Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-25wd4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T12:35:44.466Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Violence against Women and Specialized Justice in Guatemala: Advances and Limitations

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 April 2023

Erin Beck
Erin Beck*
Affiliation:
Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR, United States Email: Beck@UOregon.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article provides the first detailed account of the structure, functioning, and impact of Guatemala’s Femicide and Other Forms of Violence against Women Criminal Courts. I assess the achievements and limitations of these courts from two views: a bird’s eye view, which explores how cases proceed through these specialized courts, and an insiders’ view, which explores the perspectives and practices of their judges. Combined, these views demonstrate that judges’ personal commitments and the courts’ institutional frameworks benefit the minority of women whose cases are heard in them but that these benefits are undercut by the broader social and institutional contexts in which judges and courts operate. This can be seen both in a panoramic view that reveals key locations where cases involving violence against women and girls stall in the judicial process and also through judges’ critiques of the systems in which they are embedded. Both views provide insights that should guide policy makers and activists seeking to better fulfill the promise of these courts.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , First View , pp. 1 - 31
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Bar Foundation

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author’s work on violence against women courts in Guatemala has been supported by the Harry Frank Guggenheim Foundation (Grant no. 4410H0) as well as by the University of Oregon’s Center for Latino/a and Latin American Studies, the Center for the Study of Women in Society, and the Office of the Vice President for Research and Innovation. Her research received Institutional Review Board’s (IRB) approval (University of Oregon IRB Protocol no. 04252016.037). Much of the research for this project was conducted alongside Lynn Stephen, Philip H. Knight Chair, professor of anthropology at the University of Oregon. The author would like to thank Lynn Stephen, Alison Gash, Priscilla Yamin, and the four anonymous reviewers for their thoughtful feedback on earlier versions of this manuscript. Lastly, she thanks the many Guatemalans who lent their time, energy, and expertise to this project, especially the personnel associated with violence against women and girls (VAWG) courts in Guatemala City, Huehuetenango, and Quetzaltenango.

References

REFERENCES

Agnew-Brune, Christine, Moracco, Kathryn E., and Michael Bowling, J.. 2017. “Domestic Violence Protective Orders: A Qualitative Examination of Judges’ Decision-Making Processes.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence 32, no. 13: 1921–42.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2005. Guatemala: No Protection, No Justice: Killings of Women in Guatemala. London: Amnesty International.Google Scholar
Arensburg, Svenska, and Lewin, Elizabeth. 2014. “Comprensión de Los Nudos Institucionales en el Abordaje de la Violencia Contra las Mujeres en la Pareja: Aportes de Una Lectura Feminista a La Experiencia Chilena.” Universitas Humanística 78: 187–210.Google Scholar
Azócar, M. J. 2018. “¿Cómo Se Construye La Experticia Judicial?: Una Etnografía Judicial en Tribunales de Familia de Santiago de Chile.” Revista de Derecho (Valdivia) 31, no. 2: 9–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Azpuru, Dinorah. 2015. “Approval of Violence towards Women and Children in Guatemala.” Americas Barometer Insights 123: 1–8. http://www.vanderbilt.edu/lapop/insights/IO923en.pdf.Google Scholar
Azpuru, Dinorah, Rodríguez, Mariana, and Zechmeister, Elizabeth. 2018. “The Political Culture of Democracy in Guatemala and the Americas, 2016/17.” Latin American Public Opinion Project. https://www.vanderbilt.edu/lapop/guatemala/AB2016-17_Guatemala_Country_Report_English_V3_02.01.19_W_02.18.19.pdf.Google Scholar
Beck, Erin. 2019. “The Uneven Impacts of Violence against Women Reform in Guatemala: Intersecting Inequalities and the Patchwork State.” Latin American Research Review 56, no. 1: 20–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beck, Erin. 2021a. “The Long-Term Struggle for Violence against Women Legislation: The Guatemalan Women’s Movement and the Politics of Patience.” Politics & Gender 18, no. 4: 1043–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beck, Erin. 2021b. “The Uneven Impacts of Violence against Women Reforms in Guatemala: Intersecting Inequalities and the Patchwork State.” Latin American Research Review 56, no. 1: 20–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beck, Erin, and Mohamed, Amir. 2021. “A Body Speaks: State, Media, and Public Responses to Femicide in Guatemala.” Laws 10, no. 73: 1–27.Google Scholar
Beck, Erin, and Stephen, Lynn. 2021. “From Legislation to Everyday Practices in Guatemala’s Violence against Women Courts.” Journal of Latin American Studies. 53, no. 4: 741–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biland, Émilie, and Steinmetz, Hélène. 2017. “Are Judges Street-Level Bureaucrats? Evidence from French and Canadian Family Courts.” Law & Social Inquiry 42, no. 2: 298–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, Rachel. 2013. “Judicial Autonomy in Central America: A Typological Approach.” Political Research Quarterly 66, no. 4: 831–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, Rachel. 2017. The Achilles Heel of Democracy: Judicial Autonomy and the Rule of Law in Central America. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Casas, Lidia B., Riveros, Francisca W., and Vargas, Macarena P.. 2010. Violencia de Género y La Administración de Justicia. Santiago, Chile: Servicio Nacional de la Mujer.Google Scholar
Casas, Lidia, and Mera, Alejandara. 2004. Violencia de Género y Reforma Procesal Penal Chilena. Chile: Facultad de Derecho, Universidad Diego Portales.Google Scholar
Castellano, Ursula. 2017. “The Politics of Benchcraft: The Role of Judges in Mental Health Courts.” Law & Social Inquiry 42, no. 2: 398–422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, Morgan. 2012. “The Judge as Tragic Hero: Judicial Ethics in Lebanon’s Shari’a Courts.” American Ethnologist 38, no. 1: 106–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Comisión de Esclarecimiento Histórico. 1999. Guatemala: Memory of Silence: Report of the Commission for Historical Clarification. Guatemala: Comisión de Esclarecimiento Histórico.Google Scholar
Darbyshire, Penny. 2011. Sitting in Judgement: The Working Lives of Judges. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Eley, Susan. 2003. “Changing Practices: The Specialised Domestic Violence Court Process.” Howard Journal 44, no. 2: 113–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
England, Sarah. 2014. “Protecting a Woman’s Honor or Protecting Her Sexual Freedom?: Challenging the Guatemalan Patriarchal State through Reforms to Sexual Violence Legislation.” Latin American Perspectives 41, no. 1: 124–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Facio Montejo, Alda. 1992. Cuando El Género Suena Cambios Trae. San José, Costa Rica: Instituto Latinoamericano de las Naciones Unidas para la Prevención del Delito y el Tratamiento de Delicuente.Google Scholar
Fourcade, Marion. 2011. “Cents and Sensibility: Economic Valuation and the Nature of ‘Nature.’” American Journal of Sociology 116, no. 6: 1721–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frankel, Marvin E. 2013. “The Adversary Judge: The Experience of the Trial Judge.” In Judges on Judging: Views from the Bench, edited by O’Brien, David O., 97–105. 4th ed. Los Angeles: CQ Press.Google Scholar
Friedman, Elisabeth Jay. 2009. “Re(Gion)Alizing Women’s Human Rights in Latin America.” Politics & Gender 5: 349–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ginsburg, Tom, and Moustafa, Tamir. 2008. Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Godoy-Paiz, Paula. 2008. “Women in Guatemala’s Metropolitan Area: Violence, Law, and Social Justice.” Studies in Social Justice 2, no. 1: 27–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gover, Angela R., MacDonald, John M., and Alpert, Geoffrey. 2003. “Combating Domestic Violence: Findings from an Evaluation of a Local Domestic Violence Court.” Criminology and Public Policy 3, no. 1: 109–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grupo Guatemalteco de Mujeres. 2020. “Datos Estadísticos: Muertes Violentas de Mujeres-MVM Femicidios República de Guatemala.” Guatemala: Grupo Guatemalteco de Mujeres. http://ggm.org.gt/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Datos-estad%C3%ADsticos_-MVM-ACTUALIZADO-1-de-enero-al-30-de-abril-2020.pdf.Google Scholar
Haney, Lynne. 1996. “Homeboys, Babies, and Men in Suits.” American Sociological Review 61, no. 5: 759–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hersant, Jeanne, and Vigour, Cécile. 2017. “Judicial Politics on the Ground.” Law & Social Inquiry 42, no. 2: 292–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2014. Violencia En Contra de La Mujer 2008–2013. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2017. Estadísticas de Violencia En Contra de La Mujer 2014–2016. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2018a. Estadísticas de Violencia En Contra de La Mujer 2017. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadística Guatemala.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2018b. XII Censo Nacional de Población y VII de Vivienda. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadística Guatemala. https://www.censopoblacion.gt/.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2019. Estadísticas de Violencia En Contra de La Mujer 2018. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadística Guatemala.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas. 2021. Estadísticas de Violencia En Contra de La Mujer y Violencia Sexual 2020. Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas.Google Scholar
Jaffe, Peter G., Crooks, Claire V., Lee Dunford-Jackson, Billie, and Michael Town, Judge. 2003. “Vicarious Trauma in Judges: The Personal Challenge of Dispensing Justice.” Juvenile and Family Court Journal (Fall): 1–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kramer, Ronald. 2016. “Differential Punishment of Similar Behaviour: Sentencing Assault Cases in a Specialized Family Violence Court and ‘Regular Sentencing’ Courts.” British Journal of Criminology 56, no. 4: 689–708.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lainfiesta, Javier. 2018. “Jueces y Magistrados Piden Que Se Les Doble El Salario.” Prensa Libre, July 17. https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/jueces-y-magistrados-piden-que-se-les-doble-el-salario/.Google Scholar
Lazarus-Black, Mindie. 2007. Everyday Harm: Domestic Violence, Court Rites, and Cultures of Reconciliation. Champaign: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Lazarus-Black, Mindie, and McCall, Patricia. 2006. “The Politics of Place: Practice, Process, and Kinship in Domestic Violence Courts.” Human Organization 65, no. 2: 140–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lens, Vicki. 2015. “Against the Grain: Therapeutic Judging in a Traditional Family Court.” Law & Social Inquiry 41, no. 3: 701–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lipsky, Michael. 1980. Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Maytal, Anat. 2008. “Spacialized Domestic Violence Courts: Are They Worth the Trouble in Massachuesetts.” Public Interest Law Journal 18: 197–235.Google Scholar
Menjívar, Cecilia. 2011. Enduring Violence: Ladina Women’s Lives in Guatemala. Berkeley: Univeristy of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menjívar, Cecilia, and Drysdale Walsh, Shannon. 2016. “Subverting Justice: Socio-Legal Determinants of Impunity for Violence against Women in Guatemala.” Laws 5, no. 31: 8–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ministerio de Salud Pública y Asistencia Social. 2011. Informe Final v Encuesta Nacional de Salud Materno Infantil 2008–2009. Guatemala: Ministerio de Salud Pública y Asistencia Social.Google Scholar
Ministerio de Salud Pública y Asistencia Social. 2017. Informe Final VI Encuesta Nacional de Salud Materno Infantil 2014–2015. Guatemala: Ministerio de Salud Pública y Asistencia Social.Google Scholar
Mirador Judicial. 2022. “Respuestas Efectivas Por Fiscalía de Sección,” accessed March 14. https://iccpg.org.gt/indicadores/indicador-41/.Google Scholar
Mirchandani, Rekha. 2006. “‘Hitting Is Not Manly’ Domestic Violence Court and the Re-Imagination of the Patriarchal State.” Gender & Society 20, no. 6: 781–804.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neumann, Pamela. 2017. “When Laws Are Not Enough: Violence against Women and Bureaucratic Practice in Nicaragua.” Social Forces 95, no. 3: 1105–25.Google Scholar
Organismo Judicial. 2010. Protocolo de La Ley Contra El Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia Contra La Mujer. Guatemala: Escuela de Estudios Judiciales. http://ww2.oj.gob.gt/es/QueEsOJ/EstructuraOJ/UnidadesAdministrativas/CentroAnalisisDocumentacionJudicial/cds/CDs%20compilaciones/Normativa%20Femicidio/1_documentos/1-6.html.Google Scholar
Organismo Judicial. 2017. Audiencias Por Estado. Guatemala: Organismo Judicial. http://www.oj.gob.gt/estadisticaj/REPORTES%20CIDEJ/2017/AUDIENCIAS/Tribunal%20De%20Sentencia%20Femicidio/HUEHUETENANGO/Tribunal%20De%20Sentencia%20Femicidio.pdf.Google Scholar
Picard-Fritsche, Sarah, Bryan, Jennifer, Kralstein, Dana, and Farley, Erin. 2011. The Bronx Family Treatment Court 2005–2010: Impact on Family Court Outcomes and Participant Experiences and Perceptions. New York: Center for Court Innovation.Google Scholar
Pierobom do Ávila, Thiago. 2018. “Facing Domestic Violence against Women in Brazil: Advances and Challenges.” International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 7, no. 1: 15–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Insider, Prison. 2017. Guatemala. Guatemala City: Prison Insider. https://www.prison-insider.com/countryprofile/prisonsinguatemala#.Google Scholar
Riquelme Espinosa, Ignacio. 2021. The Construction of Legal Authority: An Ethnography of Intrafamily Violence Procedures in Chilean Family Courts. Bristol, UK: University of Bristol. https://research-information.bris.ac.uk/en/studentTheses/the-construction-of-legal-authority.Google Scholar
Roggeband, Conny. 2016. “Ending Violence against Women in Latin America: Feminist Norm Setting in a Multlevel Context.” Politics & Gender 12: 143–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rossman, Shelli B., Rempel, Michael, Roman, John K., Zweig, Janine M., Lindquist, Christine H., Mia Green, P. Mitchell Downey, Yahner, Jennifer, Bhati, Avinash, and Farole, Donald J. Jr. 2011. “What Have We Learned from the Multi-Site Adult Drug Court Evaluation? Implications for Policy, Practice, and Future Research.” In The Multi-Site Adult Drug Court Evaluation: The Impact of Drug Courts, edited by Shelli, B. Rossman, John, K Roman, Janine, M. Zweig, Rempel, Michael, and Christine, H. Lindquist, 251–67. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Justice Policy Center.Google Scholar
Santos, Cecilia. 2005. Women’s Police Stations: Gender, Violence and Justice in Sao Paulo, Brazil. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Segato, Rita Laura. 2003. “Las Estructuras Elementales de La Violencia: Contrato y Status en la Etiología de la Violencia.” Série Antropologia 334: 1–19. http://ovsyg.ujed.mx/docs/biblioteca-virtual/Las_estructuras_elementales_de_la_violencia.pdf.Google Scholar
Sieder, Rachel, Ansolabehere, Karina, and Alfonso, Tatiana. 2019. “Law and Society in Latin America: An Introduction.” In Routledge Handbook of Law and Society in Latin America, edited by Sieder, Rachel, Ansolabehere, Karina, and Alfonso, Tatiana, 1–22. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stephen, Lynn. 2019. “Fleeing Rural Violence: Mam Women Seeking Gendered Justice in Guatemala and the U.S.” Journal of Peasant Studies 46, no. 2: 229–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Travers, Max. 2017. “Business as Usual? Bail Decision Making and ‘Micro Politics’ in an Australian Magistrates Court.” Law & Social Inquiry 42, no. 2: 325–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trujillo, Hilda Morales. 2010. “Femicide and Sexual Violence in Guatemala.” In Terrorizing Women: Feminicide in the Américas, edited by Rosa Linda Fregoso and Bejarano, Cynthia L., 127–37. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsai, Betsy. 2000. “Trend Toward Specialized Domestic Violence Courts: Improvements on Effective Innovation.” Fordham Law Review 68: 1285–1327.Google Scholar
Unidad de Control, Seguimiento y Evaluación de los Órganos Especializados en Delitos de Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia contra la Mujer. 2019. Ocho Años de La Justicia Especializada En Delitos de Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia Contra La Mujer y Violencia Sexual 2010–2018. Guatemala: Unidad de Control, Seguimiento y Evaluación de los Órganos Especializados en Delitos de Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia contra la Mujer del Organismo Judicial.Google Scholar
Unidad de Control, Seguimiento y Evaluación de los Órganos Especializados en Delitos de Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia contra la Mujer. 2022. Informe de La Justicia Especializada En Delitos de Femicidio, Otras Formas de Violencia Contra La Mujer y Violencia Sexual 2019–2020. Guatemala: Unidad de Control, Seguimiento y Evaluación de los Órganos Especializados en Delitos de Femicidio y Otras Formas de Violencia contra la Mujer del Organismo Judicial.Google Scholar
United Nations Women. 2016. Guatemala Case Study: Advances in and Challenges for Specialized Justice: Regional Assessment of Access to Justice as a Preventative Mechanism to End Violence against Women 2011–2015. Guatemala: United Nations Women. https://gate.unwomen.org/EvaluationDocument/Download?evaluationDocumentID=9134.Google Scholar
US State Department. 2021. “Guatemala 2020 Human Rights Report.” US State Department, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor. https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-country-reports-on-human-rights-practices/guatemala/.Google Scholar
Walsh, Shannon Drysdale. 2008. “Engendering Justice: Constructing Institutions to Address Violence against Women.” Studies in Social Justice 2, no. 1: 48–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walsh, Shannon Drysdale, and Menjívar, Cecilia. 2016. “‘What Guarantees Do We Have?’ Legal Tolls and Persistent Impunity for Feminicide in Guatemala.” Latin American Politics and Society 58, no. 4: 31–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, Rhodri. 2018. “ILAC Rule of Law Assessment Report: Guatemala.” International Legal Assistance Consortium. http://www.ilacnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Guatemala-Rule-of-Law-Assessment.pdf.Google Scholar