Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-5g6vh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T00:51:30.868Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Church of America and the Heresy of Peace

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 May 2021

Dominic Erdozain
Dominic Erdozain*
Affiliation:
Emory University
*
*E-mail: dominic@erdozain.net.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

America, said G. K. Chesterton, is a nation with the soul of a church. It is a sacred community commanding sacrificial loyalty. It is also a violent and weapon-loving civilization, in which force is tethered to patriotism and national identity. American culture is at once militarist and theological, Christian and violent. How can this paradox be explained? This article discusses the role of New England puritanism in establishing a providentialist nationalism that would define war as a theological prerogative and non-violence as heresy. It shows how theologians such as Cotton Mather identified the emerging nation of America with the sacred vessel of the Christian church to the point that ‘chosenness’ or divine election represented a blank cheque for military adventure. It also shows how theologies of peace and restraint were anathematized as not merely heretical but a form of spiritual violence against the American project. In this sense, American nationhood functions as a controlling consideration akin to an institution, and Christian pacifism serves as a charismatic critique – or inspiration. To what extent were attitudes to violence framed by models of salvation? How did identity or chosenness trump ethics or the duty of love in the puritan imagination? The article concludes with more recent observations about the relationship of the ‘institution’ of nationhood to the troublesome, fissiparous energies of peace.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 57: INSPIRATION AND INSTITUTION IN CHRISTIAN HISTORY , June 2021 , pp. 364 - 385
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Ecclesiastical History Society

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Tolstoy, Leo, 'The Kingdom of God is within you': Christianity not as a Mystic Religion but as a New Theory of Life (London, 1894)Google Scholar.

2 Lepore, Jill, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York, 2018), 379–80Google Scholar.

3 Ronald Reagan, ‘Remarks at the Annual Members Banquet of the National Rifle Association in Phoenix, Arizona’, 6 May 1983, online at: <http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=41289>, accessed 17 November 2016.

4 May, Rollo, Power and Innocence: A Search for the Sources of Violence (New York, 1998), 50–2Google Scholar.

5 Berens, John F., Providence and Patriotism in Early America, 1640–1815 (Charlottesville, VA, 1978)Google Scholar.

6 Stout, Harry S., Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the American Civil War (New York, 2006)Google Scholar.

7 Albert J. Beveridge, ‘The March of the Flag’, 1898, online at: <https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/mod/1898beveridge.asp>, last accessed 26 January 2021 (italics mine).

8 Cited by Bercovitch, Sacvan, The Puritan Origins of the American Self (New Haven, CT, 1975), 55Google Scholar.

9 Ibid. 51, 53.

10 Jennings, Francis, The Invasion of America: Indians, Colonialism, and the Cant of Conquest (Chapel Hill, NC, 2010), 83Google Scholar.

11 Underhill, John, Newes from America; Or, A New and Experimentall Discoverie of New England; Containing, A Trve Relation of Their War-like Proceedings These Two Yeares Last Past, with a Figure of the Indian Fort, or Palizado, ed. Royster, Paul (London, 1638), 32–3Google Scholar.

12 Ibid. 35–6.

13 Ibid. 36.

14 Ibid. 36, 32.

15 Ibid. 38–9.

16 Ibid. 35.

17 Bradford, William, Of Plymouth Plantation: Sixteen Twenty to Sixteen Forty-Seven (New York, 1952), 296Google Scholar.

18 Mather, Cotton, Magnalia Christi Americana, 2 vols (Hartford, CT, 1820), 1: 50Google Scholar.

19 Ibid. 2: 317.

20 Ibid. 482.

21 Ibid. 318.

22 Ibid. 336.

23 Ibid.

24 Ibid.

25 Ibid. 336–7.

26 Slotkin, Richard and Folsom, James K., So Dreadfull a Judgment: Puritan Responses to King Philip's War, 1676–1677 (Middletown, CT, 1978), 114Google Scholar.

27 Cotton Mather, Souldiers Counselled and Comforted. A Discourse Delivered unto Some Part of the Forces Engaged in the Just War of New-England against the Northern & Eastern Indians. Sept. 1. 1689 (Boston, 1689), 34.

28 Ibid. 26.

29 Cotton Mather, Decennium Luctuosum. An History of Remarkable Occurrences, in the Long War, Which New-England Hath Had with the Indian Savages, from the Year 1688 to the Year 1698 (Boston, 1699), 24.

30 Mather, Magnalia Christi Americana, 2: 501.

31 Ibid.

32 Ibid. 462; Mather, Decennium Luctuosum, 29.

33 Mather, Souldiers Counselled and Comforted, 26, 27.

34 Ibid. 28.

35 Edward Wharton, New-England's Present Sufferings under Their Cruel Neighbouring Indians Represented in Two Letters Lately Written from Boston to London (London, 1675), 4, online at: <http://name.umdl.umich.edu/A65574.0001.001>, accessed 7 January 2021.

36 Mather, Decennium Luctuosum, 163.

37 Susan Juster, Sacred Violence in Early America (Philadelphia, PA, 2016).

38 Benedict de Spinoza, Theological-Political Treatise, ed. Jonathan I. Israel (Cambridge, 2007), 97–8.

39 Meredith Baldwin Weddle, Walking in the Way of Peace: Quaker Pacifism in the Seventeenth Century (Oxford and New York, 2001), 90.

40 Berens, Providence & Patriotism, 50. Bercovitch likewise writes that ‘[t]he myth of America is the creation of the New England Way’: Puritan Origins of the American Self, 143.

41 Jonathan Edwards, ‘Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God’, in The Works of Jonathan Edwards Online, 22: Sermons and Discourses, 1739–1742, ed. Harry S. Stout (New Haven, CT, 2003), 410–11, online at: <http://edwards.yale.edu/archive?path=aHR0cDovL2Vkd2FyZHMueWFsZS5lZHUvY2dpLWJpbi9uZXdwaGlsby9nZXRvYmplY3QucGw/Yy4yMTo0Ny53amVv>, accessed 10 May 2018.

42 Ibid. 414.

43 Ibid. 406, 411.

44 Jonathan Edwards, ‘To a Correspondent in Scotland’, in The Works of Jonathan Edwards Online, 16: Letters and Personal Writings, ed. George S. Claghorn (New Haven, CT, 1998), 179–97, at 193–4 (no. 63), online at: <http://edwards.yale.edu/archive?path=aHR0cDovL2Vkd2FyZHMueWFsZS5lZHUvY2dpLWJpbi9uZXdwaGlsby9nZXRvYmplY3QucGw/Yy4xNTo1OjYyLndqZW8=>, accessed 10 May 2018.

45 Ibid. 194.

46 James P. Byrd, ‘Jonathan Edwards, War, and the Bible’, in David P. Barshinger and Douglas A. Sweeney, eds, Jonathan Edwards and Scripture: Biblical Exegesis in British North America (Oxford, 2018), 192–211, online at: <http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/oso/9780190249496.001.0001/oso-9780190249496-chapter-12>, accessed 28 June 2018.

47 Edwards ‘To a Correspondent in Scotland’, 196.

48 Ibid.

49 Byrd, ‘Edwards, War, and the Bible’, 194.

50 Quoted ibid. 198.

51 Ibid. 197.

52 Ibid. 203.

53 Charles Royster, ‘The War to begin all Wars’, New York Times, 13 February 2000, Books section, online at: <https://www.nytimes.com/2000/02/13/books/the-war-to-begin-all-wars.html>, accessed 11 January 2021.

54 Jonathan Edwards, ‘In the Name of the Lord of Hosts’, in The Works of Jonathan Edwards Online, 25: Sermons and Discourses, 1743–1758, ed. Wilson H. Kimnach (New Haven, CT, 2006), 680–4, at 682, online at: <http://edwards.yale.edu/archive?path=aHR0cDovL2Vkd2FyZHMueWFsZS5lZHUvY2dpLWJpbi9uZXdwaGlsby9nZXRvYmplY3QucGw/Yy4yNDozNS53amVv>, accessed 10 May 2018.

55 Byrd, ‘Edwards, War, and the Bible’, 198.

56 Samuel Davies, The Curse of Cowardice: A Sermon preached to the Militia of Hanover County, in Virginia at a General Muster, May 8, 1758 (London, 1759), 2, online at: <https://quod.lib.umich.edu/e/evans/N06566.0001.001?rgn=main;view=fulltext>, accessed 11 January 2021.

57 Ibid. 5.

58 Charles Chauncy, Marvellous Things done by the right Hand and holy Arm of God in getting him the Victory (Boston, 1745), 12.

59 Berens, Providence and Patriotism, 43.

60 James P. Byrd, Sacred Scripture, Sacred War: The Bible and the American Revolution (Oxford, 2013), 22.

61 John Witherspoon, ‘Dominion of Providence over the Passions of Men’, in Political Sermons of the American Founding Era: 1730–1805 , vol. 1, 2nd edn (Indianapolis, IN, 1998), 529–58, at 537, online at: <http://oll.libertyfund.org/pages/1776-witherspoon-dominion-of-providence-over-the-passions-of-men-sermon>, accessed 4 May 2017.

62 Ibid. 538, 541.

63 Ibid. 542.

64 Ibid. 547.

65 Abraham Keteltas, ‘God arising and pleading his People's Cause’ (1777), in Political Sermons, 1: 579–606, at 586, online at: <http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/sandoz-political-sermons-of-the-american-founding-era-vol-1-1730-1788--5>, accessed 4 May 2017.

66 Weddle, Walking in the Way of Peace, 202.

67 Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down: Radical Ideas during the English Revolution (Harmondsworth, 1978), 260.

68 Robert Barclay, Universal Love Considered and Established upon Its Right Foundation, Being a Serious Enquiry How Far Charity May and Ought to Be Extended towards Persons of Different Judgments in Matters of Religion and Whose Principles among the Several Sects of Christians Do Most Naturally Lead to That Due Moderation Required (n.pl., 1677), 23, 28, online at: <http://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=eebo;idno=A30906.0001.001>, accessed 18 December 2015.

69 Ibid. 29, 24.

70 Robert Barclay, Apology for the True Christian Divinity (1676), Propositions 5 and 6, online at: <http://www.qhpress.org/texts/barclay/apology/props5-6.html>, accessed 17 December 2015.

71 Jean-Jacques Rousseau, The Social Contract and other later Political Writings (Cambridge, 1997), 151.

72 Barclay, Universal Love Considered.

73 Anthony Benezet, Serious Considerations on Several Important Subjects: Viz. on War and Its Inconsistency with the Gospel; Observations on Slavery. And Remarks on the Nature and Bad Effects of Spirituous Liquors (London, 1778), 7, 15; online at: <https://quod.lib.umich.edu/e/evans/N12457.0001.001?rgn=main;view=fulltext>, last accessed 4 February 2021.

74 Robert Barclay and Anthony Benezet, A Concise View of the Chief Principles of the Christian Religion: As Professed by the People Called Quakers (Baltimore, 1840), 6, 15, 17.

75 Weddle, Walking in the Way of Peace, 200.

76 Donald J. D'Elia, ‘The Republican Theology of Benjamin Rush’, Pennsylvania History 33 (1966), 187–203, at 188.

77 Benjamin Rush, Essays, Literary, Moral & Philosophical (Philadelphia, 1798), 9.

78 Ibid. 176.

79 ‘Brutus VII’ (1788), online at Teaching American History: <http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/document/brutus-vii/>, accessed 28 March 2019.

80 Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 24 March 1793, in The Letters of Thomas Jefferson 1743–1826 [online collection], at: <http://www.let.rug.nl/usa/presidents/thomas-jefferson/letters-of-thomas-jefferson/jefl103.php>, accessed 11 May 2019.

81 Thomas Jefferson to José Corrêa da Serra, 27 December 1814, in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Retirement Series, 8: 1 October 1814 to 31 August 1815, ed. J. Jefferson Looney (Princeton, NJ, 2011), 166–9, online at ‘Founders Online’: <http://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-08-02-0143>, accessed 11 May 2019.

82 Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America and Two Essays on America, ed. Isaac Kramnick, trans. Gerald Bevan (London, 2003), 324.

83 Kazin, Michael, War against War: The American Fight for Peace, 1914–1918 (New York, 2017)Google Scholar.

84 Loughery, John and Randolph, Blythe, Dorothy Day: Dissenting Voice of the American Century (New York, 2020)Google Scholar.

85 Thanks to Tim Grass for making this important point.

86 David Brooks, ‘The Brutalism of Ted Cruz’, New York Times, 12 January 2016, online at: <http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/12/opinion/the-brutalism-of-ted-cruz.html>, last accessed 26 January 2021.

87 Pasternak, Boris L., Doctor Zhivago (New York, 1991), 50Google Scholar.