Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-qsmjn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T17:46:17.557Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Kymlicka’s Alignment of Mill and Engels: Nationality, Civilization, and Coercive Assimilation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 November 2021

Tim Beaumont Open the ORCID record for Tim Beaumont [Opens in a new window]
Tim Beaumont*
Affiliation:
School of Foreign Languages, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen, China
*
Email: tbeaumont4@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

John Stuart Mill claims that free institutions are next to impossible in a multinational state. According to Will Kymlicka, this leads him to embrace policies kindred to those of Friedrich Engels, aimed at promoting mononational states in Europe through coercive assimilation. Given Mill’s harm principle, such coercive assimilation would have to be justified either paternalistically, in terms of its civilizing effects upon the would-be assimilated, or non-paternalistically, with reference to the danger that their non-assimilation would pose to others. However, neither possible interpretation is plausible; Mill takes Europe’s civilized status to shield Europeans from paternalistic coercion, and he opposes coercive assimilation where it could conceivably be justified in the name of defense. Although this much suggests that Kymlicka misinterprets Mill by ignoring his definition of nationality, it leaves scope for Kymlicka to argue that Mill favors policies that promote mononationality through neglecting the languages and cultures of national minorities.

Keywords

John Stuart MillWill KymlickaFriedrich Engelscivilizationcoercive assimilation
Type
Article
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 50 , Issue 5: Special Issue on Accommodating National Diversity Within States , September 2022 , pp. 1003 - 1021
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Association for the Study of Nationalities

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Beaumont, Tim. 2019. “Mill and Pettit on Freedom, Domination, and Freedom-as-Domination.” Prolegomena: Journal of Philosophy 18 (1): 27–50.Google Scholar
Blake, Michael. 2003. “Language Death and Liberal Politics.” In Language Rights and Political Theory, edited by Will Kymlicka and Alan Patten, 210–229. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Coakley, John. 2018. “National Identity and the ‘Kohn Dichotomy.’” Nationalities Papers 46 (2): 252–271.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davidson, Neil. 2001. “Marx and Engels on the Scottish Highlands.” Science & Society 65 (3): 286–326.Google Scholar
Davies, Janet. 2014. The Welsh Language: A History. Cardiff: University of Wales Press.Google Scholar
De Schutter, Helder. 2014. “Testing for Linguistic Injustice: Territoriality and Pluralism.” Nationalities Papers 42 (6): 1034–1052.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Durham, John Lambton, Earl of. 1839. “The Report.” In The Report and Despatches of the Earl of Durham, Her Majesty’s High Commissioner and Governor-General of British North America, 1–250, London: Ridgways.Google Scholar
Engels, Friedrich. 1977a. “The Danish-Prussian Armistice.” In Marx and Engels: 1848, edited by Cohen, Jack et al., translated by Benton, Gregor et al., 421–425, vol. 7 of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Collected Works. Lawrence & Wishart. https://lwbooks.co.uk/marx-engels-collected-works/read-and-search-online.Google Scholar
Engels, Friedrich. 1977b. “Democratic Pan-Slavism.” In Marx and Engels: 1848–49, edited by Cohen, Jack et al., translated by Benton, Gregor et al. 362–378, vol. 8 of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Collected Works. Lawrence & Wishart. https://lwbooks.co.uk/marx-engels-collected-works/read-and-search-online.Google Scholar
Engels, Friedrich. 1977c. “The Magyar Struggle.” In Marx and Engels: 1848–49, edited by Cohen, Jack et al. translated by Benton, Gregor et al., 227–238, vol 8 of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Collected Works. Lawrence & Wishart. https://lwbooks.co.uk/marx-engels-collected-works/read-and-search-online.Google Scholar
Hobsbawm, Eric. 1992. Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jaskułowski, Krzysztof. 2010. “Western (civic) versus Eastern (ethnic) Nationalism. The Origins and Critique of the Dichotomy.” Polish Sociological Review 3 (171), 1231–1413.Google Scholar
Kasprzak, Michal. 2012. “To Reject or not to Reject Nationalism: Debating Marx and Engels’ Struggles with Nationalism, 1840s–1880s.” Nationalities Papers 40(4): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kymlicka, Will. 1995. Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Martins, Amy. 2012. Alter-Nations: Nationalisms, Terror, and the State in Nineteenth-Century Britain and Ireland. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1965. Principles of Political Economy . In Principles of Political Economy Part II, edited by Robson, John M., 455–974, vol. 3 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-iii-principles-of-political-economy-part-ii.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1972. “Letter to Col. William F. P. Napier.” In The Later Letters 1849-1873 Part IV, edited by Mineka, Francis E. and Lindley, Dwight N., 1982–1983, vol. 17 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, edited by Robson, John M. (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xvii-the-later-letters-1849-1873-part-iv.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1977a. Considerations on Representative Government . In Essays on Politics and Society Part II, edited by Robson, John M., 371–578, vol. 19 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/robson-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xix-essays-on-politics-and-society-part-2.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1977b. On Liberty . In Essays on Politics and Society Part I, edited by Robson, John M., 214–310, vol. 18 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/robson-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xviii-essays-on-politics-and-society-part-i.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1981. Autobiography . In Autobiography and Literary Essays, edited by Robson, John M. and Stillinger, Jack, 1–298, vol. 1 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-i-autobiography-and-literary-essays.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1982a. England and Ireland . In Essays on England, Ireland, and the Empire, edited by Robson, John M., 505–534, vol. 6 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-vi-essays-on-england-ireland-and-the-empire.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1982b. “Lord Durham’s Return.” In Essays on England, Ireland, and the Empire, edited by Robson, John M., 445–464, vol. 6 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-vi-essays-on-england-ireland-and-the-empire.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1982c. “Repeal of the Union.” In Essays on England, Ireland, and the Empire, edited by Robson, John M., 214–218, vol. 6 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-vi-essays-on-england-ireland-and-the-empire.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1982d. “What Is to be Done with Ireland?” In Essays on England, Ireland, and the Empire, edited by Robson, John M., 497–504, vol. 6 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-vi-essays-on-england-ireland-and-the-empire.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1984a. “The Contest in America.” In Essays on Equality, Law, and Education, edited by Robson, John M., 125–142, vol. 21 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xxi-essays-on-equality-law-and-education.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1984b. A Few Words on Non-intervention . In Essays on Equality, Law, and Education, edited by Robson, John M., 111–124, vol. 21 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/mill-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xxi-essays-on-equality-law-and-education.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1985. Vindication of the French Revolution of 1848 . In Essays on French History and Historians, edited by Robson, John M., 319–363, vol. 20 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/robson-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xx-essays-on-french-history-and-historians.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1986. “The Condition of Ireland [13].” In Newspaper Writings January 1835–June 1847 Part III, edited by Robson, Ann P. and Robson, John M., 927–930, vol. 24 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/robson-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xxiv-newspaper-writings-part-iii.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. 1990. Memorandum of the Improvements in the Administration of India during the Last Thirty Years . In Writings on India, edited by Robson, John M., Moir, Martin, and Moir, Zawahir, 91–160, vol. 30 of the Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). https://oll.libertyfund.org/title/moir-the-collected-works-of-john-stuart-mill-volume-xxx-writings-on-india. [Co-authored in 1858]Google Scholar
Miller, David. 1997. On Nationality. Oxford: University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 1989. “Marx, Engels and the National Question.” Science & Society 53 (3), 297–326.Google Scholar
Rabow-Edling, Susanna. 2007. “The Decembrists and the Concept of a Civic Nation.” Nationalities Papers 35 (2): 369–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raithby, John, ed. 1811. “An Act for Laws and Justice to be ministered in Wales in like Form as it is in this Realm.” In From Magna Carta to the Union of the Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, 243–255, vol. 3 of The Statutes at Large of England and of Great Britain (London: Eyre and Strahan).Google Scholar
Thomas, Alan. 1994. “English in Wales.” In The Cambridge History of the English Language. Volume 5 English in Britain and Overseas: Origins and Development, edited by Robert Burchfield, 94–147. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tunick, Mark. 2005. “John Stuart Mill and Unassimilated Subjects.” Political Studies 53 (4), 833–848.Google Scholar
Tunick, Mark. 2006. “Tolerant Imperialism: John Stuart Mill’s Defense of British Rule in India.” Review of Politics 68 (4), 586–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Varouxakis, Georgios. 2002. Mill on Nationality. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Watson, George. 1998. “Hitler and the Socialist Dream.” Preview of The Lost Literature of Socialism by George Watson. The Independent. November 22, 1998. https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/hitler-and-the-socialist-dream-1186455.html.Google Scholar
Weinstock, Daniel M. 2003. “The Antinomy of Language Policy.” In Language Rights and Political Theory, edited by Kymlicka, Will and Patten, Alan, 250–270. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar