Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-8zxtt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-12T17:35:06.777Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Legislation of Crime and Delinquency: A Review of Theory, Method, and Research

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 July 2024

John Hagan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Nearly all of us will agree that “one case does not make a sample.” Nonetheless, there is a tendency to disregard this advice when it comes to studying the historical origins of laws concerning crime and delinquency. This is understandable since it is generally acknowledged that the micro- and macro-level processes surrounding the origins of many such laws are so complex that they can only be examined case by case (e.g., Hall, 1952; Chambliss, 1964). But such an approach creates problems: although any single case study is clearly inadequate to support generalizations, strong theoretical inferences frequently are drawn, often violating the constraints adopted with more conventional data. This essay reviews a number of North American case studies in an attempt to clarify the theoretical and methodological limitations, prospects, and findings of the literature on criminal lawmaking.

I introduce this review by contrasting the two principal theoretical perspectives that guide such studies. I then discuss problems of evidence related to these rival theories, using an analysis of the origins of theft laws as my example. Following this, I review a large number of empirical studies concerned with the origin of laws that I have grouped into three categories: (i) delinquency and probation; (ii) alcohol and drug abuse; and (iii) prostitution and sexual psychopathy. Finally, I examine the implications of these and other legislative studies for future work in this important area of research.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 14 , Issue 3: Contemporary Issues in Law and Social Science , Spring 1980 , pp. 603 - 628
Copyright
Copyright © 1980 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ABEL, Richard L. (1973) “Law Books and Books About Law,” 26 Stanford Law Review 175.Google Scholar
ADDAMS, Jane (1912) A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil. New York: MacMillan Co.Google Scholar
ALMY, Frederic (1902) “Juvenile Courts in Buffalo,” 20 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 279.Google Scholar
ANDERSON, Eric (1974) “Prostitution and Social Justice: Chicago, 1910-15,” 48 Social Service Review 203.Google Scholar
BECKER, Howard S. (1963) The Outsiders. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
BERK, Richard, Harold, BRACKMAN and Selma, LESSER (1977) A Measure of Justice: An Empirical Study of Changes in the California Penal Code, 1955-1971. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
BLUM, Richard and Mary Lou, FUNKHAUSER (1965) “Legislators on Social Scientists and a Social Issue,” 1 Journal of Applied Behavioural Science 84.Google Scholar
BOHANNAN, Paul (1965) “The Differing Realms of the Law,” 67(6) (pt. 2) American Anthropologist 33 (Special Publication).Google Scholar
BONNIE, Richard J. and Charles H., WHITEBREAD (1974) The Marihuana Conviction. Charlottesville, Va.: University of Virginia Press.Google Scholar
BOYD, Neil (1978) “An Examination of Probation,” 20 Criminal Law Quarterly 355.Google Scholar
BRYANT, Keith L. (1968) “The Juvenile Court Movement: Oklahoma as a Case Study,” 49 Social Science Quarterly 368.Google Scholar
CHAMBLISS, William (1964) “A Sociological Analysis of the Law of Vagrancy,” 12 Social Problems 67.Google Scholar
CHAMBLISS, William (1976) “Functional and Conflict Theories of Crime: The Heritage of Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx,” in Whose Law, What Order? New York: John Wiley.Google Scholar
CHAMBLISS, William (1974) “The State, the Law and the Definition of Behavior as Criminal or Delinquent” in Glaser, Daniel (ed.) Handbook of Criminology. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.Google Scholar
CHAPIN, Bradley (1964) The American Law of Treason: Revolutionary and National Origins. Seattle: University of Washington Press.Google Scholar
CHELL, Eugene P. (1958) “Sunday Blue Laws: An Analysis of their Position in Our Society,” 12 Rutgers Law Review 520.Google Scholar
CHILTON, Roland (1970) “Social Control through Welfare Legislation: The Impact of a State Suitable Home Law,” 5 Law & Society Review 205.Google Scholar
COHN, S.F. and J.E., GALLAGHER (1977) “Crime and the Creation of Criminal Law,” 4 British Journal of Law and Society 220.Google Scholar
COOK, Shirley (1969) “Canadian Narcotics Legislation, 1908-23: A Conflict Model Interpretation,” 6 Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 36.Google Scholar
COOK, Shirley (1970) Variations in Response to Illegal Drug Use. Toronto: Alcoholism and Drug Addiction Research Foundation.Google Scholar
CURRIE, Elliot P. (1968) “The Control of Witchcraft in Renaissance Europe,” 3 Law & Society Review 355.Google Scholar
DAVIS, Kingsley (1966) “Sexual Behavior,” in Merton, Robert K. and Nisbet, Robert A. (eds.) Contemporary Social Problems. New York: Harcourt, Brace and World.Google Scholar
DICKSON, Donald T. (1968) “Bureaucracy and Morality: An Organizational Perspective on a Moral Crusade,” 16 Social Problems 143.Google Scholar
DURKHEIM, Emile (1964) The Division of Labor in Society. Glencoe, Illinois: Free Press.Google Scholar
DUSTER, Troy (1970) The Legislation of Morality: Law, Drugs and Moral Judgement. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
FELDMAN, Egal (1967) “Prostitution, the Alien Woman, and Progressive Imagination: 1910-15,” 19 American Quarterly 192.Google Scholar
FILLER, Louis (1950) Crusaders for American Liberalism. Yellow Springs, Ohio: Antioch Press.Google Scholar
FOOTE, Caleb (1956) “Vagrancy-Type Law and its Administration,” 104 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 603.Google Scholar
FOX, Sanford (1970) “Juvenile Justice Reform: An Historical Perspective,” 22 Stanford Law Review 1987.Google Scholar
FRIEDMANN, Wolfgang (1959) Law in a Changing Society. London: Stevens & Sons.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
GALLIHER, John F., McCARTNEY, James L. and Barbara, BAUM (1974) “Nebraska's Marijuana Law: A Case of Unexpected Legislative Innovation,” 8 Law & Society Review 441.Google Scholar
GALLIHER, John F. and Alynn, WALKER (1977) “The Puzzle of the Origins of the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937,” 24 Social Problems 367.Google Scholar
GRAHAM, James M. (1972) “Amphetamine Politics on Capitol Hill,” 9 Transaction 14.Google Scholar
GUSFIELD, Joseph R. (1963) Symbolic Crusade. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
HAGAN, John (1979) “Symbolic Justice: The Status Politics of the American Probation Movement,” 12 Sociological Focus 285.Google Scholar
HAGAN, John and Jeffrey, LEON (1977) “Rediscovering Delinquency: Social History, Political Ideology and the Sociology of Law,” 42 American Sociological Review 587.Google Scholar
HAGAN, John, Edward, SILVA and John, SIMPSON (1977) “Conflict and Consensus in the Designation of Deviance,” 56 Social Forces 320.Google Scholar
HALL, Jerome (1952) Theft, Law and Society. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merril.Google Scholar
HALL, Jerome (1960) General Principles of Law. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.Google Scholar
HALL, Jerome (1963) Comparative Law and Social Theory. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press.Google Scholar
HALLER, Mark (1970) “Urban Crime and Criminal Justice: The Chicago Case,” 57 Journal of American History 619.Google Scholar
HARRIS, George E. (1892) A Treatise on Sunday Laws. Rochester, N.Y.: Lawyers' Cooperative Publishing Co.Google Scholar
HASKINS, George Lee (1960) Law and Authority in Early Massachusetts. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
HAY, Douglas, Peter, LINEBAUGH, John G., RULE, E.P., THOMPSON, and Cal, WINSLOW (1975) Albion's Fatal Tree. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
HOLMES, Kay Ann (1972) “Reflections by Gaslight: Prostitution in Another Age,” 7 Issues in Criminology 83.Google Scholar
HOPKINS, Andrew (1975) “On the Sociology of Criminal Law,” 22 Social Problems 608.Google Scholar
HURST, J. Willard (1950) The Growth of American Law: The Law Makers. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
INTERNATIONAL PRISON COMMISSION (1904) Children's Courts in the United States: Their Origin, Development and Results. H.R. Doc. No. 701, 58th Cong., 2d Sess.Google Scholar
JEFFERY, Clarence Ray (1957) “The Development of Crime in Early English Society,” 47 Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 647.Google Scholar
JOHNSON, Alvin W. (1934) “Sunday Legislation,” 23 Kentucky Law Journal 131.Google Scholar
LACEY, Forrest W. (1953) “Vagrancy and Other Crimes of Personal Condition,” 66 Harvard Law Review 1203.Google Scholar
LEMERT, Edwin M. (1970) Social Action and Legal Change: Revolution Within the Juvenile Court. Chicago: Aldine.Google Scholar
LEVY, Leonard W. (1963) Freedom of Speech and Press in Early American History: Legacy of Suppression. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
LEWIS, Abram (1888) A Critical History of Sunday Legislation from 321 to 1888 A.D. New York: Appleton.Google Scholar
LINDESMITH, Alfred R. (1957) “The British System of Narcotics Control,” 5 Law and Contemporary Problems 138.Google Scholar
LINDESMITH, Alfred R. (1959) “Federal Law and Drug Addiction,” 7 Social Problems 48.Google Scholar
LINDESMITH, Alfred R. (1967) The Addict and the Law. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
LINDESMITH, Alfred R. (1968) Addiction and Opiates. Chicago: Aldine.Google Scholar
LOU, Herbert H. (1927) Juvenile Courts in the United States. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
LUBOVE, Roy (1962) “The Progressive and the Prostitute,” 24 Historian 308.Google Scholar
McFARLANE, George C. (1966) The Development of Probation Services in Ontario. Toronto: Queen's Printer.Google Scholar
McGAGHY, Charles H. and A. Serge, DENISOFF (1973) “Pirates and Politics: An Analysis of Interest Group Conflict,” in Denisoff, R. Serge and McGaghy, Charles H. (eds.) Deviance, Conflict and Criminality. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
MENNEL, Robert M. (1973) Thorns & Thistles: Juvenile Delinquents in the United States, 1825-1940. Hanover, New Hampshire: The University Press of New England.Google Scholar
MORRIS, Richard B. (1959) Studies in the History of American Law. New York: Joseph M. Mitchell.Google Scholar
MUELLER, Gerhard O.W. (1961) Legal Regulation of Sexual Conduct. Dobbs Ferry, New York: Oceana Publications.Google Scholar
MUSTO, David F. (1973) The American Disease: Origins of Narcotic Control. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
NELSON, Harold L. (1959) “Seditious Libel in Colonial America,” 3 American Journal of Legal History 160.Google Scholar
NELSON, William E. (1967) “Emerging Notions of Modern Criminal Law in the Revolutionary Era: An Historical Perspective,” 42 New York University Law Review 450.Google Scholar
ODEGARD, Peter H. (1928) Pressure Politics. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
PARKER, Graham (1976a) “The Juvenile Court Movement,” 26 University of Toronto Law Journal 140.Google Scholar
PARKER, Graham (1976b) “The Juvenile Court Movement: The Illinois Experience,” 26 University of Toronto Law Journal 253.Google Scholar
PARSONS, Talcott (1951) The Social System. Glencoe, Ill.: Free Press.Google Scholar
PARSONS, Talcott (1966) Societies: Evolutionary and Comparative Perspectives. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
PIVAR, David J. (1973) Purity Crusade: Sexual Morality and Social Control, 1868-1900. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, Inc.Google Scholar
PLATT, Anthony M. (1969) The Child Savers. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
PLATT, Anthony M. (1974) “The Triumph of Benevolence: The Origins of the Juvenile Justice System in the United States,” in Quinney, Richard (ed.) Criminal Justice in America. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
PLATT, Anthony M. (1975) “Prospects for a Radical Criminology in the U.S.A.,” in Taylor, Ian, Walton, Paul and Young, Jock (eds.) Critical Criminology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
PLOSCOWE, Morris (1960) “Sex Offenses: The American Legal Context,” 25 Law and Contemporary Problems 217.Google Scholar
POUND, Roscoe (1943) “A Survey of Interests,” 57 Harvard Law Review 1.Google Scholar
POWERS, Edwin (1966) Crime and Punishment in Early Massachusetts. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
PRIESTLEY, Phillip, Denise, FEARS and Roger, FULLER (1977) Justice for Juveniles: the 1969 Children and Young Persons Act: A Case for Reform? London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
QUINNEY, Richard (1970) The Social Reality of Crime. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
QUINNEY, Richard (1975a) “Crime Control in Capitalist Society: A Critical Philosophy,” in Taylor, Ian, Walton, Paul and Young, Jock (eds.) Critical Criminology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
QUINNEY, Richard (1975b) Criminology. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
REASONS, Charles (1974) “The Politics of Drugs: An Inquiry in the Sociology of Social Problems,” 15 Sociological Quarterly 381.Google Scholar
ROBY, Pamela A. (1969) “Politics and Criminal Law: Revision of the New York State Penal Law on Prostitution,” 17 Social Problems 83.Google Scholar
ROBY, Pamela A. (1972) “Politics and Prostitution: A Case Study of the Revision, Enforcement and Administration of the New York State Penal Laws on Prostitution,” 9 Criminology 425.Google Scholar
SCHLOSSMAN, Steven (1977) Love and the American Delinquent. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SCHULTZ, J.L. (1973) “The Cycle of Juvenile Court History,” 19 Crime and Delinquency 457.Google Scholar
SCHUR, Edwin M. (1962) Narcotic Addiction in Britain and America: The Impact of Public Policy. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
SHERRY, Arthur (1960) “Vagrants, Rogues and Vagabonds—Old Concepts in Need of Revision,” 48 California Law Review 567.Google Scholar
SINCLAIR, Andrew (1962) Prohibition: The Era of Excess. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
SUTHERLAND, Edwin H. (1951) “The Diffusion of Sexual Psychopath Laws,” 56 American Journal of Sociology 142.Google Scholar
SUTHERLAND, Edwin H. (1950) “The Sexual Psychopath Laws,” 40 Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 543.Google Scholar
SWANSON, Alan H. (1960) “Sexual Psychopath Statutes: Summary and Analysis,” 51 Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 215.Google Scholar
TAPPAN, Paul W. (1950) “Sexual Offender Laws and Their Administration,” 14 Federal Probation 33.Google Scholar
TAYLOR, Ian, Paul, WALTON and Jock, YOUNG (1973) The New Criminology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
TAYLOR, Ian (1975) Critical Criminology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
THOMPSON, Edward Palmer (1975) Whigs and Hunters. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
TIMBERLAKE, James H. (1963) Prohibition and the Progressive Movement: 1900-1920. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
TURK, Austin (1976) “Law as a Weapon in Social Conflict,” 23 Social Problems 276.Google Scholar
TURNER, George Kibbe (1907) “The City of Chicago: A Study of Great Immoralities,” McClure's Magazine 575 (April).Google Scholar
WATERMAN, Willoughby (1932) Prostitution and Its Repression in New York City, 1900-1931. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
WESTIN, Allan F. (1962) “Bookies and ‘Bugs’ in California,” in Westin, Allan (ed.) The Uses of Power: Seven Case Studies in American Politics. New York: Harcourt, Brace & Co.Google Scholar
WOLFGANG, Marvin and Mark, RIEDEL (1973) “Race, Judicial Discretion, and the Death Penalty,” 407 The Annals 119.Google Scholar
YOUNG, Paul (1976) “A Sociological Analysis of the Early History of Probation,” 3 British Journal of Law and Society 44.Google Scholar