Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-vpsfw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-16T10:50:00.409Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Civilians, Soldiers and Perceptions of the Afterlife in Britain during the First World War

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Michael Snape
Michael Snape*
Affiliation:
University of Birmingham
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

For most educated Britons the First World War is synonymous with death on a massive scale. Although reliable estimates remained elusive for many years (this deceptively straightforward process being complicated by issues such as determining the nationality of the fallen and when to stop counting deaths as war-related), the figures are sobering enough: according to research published in the 1980s, as many as 772,000 Britons died in military service during the First World War. Despite the problems of the statistician, the fact of mass mortality was acutely and painfully obvious to contemporaries, so much so that, in an important essay published in 1981, David Cannadine characterized inter-war Britain as a society that was ‘obsessed with death’. Since 1918, the identification of death with the experience of the First World War has lodged itself deep in the national psyche, spawning the myth of ‘the lost generation’ and dominating the perceptions of posterity. As Dan Todman recently observed:

The terrible cost of the war underpins many of our other received beliefs about it: the incompetence of the generals whose actions resulted in so many lost lives; the purposelessness of any war with such a butcher's bill; and the miraculous veneration of any veteran who managed to survive the carnage.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 45: The Church, the Afterlife and the Fate of the Soul , 2009 , pp. 371 - 403
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2009

References

1 Todman, D., The Great War: Myth and Memory (London, 2005), 44.Google Scholar

2 Cannadine, D., ‘War and Death, Grief and Mourning in Modern Britain’, in Whaley, J., ed., Mirrors of Mortality: Studies in the Social History of Death (London, 1981), 187–242, at 189, 230.Google Scholar

3 Todman, , Great War, 44.Google Scholar

4 As many as 2,270,000, although many soldiers were wounded more than once; Rawson, A., ed., The British Army Handbook 1914–1918 (Stroud, 2006), 349.Google Scholar

5 Middlebrook, M., Your Country Needs You (Barnsley, 2000), 134 Google Scholar; Todman, , Great War, 44–45 Google Scholar; Winter, J. M., The Experience of World War I (London, 2006), 207.Google Scholar

6 Todman, , Great War, 46 Google Scholar; MacLeod, J. L., ‘“Greater Love Hath No Man Than This”: Scotland’s Conflicting Religious Responses to Death in the Great War’, ScHR 81 (2002), 70–96, at 70.Google Scholar

7 Bond, B., The Unquiet Western Front: Britain’s Role in Literature and History (Cambridge, 2002), 65 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Todman, , Great War, 46 Google Scholar; Lee, S., Rural Society and the Anglican Clergy, 1815-1914 (Woodbridge, 2006), 190–91 Google Scholar; Office, War, Statistics of the Military Effort of the British Empire Duringlhe Great War (London, 1922; repr. London, 1992), 29, 237.Google Scholar

8 Todman, , Great War, 67.Google Scholar

9 Ibid. 45.

10 Wilkinson, A., The Church of England and the First World War (London, 1978), 169.Google Scholar

11 Strachan, H., The First World War, Volume I: To Arms (Oxford, 2001), 230 Google Scholar; Clayton, A., Paths of Glory: the French Army 1914–18 (London, 2005), 140.Google Scholar

12 Wilkinson, , Church of England, 196.Google Scholar

13 Cannadine, , ‘War and Death’, 218–19.Google Scholar

14 Ibid. 219.

15 See, in this volume, Byrne, Georgina, ‘“Angels Seen Today”: The Theology of Modern Spiritualism and its Impact on Church of England Clergy, 1852–1939’, 360–70.Google Scholar

16 See, for example, Doyle, A. Conan, The History of Spiritualism, 2 vols (London, 1926), 1: 224–45.Google Scholar

17 Simkins, P., ‘The Four Armies 1914–1918’, in Chandler, D. and Beckett, I., eds, The Oxford Illustrated History of the British Army (Oxford, 1994), 235–57, at 241.Google Scholar

18 Wood, H. G., ‘The Middle Classes’, in Clarke, W. K. Lowther, ed., Facing the Facts: Or, an Englishman’s Religion (London, 1911), 55–87, at 70–71.Google Scholar

19 Emmet, C. W., ‘The Bible and Hell’, in Streeter, B. H., ed., Immortality: An Essay in Discovery, Co-ordinating Scientific, Psychical and Biblical Research (London, 1917), 167–217, at 208.Google Scholar

20 Campbell, R. J., The New Theology (London, 1907), 8–9.Google Scholar

21 Parsons, G., ‘Victorian Britain’s Other Establishment: The Transformation of Scottish Presbyterianism’, in idem, ed., Religion in Victorian Britain. Volume 1: Traditions (Manchester, 1988), 117–45, at 127–29.Google Scholar

22 Macmillan, D., ‘Scotland’, in Clarke, Lowther, ed., Facing the Facts, 223–50, at 228–30.Google Scholar

23 McLeod, H., Class and Religion in the Late Victorian City (London, 1974), 69–70, 226 Google Scholar; Brown, C., Religion ana Society in Scotland since 1707 (Edinburgh, 1997), 30–31 Google Scholar; MacLeod, , ‘“Greater Love”’, 93–94.Google Scholar

24 Rowell, G., Hell and the Victorians (Oxford, 1974), 163–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

25 Ibid. 172–73; Hill, J. A., ed., Letters from Sir Oliver Lodge (London, 1932), 82–83.Google Scholar

26 Litton, E. A., Introduction to Dogmatic Theology on the Basis of the Thirty-Nine Articles (London, 1912), 542.Google Scholar

27 Ibid. 308, 540–42.

28 Gore, C., The Religion of the Church as Presented in the Church of England (London, 1916), v.Google Scholar

29 Ibid. 91–92.

30 Ibid. 93–95.

31 Rowell, , Hell and the Victorians, 99–100.Google Scholar

32 Yates, N., Anglican Ritualism in Victorian Britain 1830–1910 (Oxford, 1999), 278–79.Google Scholar

33 Bell, G. K. A., Randall Davidson: Archbishop of Canterbury, 2 vols (Oxford, 1935), 2: 830–31 n. 2.Google Scholar

34 Gore, , Religion of the Church, 96–97.Google Scholar

35 Campbell, R.J., The War and the Soul (London, 1916), 14.Google Scholar

36 Snell, B. J., ‘If Only They Had Remained!’, in Hastings, F., ed., Our Boys Beyond the Shadow (London, 1917), 35–44, at 43–44.Google Scholar

37 Bell, , Randall Davidson, 2: 828–30.Google Scholar

38 ‘What Lancashire Thinks’, The Guardian, 2 August 1917, 582, and 9 August 1917,609.

39 Forms of Thanksgiving to Almighty God to be used on Sunday, the 17th November, 1918: Being the Sunday after the Cessation of Hostilities between the Allied Powers and the German Empire. Issued under the Authority of the Archbishops of Canterbury and York (London, 1918), 2.

40 Wilkinson, , Church of England, 82–84, 178.Google Scholar

41 Brown, S. J., ‘“A Solemn Purification By Fire”: Responses to the Great War in the Scottish Presbyterian Churches, 1914–19’, JEH 45 (1994), 82–104, at 94.Google Scholar

42 Maclean, N. and Sclater, J. R. P., God and the Soldier (London, 1917), 206–08.Google Scholar

43 MacLeod, , ‘“Greater Love”’, 94.Google Scholar

44 Ibid. 87.

45 Thurston, H., ‘Communicating with the Dead’, The Month, February 1917, 134–44, at 134–44 at 134 Google Scholar

46 ‘Extracts from Sir Oliver Lodge’s Presidential Address’, Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, November 1913, 132–44, at 144.

47 ‘Life After Death’, The Guardian, 15 February 1917, 133.

48 ‘Evil Spirits’, The Guardian, 22 February 1917, 155.

49 Mews, S. P., ‘Religion and English Society in the First World War’ (unpublished Ph. D. thesis, Cambridge University, 1973), 74.Google Scholar

50 Gillie, R. C., ‘Is Purgatory Necessary?’, in Hastings, , ed., Our Boys Beyond the Shadow, 175–86, at 178.Google Scholar

51 Brodie-Innes, J. W., ‘Psychic Help for Soldiers and Sailors’, Occult Review, April 1918, 211–21, at 216–17.Google Scholar

52 Winter, J. M., ‘Spiritualism and the First World War’, in Davis, R. W. and Helmstadter, R. J., eds, Religion and Irreligion in Victorian Society (London, 1992), 185–200, at 193.Google Scholar

53 ‘Spiritualism’, Report of the Church Congress (London, 1920), 146–75, at 154, 161–62.

54 Ibid. 162; W. F. Barrett, On The Threshold of the Unseen (London, 1917), 8–9.

55 Cooper, D., Haig (London, 1935), 114.Google Scholar

56 DeGroot, G., ‘“We are safe whatever happens” – Douglas Haig, the Reverend George Duncan, and the Conduct of War, 1916–1918’, in MacDougal, N., ed., Scotland and War (Edinburgh, 1991), 193–211, at 193.Google Scholar

57 Holmes, R., The Little Field Marshal: A Life of Sir John French (London, 2005), 276–77.Google Scholar

58 Jones, E. H., The Road to En-Dor (London, 1920).Google Scholar

59 Ibid. x.

60 Owen, A., The Darkened Room (London, 1989), 8, 10.Google Scholar

61 Nelson, G. K., Spiritualism and Society (London, 1969), 143–47.Google Scholar

62 Cairns, D. S., The Army and Religion (London, 1919), vi, 19–20.Google Scholar

63 Ibid. 74.

64 Geare, W. D., Letters of an Army Chaplain (London, 1918), 84–85 Google Scholar; Worsley, F. W., ‘Beliefs Emphasised by the War’, in MacNutt, F. B., ed., The Church in the Furnace: Essays by Seventeen Temporary Church of England Chaplains on Active Service in France and Flanders (London, 1917), 71–96, at 93–95.Google Scholar

65 Maclean, and Sclater, , God and the Soldier, 181.Google Scholar

66 MacFadyen, D., Our Mess: Mess Table Talks in France (London, 1917), 114–15.Google Scholar

67 Maclean, and Sclater, , God and the Soldier, 182.Google Scholar

68 Cairns, , Army and Religion, 18.Google Scholar

69 Ibid. 19.

70 Brophy, J. and Partridge, E., eds, The Long Trail: Soldiers’ Songs and Slang 1914–18 (London, 1969), 46, 48.Google Scholar

71 Maclean, and Sclater, , God and the Soldier, 202.Google Scholar

72 Hankey, D., A Student in Arms (London, 1918), 103–04.Google Scholar

73 Candole, A. De, The Faith of a Subaltern: Essays on Religion and Life (Cambridge, 1919), 72–73.Google Scholar

74 Hannay, J. O., ‘Man To Man’, in MacNutt, , ed., Church in the Furnace, 335–46, at 340.Google Scholar

75 Maclean, and Sclater, , God and the Soldier, 109.Google Scholar

76 London, Imperial War Museum, Department of Documents, P239 W. B. St Leger (every effort has been made to trace the copyright holder, and the author and the Imperial War Museum would be very grateful for any information which may enable them to do so).

77 Richards, F., Old Soldiers Never Die (London, 1983), 97.Google Scholar

78 ‘A Padre’, ‘The Religion of the Man at the Front’, Church Times, 13 July 1917, 33.

79 London, Imperial War Museum, Department of Documents, 80/22/1, E. C. Crosse (every effort has been made to trace the copyright holder, and the author and the Imperial War Museum would be very grateful for any information which may enable them to do so).

80 Creighton, L., ed., Letters of Oswin Creighton, C. F. 1883–1918 (London, 1920), 130.Google Scholar

81 Kennedy, G. A. Studdert, The Hardest Part (London, 1018), 172–73.Google Scholar

82 Kennedy, G. A. Studdert, Rough Rhymes of a Padre (London, 1918), 45–46 Google Scholar; see also, in the same volume, ‘Well?’, ‘To-day Thou shalt be with Me’ and ‘Judgment’.

83 Snape, M., The Royal Army Chaplains’ Department, 1796-1953; Clergy Under Fire (Woodbridge, 2008), 178.Google Scholar

84 Blackburne, H. W., This Also Happened on the Western Front (London, 1932), 32.Google Scholar

85 Birmingham, University of Birmingham, CMS Archives, XACC /i 8/F/1/51, Diaries of L. H. Gwynne, 2 December 1914.

86 Keable, R., Standing By: War- Time Reflections in France and Flanders (London, 1919), 42.Google Scholar

87 White, J., With the Cameronians (Scottish Rifles) in France: Leaves from a Chaplain’s Diary (Glasgow, 1917), 110.Google Scholar

88 MacFadyen, , Our Mess, 123.Google Scholar

89 MacDonald, L., 1914-1918: Voices and Images of the Great War (London, 1991), 179.Google Scholar

90 London, Imperial War Museum, Department of Documents, P310, E. V. Tanner (every effort has been made to trace the copyright holder, and the author and the Imperial War Museum would be very grateful for any information which may enable them to do so); Amport, Andover, Amport House, Royal Army Chaplains’ Department Archive, E. V. Tanner, ‘An Army Chaplain’s Work in War-Time’.

91 Milner-White, E., ‘Worship and Services’, in MacNutt, , ed., Church in the Furnace, 175–210, at 179–81.Google Scholar

92 The National Mission of Repentance and Hope: Reports of the Archbishops’ Committees of Inquiry. The Worship of the Church, being the Report of the Archbishops’ Second Committee of Inquiry (London, 1919), 39.

93 Williams, H. Cernyw, ‘The Fate of those who have Fallen in the War’, Expository Times, April 1919, 329.Google Scholar

94 Mews, , ‘Religion and English Society’, 80.Google Scholar

95 Campbell, , New Theology, 210.Google Scholar

96 ODNB, s. v. ‘Robert Peel Glanville Blatchford’.

97 Stevenson, F. L., ed., Through Terror to Triumph: Speeches and Pronouncements of the Right Hon. David Lloyd George, M. P., since the Beginning of the War (London, 1915), 13.Google Scholar

98 Ibid. 57–58.

99 Haig, D., Haig’s Autograph Great War Diary (microfilm; Brighton, 1987), 15 January 1916.Google Scholar

100 Gough, H., Address Delivered by a well-known Corps Commander to the Chaplains of his Corps in France (London, 1916), 6.Google Scholar

101 London, Imperial War Museum, Department of Documents, 67/180/1, J. B. Mar shall (every effort has been made to trace the copyright holder, and the author and the Imperial War Museum would be very grateful for any information which may enable them to do so).

102 London, King’s College, Liddell Hart Centre for Military Archives, GB99 KCLMA Beddington.

103 Cairns, , Army and Religion, 19.Google Scholar

104 IWM, 80/22/1, E. C. Crosse.

105 Woods, E. S., ‘The Great Adventure’, in MacNutt, , ed., Church in the Furnace, 429–54, at 434.Google Scholar

106 Macfadyen, , Our Mess, 125–26.Google Scholar

107 Brown, M., The Imperial War Museum Book of the First World War (London, 1991), 248.Google Scholar

108 IWM, P310, E.V. Tanner.

109 Birmingham, University of Birmingham, CMS Archives, XACC /18/F/4/4-9, Sermon books of L. H. Gwynne.

110 Macfadyen, , Our Mess, 117.Google Scholar

111 Birmingham, University of Birmingham, CMS Archives, XACC /18/Z/1, Army book of L. H. Gwyrme.

112 Rogers, G., A Rebel at Heart (London, 1956), 125.Google Scholar

113 Worsley, , ‘Beliefs Emphasised by the War’, in MacNutt, , ed., Church in the Furnace, 93.Google Scholar

114 ‘A Padre’, ‘The Religion of the Man at the Front’, 33.

115 Mews, , ‘Religion and English Society’, 206–07.Google Scholar

116 Maclean, and Sclater, , God and the Soldier, 202–03.Google Scholar

117 Robertson, J. D., ‘Question Time in the Hut’, The Red Triangle, November 1918, 103–04, at 104.Google Scholar

118 Ibid.

119 Blacker, J., ed., Have You Forgotten Yet? The First World War Memoirs of C. P. Blacker (Barnsley, 2000), 114.Google Scholar

120 Casgrain, P., The Catholic Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Prayer-Book (London, 1917), 10.Google Scholar

121 O’Rahilly, A., ed., Father William Doyle S. J.: A Spiritual Study (London, 1932), 494–95.Google Scholar

122 IWM, 67/180/1, J. B. Marshall.

123 Brown, , Imperial War Museum Book of the First World War, 249.Google Scholar

124 rWM, 67/180/1, J. B. Marshall.

125 Ibid.

126 O’Rahilly, , ed., Father William Doyle, 509–10.Google Scholar