Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-22dnz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T22:52:34.225Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

EXPELLING THE FOREIGN-BORN MENACE: IMMIGRANT DISSENT, THE EARLY DEPORTATION STATE, AND THE FIRST AMERICAN RED SCARE

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Emily Pope-Obeda
Emily Pope-Obeda*
Affiliation:
Harvard University
*
email: popeobeda@fas.harvard.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This essay explores the impact of the First Red Scare on immigrant populations, focusing on the function that detentions, deportations, and attempted deportations occupied within the broader antiradical politics of the period. I assert that deportations were far more than an instrumentalist tactic of the Red Scare, but instead, were part of a much longer trajectory of expanding anti-immigrant enforcement and the postentry social control of foreign-born residents. Antiradical raids during the era have held a prominent place in the scholarly imagination, which has remained overly constrained by the exceptionalist and episodic narratives put forth by its earliest historians. I trace the evolution of scholarship on the Red Scare's temporal boundaries, the motivations for targeting immigrants, and the debates over how radical a rupture this period represented from earlier practices of antiradicalism and anti-immigrant politics. In doing so, I argue that Red Scare deportations must be understood in relationship to the broader deportation practices of the period and the rapid (and more consistent) growth of removals instigated because of racialized criteria of poverty, crime, health, or violations of an ever-stricter border regime.

Type
Special Forum
Information
The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era , Volume 18 , Issue 1 , January 2019 , pp. 32 - 55
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1 Report of Meeting Held at the Hall of Local Number 127, Nov. 26, 1919, reel 13, box 64, Emma Goldman Papers, New York Public Library.

2 Murray, Robert K., Red Scare: A Study in National Hysteria, 1919–1920 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1955)Google Scholar.

3 For general scholarship on immigrants and the Red Scare, see Preston, William Jr., Aliens and Dissenters: Federal Suppression of Radicals, 1903–1933 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1963)Google Scholar; Cohen, Harlan Grand, “The (Un)Favorable Judgment of History: Deportation Hearings, the Palmer Raids, and the Meaning of History,” New York University Law Review 78:4 (Oct. 2003)Google Scholar; Hong, Nathaniel, “The Origins of American Legislation to Exclude and Deport Aliens for their Political Beliefs and its Initial Review by the Courts,” Journal of Ethnic Studies 18:2 (Summer 1990)Google Scholar; Sarah Becker, “The Attack on Aliens in the United States, 1917–1921” (PhD diss., University of Wisconsin, 1935); Kraut, Julia Rose, “Global Anti-Anarchism: The Origins of Ideological Deportation and the Suppression of Expression,” Indiana Journal of Urban & Extra Urban Studies 19:1 (Winter 2012)Google Scholar; Kovel, Joel, Red Hunting in the Promised Land: Anticommunism and the Making of America (New York: Basic Books, 1994)Google Scholar; Abramowitz, Howard, “The Press and the Red Scare, 1919–1921” in Popular Culture and Political Change in Modern America, eds. Edsforth, Ronald and Bennet, Larry (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1991)Google Scholar; Schmidt, Regin, FBI and the Origins of Anticommunism in the United States, 1919–1943 (Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2000)Google Scholar; and Battisti, Danielle, “The American Committee on Italian Migration, Anti-Communism, and Immigration Reform,” Journal of American Ethnic History 31:2 (Winter 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Finan, Christopher M., From the Palmer Raids to the Patriot Act: A History of the Fight for Free Speech in America (Boston: Beacon Press, 2007), 3Google Scholar.

5 Murray, Red Scare, 200.

6 Murray, Red Scare, 206.

7 Heale, M. J., American Anticommunism: Combating the Enemy Within, 1830–1970 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990), 29Google Scholar.

8 Murray, Red Scare, 3.

9 Higham, John, Strangers in the Land: Patterns of American Nativism, 1860–1925 (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1955; 1998), 175Google Scholar.

10 Ibid., 177.

11 Ibid., 183.

12 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 63–87.

13 Schmidt, Red Scare, 54.

14 Heale, American Anticommunism, 77.

15 Kanstroom, Daniel, Deportation Nation: Outsiders in American History (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007), 6Google Scholar.

16 Higham, Strangers in the Land, 220–21.

17 Even at their height, deportations under the anarchist provisions of the law only reached 37 in 1919, 314 in 1920, a peak of 446 in 1921, and 64 in 1922. See Clark, Jane Perry, The Deportation of Aliens from the United States to Europe (New York: Ayer Co., 1931), 225Google Scholar. Although the Acting Secretary of Labor issued over 3,000 warrants on Dec. 27, 1919 under 1918 provision that allowed for deportation of foreign-born members of the Communist Party or the Communist Labor Party, and over 4,000 suspected radicals were rounded up around the country on Jan. 2, 1920, the numbers actually deported were a much smaller fraction. Many warrants were never executed, and many others were later discarded because of a lack of evidence or the impossibility of transportation. See Murray, Red Scare, 210–19.

18 Zimmer, Kenyon, “The Voyage of the Buford: Political Deportations and the Making and Unmaking of America's First Red Scare” in Deportation in the Americas: Histories of Exclusion and Resistance, eds. Zimmer, Kenyon and Salinas, Christina (College Station: TX A&M University Press, 2018), 140Google Scholar.

19 Higham, Strangers in the Land, 227.

20 Murray, Red Scare, 246.

21 Murray, Red Scare, 176–77.

22 Murray, Red Scare, 205.

23 Annual Report of the Commissioner General of Immigration to the Secretary of Labor (Washington, DC, 1920).

24 Ibid.

25 Annual Report of the Commissioner General of Immigration to the Secretary of Labor (Washington, DC, 1930).

26 For discussion of broader deportation patterns of the era, see Moloney, Deirdre, National Insecurities: Immigrants and U.S. Deportation Policy Since 1882 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2012)Google Scholar; Hester, Torrie, Deportation: The Origins of U.S. Policy (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2017)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kanstroom, Deportation Nation.

27 Annual Report of the Commissioner General of Immigration to the Secretary of Labor (Washington, DC, 1919–1924).

28 Murray, Red Scare, 53.

29 Fischer, Nick, Spider Web: The Birth of American Anticommunism (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2016), 32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

30 Dubofsky, Melvyn, We Shall Be All: A History of the Industrial Workers of the World (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2000; 1969), 11Google Scholar.

31 Salerno, Salvatore, Red November, Black November: Culture and Community in the Industrial Workers of the World (Albany: State University of New York, Press, 1989), 4Google Scholar.

32 Avrich, Paul, Sacco and Vanzetti: The Anarchist Background (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1991), 45–46Google Scholar.

33 Green, James, Death in the Haymarket: A Story of Chicago, the First Labor Movement and the Bombing that Divided Gilded Age America (New York: Anchor, 2007), 132–34Google Scholar.

34 Heale, American Anticommunism, 31.

35 Green, Death in the Haymarket, 11–12.

36 Zimmer, Kenyon, Immigrants Against the State: Yiddish and Italian Anarchism in America (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2015), 1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 Zimmer, Immigrants Against the State, 1.

38 Zimmer, Immigrants Against the State, 2.

39 Salerno, Red November, Black November, 58

40 Heale, American Anticommunism, 58.

41 Jaffe, Julian F., Crusade Against Radicalism: New York During the Red Scare, 1914–1924 (Port Washington, NY: Associated Faculty Press, 1972), 194Google Scholar.

42 Goodall, Alex, Loyalty and Liberty: American Countersubversion from World War I to the McCarthy Era (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2013), 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

43 Fischer, Spider Web, 67.

44 Fischer, Spider Web, 67–68.

45 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 151.

46 Higham, Strangers in the Land, 169.

47 Higham, Strangers in the Land, 202.

48 Jaffe, Crusade Against Radicalism, 6.

49 Fischer, Spider Web, 11.

50 Capozzola, Christopher, Uncle Sam Wants You: World War I and the Making of the Modern American Citizen (New York: Oxford University Press, 2008), 10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

51 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters.

52 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 10.

53 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 82.

54 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 73.

55 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 177.

56 Preston, Aliens and Dissenters, 177.

57 “An Italian Taken in the Alien Deportation Raids of Feb. and Mar. 1926,” folder 50, box 4, Immigrants Protective League Records, University of Illinois at Chicago.

58 Schmidt, Red Scare, 27.

59 Schmidt, Red Scare, 15.

60 Schmidt, Red Scare, 27.

61 File 55208/General, RG 85, entry 9, Immigration and Naturalization Service Records, NARA.

62 Kanstroom, Deportation Nation, 148.

63 Kanstroom, Deportation Nation; Hong, “The Origins of American Legislation to Exclude and Deport Aliens for their Political Beliefs, and its Initial Review by the Courts”; Kraut, “Global Anti-Anarchism.”

64 Kraut, “Global Anti-Anarchism,” 180.

65 Zimmer, Immigrants Against the State, 20.

66 Kraut, “Global Anti-Anarchism,” 182.

67 Kanstroom, Deportation Nation, 137.

68 Hong, “Origins of American Legislation to Exclude and Deport Aliens,” 2.

69 Murray, Red Scare, 12.

70 Letter from Commissioner General to Commissioner of Immigration at Seattle, July 14, 1928, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

71 Murray, Red Scare, 182.

72 Murray, Red Scare, 181.

73 Tyler, Robert L., Rebels of the Woods: The I.W.W. in the Pacific Northwest (Eugene: Oregon State University Press, 1967), 155–63Google Scholar.

74 Tyler, Rebels of the Woods, 184.

75 Letter from Commissioner General to Commissioner of Immigration at Seattle, July 14, 1928, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

76 Report from Immigrant Inspector Harry G. Yeager, Mar. 28, 1928, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71–42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

77 Ibid.

78 Letter from Commissioner of Immigration at Seattle to Commissioner General, Apr. 3, 1928, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

79 Benton-Cohen, Katherine, Borderline Americans: Racial Divisions and Labor War in the Arizona Borderlands (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2009), 198–239CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

80 “Wobbly Threat Frustrated: Emissary Bearing Order for General Walkout Arrested Immediately Upon Arrival,” Verde Copper News, Sept. 9, 1918, 1.

81 Letter from Arizona Peace Officers’ Association to President Hoover, May 16, 1930, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

82 Letter from Commissioner General to Congressman J. V. McClintic, Mar. 25, 1930, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

83 Letter from Arizona Peace Officers’ Association to President Hoover, May 16, 1930, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

84 Benton-Cohen, Borderline Americans, 8.

85 Noel, Linda C., Debating American Identity: Southwestern Statehood and Mexican Immigration (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 2014), 79Google Scholar.

86 Letter from Arizona Peace Officers’ Association to Secretary of Labor Davis, Aug. 6, 1930, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

87 Memorandum for Mr. Husband, Aug. 21, 1922, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

88 Letter from Ethel Strauss, Sept. 2, 1930, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

89 Letter from Chief Burgess James J. Hanlon to Secretary of Labor, Jan. 18 1932, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

90 Fischer, Spider Web, 69.

91 Murray, Red Scare, 239.

92 Murray, Red Scare, 240.

93 Ibid.

94 Goodall, Loyalty and Liberty, 82.

95 Murray, Red Scare, 261.

96 Murray, Red Scare, 265.

97 Moloney, National Insecurities, 24–27.

98 Fischer, Nick, “The Australian Right, the American Right, and the Threat of the Left, 1917–1935,” Labour History 89 (Nov. 2005): 19Google Scholar.

99 Francis, Daniel, Seeing Reds: The Red Scare of 1918–1919, Canada's First War on Terror (Vancouver: Arsenal Pulp Press, 2010), 141Google Scholar.

100 Francis, Seeing Reds, 151.

101 Francis, Seeing Reds, 153.

102 Roberts, Barbara, Whence They Came: Deportation from Canada, 1900–1935 (Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press, 1988), 73CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

103 As Roberts notes, from 1918 to 1922, the IWW was made illegal, along with a number of other radical organizations. However, she reminds us, before and after that period, Wobblies were still deported in significant numbers through other legal mechanisms. Roberts, Whence They Came, 72.

104 Roberts, Whence They Came, 83.

105 Roberts, Whence They Came, 82.

106 Report of Meeting Held at the Hall of Local Number 127, Nov. 26, 1919, reel 12, Emma Goldman Papers, New York Public Library.

107 Hester, Deportation.

108 Hester, Deportation, 113.

109 Hester, Deportation, 139.

110 Zimmer, “The Voyage of the Buford,” 155.

111 Annual Report of the Commissioner General of Immigration to the Secretary of Labor (Washington, DC, 1920).

112 Fischer, Spider Web, 207–8.

113 Post, Louis Freeland, The Deportations Delirium of Nineteen-Twenty: A Personal Narrative of an Historic Official Experience (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr & Co., 1923), 170Google Scholar.

114 Mitrani, Samuel, “Labor Research Association,” in Encyclopedia of U.S. Labor and Working-Class History, Volume 1, ed. Arnesen, Eric (New York: Routledge, 2007), 765–66Google Scholar.

115 Honig, “Document on Deportation,” folder 26: Deportations, box 4, Record Group 129: Labor Research Association Records, Tamiment Library.

116 Letter from Jacob Margolis to Louis F. Post, Mar. 23, 1920, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

117 Letter from Isaac Shorr to Commissioner Caminetti, Mar. 25, 1920, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

118 Telegram from Charles Recht to Commissioner General, Mar. 22, 1920, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service Files 71-42, P2707, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

119 Letter from Commissioner of Immigration at Seattle to Commissioner General of Immigration, May 24, 1930, File 55727/399, RG 85, entry 9, NARA.

120 Moloney, National Insecurities, 164.

121 Emanuel Pollack, “Whose America Is It Anyhow,” folder 26, box 4, Record Group 129: Labor Research Association Records, Tamiment Library.

122 “Italian I.W.W. is Ordered to Get Out of Country,” folder 12: Deportation Cases, box 12, record group 44: New York Bureau of Legal Advice Records, Tamiment Library.

123 Letter from Norman Thomas to Eugene Lyons, Jan. 6, 1920, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn Papers, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.

124 Letter from A. J. Muste, General Secretary Amalgamated Textile Workers of America to Eugene Lyons, Jan. 10, 1920, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn Papers, Immigration History Research Center, University of Minnesota.