Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-xm8r8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-20T14:32:24.443Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Sacrament of the Dynamic Transcendence of Christianity’: Cornelius Ernst on the Church

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Oliver James Keenan OP
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The new ontology of meaning proposed by Fr Cornelius Ernst OP as a means of articulating the Thomistic synthesis in the idiom of the modern era coheres around ecclesiology. Drawing upon the linguistic philosophy of Ludwig Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations, Ernst sees meaning as the distinctively human praxis by which man ‘subdues’ and ‘transcends’ the world to which he belongs, thereby transposing it into the world that belongs to man. The Church, as the Body of Christ – who is personally the ontological meaning of history – is the distinctively Christian linguistic community of meaning, in which ultimate meaning – the ‘meaning of meaning’, i.e. God – is present in each successive era. Established in the illuminating event of Christ's incarnation, the Church is the sacramental institution that makes present Christ's re-integration of the plurality of human meanings, realising itself as a concrete community within the world, and realising the world authentically within itself. As the sacrament of the Trinitarian mediation of meaning, therefore, the Church is irreducibly both human institution and mystical communion, serving as the ontological a priori of faith, and thus the authentic locus of Christian theology.

Keywords

Cornelius ErnstCartesianismWittgensteinRicoeur
Type
Original Article
Information
New Blackfriars , Volume 94 , Issue 1052 , July 2013 , pp. 396 - 414
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 The Author. New Blackfriars © 2013 The Dominican Council

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 I am indebted to a collection of notes taken in Enst's 1957/8 Rational Psychology Class by the late Fr Austin Gaskell OP.

2 Ernst, Cornelius, Kerr, Fergus (ed), Radcliffe, Timothy (ed), Multiple Echo. (London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 1979), p. 33Google Scholar. [Henceforth cited as M.E.]

3 M.E., p. 27.

4 Lindbeck, George A., The Nature of Doctrine: Religion and Theology in a Postliberal Age. 25th Anniversary Ed'n. (London: WJK, 2009), pp. 65–69Google Scholar, et passim.

5 Kerr, Fergus, ‘Anscombe, Ernst and McCabe: Wittgenstein and Catholic Theology’, Josephinum Journal of Theology. 15.1 (2008) pp. 67–86Google Scholar; Kerr, Fergus, ‘Wittgenstein and Theological Studies’, New Blackfriars. 63 (1982), pp. 500–508CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Roy, Louis, ‘Cornelius Ernst's Theological Seeds’, New Blackfriars. 85 (2004), pp. 459–470CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 cf., M.E., pp. 137ff.

8 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘A Theological Chronicle’, New Blackfriars. 41 (1960), pp. 220–227CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 M.E., p. 20.

10 St Thomas Aquinas, De Ente et Essentia, §1.

11 S.T. I, q3, a4.

12 S.T. I, q44, a1.

13 M.E., p. 21.

14 P.I., §693.

15 M.E., p. 83.

16 e.g., M.E., pp. 83–5.

17 English Province of the Order of Preachers, Acts of the Provincial Chapter. (1978), p. 41.

18 M.E., p. 211.

19 Cornelius Ernst, ‘Introduction’. In: St Thomas Aquinas, ‘The Gospel of Grace’, being vol. 30 of Summa Theologiae [I-II qq106–114], (London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1972), p. xxGoogle Scholar.

20 Roy, ‘Cornelius Ernst's Theological Seeds’, at p. 468.

21 Ernst, Introduction to ‘The Gospel of Grace’, pp. xx-xxi.

22 Lash, Nicholas, ‘Listening to the Echo’. New Blackfriars. 61 (1980), pp. 89–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 M.E., p. 133.

24 M.E., p. 85.

25 c.f., M.E., p. 84.

26 M.E., p. 75.

27 M.E., p. 140.

28 Ludwig Wittgenstein, Zettel. §16.

29 P.I., §§244–271.

30 P.I., §693.

31 Ernst, Cornelius, The Theology of Grace. (Notre Dame, Indiana: Fides Publication, 1974), p. 73Google Scholar.

32 Ernst, The Theology of Grace, p. 68.

33 e.g., Ernst, The Theology of Grace, p. 174–6.

34 P.I., §§21–64.

35 M.E., p. 53.

36 M.E., p. 55.

37 M.E., p. 55.

38 Rowan Williams, ‘Benedict and the Future of Europe’. Speech given at Sant’ Anselmo, Rome, 21st November 2006.

39 M.E., pp. 33, 57, 61, 83, 126.

40 M.E., p. 27.

41 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘Introduction’ In: Rahner, Karl, Ernst, Cornelius (tr), Theological Investigations. Volume I. (London: Darton Longman and Todd, 1961), pp. xvi-xviiGoogle Scholar.

42 M.E., p. 156.

43 M.E., p. 55.

44 M.E., p. 79.

45 M.E., p. 34.

46 M.E., p. 27.

47 Ricoeur, Paul, ‘Réponses’, Espirit. 31 (1963), pp. 628–53Google Scholar.

48 M.E., pp. 52–3.

49 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘Preface to Theology’, Journal of the Anthropological Society of Oxford. 2.1 (1971), pp. 1–8, at p. 4Google Scholar.

50 M.E., p. 86.

51 M.E., p. 156.

52 M.E., p. 27.

53 M.E., p. 27.

54 M.E., pp. 236–237.

55 M.E., p. 75, p. 9.

56 M.E., p. 79.

57 M.E., p. 79.

58 M.E., p. 75.

59 M.E., p. 34.

60 M.E., p. 218.

61 cf., C.C.C., §485.

62 M.E., p. 161.

63 Ernst, The Theology of Grace, p. 74.

64 M.E., p. 95, p. 34.

65 M.E., p. 49ff.

66 M.E., p. 106, fn. 16.

67 Ott, Ludwig, Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma. (Cork: Mercier, 1955), pp. 301–4Google Scholar; cf. also the ‘subsistit in’ of Lumen Gentium, §8.

68 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘The Church as Institution’, New Blackfriars. 47 (1965), pp. 26–31, at p. 27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

69 M.E., p. 218.

70 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘Gospel and the Church’, New Blackfriars. 43 (1962), pp. 301–313, at p. 301CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 M.E., p. 158.

72 Küng, Hans, Hastings, Cecily (tr), The Council, Reform and Reunion. (London: Sheed and Ward, 1961)Google Scholar.

73 Ernst, ‘Gospel and the Church’, passim.

74 Ernst, ‘Gospel and the Church’, at p307.

75 Ratzinger, Joseph Cardinal, Principles of Catholic Theology, (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1982), pp. 239–249Google Scholar.

76 M.E., p107.

77 Ernst, Cornelius, Charles Davis and his Book. (London: Ealing Abbey, 1967), p. 14Google Scholar.

78 Ernst, Charles Davis and his Book, pp. 15–17.

79 M.E., pp. 171–186.

80 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘Priesthood and Ministry’, New Blackfriars. 49 (1967), pp. 121–132, at p. 128CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

81 Lumen Gentium. §10.

82 M.E., pp. 162–3.

83 M.E., p. 173.

84 M.E., p. 213.

85 M.E., p. 213–4.

86 M.E., p. 214–8.

87 M.E., pp. 139f, p. 43.

88 M.E., p. 109ff.

89 cf., M.E., p. 11.

90 M.E., p. 201, p. 110.

91 M.E., p. 218.

92 cf., MacKinnon, Donald, ‘Revelation and Social Justice’. In: Malvern 1941: The Life of the Church and the Order of Society. (London, Longmans, 1941), pp. 81–116Google Scholar.

93 M.E., p. 111.

94 M.E., p. 237.

95 M.E., p. 183.

96 Zizioulas, John D., ‘The Ecclesiological Presupposition of the Holy Eucharist’ in: The Eucharistic Communion and the World. (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 2010), pp. 100–111Google Scholar.

97 Zizioulas, John D., ‘Symbolism and Realism in Orthodox Worship’ in: The Eucharistic Communion and the World. (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 2010), pp. 83–97Google Scholar.

98 Ernst, Introduction to Theological Investigations, p. vi-ix.

99 Ernst, Cornelius, ‘Meaning and Metaphor in Theology’, New Blackfriars, 61 (1980), pp. 100–112, at p109CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

100 M.E., p. 75.

101 M.E., p. 236.

102 Ernst, ‘Meaning and Metaphor in Theology’, at p. 112.

103 Ernst, Priesthood and Ministry, at p. 122.

104 Ernst, Introduction to Theological Investigations, p. vi.

105 cf., the proposed ‘musical ontology of time’ in: M.E., pp. 106–9.

106 Ernst, Introduction to Theological Investigations, p. viii.

107 M.E., p. 128.

108 M.E., p. 170.

109 MacKinnon, Donald, ‘Christology and Protest’. In: Honoré, Deborah Duncan (ed), Trevor Huddleston: Essays on his Life and Work. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), pp. 175–187Google Scholar.

110 M.E., pp. 169–70.

111 M.E., p. 78.

112 M.E., p. 139.

113 M.E., p. 30, p. 43.

114 M.E., p. 221.

115 M.E., p. 211.

116 M.E., p. 144.

117 M.E., p. 151.

118 Published at M.E., pp. 225–238.

119 Caroline Smith, ‘The Week Ahead’. New Scientist. 3rd February (1972), p. 280.

120 M.E., p. 214.

121 Aidan Nichols, Catholic Theology in Britain: The Scene Since Vatican II. At: http://www.christendom-awake.org/pages/anichols/theolog1.html [Last Accessed: 13th November 2012; Last Updated: 18th July 2009].

122 Simon Tugwell OP, ‘Cornelius Ernst OP’. New Blackfriars. 59 (1978), pp. 2–4.

123 M.E., p. 13.