Die Tropen-Sumpffachmoor-Natur der Moore des Produktiven Karbons. Jarbuch der Konigl. Presuss. Geologie Landesamt, 30(3):389–443.Google Scholar
Price, G.Mc. 1906. Illogical Geology: The weakest point in the Evolution Theory. The Modern Heretic Company, Los Angeles, 93 p.Google Scholar
Price, G.Mc. 1923. The New Geology. Pacific Press, Mountain View, California, 462 p.Google Scholar
Price, G.Mc. 1943. Some cyclic phenomena in stratigraphic geology. The Bulletin of Creation, the Deluge and Related Science, 3:9–20.Google Scholar
Raymond, A., 1987. Interpreting ancient swamp communities: Can we see the forest in the peat? Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology, 52:217–231.Google Scholar
Raymond, A. Phillips, M.K. and Gennett, J.A. and Comet, P.A. 1997. Palynology and paleoecology of lignites from the Manning Formation (Jackson Group) outcrop in the Lake Somerville Spillway of east-central Texas. International Journal of Coal Geology, 34:195–223.Google Scholar
Rich, R.J. 1982. Modern wetlands and their potential as coal-forming environments. AAPG Bulletin. 66:1682–1683.Google Scholar
Rich, F.J. 1988. A review of the taphonomy of plant remains in lacustrine sediments. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology, 58:33–46.Google Scholar
Rogers, H.D. 1843. An inquiry into the origin of the Appalachian coal strata, bituminous and anthracite. Reports of the American Association of Geologists and Naturalists, Boston, p. 434–467.Google Scholar
Rupke, N.A. 1966. Prolegomena to a study of cataclysmal sedimentation. Creation Research Science Quarterly, 3:16–37.Google Scholar
Rupke, N.A., 1969, Sedimentary Evidence for the Allochthonous Origin of Stigmaria, Carboniferous Nova Scotia. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 80:2109–2114.Google Scholar
Rusch, W.H. 1991. Origins. What is at Stake?. Creation Research Society Books, Kansas City, Missouri, 73 p.Google Scholar
Russell, R.J. 1942. Flotant. Geography Review, 32:74–98.Google Scholar
Scheven, J. 1979. Floating forests on firm ground. Advances in Carboniferous Research. 15th Annual Convention Bible-Science Association, Anaheim, California, p. 187–189.Google Scholar
Scheven, J. 1980a. Karbon studien 3. Hohe Sedimentation straten der Zwischengestene. Factum, January, p. 30–33.Google Scholar
Scheven, J. 1980b. Karbon studien 6. Die Seimentatur der songenannten wurzelboden. Factum, June, p. 10–16.Google Scholar
Schobert, H.H. 1987. Coal. The Energy Source of the Past and Future. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, 298 p.Google Scholar
Sedgwick, A. 1831. Address upon awarding the Wollaston Prize to William Smith. Proceedings of the Geological Society, London, 1:270–280.Google Scholar
Snelling, A. 1986. Coal beds and Noah's Flood. Creation Magazine, 8:20–21.Google Scholar
Stach, E. Mackowsky, M.Th. Teichmüller, M. Taylor, G.H. Chandra, D. and Teichmüller, R. 1982. Stack's textbook of Coal Petrology. Gebrüder Borntraeger, Berlin, Germany, 535 p.Google Scholar
Staub, J.R., and Esterle, J. 1994. Peat accumulating depositional systems of Sarawak, East Malaysia. Sedimentary Geology, 89:91–106.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J.J. 1911a. The Formation of Coal Beds. I. An Historical Summary of Opinion from 1700 to the Present Time. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 50:1–116.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J.J. 1911b. The Formation of Coal Beds. II. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 50:519–643.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J.J. 1912. The Formation of Coal Beds. III. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 51:423–553.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J.J. 1913. The Formation of Coal Beds. IV. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 52:31–162.Google Scholar
Styan, W.B. and Bustin, R.M. 1984. Sedimentology of Frasier River delta peat deposits. A modern analogue for some deltaic coals, p. 241–274. In Rahmani, R.A. and Flores, R.M., (eds.), Sedimentology of Coal and Coal-bearing Sequences. Special Publication of the International Association of Sedimentologists, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.Google Scholar
Teichmüller, R. 1955. Über Kustenmoore der gegenwart und die Moore des RuhrKarbons. Eine vergleichende sedimentologische Betrachtuntg. Geologische Jahrbuch, 71:197–220.Google Scholar
Von Beroldingen, F. 1778. Beobachtungen, Zweifel und Fragen, die Mineralogie betreffend, Erster Versuch, Hannover, 203 p.Google Scholar
Warwick, P.D., SanFilipo, J.R., Crowley, S.S., Thomas, R.E., and Freid, J. 1997. Map showing outcrop of the coal-bearing units and land use in the Gulf Coast Region. U.S. Geological Survey Open FileReport, 97–172.(http://energy.er.usgs.gov/products/openfile/OFR97-172/index.htm)Google Scholar
Whitcomb, J.C. Jr. Morris, H.M. and McCampbell, J.C. 1961. The Genesis Flood The Biblical Record and Its Scientific Implications. The Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Company, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 518 p.Google Scholar
Whitney, D.J. 1937. The possible Antediluvian Origin of coal vegetation. The Creationist, 1:12.Google Scholar
Wiant, H.V. Jr. 1994. A quantitative comparison of the carbon in the biomass and coal beds of the world. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 11:142.Google Scholar
Williams, J. 1789. The natural history of the mineral kingdom. Part I. Of the natural history of the strata of coal, and of the concomitant strata. Thomas Ruddiman, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Williams, J. 1810. The natural history of the mineral kingdom, relative to the strata of coal, mineral veins, and the prevailing strata of the globe. Bell & Bradfute, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Winston, R.B. 1990. Coal-paleobotany of the Mary Lee coal bed of the Pennsylvanian “Pottsville” Formation near Carbon Hill, Walker County, Alabama, p. 55–64. In Gastaldo, R. A., Demko, T.M., and Liu, Y., (eds.), Carboniferous coastal environments and paleocommunities of the Mary Lee coal zone, Marion and Walker counties, Alabama. Alabama Geological Survey.Google Scholar
Winston, R.B., and Phillips, T.L. 1991. A structurally preserved, Lower Pennsylvanian flora from the New Castle Coal Bed of Alabama. Geological Survey of Alabama, Circular 157, 21 p.Google Scholar
Wise, D.U. 1998. Creationism's Geologic Time Scale. American Scientist, 86:160–173.Google Scholar
Wood, G.H. Jr., Kehn, T.M., Carter, M.D., and Culbertson, W.C. 1983. Coal resource classification system of the U.S. Geological Survey, U.S. Geological Survey Circular 891, 45 p.Google Scholar
Woodward, J. 1695. An essay toward a natural history of the earth: and terrestrial bodies, especially minerals: as also of the sea, rivers, and springs. With an account of the universal deluge: and of the effects that it had upon the earth. R. Wilkin, London, 277 p.Google Scholar
Woodward, J. 1702. An Essay Toward a Natural History of the Earth and Terrestrial Bodies. London, 2nd ed. 277 p.Google Scholar