Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-16T17:07:11.377Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Community Divided: Defense Attorneys and the Ethics of Death Row Volunteering

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

C. Lee Harrington
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

When death row inmates elect to waive appeals and proceed directly to execution a series of problematic legal and ethical questions are raised. This article examines the ethics of volunteering from the perspective of death row inmates'defense attorneys. Studying attorneys is important for two reasons: since they are charged with protecting their clients' interests they must resolve the difficult question of whether death is ever in someone's best interest; and perhaps more important, most death row defense attorneys are themselves against the death penalty and must thus negotiate between their clients' desire for execution and their own personal value systems. Interviews were conducted with 20 attorneys who have participated in representing would-be volunteers. Qualitative analysis suggests that most are faced with profound ethical dilemmas, both professional and personal, when a client elects to waive appeals. This article explores how attorneys interpret, experience, and resolve those dilemmas.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 25 , Issue 3 , Summer 2000 , pp. 849 - 881
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2000 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Appelbaum, Paul S. 1981. Psychiatrists' Role in the Death Penalty. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 32:761–62.Google Scholar
Bonnie, Richard J. 1990a. The Competence of Criminal Defendants with Mental Retardation to Participate in Their Own Defense. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 81:419–46.Google Scholar
Bonnie, . 1990b. Healing-Killing Conflicts: Medical Ethics and the Death Penalty. Hastings Center Report , May-June, 12–18.Google Scholar
Bonnie, . 1990c. Dilemmas in Administering the Death Penalty: Conscientious Abstention, Professional Ethics, and the Needs of the Legal System. Law and Human Behavior 14:67–90.Google Scholar
Bonnie, . 1992. The Competence of Criminal Defendants: A Theoretical Reformulation. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 10:291–316.Google Scholar
Bonnie, Richard J., Norman, G. Poythress, Steven K. Hoge, Monahan John, and Marlene, Eisenberg M. 1996. Decision-Making in Criminal Defense: An Empirical Study of Insanity Pleas and the Impact of Doubted Client Competence. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 87:48–62.Google Scholar
Burr, Richard H. III 1990. Representing the Client on Death Row: The Politics of Advocacy. UMKC Law Review 59:1–16.Google Scholar
Cooper, Deborah K., and Grisso, Thomas. 1997. Five-Year Research Update (1991–1995): Evaluations for Competence to Stand Trial. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 15:347–64.Google Scholar
Cruise, Keith R., and Rogers, Richard. 1998. An Analysis of Competency to Stand Trial: An Integration of Case Law and Clinical Knowledge. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 16:35–50.Google Scholar
Davis, David A. 1992. Capital Cases: When the Defendant Wants to Die. The Champion June, 45–47.Google Scholar
Dick, Rachelle Deckert. 1987. Ford v. Wainwright: Warning—Sanity on Death Row May Be Hazardous to Your Health. Louisiana Law Review 47:1351–64.Google Scholar
Dieter, Richard L. 1990. Ethical Choices for Attorneys Whose Clients Elect Execution. Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics 3:799–820.Google Scholar
Engel, David M. 1993. Law in the Domains of Everyday Life: The Construction of Community and Difference. In Law and Everyday Life, ed. Sarat, Austin and Thomas Kearns, R., 123–70. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Ewing, Charles Patrick. 1987. Diagnosing and Treating “Insanity” on Death Row: Legal and Ethical Perspectives. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 5:175–85.Google Scholar
Gallemore, Johnnie L., and James Panton, H. 1972. Inmate Responses to Lengthy Death Row Confinement. American Journal of Psychiatry 129:81–86.Google Scholar
Gillers, Stephen, and Dorsen, Norman. 1989. Regulation of Lawyers: Problems of Laws and Ethics. 2d ed. Boston: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Glass, Kathleen Cranley. 1997. Refining Definitions and Devising Instruments: Two Decades of Assessing Mental Competence. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 20:5–33.Google Scholar
Gould, Keri A. 1995. A Therapeutic Jurisprudence Analysis of Competency Evaluation Requests: The Defense Attorney's Dilemma. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 18:83–100.Google Scholar
Greenhouse, Carol J. 1986. Praying for Justice: Faith, Order and Community in an American Town. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Greenhouse, . 1988. Courting Difference: Issues of Interpretation and Comparison in the Study of Legal Ideologies. Law and Society Review 22:687–707.Google Scholar
Grisso, Thomas. 1986. Evaluating Competencies: Forensic Assessments and Instruments. New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Grisso, . 1992. Five-Year Research Update (1986–1990): Evaluations for Competence to Stand Trial. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 10:353–69.Google Scholar
Grisso, Thomas, and Paul Appelbaum, S. 1998. Assessing competence to Consent to Treatment. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Hoge, Steven K., Richard, J. Bonnie, Norman Poythress, and Monahan, John. 1992. Attorney-Client Decision-Making in Criminal Cases: Client Competence and Participation as Perceived by Their Attorneys. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 10:385–94.Google Scholar
Jack, Rand, and Crowley Jack, Dana 1989. Moral Vision and Professional Decisions: The Changing Values of Women and Men Lawyers. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Johnson, Kathleen L. 1981. The Death Row Right to Die: Suicide or Intimate Decision Southern California Law Review 54:575–631.Google Scholar
Johnson, Robert. 1981. Condemned to Die: Life under Sentence of Death. New York: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Lawry, Robert P. 1996. Damned and Damnable: A Lawyer's Moral Duties with Life on the Line. Loyola of Los Angels Law Review 29:1641–58.Google Scholar
Lewis, Dorothy Otnow, Jonathan, H. Pincus, Feldman, Marilyn, Jackson, Lori, and Bard, Barbara. 1986. Psychiatric, Neurological, and Psychoeducational Characteristics of 15 Death Row Inmates in the United States. American Journal of Psychiatry 143:838–45.Google Scholar
Lewis, Dorothy Otnow, Jonathan, H. Pincus, Bard, Barbara, Richardson, Ellis, Leslie, S. Prichep, Feldman, Marilyn, and Yeager, Catherine. 1988. Neuropsychiatric, Psychoeducational and Family Characteristics of 14 Juveniles Condemned to Death in the United States. American Journal of Psychiatry 145:584–89.Google Scholar
McClellan, Jane L. 1994. Stopping the Rush to the Death House: Third-Party Standing in Death-Row Volunteer Cases. Arizona State Law Journal 37:201–41.Google Scholar
Menkel-Meadow, Carrie. 1998. The Causes of Cause Lawyering: Toward an Understanding of the Motivation and Commitment of Social Justice Lawyers. In Sarat and Scheingold 1998.Google Scholar
Miller, Robert D., Olin, Jonathan, Johnson, David, Doidge, John, Iverson, David, and Fantone, Emmanuel. 1996. Forcing the Insanity Defense on Unwilling Defendants: Best Interests and the Dignity of the Law. Journal of Law and Psychiatry , Winter, 487–509.Google Scholar
Mossman, Douglas. 1994. Is Expert Psychiatric Testimony Fundamentally Immoral International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 17:347–68.Google Scholar
Perlin, Michael L. 1996. “Dignity Was the First to Leave”: Godines v. Moran, Colin Ferguson, and the Trial of Mentally Disabled Criminal Defendants. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 14:61–81.Google Scholar
Radelet, Michael L., and George Barnard, W. 1988. Treating Those Found Incompetent for Execution: Ethical Chaos with Only One Solution. Bulletin of the American Academy of Science and the Law 16:297–308.Google Scholar
Riepenhoff, Jill. 1998. Volunteers Clear Way for Executions. Columbus Dispatch , March 2. http://www.dispatch.com.Google Scholar
Roesch, Ronald, and Stephen Golding, L. 1980. Competency to Stand Trial. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Ross, Josephine. 1998. Autonomy versus a Client's Best Interests: The Defense Lawyer's Dilemma When Mentally Ill Clients Seek to Control Their Own Defense. American Criminal Law Review 35:1343–86.Google Scholar
Salguero, Rochelle Graff. 1986. Medical Ethics and Competency to Be Executed. Yale Law Journal 96:167–86.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin. 1998. Between the (Presence of) Violence and the (Possibility of) Justice. In Sarat and Scheingold 1998.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin, and Scheingold, Stuart, eds. 1998. Cause Lawyering: Political Commitments and Professional Responsibilities. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Shaffer, Thomas L. 1991. American Lawyers and Their Communities. Notre Dame, Ind: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Susan P. 1995. Conflicting Responsibilities: Maneuvering through the Minefield of Fiduciary Obligations. Chicago: American Bar Foundation.Google Scholar
Showalter, C. Robert. 1990. Psychiatric Participation in Capital Sentence Procedures: Ethical Considerations. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 13:261–80.Google Scholar
Strafer, Richard G. 1983. Volunteering for Execution: Competency, Voluntariness and the Propriety of Third Party Intervention. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 74:860–912.Google Scholar
Uphoff, Rodney I., ed. 1995. Ethical Problems Facing the Criminal Defense Lawyer: Practical Answers to Tough Questions. Chicago: American Bar Association.Google Scholar
Urofsky, Melvin I. 1984. A Right to Die: Termination of Appeal for Condemned Prisoners. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 75:553–82.Google Scholar
Waksmundski, Nicole. 1998. Volunteer for Death Is No Rare Bird. Akron Beacon-Journal , 23 February. http://www.ohio.com.Google Scholar
Wallace, Donald H. 1992. The Need to Commute the Death Sentence: Competency for Execution and Ethical Dilemmas for Mental Health Professionals. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 15:317–37.Google Scholar
White, Welsh S. 1987. Defendants Who Elect Execution. University of Pittsburgh Law Review 48:853–77.Google Scholar
Willing, Richard. 1999. Ohio Death Row Inmate Wants to Die. USA Today, 1 February, 2A.Google Scholar
Winick, Bruce J. 1992. Competency to Be Executed: A Therapeutic Jurisprudence Perspective. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 10:317–37.Google Scholar
Winick, . 1995. Ambiguities in the Legal Meaning and Significance of Mental Illness. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 1:534–611.Google Scholar
Winick, . 1996. Incompetency to Proceed in the Criminal Process: Past, Present, and Future. In Law, Mental Health, and Mental Disorder, ed. Bruce Sales, D. and Daniel Shuman, W., 310–40. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Brooks/Cole Publishing Company.Google Scholar