Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-wxhwt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-09T01:24:14.694Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Science, Sulloway, and Birth Order: An Ordeal and An Assessment

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Get access

Abstract

This issue of Politics and the Life Sciences includes an article, ten commentaries, and three responses on the subject of birth order and rebelliousness, focusing in particular on Frank Sulloway's Born to Rebel (1996, 1997). Extraordinary events have surrounded the publication of this roundtable, including threats of legal action, accusations of misconduct, letters to university officials, termination of the journal's publishing contract, and an almost five-year delay in publication. This editorial reviews these events and goes on to assess Frank Sulloway's responses (published in this issue), as well as parts of Born to Rebel. It also reports the results of a replication of Sulloway's study of Reformation martyrs. The replication generated markedly different data than those reported by Sulloway. Data from an expanded sample were also inconsistent with the relationship that Sulloway reported finding between birth order and religious commitment among Reformation martyrs. The editorial supports the suggestion by Frederic Townsend that an independent review of Born to Rebel would be appropriate. It concludes with a call for establishment of a multidisciplinary legal defense fund that would reduce the likelihood that legal threats can succeed in stifling research and publication in the natural and social sciences.

Type
Editorial
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 19 , Issue 2 , September 2000 , pp. 211 - 245
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Reference Works Consulted for Birth Order Information on Reformation Martyrs

Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie (1875–1912). Edited by von Rochus Liliencron, Freiherr et al. Leipzig: Duncker and Humblot.Google Scholar
Allgemeines Gelehrten-Lexicon (1750–1751; 1960). Edited by Jöcher, Christian Gottlieb. Leipzig: J.F. Gleditsch.Google Scholar
Archives Biographiques Françaises (1600, 1988). Edited by Bradley, Susan. New York: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Archivio Biográfico Italiano. Edited by Nappo, Tommaso and Furlani, Silvio(1987–1990). München: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Archivo Biográfico de España, Portugal e Iberoamérica (Arquivo Biográfico de Espanha, Portugal e Ibero-America (1990). Edited by Mediavilla, Victor Herrero and Rosa Aguayo Nayle, L.München: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Biographie Nationale de Belgique (1866-). Brussels: Academie royale des sciences, des letters et des beaux-arts.Google Scholar
Biographie Nationale du Pays de Luxembourg Depuis ses Origines Jusqu'a nos Jours (1947). Second edition. Edited by Mersch, Jules. Luxembourg: Imprimerie de la Cour victor Buck.Google Scholar
Biographisch Woordenboek der Nederlanden (1852). Edited by van der Aa, A.J.Haarlem: J.J. van Brederode.Google Scholar
Biographisches Lexikon zur Geschichte der Böhmischen Länder (1974-). Edited by Sturm, Heribert. München: R. Oldenbourg.Google Scholar
Biographisches Wörterbuch zur Deutschen Geschichte (1973–1975). Edited by Rössler, Hellmuth, Franz, Günther, Bosl, Karl, and Hofmann, Hanns Hubert. München: Francke Verlag.Google Scholar
Britain's Royal Families: The Complete Genealogy (1989). By Weir, Alison. London: Bodley Head.Google Scholar
British Biographical Archive (1984-). Edited by Baillie, Laureen and Sieveking, Paul. New York: Saur.Google Scholar
Burke's Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Landed Gentry (1965). 18th Edition. Edited by Townend, Peter. London: Burke's Peerage.Google Scholar
Burke's Peerage and Baronetage (1999). 106th Edition. Edited by Mosley, Charles. Crans, Switzerland: Burke's Peerage.Google Scholar
The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907–1912). Edited by Habermann, Charles George et al. New York: Robert Appleton. Available online atwww.newadvent.org/cathen.Google Scholar
Coleccion Bibliografico-Biografica de Noticias Referentes a la Provincia de Zahmora (1891). By Duro, Cesáreo Fernández. Madrid: M. Tello.Google Scholar
A Compendium of Irish Biography: Comprising Sketches of Distinguished Irishmen and of Eminent Persons Connected with Ireland by Office or by Their Writings (1878, 1970). Edited by Webb, Alfred. New York: Lemma Publishing.Google Scholar
Contemporaries of Erasmus: A Biographical Register of the Renaissance and Reformation (1985). Edited by Beitenholz, Peter G. and Deutscher, Thomas B.Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dansk Biografisk Lexikon: Tillige Omfattende Norge for Tidsrummet 1537–1814 (1887–1905). Edited by Bricka, Carl Frederik, Laursen, L, Johannes Christoffer Hagemann Reinhardt Steenstrup. Kjøbenhavn: Gyldendal.Google Scholar
Das geistige Ungarn: Biographisches Lexikon (1918). Edited by Jásznigi, Alexander and Parlagi, Imre. Wien: W. Braumüller.Google Scholar
Das Grosse Buch der Österreicher: 4500 Personendarstellungen in Wort und Bild: Namen, Daten, Fakten (1987). Edited by Kleindel, Walter and Veigl, Hans. Wien: Kremayr and Scheriau.Google Scholar
Deutsche Biographische Enzyklopädie (1995–2000). Edited by Killy, Walther, von Engelhardt, Dietrich, and Vierhaus, Rudolf. München: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Deutsches Biographisches Archiv: Eine Kumulation aus 254 der Wichtigsten Biographischen Nachschlagewerke für den Deutschen Bereich bis zum Ausgang des Neunzehnten Jahrhunderts (1982). Edited by Fabian, Berhnard, Gorzny, Willi, and Koch, Hans-Albrecht. New York: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Diccionario de historia de España (1968–1969). Second edition. Edited by Bleiberg, German. Madrid: Revista de Occidente.Google Scholar
Diccionario de Historia Eclesiástica de España (1972–1975). Edited by Vaquero, Quintín Aldea, Martínez, Tomás Marín, and Vives, José. Madrid: Instituto Enrique Flórez, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas.Google Scholar
Dictionary of Catholic Biography (1961). By Delaney, John J. and Tobin, James Edward. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Dictionary of English History (1928, 1971). New edition. Edited by Low, Sidney Sir, Pulling, Frederick Sanders, Hearnshaw, F.J.C., Chew, Helena M., and Beales, Arthur Charles Frederick. Ann Arbor, Ml: Gryphon Books.Google Scholar
Dictionary of German Biography (2001 -). Edited by Killy, Walther and Vierhaus, Rudolf. München: K.G. Saur.Google Scholar
Dictionary of National Biography: From the Earliest Times to 1900 (1917). Edited by Stephen, Leslie and Lee, Sidney. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Dictionnaire de Biographie des Hommes Célèbres de I'Alsace (1973). By Sitzmann, Édouard. Paris: Éditions du Palais Royal.Google Scholar
Dictionnaire de Biographie Francaise (1933-). Edited by Balteau, J., Barroux, M., and Prevost, M.Paris: Librairie Letouzey et Ane.Google Scholar
Dictionnaire Historique et Biographique de la Suisse (1921). Edited by Attinger, Victor. Neuchâtel: Administration du Dictionnaire Historique et Biographique de la Suisse.Google Scholar
Die Grossen Deutschen: Deutsche Biographie (1956-). Edited by Heimpel, Hermann. Berlin: Propyläen-Verlag.Google Scholar
Dizionario Biografico degli Italiana (1960-). Edited by Ghisalberti, A.M. et al. Rome: Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana.Google Scholar
Grande Enciclopédia Portuguesa e Brasileira (1936–1960). Lisboa: Editorial Enciclopédia.Google Scholar
Historia de los Heterodoxos Españoles (1911–1932). Edited by Pelayo, Marcelino Menéndez y, Martín, Adolfo Bonilla y San, and Artigas, Miguel. Madrid: V. Suárez.Google Scholar
Jesuit Saints and Martyrs: Short Biographies of the Saints, Blessed, Venerables, and Servants of God of the Society of Jesus (1998). Second edition. By Tylenda, J. N.Chicago: Jesuit Way.Google Scholar
Kleine Slavische Biographie (1958). Wiesbaden: O. Harrassowitz.Google Scholar
La France Protestante (1846–1859). By Haag, Eugène and Haag, Émile. Paris: J. Cherbuliez.Google Scholar
A Literary and Biographical History, Or Bibliographical Dictionary of the English Catholics, from the Breach with Rome, in 1534, to the Present Time (1885, 1968). By Gillow, Joseph. New York: Burt Franklin.Google Scholar
Nationaal Biografisch Woordenboek (1964-). Edited by Duverger, Jozef. Brussels: Paleis der Academiën.Google Scholar
Neue Deutsch Biographie (1953). Berlin: Duncker and Humblot.Google Scholar
New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967). Edited by Catholic University of America. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
New Catholic Encyclopedia, Second Edition (2003). Edited by Catholic University of America. Washington, DC: Catholic University of America.Google Scholar
Nouvelle Biographie Générate Depuis les Temps les Plus Reculés Jusqu'à nos Jours, Avec les Renseignements Bibliographiques et l'Indication des Sources à Consulter (1862–1877). Edited by Hoefer, M.Paris: Firmin Didot Frères.Google Scholar
The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Reformation (1996). Edited by Hillerbrand, Hans J.New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Portugal: Diccionario Historico, Chorographico, Heraldico, Biographico, Bibliographico, Numismatico e Artistico (1904–1915). By Pereira, João Manuel Esteves and Rodrigues, Guilherme. Lisboa: J. Romano Torres.Google Scholar
Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart: Handwörterbuch für Theologie und Religionswissenschaft (1998-) By Betz, Hans Dieter. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.Google Scholar
Renaissance and Reformation, 1500–1620: A Biographical Dictionary (2001). Edited by Carney, Jo Eldridge. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
The Scottish Nation: Or, The Surnames, Families, Literature, Honours, and Biographical History of the People of Scotland (1863). Edited by Anderson, William. Edinburgh: Fullarton.Google Scholar
Vaderlandsch Woordenboek (1785–1796). By Kok, Jacobus and Fokke, Jan. Amsterdam: J. Allart.Google Scholar
Who's Who in Tudor England (1990). Second Edition. By Routh, C.R.N. (Revised by Holmes, Peter). Chicago: St. James Press.Google Scholar

References

Antman, A.E. (1993). “Big Brother” [Letter to the Editor]. The Economist 329 (December 25):8.Google Scholar
Boynton, R.S. (1996). “The Birth of an Idea.” The New Yorker 72 (October 7):72–81.Google Scholar
Brown, J.N. (1854). Memorials of Baptist Martyrs. Philadelphia: American Baptist Publication Society.Google Scholar
Carlyle, E.I. (1917). “Tyndale, William.” Dictionary of National Biography 19:1351–58.Google Scholar
Carney, J.E., ed. (2001). Renaissance and Reformation, 1500–1620: A Biographical Dictionary. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907–1912). Edited by Habermann, Charles George et al. New York: Robert Appleton. Available online atwww.newadvent.org/cathen.Google Scholar
Catholic Church (1979). Catholic Martyrs of England and Wales: A Chronological List of English and Welsh Martyrs Who Gave Their Lives for Christ and His Church during the “Penal Times” (A.A. 1535–1680): The Saints, the Beati, and the Eighty-Five Venerable Martyrs Whose Cause of Beatification Was Resumed on 21 September 1978. London: Catholic Truth Society.Google Scholar
Chambers, R.W. (1935). Thomas More. London: Jonathan Cape.Google Scholar
Daniell, D. (1994). William Tyndale: A Biography. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Dickens, A. G. (1989). The English Reformation. Second edition. London: B. T. Batsford.Google Scholar
Dodds, M.H. and Dodds, R. (1915, 1971). The Pilgrimage of Grace, 1536–1537 and The Exeter Conspiracy, 1538. Two volumes. London: Frank Cass.Google Scholar
Durant, W. (1957). The Reformation: A History of European Civilization from Wyclif to Calvin, 1300–1564. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Elton, G. R. (1963). Reformation Europe, 1517–1559. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Elton, G. R. (1977). Reform and Reformation: England, 1509–1558. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Ernst, C. and Angst, J. (1983). Birth Order: Its Influence on Personality. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Farrow, J. (1954). The Story of Thomas More. New York: Sheed and Ward.Google Scholar
Ferguson, C.W. (1958). Naked to Mine Enemies: The Life of Cardinal Wolsey. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Foxe, J. (1570, 1981). Fox's Book of Martyrs. Originally The Acts and Monuments of These Latter and Perilous Days. Springdale, PA: Whitaker House. The Book of Martyrs is also available in several on-line versions, such aswww.blackmask.com/books29c/foxesbook. These versions are useful because of the search capability.Google Scholar
Freese, J., Powell, B., and Steelman, L.C. (1999). “Rebel without a Cause or Effect: Birth Order and Social Attitudes.” American Sociological Review 64:207–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gairdner, J. (1917). “Pole, Reginald.” Dictionary of National Biography 16:35–46.Google Scholar
Greene, M.T. (1999). “Mom Always Liked You Best” [Review of Born to Rebel]. Isis 90:332–38.Google Scholar
Gregory, B.S. (1999). Salvation at Stake: Christian Martyrdom in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Harris, J.R. (1998). The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the Way They Do. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Hillenbrand, H.J. (1971). Christendom Divided: The Protestant Reformation. New York: Corpus.Google Scholar
Hillerbrand, H.J. (1973). The World of the Reformation. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.Google Scholar
Hillenbrand, H.J. ed. (1996). The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Reformation. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Hudson, L. (1997). “Slaying the First-Born.” The Times Literary Supplement 4898 (February 14):26.Google Scholar
Kamen, H. (1985). Inquisition and Society in Spain in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Léonard, É.G. (1965). A History of Protestantism: 1. The Reformation. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons.Google Scholar
Léonard, É.G. (1967). A History of Protestantism: 2. The Establishment. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons.Google Scholar
Loades, D. M. (1970). The Oxford Martyrs. New York: Stein and Day.Google Scholar
Loane, M.L. (1964). Pioneers of the Reformation in England. London: Church Book Room Press.Google Scholar
Longhurst, John E. (1969). Luther's Ghost in Spain (1517–1546). Lawrence, KS: Coronado Press. Available on-line athttp://www.ku.edu/carrie/texts/carrie_books/longhurst/.Google Scholar
Lueker, E., Poellot, L., and Jackson, P. (2002). Christian Cyclopedia. Available athttp://www.lcms.org/cyclopedia. Earlier print editions published as the Lutheran Cyclopedia.St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House.Google Scholar
McNeill, C. (1910, 2003). “Irish Confessors and Martyrs.” The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume VIII. New York: Robert Appleton. Available on-line atwww.newadvent.org/cathen.Google Scholar
Modell, J. (1997). “Family Niche and Intellectual Bent” [Book Review of Born to Rebel]. Science 275:624–25.Google Scholar
Moeller, B. (1972). Imperial Cities and the Reformation: Three Essays. Edited and translated by Erik Midelfort, H.C. and Edwards, Mark U. Jr.Philadelphia: Fortress Press.Google Scholar
Moore, J.A. (1984). Anabaptist Portraits. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press.Google Scholar
Mosley, J.F. (1937). William Tyndale. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Neilson, G.A. (1960). Twelve Reformation Heroes. London: Pickering and Inglis.Google Scholar
Ozment, S.E. (1975). The Reformation in the Cities: The Appeal of Protestantism to Sixteenth-Century Germany and Switzerland. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Ozment, S. (1980). The Age of Reform, 1250–1550: An Intellectual and Religious History of Late Medieval and Reformation Europe. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Ozment, S. (1992). Protestants: The Birth of a Revolution. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Pollard, A.F. (1917a). “Seymour, Edward.” Dictionary of National Biography 17:1237–48.Google Scholar
Pollard, A.F. (1917b). “Seymour, Thomas.” Dictionary of National Biography 17:1268–71.Google Scholar
Pollen, J.H. (1909, 2003). “English Confessors and Martyrs (1534–1729).” The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume 5. New York: Robert Appleton. Available on-line atwww.newadvent.xorg/cathen.Google Scholar
“Rebels with a Cause” (1993). The Economist 329 (November 20):99–100.Google Scholar
Ridley, J.G. (1957). Nicholas Ridley: A Biography. London: Longmans, Green.Google Scholar
Ridley, J. (1982). The Statesman and the Fanatic: Thomas Wolsey and Thomas More. London: Constable.Google Scholar
Ridley, J. (2001). Bloody Mary's Martyrs: The Story of England's Terror. New York: Carroll and Graf.Google Scholar
Scarisbrick, J.J. (1967). “Wolsey, Thomas.” New Catholic Encyclopedia 14:989–90.Google Scholar
Spitz, L.W. (1985). The Protestant Reformation, 1517–1559. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Sulloway, F.J. (1991). “Modeling Responses to Scientific Innovation.” National Science Foundation Grant Proposal No. DIR-9112305. Approved December 7, 1991.Google Scholar
Sulloway, F. J. (1996). Born to Rebel: Birth Order, Family Dynamics, and Creative Lives. New York: Pantheon.Google Scholar
Sulloway, F. J. (1997). Born to Rebel: Birth Order, Family Dynamics, and Creative Lives. Revised edition. New York: Vintage.Google Scholar
Sulloway, F. J. (2000a). “Born to Rebel and Its Critics.” Politics and the Life Sciences 19:181–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sulloway, F. J. (2000b). “Reconceptualizing the Influence of Birth Order: A Reply to the Commentators.” Politics and the Life Sciences 19:203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Townsend, F. (1997). “Rebelling Against Born to Rebel' [Book Review]. Journal of Social and Evolutionary Systems 20:191–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Townsend, F. (2000a). “Birth Order and Rebelliousness: Reconstructing the Research in Born to Rebel.” Politics and the Life Sciences 19:135–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Townsend, F. (2000b). “Taking Born to Rebel Seriously: The Need for Independent Review.” Politics and the Life Sciences 19:205–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
University of Chicago Press (1982). The Chicago Manual of Style. Thirteenth Edition, Revised and Expanded. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
van Braght, T. J. (1660, 1886). The Bloody Theater or Martyrs Mirror of the Defenseless Christians Who Baptized Only upon Confession of Faith, and Who Suffered and Died for the Testimony of Jesus, their Savior, from the Time of Christ to the year A.D. 1660. Translated from the original Dutch by Joseph F. Sohm, 1886. Available athttp://www.homecomers.org/mirror/index.htm.Google Scholar
Water, M., comp. (2001). The New Encyclopedia of Christian Martyrs. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books.Google Scholar
Williams, G.H. (1962). The Radical Reformation. Philadelphia: Westminster Press.Google Scholar