Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-t5pn6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T09:49:43.766Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reframing Black Southerners’ Experiences in the Courts, 1865–1950

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 May 2019

Melissa Milewski
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In civil cases that took place in southern courts from the end of the Civil War to the mid-twentieth century, black men and women frequently chose to bring litigation and then negotiated the white-dominated legal system to shape their cases and assert rights. In some ways, these civil cases were diametrically opposite from the criminal cases of black defendants who did not choose to enter a courtroom and often received unequal justice. However, this article draws on almost 2,000 cases involving black litigants in eight state supreme courts across the South between 1865 to 1950 to argue that in both civil and criminal cases African Americans were at times shaping their cases and fighting for their rights, as well as obtaining decisions that aligned with the interests of white elites. Southern state courts during the era of Jim Crow were thus spaces for negotiating for rights and sites of white domination, in both criminal and civil cases.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 44 , Issue 4 , November 2019 , pp. 1113 - 1140
Copyright
© 2019 American Bar Foundation 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Ayers, Edward L. Vengeance & Justice: Crime and Punishment in the 19th-Century American South. New York: Oxford University Press, 1984.Google Scholar
Ayers, Edward L. The Promise of the New South: Life after Reconstruction. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992.Google Scholar
Black, Henry Campbell. A Treatise on the Rescission of Contracts and Cancellation of Written Instruments. Kansas City, MO: Vernon Law Book Company, 1916.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blackmon, Douglas A. Slavery by Another Name. New York: Doubleday, 2008.Google Scholar
Blight, David W. Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2001.Google Scholar
Boyle, Kevin. Arc of Justice: A Saga of Race, Civil Rights, and Murder in the Jazz Age. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2004.Google Scholar
Browne, Causten. A Treatise on the Construction of the Statute of Frauds. Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1895.Google Scholar
Carle, Susan D. Defining the Struggle: National Organizing for Racial Justice, 1880–1915. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“Courting Reversal: The Supervisory Role of State Supreme Courts.” Yale Law Journal 87, no. 6 (1978): 1191–1218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dailey, Jane. The Age of Jim Crow: A Norton Casebook in History. New York: W. W. Norton, 2009.Google Scholar
Dorr, Lisa Lindquist. White Women, Rape, & the Power of Race in Virginia, 1900–1960. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2004.Google Scholar
Edwards, Laura F. Gendered Strife and Confusion: The Political Culture of Reconstruction. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1997.Google Scholar
Edwards, Laura F. A Legal History of the Civil War and Reconstruction: A Nation of Rights. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2015.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elliott, Mark. Color-Blind Justice: Albion Tourgée and the Quest for Legal Equality from the Civil War to Plessy v. Ferguson. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.Google Scholar
Goluboff, Risa L. The Lost Promise of Civil Rights. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gonda, Jeffrey D. Unjust Deeds: The Restrictive Covenant Cases and the Making of the Civil Rights Movement. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2015.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haley, Sarah. No Mercy Here: Gender, Punishment, and the Making of Jim Crow Modernity. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2016.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodes, Martha. White Women, Black Men: Illicit Sex in the Nineteenth-Century South. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1997.Google Scholar
Jett, Brandon. “‘I Want Him Put In; I Don’t Want Him to Kill Me’: Black Women, Domestic Violence, and the Law in the Jim Crow South.” Unpublished paper presented at the American Society for Legal History Annual Meeting, November 2018.Google Scholar
Jones, Martha. Birthright Citizens: A History of Race and Rights in Antebellum America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kagan, Robert A., Cartwright, Bliss, Friedman, Lawrence M., and Wheeler, Stanton. “The Business of State Supreme Courts, 1870–1970.” Stanford Law Review 30, no. 1 (1977): 121–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karsten, Peter. “Enabling the Poor to Have Their Day in Court: The Sanctioning of Contingency Fee Contracts, A History to 1940.” DePaul Law Review 47, no. 2 (1998): 231–60.Google Scholar
Kendi, Ibram X. Stamped from the Beginning: The Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America. New York: Nation Books, 2016.Google Scholar
Kennedy, Randall. Race, Crime, and the Law. New York: Vintage, 1997.Google Scholar
Kennington, Kelly. In the Shadow of Dred Scott: St. Louis Freedom Suits and the Legal Culture of Slavery in Antebellum America. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press, 2016.Google Scholar
Kluger, Richard. Simple Justice: The History of Brown v. Board of Education and Black America’s Struggle for Equality. New York: Knopf, 1975.Google Scholar
LeFlouria, Talitha. Chained in Silence: Black Women and Convict Labor in the New South. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2015.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leubsdorf, John. “Toward a History of the American Rule on Attorney Fee Recovery.” Law and Contemporary Problems 47, no. 1 (1984): 9–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lofgren, Charles A. The Plessy Case: A Legal-Historical Interpretation. New York: Oxford University Press, 1987.Google Scholar
McElya, Micki. Clinging to Mammy: The Faithful Slave in Twentieth-Century America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLaughlin, Glory. “A ‘Mixture of Race and Reform’: The Memory of the Civil War in the Alabama Legal Mind.” Alabama Law Review 56, no. 1 (2004): 285–309.Google Scholar
McMillen, Neil R. Dark Journey: Black Mississippians in the Age of Jim Crow. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1989.Google Scholar
Milewski, Melissa. Litigating across the Color Line: Civil Cases between Black and White Southerners from the End of Slavery to Civil Rights. New York: Oxford University Press, 2018.Google Scholar
Nieman, Donald G. “Black Political Power and Criminal Justice: Washington County, Texas, 1868–1884.” The Journal of Southern History 55, no. 3 (1989): 398–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Novkov, Julie. Racial Union: Law, Intimacy, and the White State in Alabama, 1865–1954. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2008.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oshinsky, David. “Worse than Slavery”: Parchman Farm and the Ordeal of Jim Crow Justice. New York: Free Press, 1996.Google Scholar
Popper, Robert. “History and Development of the Accused’s Right to Testify.” Washington University Law Review 1962, no. 4 (1962): 454–71.Google Scholar
Reed, John C. Conduct of Lawsuits out of and in Court. Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1885.Google Scholar
Riser, R. Volney. Defying Disfranchisement: Black Voting Rights Activism in the Jim Crow South, 1890–1908. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press, 2010.Google Scholar
Schmidt, Christopher W. The Sit-ins: Protest and Legal Change in the Civil Rights Era. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2018.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scott, Rebecca J. “The Atlantic World and the Road to ‘Plessy v. Ferguson’.” The Journal of American History 94, no. 3 (2007): 726–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, J. Clay. Emancipation: The Making of the Black Lawyer, 1844–1944. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1993.Google Scholar
Smith, John W. A Treatise on The Law of Frauds and The Statute of Frauds. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill Co., 1907.Google Scholar
Smith, Wilford H. “The Negro and the Law.” In The Negro Problem, 125–60. New York: J. Pott & Company, 1903.Google Scholar
A South Carolinian. “South Carolina Morals.” The Atlantic Monthly, April 1877, 474.Google Scholar
Sullivan, Patricia. Lift Every Voice: The NAACP and the Making of the Civil Rights Movement. New York: The New Press, 2009.Google Scholar
Tushnet, Mark V. The NAACP’s Legal Strategy against Segregated Education, 1925–1950. Chapel Hill, NC: University of Chapel Hill Press, 1987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Twitty, Anne. Before Dred Scott: Slavery and Legal Culture in the American Confluence, 1787–1857. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldrep, Christopher. “Substituting Law for the Lash: Emancipation and Legal Formalism in a Mississippi County Court.” The Journal of American History 82, no. 4 (1996): 1425–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldrep, Christopher. Roots of Disorder: Race and Criminal Justice in the American South. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1998.Google Scholar
Welch, Kimberly M. Black Litigants in the Antebellum American South. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2018.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“William N. Pratt Estate Records,” Orange County, North Carolina. North Carolina State Archives.Google Scholar
Abercrombie v. Carpenter, 150 Ala. 294 (1907).Google Scholar
Anderson v. Green, 46 Ga. 361 (1872).Google Scholar
Andrews v. Aderhold, 201 Ga. 132 (1946).Google Scholar
Barge v. Weems, 109 Ga. 685 (1900).Google Scholar
Board of Trustees v. Board of Trustees, 181 Ky. 810 (1918).Google Scholar
Boswell v. Bethea, 242 Ala. 292 (1942).Google Scholar
Briley v. Underwood, 41 Ga. 9 (1869).Google Scholar
Broome v. Jackson, 193 Miss. 66 (1942).Google Scholar
Brown v. Bonds, 125 Ga. 833 (1906).Google Scholar
Bryant v. Barnes, 144 Miss. 732 (1925).Google Scholar
Burdine v. Burdine’s Ex’or, 98 Va. 515 (1900).Google Scholar
Burgess v. State, 164 Ga. 92 (1927).Google Scholar
Canady v. State, 171 Ga. 11 (1930).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carey v. City of Atlanta, 143 Ga. 192 (1915).Google Scholar
Carter v. State, 154 Ga. 359 (1922).Google Scholar
Chaires v. City of Atlanta, 164 Ga. 755 (1927).Google Scholar
Cobb v. Battle (1866), Case No. A-3927.Google Scholar
Cochreham v. Kirkpatrick, 48 Tenn. 327 (1870).Google Scholar
Cowan v. Stamps, 46 Miss. 435 (1872).Google Scholar
Croom v. State, 85 Ga. 718 (1890).Google Scholar
Curtis v. State, 226 Ala. 29 (1933).Google Scholar
Dooley v. Sterling Stores, 214 Ark. 895 (1949).Google Scholar
Dorsey v. State, 108 Ga. 477 (1899).Google Scholar
Duncan v. Pope, 47 Ga. 445 (1872).Google Scholar
Ex parte Banks, 254 Ala. 117 (1950).Google Scholar
Ex parte Taylor. Taylor v. State, 249 Ala. 667 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gabriel (Freedman) v. State, 40 Ala. 357 (1867).Google Scholar
Gaskin v. State, 105 Ga. 631 (1898).Google Scholar
Glover v. City of Atlanta, 148 Ga. 285 (1918).Google Scholar
Goldsmith v. State, 232 Ala. 436 (1936).Google Scholar
Hairston v. Atlantic Greyhound Corporation, 220 N.C. 642 (1942).Google Scholar
Hall v. Jones, 129 Ark. 18 (1917).Google Scholar
Hardrick v. Southeastern Greyhound Lines, 306 Ky. 579 (1949).Google Scholar
Hayes v. Lancaster, 200 N.C. 293 (1931).Google Scholar
Herndon v. State, 178 Ga. 832 (1934).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hicks v. State, 76 Ga. 326 (1886).Google Scholar
Hough v. Leech, 187 Ark. 719 (1933).Google Scholar
Howard v. State, 115 Ga. 244 (1902).Google Scholar
Howell v. Harris and Queen City Coach, 220 N.C. 198 (1941).Google Scholar
Hudson v. Hodge, 139 N.C. 308 (1905).Google Scholar
Jackson v. Parks, 216 N.C. 329 (1939).Google Scholar
Jackson v. State, 176 Ga. 148 (1932).Google Scholar
James v. State, 170 Ala. 72 (1911).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson v. State, 63 Ga. 356 (1879).Google Scholar
Johnson v. State, 128 Ga. 102 (1907).Google Scholar
King v. State, 40 Ala. 314 (1867).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lattimore v. Dickson, 63 N.C. 356 (1869).Google Scholar
Lattimore v. Dixon, 65 N.C. 664 (1871).Google Scholar
Levison v. State, 54 Ala. 520 (1875).Google Scholar
Lowery v. Board of Graded School, 140 N.C. 33 (1905).Google Scholar
Madison v. Nunnelee, 246 Ala. 325 (1945).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marshall v. State, 59 Ga. 154 (1877).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McFarland v. Goins, 96 Miss. 67 (1909).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKinnon v. Henderson, 145 Ga. 373 (1916).Google Scholar
Melton v. Allen, 212 Ky. 310 (1925).Google Scholar
Miller v. State, 40 Ala. 54 (1866).Google Scholar
Millhouse v. State, 232 Ala. 567 (1936).Google Scholar
Millhouse v. State, 235 Ala. 85 (1937).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mississippi Cooperative v. Walker, 186 Miss. 870 (1939).Google Scholar
Mississippi Power & Light v. Garner, 179 Miss. 588 (1937).Google Scholar
Montgomery v. Wallace, 216 Ark. 525 (1950).Google Scholar
Munroe v. Phillips, 64 Ga. 32 (1879).Google Scholar
New v. Atlantic Greyhound Corporation, 186 Va. 726 (1947).Google Scholar
Norris v. State, 229 Ala. 226 (1934).Google Scholar
Palmore v. State, 244 Ala. 227 (1943).Google Scholar
Porter v. State, 55 Ala. 95 (1876).Google Scholar
Potter v. Gracie, 58 Ala. 303 (1877).Google Scholar
Ray v. Commissioners of Durham County, 110 N.C. 169 (1892).Google Scholar
Redding v. State, 167 Ga. 549 (1928).Google Scholar
Robinson v. Holman, 181 Ark. 428 (1930).Google Scholar
Simmons v. Hessey, 11 Ky. Op. 40 (1881).Google Scholar
Smith v. Summerlin, 48 Ga. 425 (1873).Google Scholar
State v. Elks, 125 N.C. 603 (1899).Google Scholar
Steele v. Louisville & N.R. Co., 245 Ala. 113 (1944).Google Scholar
Sullivan v. Padrosa, 122 Ga. 338 (1905).Google Scholar
Sutton v. Dunn, 176 N.C. 202 (1918).Google Scholar
Sweeney v. City of Louisville, 309 Ky. 465 (1949).Google Scholar
Tannehill v. State, 159 Ala. 51 (1909).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor v. State, 249 Ala. 667 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tri-State Transit v. Westbrook, 207 Ark. 270 (1944).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vernon v. State, 240 Ala. 577 (1941).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vernon v. State, 245 Ala. 633 (1944).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker v. State, 194 Ga. 727 (1942).Google Scholar
Wall v. State. Lewis v. State, 153 Ga. 309 (1922).Google Scholar
Warley v. Board of Park Commissioners, 233 Ky. 688 (1930).Google Scholar
Warren v. Knox County, 258 Ky. 212 (1935).Google Scholar
Williams v. Wright, 249 Ala. 9 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson v. Singer Sewing Machine Company, 184 N.C. 40 (1922).Google Scholar
Wilson v. State, 69 Ga. 224 (1882).Google Scholar
Abercrombie v. Carpenter, 150 Ala. 294 (1907).Google Scholar
Anderson v. Green, 46 Ga. 361 (1872).Google Scholar
Andrews v. Aderhold, 201 Ga. 132 (1946).Google Scholar
Barge v. Weems, 109 Ga. 685 (1900).Google Scholar
Board of Trustees v. Board of Trustees, 181 Ky. 810 (1918).Google Scholar
Boswell v. Bethea, 242 Ala. 292 (1942).Google Scholar
Briley v. Underwood, 41 Ga. 9 (1869).Google Scholar
Broome v. Jackson, 193 Miss. 66 (1942).Google Scholar
Brown v. Bonds, 125 Ga. 833 (1906).Google Scholar
Bryant v. Barnes, 144 Miss. 732 (1925).Google Scholar
Burdine v. Burdine’s Ex’or, 98 Va. 515 (1900).Google Scholar
Burgess v. State, 164 Ga. 92 (1927).Google Scholar
Canady v. State, 171 Ga. 11 (1930).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carey v. City of Atlanta, 143 Ga. 192 (1915).Google Scholar
Carter v. State, 154 Ga. 359 (1922).Google Scholar
Chaires v. City of Atlanta, 164 Ga. 755 (1927).Google Scholar
Cobb v. Battle (1866), Case No. A-3927.Google Scholar
Cochreham v. Kirkpatrick, 48 Tenn. 327 (1870).Google Scholar
Cowan v. Stamps, 46 Miss. 435 (1872).Google Scholar
Croom v. State, 85 Ga. 718 (1890).Google Scholar
Curtis v. State, 226 Ala. 29 (1933).Google Scholar
Dooley v. Sterling Stores, 214 Ark. 895 (1949).Google Scholar
Dorsey v. State, 108 Ga. 477 (1899).Google Scholar
Duncan v. Pope, 47 Ga. 445 (1872).Google Scholar
Ex parte Banks, 254 Ala. 117 (1950).Google Scholar
Ex parte Taylor. Taylor v. State, 249 Ala. 667 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gabriel (Freedman) v. State, 40 Ala. 357 (1867).Google Scholar
Gaskin v. State, 105 Ga. 631 (1898).Google Scholar
Glover v. City of Atlanta, 148 Ga. 285 (1918).Google Scholar
Goldsmith v. State, 232 Ala. 436 (1936).Google Scholar
Hairston v. Atlantic Greyhound Corporation, 220 N.C. 642 (1942).Google Scholar
Hall v. Jones, 129 Ark. 18 (1917).Google Scholar
Hardrick v. Southeastern Greyhound Lines, 306 Ky. 579 (1949).Google Scholar
Hayes v. Lancaster, 200 N.C. 293 (1931).Google Scholar
Herndon v. State, 178 Ga. 832 (1934).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hicks v. State, 76 Ga. 326 (1886).Google Scholar
Hough v. Leech, 187 Ark. 719 (1933).Google Scholar
Howard v. State, 115 Ga. 244 (1902).Google Scholar
Howell v. Harris and Queen City Coach, 220 N.C. 198 (1941).Google Scholar
Hudson v. Hodge, 139 N.C. 308 (1905).Google Scholar
Jackson v. Parks, 216 N.C. 329 (1939).Google Scholar
Jackson v. State, 176 Ga. 148 (1932).Google Scholar
James v. State, 170 Ala. 72 (1911).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson v. State, 63 Ga. 356 (1879).Google Scholar
Johnson v. State, 128 Ga. 102 (1907).Google Scholar
King v. State, 40 Ala. 314 (1867).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lattimore v. Dickson, 63 N.C. 356 (1869).Google Scholar
Lattimore v. Dixon, 65 N.C. 664 (1871).Google Scholar
Levison v. State, 54 Ala. 520 (1875).Google Scholar
Lowery v. Board of Graded School, 140 N.C. 33 (1905).Google Scholar
Madison v. Nunnelee, 246 Ala. 325 (1945).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marshall v. State, 59 Ga. 154 (1877).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McFarland v. Goins, 96 Miss. 67 (1909).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKinnon v. Henderson, 145 Ga. 373 (1916).Google Scholar
Melton v. Allen, 212 Ky. 310 (1925).Google Scholar
Miller v. State, 40 Ala. 54 (1866).Google Scholar
Millhouse v. State, 232 Ala. 567 (1936).Google Scholar
Millhouse v. State, 235 Ala. 85 (1937).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mississippi Cooperative v. Walker, 186 Miss. 870 (1939).Google Scholar
Mississippi Power & Light v. Garner, 179 Miss. 588 (1937).Google Scholar
Montgomery v. Wallace, 216 Ark. 525 (1950).Google Scholar
Munroe v. Phillips, 64 Ga. 32 (1879).Google Scholar
New v. Atlantic Greyhound Corporation, 186 Va. 726 (1947).Google Scholar
Norris v. State, 229 Ala. 226 (1934).Google Scholar
Palmore v. State, 244 Ala. 227 (1943).Google Scholar
Porter v. State, 55 Ala. 95 (1876).Google Scholar
Potter v. Gracie, 58 Ala. 303 (1877).Google Scholar
Ray v. Commissioners of Durham County, 110 N.C. 169 (1892).Google Scholar
Redding v. State, 167 Ga. 549 (1928).Google Scholar
Robinson v. Holman, 181 Ark. 428 (1930).Google Scholar
Simmons v. Hessey, 11 Ky. Op. 40 (1881).Google Scholar
Smith v. Summerlin, 48 Ga. 425 (1873).Google Scholar
State v. Elks, 125 N.C. 603 (1899).Google Scholar
Steele v. Louisville & N.R. Co., 245 Ala. 113 (1944).Google Scholar
Sullivan v. Padrosa, 122 Ga. 338 (1905).Google Scholar
Sutton v. Dunn, 176 N.C. 202 (1918).Google Scholar
Sweeney v. City of Louisville, 309 Ky. 465 (1949).Google Scholar
Tannehill v. State, 159 Ala. 51 (1909).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor v. State, 249 Ala. 667 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tri-State Transit v. Westbrook, 207 Ark. 270 (1944).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vernon v. State, 240 Ala. 577 (1941).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vernon v. State, 245 Ala. 633 (1944).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker v. State, 194 Ga. 727 (1942).Google Scholar
Wall v. State. Lewis v. State, 153 Ga. 309 (1922).Google Scholar
Warley v. Board of Park Commissioners, 233 Ky. 688 (1930).Google Scholar
Warren v. Knox County, 258 Ky. 212 (1935).Google Scholar
Williams v. Wright, 249 Ala. 9 (1947).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson v. Singer Sewing Machine Company, 184 N.C. 40 (1922).Google Scholar
Wilson v. State, 69 Ga. 224 (1882).Google Scholar