Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-8bljj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-28T22:35:14.178Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Cows in the Corn, Pigs in the Garden, and “the Problem of Social Costs”: “High” and “Low” Legal Cultures of the British Diaspora Lands in the 17th, 18th, and 19th Centuries

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 April 2024

Peter Karsten
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Economist Ronald Coase's famous theorem regarding the ways that neighboring property owners bargain “around” law and government has been refined by Robert Ellickson, who studied the ways ranchers and their ranchette neighbors resolve problems of fencing and animal trespass. Both Coase and Ellickson rely on rational actor models of Economic Man in predicting and explaining human behavior and dispute resolution. Both offer animal trespasses as the prime illustrations. Both models are flawed.

Ellickson asked what might one learn by mining historical sources to reconstruct “bargaining” between ranchers and farmers, but he found the task daunting.

In the course of research into the “high” (formal) legal cultures and the “low” (informal) legal cultures in the lands of the British diaspora, 1630–1910, I gathered information on just such interactions (over fencing and animal trespass), and in this article I put Coase's and Ellickson's models to the test of the historian's laboratory. While Ellickson's model has significant power in predicting the behavior of mature British settlements where the neighbors were of the same core culture, it is not as effective in predicting dispute resolutions in frontier conditions and is of little use in predicting the interactions of Puritans and Algonquins, Pakehas and Maoris.

Type
Research Article
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 32 , Issue 1 , 1998 , pp. 63 - 92
Copyright
Copyright © The Law and Society Association, 1998. All Rights Reserved

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author thanks Werner Troesken, Bruce Kercher, Bronwyn Dalley, Bernard Hibbitts, and the anonymous readers for their critiques, absolving them etc., etc.

References

References

Adams, Peter (1977) Fatal Necessity: British Intervention in New Zealand, 1830–1847. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Allen, David Grayson (1981) In English Ways: The Movement of Societies and the Transformation of English Local Law and Custom to Massachusetts Bay in the 17th Century. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Anderson, Virginia Dejohn (1994) “King Philip's Herds: Indians, Colonists, and the Problem of Livestock in Early New England,” 51 William & Mary Q. 601–24.Google Scholar
Banner, Stuart (1996) “Written Law and Unwritten Norms in Colonial St. Louis,” 14 Law & History Rev. 33–80.Google Scholar
Bennett, J. M. (1971) “The Day of Retribution: Commissioner Bigge's Inquiries in Colonial New South Wales,” 15 American J. of Legal History 85–100.Google Scholar
Black, Donald (1990) “The Elementary Forms of Conflict Management,” in New Directions in the Study of Justice, Law and Social Control. Tempe: School of Justice Studies, Arizona State Univ.Google Scholar
Boyer, Paul, & Nissenbaum, Steven, eds. (1977) The Salem Village Witchcraft Papers: Verbatim Transcripts of the Legal Documents of the Salem Witchcraft Outbreak of 1692. 3 vols. New York: De Capo Press.Google Scholar
Brown, R. Ben (1989) “Let Us Go Down and There Confound Their Language”: The Multiplicity of Legal Discourses in the Antebellum United States. American Bar Foundation Working Paper 8901. Chicago: American Bar Foundation.Google Scholar
Brown, R. Ben (1990) Closing the Southern Range: A Chapter in the Decline of Southern Yeomanry. American Bar Foundation Working Paper 9020. Chicago: American Bar Foundation.Google Scholar
Byrne, Paula J. (1993) Criminal Law and Colonial Subject: New South Wales, 1810–1830. Sydney: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cadigan, Sean (1995) Hope and Deception in Conception Bay: Merchant-Settler Relations in Newfoundland, 1785–1855. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Calloway, Colin (1995) The American Revolution in Indian Country. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carr, Lois (1977) “The Development of the Maryland Orphan's Court, 1654–1715,” in Carr, L. & Land, A., eds., Law, Society and Politics in Early Maryland. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Carroll, Charles (1973) The Timber Economy of Puritan New England. Providence, RI: Brown Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Clark, C. M. H. (1978) A History of Australia, Vol. 4: The Earth Abideth Forever, 1851–1888. Carlton, Vic, Australia: Melbourne Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Coase, Ronald (1960) “The Problem of Social Costs,” 3 J. of Law & Economics 1–44.Google Scholar
Cooney, Mark (1993) “Why Is Economic Analysis So Appealing to Law Professors?” 45 Stanford Law Rev. 2211–30.Google Scholar
Cronon, William (1983) Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists and the Ecology of New England. New York: Hill & Wang.Google Scholar
Dayton, Cornelia H. (1995) Women before the Bar: Gender, Law and Society in Connecticut, 1639–1850. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Dechêne, Louise (1992) Habitants and Merchants in 17th Century Montreal. Montreal: McGill–Queen's Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Demos, John (1982) Entertaining Satan: Witchcraft and the Culture of Early New England. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Deverell, William (1994) Railroad Crossing: Californians and the Railroad, 1850–1910. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dykstra, Robert (1968) The Cattle Towns. New York: Atheneum.Google Scholar
Ellickson, Robert (1991) Order without Law: How Neighbors Settle Disputes. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fairburn, Miles (1989) The Ideal Society and Its Enemies: The Foundations of Modern New Zealand Society, 1850–1900. Auckland, NZ: Auckland Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Fisher, Robin (1977) Contact and Conflict: Indian-European Relations in British Columbia, 1774–1890. Vancouver: Univ. of British Columbia Press.Google Scholar
Fresne, Yvonne du (1989) The Bear from the North: Tales of a New Zealand Childhood. London: Women's Press.Google Scholar
Galbraith, John Kenneth (1964) The Scotch. Boston: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Greene, Jack P., ed. (1965) The Diary of Colonel Landon Carter [J.P.] of Sabine Hall, 1752–1778, ed. Greene, Jack P., vol. 2. Charlottesville: Univ. Press of Virginia.Google Scholar
Hahn, Stephen (1982) “Hunting, Fishing and Foraging: Common Rights and Class Relations in the Postbellum South,” 26 Radical History Rev. 37–64.Google Scholar
Hahn, Stephen-(1993) “A Response: Common Cents or Historical Sense,” 59 J. of Southern History 243–58.Google Scholar
Harring, Sidney (1994) Crow Dog's Case. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, Marvin (1979) Cultural Materialism: The Struggle for a Science of Culture. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Hartog, Hendrik (1985) “Pigs and Positivism,” 1985 Wisconsin Law Rev. 899–935.Google Scholar
Hayter, Earl (1963) “Livestock-Fencing Conflicts in Rural America,” 37 Agricultural History 11–20.Google Scholar
Heckman, James J. (1997) “The Intellectual Roots of the Law & Economics Movement,” 15 Law & History Rev. 327–34.Google Scholar
Hill, Richard (1986) Policing the Colonial Frontier, vol. I, pt. 2: The Theory and Practice of Coercive Social and Racial Control in New Zealand, 1767–1867. Wellington: Historical Publications Branch, Dept. of Internal Affairs.Google Scholar
Hill, R. (1989) The Colonial Frontier Tamed: New Zealand Policing in Transition, 1867–1886. Wellington, NZ: G. P. Books.Google Scholar
Jackson, Donald, ed. (1964) Black Hawk: An Autobiography. Urbana: Univ. of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Kantor, Shawn, & Kousser, Morgan (1983a) “Common Sense or Commonwealth? The Fence Law and Institutional Change in the Postbellum South,” 59 J. of Southern History 201–42.Google Scholar
Kousser, Morgan-(1983b) “A Rejoinder: Two Visions of History,” 59 J. of Southern History 259–66.Google Scholar
Kawashima, Yasuhide (1994) “Fence Laws on the Great Plains, 1865–1900,” in Cawthon, Elizabeth & Narrett, David, eds., Essays on English Law and the American Experience. College Station: Texas A&M Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Kercher, Bruce (1995) Unruly Child: A History of Law in Australia. St. Leonards, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Kercher, Bruce-(1996) Debt, Seduction and Other Disasters: The Birth of Civil Law in New South Wales. Sydney: Federation Press.Google Scholar
Konig, David (1979) Law and Society in Puritan Massachusetts: Essex County, 1629–1692. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Kornhauser, Lewis (1992) “Are There Cracks in the Foundations of Spontaneous Order?” 51 New York Univ. Law Rev. 647–73.Google Scholar
Kugel, Rebecca (1994) “Of Missionaries and Their Cattle: Ojibwa Perceptions of a Missionary as Evil Shaman,” 41 Ethnohistory 227–44.Google Scholar
Landes, William, & Posner, Richard (1987) The Economic Structure of Tort Law. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewthwaite, Susan (1994) “Violence, Law and Community in Rural Upper Canada,” in Phillips, Jim et al., eds., Essays in the History of Canadian Law, Vol. 5. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loo, Tina (1994) Making Law, Order, and Authority in British Columbia, 1821–1871. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mandell, Daniel (1996) Behind the Frontier: Indians in Eighteenth Century Eastern Massachusetts. Lincoln: Univ. of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar
McMath, Robert (1985) “Sandy Land and Hogs in Timber: Farmers Alliance in Texas,” in Prude, Jonathan & Hahn, Stephen, eds., The Countryside in the Age of Capitalist Transformation. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Merry, Sally Engle (1990) Getting Justice and Getting Even: Legal Consciousness among Working-Class Americans. Chicago, Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Morgan, Gwenda (1989) The Hegemony of the Law: Richmond County, Virginia, 1692–1776. New York: Garland.Google Scholar
Morison, Samuel Eliot, ed. (1952) Of Plymouth Plantation, 1620-1647. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Morrison, Kenneth (1984) The Embattled Northeast: The Elusive Ideal of Alliance in Abenaki-Euramerican Relations. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nagle, J. F. (1996) Collins, the Courts and the Colony: Law and Society in Colonial New South Wales, 1788–1796. Sydney: Univ. of New South Wales Press.Google Scholar
O'Brien, Jean (1997) Dispossession by Degrees: Indian Land and Identity in Natick, Massacusetts, 1650–1790. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parsons, T. G. (1985) “Was John Boston's Pig a Political Martyr? The Reaction to Popular Radicalism in Early New South Wales,” 71 J. of the Royal Australian Historical Society 170.Google Scholar
Peters, Alvin (1989) “Posts & Palings, Posts & Planks,” 12 (Winter) Kansas History 222–31.Google Scholar
Pinney, Robert (1971) Early South Canterbury Runs. Wellington, N.Z.: Reed.Google Scholar
Potter, Stephen (1993) Commoners, Tribute and Chiefs: Algonquians in the Potomac Valley. Charlottesville: Univ. Press of Virginia.Google Scholar
Prucha, Francis Paul (1962) American Indian Policy in the Formative Years: The Indian Trade and Intercourse Acts, 1780–1834. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Rappaport, Roy (1967) Pigs for the Ancestors: Ritual in the Ecology of a New Guinea People. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Reid, John Phillip (1976) A Better Kind of Hatchet: Law, Trade, and Diplomacy in the Cherokee Nation during the Early Years of European Contact. University Park: Penn State Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Roberts, Stephen (1935) The Squatting Age in Australia, 1835–1847. Melbourne: Melbourne Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Sitton, Thad (1995) Backwoodsmen: Stockmen and Hunters along a Big Thicket River Valley. Norman: Univ. of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Joseph H., ed. (1961) Colonial Justice in Western Massachusetts, 1639–1702: The Pyncheon Court Record. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Taylor, Peter (1988) Station Life in Australia: Pioneers and Pastoralists. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Vickers, Daniel (1994) Farmers and Fishermen: Two Centuries of Work in Essex County, Massachusetts, 1630–1850. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Ward, Alan (1974) A Show of Justice: Racial “Amalgamation” in Nineteenth Century New Zealand. Canberra: Australian National Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Wards, Ian (1968) The Shadow of the Land: A Study of British Policy and Racial Conflict in New Zealand, 1832–1852. Wellington: Historical Publications Branch, Dept. of Internal Affairs.Google Scholar
Weber, Eugen (1976) Peasants into Frenchmen: The Modernization of Rural France, 1870–1914. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wynne, Graeme (1992) “Ideology, Society and State in the Maritime Colonies of British North America, 1840–60,” in Greer, A., ed., Colonial Leviathan: State Formation in Mid-19th Century Canda. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Wynne-Edwards, V. C. (1962) Animal Dispersion in Relation to Social Behavior. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd.Google Scholar
Yngvesson, Barbara (1993) “Beastley Neighbors: Continuing Relations in Catde Country,” 102 Yale Law J. 1787–1801.Google Scholar

Cases

Aylesworth v. Herrington, 17 Mich. 416 (1868).Google Scholar
Bliss v. Dorchester, J.P. Ct., Springfield, Mass., March 2, 1653.Google Scholar
Cameron v. Reed, 2 Mich. Nisi Prius (Brown) 150 (1871).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cantrell v. Adderholt, 28 Ga. 239 (1858).Google Scholar
Challoner & Another v. McPhail & Another, NSW SCR (Knox) 157 (1877).Google Scholar
Champion v. Vincent, 20 Tex. 812 at 817 (1859).Google Scholar
Cole v. Tucker, 6 Texas 266 (1851).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Les Curé et Marguilliers de l'OEuvre et Fabrique de l' Isle Perrot v. Ricard, 9 Lower C.J. 99 (1864).Google Scholar
Curtiss v. Townsend, 6 UCCP 255 (1857).Google Scholar
Firth v. Martin, Nov. 1858, Wellington, N.Z., Magistrate's Court, reported in N.Z. Spectator, Nov. 13, 1858, p. 2.Google Scholar
Fugate v. Smith, 4 Col. App. 201, 35 Pac. 283 (1894).Google Scholar
Mackay Bros. v. Wellington–M. Ry., 6 N.Z.L.R. (CA.) 185 (1887).Google Scholar
Malone v. Faulkner, 11 U.C.Q.B. 116 (1853).Google Scholar
Martin v. Jones, 15 Lower C.J. 6 (1869).Google Scholar
McGill v. Morley, 3 Newf. R. 146 (1850).Google Scholar
Pattenaude v. Charron, 17 Lower C.J. 85 (1870).Google Scholar
Ricard v. La Fabrique de la paroisse St. Jeanne … (unreported, Q.B. Montreal, 1868).Google Scholar
Wellis v. Beal, 9 Kans. 406 (1872).Google Scholar
Whitman v. Corp. of Town of Stanbridge, 26 Lower C.J. 144 (1881).Google Scholar