Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-vpsfw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T01:24:20.523Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Comment and Debate French Steel and the Metal-Working Industries: A Contribution to Debate on Economic Development in Nineteenth-Century France

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Ann Wendy Mill
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This article addresses recent revisionist literature concerning nineteenth-century French economic history, and in particular Cameron’s and Freedeman’s “French Economic Growth; a Radical Revision” (1983, see also Roehl, 1976 and O’Brien and Keyder, 1978 and the critical response of Locke, 1981 and Crafts, 1984). It questions the latter’s criteria for the perception of economic development or retardation and challenges revisionist affirmations concerning the role of entrepreneurial attitudes in the achievement of industrialization in France. The problems raised by the revisionist interpretation appear clearly with respect to the history of the French steel industry. The principal steel producers’ dynamism and technically progressive attitudes, which the authors cite to demonstrate the irrelevance of sociocultural hypotheses concerning French industrial retardation, represented only one component of the ferrous industrial scene. Sociocultural factors beyond the steel firms’ control, together with poor financial conditions and the economic geography of France outweighed entrepreneurial dynamism as determinants of the industry’s overall performance in the later nineteenth century, chiefly by their inhibiting effect on per capita steel consumption.

Type
Research Article
Information
Social Science History , Volume 9 , Issue 3 , Summer 1985 , pp. 307 - 338
Copyright
Copyright © Social Science History Association 1985 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

AN: Archives Nationales, France. 65 AQ series (Association des porteurs de valeurs mobilières): K (metallurgy). K 46, Compagnie des Forges de Châtillon-Commentry et Neuves-Maisons, K 135, Compagnie des Hauts-Fourneaux, Forges et Aciéries de la Marine et des Chemins de Fer, K 159, Compagnie des Forges et Aciéries du Nord et de l’Est, K 198, Compagnie des Fonderies, Forges et Aciéries de Saint-Etienne.Google Scholar
Babu, E. (1899) L’industrie métallurgique dans la région de Saint-Etienne. Saint-Etienne.Google Scholar
Baclé, L. (1911) “La métallurgie en France: région du Centre et Bassin de la Loire.” Revue Economique Internationale: 510–535.Google Scholar
Bairoch, P. (1965) “Niveaux de développement économique de 1810 à 1910.” Annales E.S.C. 20 (part 2): 1091–1117.Google Scholar
Bastié, J. (1964) La croissance de la banlieue parisienne. Paris.Google Scholar
Baudant, A. (1980) “Une entreprise française face à l’exportation: Pont-à-Mousson 1860–1940.” La Revue Economique 31: 685–705.Google Scholar
Benaerts, P. (1933) Les origines de la grande industrie allemande. Paris.Google Scholar
Bertheault de Noiron, C. (1927) Du rôle du crédit dans le développement de la métallurgie en France. Thesis, Paris.Google Scholar
Boyer, P. (1978) Urban Masses and Moral Order in America 1870–1920. Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
Braudel, F. and Labrousse, E. [eds] (1979) Histoire économique et sociale de la France. Tome IV, vol. 1. Paris.Google Scholar
Burnett, J. (1980) A Social History of Housing, 1815–1970. Newton-Abbott.Google Scholar
Cameron, R. and Freedeman, C. (1983) “French economic growth: a radical revision.” Social Science History 7: 3–30.Google Scholar
Carmen, H. (1968) Social and Economic History of the United States, vol. 2. New York.Google Scholar
Caron, F. (1973) Histoire de l’exploitation d’un grand réseau: la Compagnie du Chemin de Fer du Nord, 1845–1937. Tome 1. Paris.Google Scholar
Chandler, A. (1977) The Visible Hand. Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
Chaulanges, M. and Pages, J. (1948) La région de Lyon et de Saint-Etienne, sa gégraphie, son histoire. Paris.Google Scholar
Courthéoux, J-P. (1959) “Le mouvement long du prix des rails en France de 1828 à 1955,” in Fourastié, J. (dir.) Prix de vente, prix de revient: recherches sur l’évolution des prix en période de progrès technique. 7th series. Paris.Google Scholar
Crafts, N. (1984) “Economic growth of France and Britain, 1830–1910: a review of the evidence.” Journal of Economic History 44: 49–67.Google Scholar
Crouzet, F. (1974) “Recherches sur la production d’armements en France.” Revue Historique 251: 45–84.Google Scholar
Crew, D. (1979) A Town in the Ruhr. New York.Google Scholar
Daunton, M. (1983) House and Home in the Victorian City. London.Google Scholar
Desai, A. (1968) Real Wages in Germany. Oxford.Google Scholar
Désorbiaux, P. (1910) La grosse métallurgie dans l’arrondissement de Valenciennes. Thesis, Lille.Google Scholar
L’Economiste français, 1871, 1874, 1875.Google Scholar
Engérand, F. and Marquet, C. (1920) A propos de notre politique sidérurgique: un Etat dans l’Etat. Paris.Google Scholar
France. Ministre du Commerce (1896) Résultats statistiques du recensement des industries et des professions. T. IV. Résultats généraux. Paris.Google Scholar
France. Ministre du Commerce (1917) Evaluation de la production d’après les renseignements fournis par les Chambres de Commerce (1910) et les Statistiques Administratives (1912) Paris.Google Scholar
Franchonne, G. (1969) “L’évolution démographique de Roubaix de 1870 à 1900.” Revue du Nord 51: 201–248.Google Scholar
Fraser, W. (1981) The Coming of the Mass Market. Hamden, CT.Google Scholar
Gaillard, J. (1976) Paris, la ville. Thesis, Paris.Google Scholar
Gendarme, R. (1954) La région du Nord. Essai d’analyse économique. Paris.Google Scholar
Gille, B. (1968) La sidérurgie française au XIXe siècle. Geneva.Google Scholar
Gillet, M. (1973) Les charbonnages du Nord de la France. Paris.Google Scholar
Gras, L. (1908) Histoire économique de la métallurgie de la Loire, suivie d’une notice sur la construction mécanique et l’industrie des cycles et automobiles dans la région stéphanoise. Saint-Etienne.Google Scholar
Gravier, J-F. (1972) Paris et le désert français en 1972. Paris.Google Scholar
Guerrand, R. (1967) Les origines du logement social en France. Paris.Google Scholar
Gutman, H. (1977) Work, Culture and Society in Industrializing America. New York.Google Scholar
Habakkuk, H. (1962) American and British Technology in the 20th Century. Cambridge, Eng.Google Scholar
Henderson, W. (1975) The Rise off German Industrial Power, 1834–1914. Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
Jobard, J-P. (1962) Retard et croissance et disparités régionales. L’exemple du Centre-Est de la France. Dijon.Google Scholar
Jorberg, L. (1976) “The Nordic countries, 1850–1914,” in Cipolla, C. [ed.] (Fontana Economic History of Europe, vol. IV, The Emergence of Industrial Societies, pt. 2. London: 375–485.Google Scholar
Kemp, T. (1972) The French Economy, 1919–1939: the History of a Decline. New York.Google Scholar
Kirchner, W. (1981) “Russian tariffs and foreign industries before 1914: the German entrepreneur’s perspective.” Journal of Economic History 41: 361–379.Google Scholar
Kocka, J. (1978) “Entrepreneurs and managers in German industrialization,” in Mathias, P. and Postan, M. (eds.) Cambridge Economic History of Europe. vol. 7: The Industrial Economies, pt. 1: 492–589.Google Scholar
Landes, D. (1969) The Unbound Prometheus. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Laur, F. (1897) La France sans houillères. Paris.Google Scholar
Laur, F. (1900) Les mines et usines au XXe siècle: les mines et la métallurgie à l’exposition universelle de 1900. T. I. Paris.Google Scholar
de Lavelaye, Baron (1911) “La métallurgie en Belgique.” Revue Economique Internationale: 443–445.Google Scholar
Leroy-Beaulieu, P. (1890) L’Etat moderne et ses fonctions. Paris.Google Scholar
Locke, R. (1981) “French industrialization: the Roehl thesis reconsidered.” Explorations in Economic History 18: 415–433.Google Scholar
La Machine à Coudre (1889-1890).Google Scholar
La Métallurgie (1875) January 21.Google Scholar
Michinton, W. (1976) “Patterns of Demand, 1750–1914,” in Cipolla, C. (ed.) (1976) Fontana Economic History of Europe, vol. III. The Industrial Revolution. London.Google Scholar
Mill, W. (1983) “Self-financing in the French Iron and Steel Industry, 1865–1895.” Doctoral dissertation, Univ. of Rochester.Google Scholar
Navin, T. and Sears, M. (1955) “The rise of a market for industrial securities.” Business History Review 29: 105–138.Google Scholar
Nistri, R. and Prêcheur, C. (1959) La région du Nord et Nord-est. Paris.Google Scholar
Le Nord Métallurgique (1983) August 22.Google Scholar
O’Brien, P. and Keyder, C. (1978) Economic Growth in Britain and France 1780–1914. London.Google Scholar
Omnes, C. (1980) “Contraintes du marché et stratégies patronales: l’industrie française du tube d’acier de 1880 à 1978.” Le Mouvement Social 110:75–102.Google Scholar
Passama, P. (1910) L’intégration du travail: formes nouvelles de concentration industrielle. Paris.Google Scholar
Perrot, M. (1979) “Les classes populaire urbaines,” in Braudel, F. and Labrousse, E. (eds.) Histoire économique et sociale de la France. T. IV, pt. 1. Paris: 454–534.Google Scholar
Pinot, R. (n.d.: circa 1912) Quatre études sur l’industrie métallurgique française. Paris.Google Scholar
Pounds, N. and Parker, W. (1957) Coal and Steel in Western Europe. Indiana.Google Scholar
Riesser, J. (1911) The Great German Banks and their Concentration in Connection with the Economic Development of Germany. Washington.Google Scholar
Roehl, R. (1976) “French industrialization: a reconsideration.” Explorations in Economic History 13: 233–281.Google Scholar
Saul, S. (1967) “The market and the development of the mechanical engineering industries in Britain, 1860–1914.” Economic History Review 2, 20: 111–130.Google Scholar
Soltow, J. (1965) “Origins of small business metal fabricators and machinery makers in New England, 1890–1957.” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society (December): 1–42.Google Scholar
Souvestre, P. (1907) Histoire de l’automobile. Paris.Google Scholar
Statistique de l’industrie minérale et des appareils à vapeur en France et en Algérie (1880, 1885, 1890, 1895). Paris.Google Scholar
Sutcliffe, A. (1971) The Autumn of Central Paris. Montreal.Google Scholar
Sutcliffe, A. (1981) Towards the Planned City: Germany, Britain, the United States and France, 1780–1914. Oxford.Google Scholar
Tannenbaum, E. (1976) 1900: the Generation before the Great War. New York.Google Scholar
Technology Review (1984) (November-December).Google Scholar
Temin, P. (1964) Iron and Steel in Nineteenth-century America. MIT.Google Scholar
Tilly, R. (1974) “Growth of large-scale enterprise in Germany since the middle of the nineteenth century,” in Daems, H. and Wee, H. Van der (eds.) The Rise of Managerial Capitalism. The Hague: 145–169.Google Scholar
Tipton, F. (1976) Regional Variations in the Economic Development of Germany during the Nineteenth Century. Middletown, CT.Google Scholar
Trebilcock, C. (1981) The Industrialization of the Continental Powers, 1780–1914. London.Google Scholar
Tribot-Laspierre, (1917) L’industrie de l’acier en France. Paris.Google Scholar
Vatter, H. (1975) The Drive to Industrial Maturity: the United States Economy 1860–1914. Westport, CT.Google Scholar
Vignes, M. (1912, 1913) “Le Bassin de Briey et la politique de ses entreprises sidérurgiques ou minières.” Revue d’Economie Politique 26: 669–718 and 27: 1–40, 300–337.Google Scholar
Warren, K. (1973) The American Steel Industry, 1850–1970: a Geographical Interpretation. Oxford.Google Scholar