No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Settler cities in the Dutch Indies: Race, class and the emergence of settler colonialism
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 April 2023
Abstract
This article explores the colonial land tenure system which evolved in the municipalities of the Dutch Indies in the early twentieth century, resulting in structural differences in urban property ownership. The development of a formal and informal property regime during this period created the logic of racialised capitalism that underpinned settler colonialism. By looking at the actions of the Indo-Europeesche Verbond (IEV), the main Indo-European political party, this article seeks to understand why settler colonialism failed in the Dutch Indies. It finds that the success of the settler colonialism project depended on its relationship with global capitalism and imperial support. This study also finds that structural differences in property ownership have continued in postcolonial Indonesia.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The National University of Singapore, 2023
Footnotes
The author would like to thank the Kementerian Pendidikan, Kebudayaan, Riset dan Teknologi (Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology) for providing the funding for research on land commodification in Indonesian cities in the 20th century through a PDUPT research grant.
References
1 MLeaf, ichael, ‘Land rights for residential development in Jakarta, Indonesia: The colonial roots of contemporary urban dualism’, International Journal of Urban Regional Research 17, 4 (1993): 477–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Colombijn, Freek, ‘Solid as a rock, or a handful of dust? The security of land tenure in Indonesian cities from 1930–1960’, in Beyond empire and nation: The decolonization of African and Asian societies, 1930s–1970s, ed. Bogaerts, Els and Raben, Remco (Leiden: Brill, 2012), pp. 213–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
2 Abidin Kusno, ‘Middling urbanism and the contradictory space of the kampung in Indonesian capitalism’, Platform, 23 Sept. 2019, https://www.platformspace.net/home/middling-urbanism-and-the-contradictory-space-of-the-kampung-in-indonesian-capitalism (last accessed 27 Feb. 2023).
3 Leitner, Helga and Sheppard, Eric, ‘Global urbanism inside/out: Thinking through Jakarta’, in Global urbanism: Knowledge, power and the city, ed. Lancione, Michelle and MacFarlane, Colin (London: Routledge, 2021), pp. 107–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
4 Reerink, Gustaaf and Gelder, Jean-Louis van, ‘Land titling, perceived tenure security, and housing consolidation in the kampongs of Bandung, Indonesia’, Habitat International 34, 1 (2010): 78–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Simone, AbdouMaliq and Rao, Vyjayanthi, ‘Securing the majority: Living through uncertainty in Jakarta’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 36, 2 (2012): 315–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Simone, AbdouMaliq, ‘The urban poor and their ambivalent exceptionalities: Some notes from Jakarta’, Current Anthropology 56, S11 (2015): 15–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 Kusno, Abidin, ‘Middling urbanism: The megacity and the kampung’, Urban Geography 41, 7 (2020): 954–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Blomley, Nicholas, ‘Law, property, and the geography of violence: The frontier, the survey, and the grid’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers 93, 1 (2003): 121–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Blatman-Thomas, Naama and Porter, Libby, ‘Placing property: Theorizing the urban from settler colonial cities’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 43, 1 (2019): 30–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hugill, David, ‘What is a settler-colonial city?’, Geography Compass 11, 5 (2017): e12315CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
8 Wolfe, Patrick, ‘Settler colonialism and the elimination of the native’, Journal of Genocide Research 8, 4 (2006): 387–409CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
9 Veracini, Lorenzo, Settler colonialism: A theoretical overview (Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 Bhandar, Brenna, Colonial lives of property: Law, land and racial regimes of ownership (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2018), p. 4Google Scholar.
11 Dorries, Heather, Hugill, David and Tomiak, Julie, ‘Racial capitalism and the production of settler colonial cities’, Geoforum 132 (2022): 263–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
12 Cheryl I. Harris, ‘Whiteness as property’, Harvard Law Review 106, 8 (1993): 1710–91.
13 Bhandar, Colonial lives of property, p. 51.
14 Englert, Sai, ‘Settlers, workers, and the logic of accumulation by dispossession’, Antipode 52, 6 (2020): 1647–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lucy Taylor and Geraldine Lublin, ‘Settler colonial studies and Latin America’, Settler Colonial Studies 11, 3 (2021): 259–70.
15 Mamdani, Mahmood, ‘Settler colonialism: Then and now’, Critical Inquiry 41, 3 (2015): 596–614CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
16 Kelley, Robin D.G., ‘The rest of us: Rethinking settler and native’, American Quarterly 69, 2 (2017): 267–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 Taylor, Lucy, ‘Four foundations of settler colonial theory: Four insights from Argentina’, Settler Colonial Studies 11, 3 (2021): 344–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
18 Englert, ‘Settlers, workers, and the logic of accumulation by dispossession’.
19 Jean Gelman Taylor, The social world of Batavia: European and Eurasian in Dutch Asia (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2004).
20 Mamdani, Mahmood, ‘Beyond settler and native as political identities: Overcoming the political legacy of colonialism’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 43, 4 (2001): 651–64Google Scholar.
21 Luttikhuis, Bart, ‘Beyond race: Constructions of “Europeanness” in late-colonial legal practice in the Dutch East Indies’, European Review of History: Revue europeenne d'histoire 20, 4 (2013): 539–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
22 Nordholt, Henk Schulte, ‘Modernity and cultural citizenship in the Netherlands Indies: An illustrated hypothesis’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 42, 3 (2011): 435–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
23 Englert, ‘Settlers, workers, and the logic of accumulation by dispossession’.
24 Taylor, The social world of Batavia; Pauline D. Milone, ‘Indische culture, and its relationship to urban life’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 9, 4 (1967): 407–26.
25 Ulbe Bosma, ‘Sailing through Suez from the South: The emergence of an Indies-Dutch migration circuit, 1815–1940’, International Migration Review 41, 2 (2007): 511–36.
26 P.J.M. Nas, ‘Origin and development of the urban municipality in Indonesia’, in Decentralization and regional autonomy in Indonesia: Implementation and challenges, ed. Coen J.G Holtzappel and Martin Ramstedt (Singapore: ISEAS, 2009), p. 222.
27 Farabi Fakih, ‘Colonial domesticity and the modern city: Bandung in the early twentieth-century Netherlands Indies’, Journal of Urban History (2021): 1–23.
28 ‘Contact commissions’ with kampung councils (sometimes with the help of parties such as Parindra) started in the 1930s, i.e., institutional contact between municipalities and kampungs started only in the last decade of colonial rule. Anon., De Locomotief, 2 June 1928; Anon., ‘Contact Commissie tusschen Kampong bevolking en Gemeentebestuur’, Soerabaiasch Handelsblad, 15 Apr. 1931.
29 Michelle Kooy and Karen Bakker, ‘Technologies of government: Constituting subjectivities, spaces, and infrastructures in colonial and contemporary Jakarta’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32, 2 (2008): 375–91; Prathiwi Widyatmi Putri, ‘Sanitizing Jakarta: Decolonizing planning and kampung imaginary’, Planning Perspectives 34, 5 (2019): 805–25.
30 S. Jaarsma, Grond voor Nederlander (Surabaya: De Toekomst, 1936), pp. 6–17.
31 S. Jaarsma, Bewijsmiddelen van recht op grond in Nederlandsch-Indië (Leiden: Eduard Idjo, 1918); Leaf, ‘Land rights for residential development in Jakarta’; Freek Colombijn, Under construction: The politics of urban space and housing during the decolonization of Indonesia, 1930–1960 (Leiden: Brill, 2013), pp. 141–56.
32 Brenna Bhandar, ‘Title by registration: Instituting modern property law and creating racial value in the settler colony’, Journal of Law and Society 42, 2 (2015): 253–82; Bhandar, Colonial lives of property.
33 S. Jaarsma, Bewijsmiddelen van recht op grond in Nederlandsch-Indië, pp. 89–93.
34 MacKenzie later became Surveyor General of India.
35 W.R. Hugenholtz, ‘Landrentebelasting op Java 1812–1920’ (PhD diss., University of Leiden, 2008), pp. 19–41; T. Karsten, Toelichting op de Stadsvormingsordonnantie Stadgemeenten Java (Jakarta: Landsdrukkerij, 1938), p. 64.
36 Leaf, ‘Land rights’; Colombijn, Under construction, pp. 141–56.
37 Leaf, ‘Land rights’.
38 Jaarsma, Grond voor den Nederlander, p. 45.
39 Leaf, ‘Land rights’.
40 Sudargo Gautama and Robert N. Hornick, An introduction to Indonesian law: Unity in diversity (Bandung: Alumni, 1976), pp. 122–3.
41 Karsten, Toelichting op de stadsvormingsordonnantie, pp. 65–6.
42 A.V. Doorninck, Grondrechten aan niet Inheemschen: Een Prae-Advies (Jakarta: Olt & Co., 1932), p. 1.
43 G. Jansen, ‘De decentralisatie en de grond’, 25 Jaren Decentralisatie in Nederlandsch Indie, 1905–1930 (Semarang: FWM Kerchman, 1930), p. 146.
44 K.L.J. Enthoven, De huurcommissie ordonnantie (regeling ter beteugeling van onredelijk opdrijving van de huurprijzen van woningen) staatsblad 1918 no. 228, benevens de uitvoeringsvoorschrijften, staatsblad 1918 no. 289 (Jakarta: Kolff, 1918).
45 H. Heetjans, Uitbreidingsplan Noord Bandoeng (Bandung: Voorkink, 1919).
46 Jansen, ‘De decentralisatie en de grond’, p. 147; H. Heetjans, Grondslagen van de grondpolitiek (Bandung: Visser & Co, 1929), p. 52.
47 Indisch Genootschap, Uitbreidingsplan der Indische Gemeente (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1917), pp. 1–2; van Roosmalen, Ontwerpen aan de stad: Stedenbouw in Nederlands-Indië en Indonesië (1905–1950).
48 Jansen, ‘De decentralisatie en de grond’, p. 147.
49 Ibid.
50 G.H. von Faber, Nieuwe Soerabaia (Surabaya: H. van Ingen, 1931), pp. 171, 176.
51 Municipality of Batavia, Batavia as a commercial, industrial and residential centre (Batavia: G. Kolff & Co, 1937), p. 142.
52 Gemeente Bandoeng, Dienst van het Grondbedrijf. Prospectus voor de uitgifte van gronden (Bandung: Vorkink, 1931), p. 19.
53 Thomas Karsten, Toelichting op de stadsvormingsordonnantie stadsgemeenten Java (Batavia: Landsdrukkerij, 1938), p. 72.
54 Handboek voor cultuur- en handels-ondernemingen in Nederlandsch Indie (Amsterdam: J.H. De Bussy); available at: http://colonialbusinessindonesia.nl.
55 M.A.J. Kelling, Het Hypotheekwezen in Nederlandsch Indie (Bandung: A.C. Nix & Co., 1928), pp. 159–62.
56 T. Karsten, ‘Over the Semarang Koncept-bouwverordening’, Locale Belangen 6, 4 (1918): 141.
57 Howard W. Dick. Surabaya, city of work: A socioeconomic history, 1900–2000 (Singapore: NUS Press, 2003), p. 357.
58 Regeringsalmanaak voor Nederlandsch Indie (Batavia: Landsdrukkerij, 1910), p. 650; and Regerings Almanaak (Batavia: Landsdrukkerij, 1930), p. 780.
59 James L. Cobban, ‘Public housing in colonial Indonesia 1900–1940’, Modern Asian Studies 27, 4 (1993): 871–96.
60 Anon., ‘Batavia's begrooting’, Soearabaijasch Handelsblad, 21 May 1935.
61 Fakih, ‘Colonial domesticity’, pp. 8–13.
62 Karsten, Stadsvormingsordonnantie, pp. 61–3.
63 Upik Djalins, ‘Becoming Indonesian citizens: Subjects, citizens, and land ownership in the Netherlands Indies, 1930–37’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 46, 2 (2015): 227–45.
64 Paul W. van der Veur, ‘The Eurasians of Indonesia: A problem and challenge in colonial history’, Journal of Southeast Asian History 9, 2 (1968): 191–207.
65 Ibid.
66 P.J.Th. Blumbergen, De Indo-Europeesche Beweging in Nederlandsch-Indie (Haarlem: HD Tjeenk Willink & Zoon, 1939), p. 56.
67 Djalins, ‘Becoming Indonesian citizens’.
68 Fakih, ‘Colonial domesticity’, p. 18.
69 Gautama and Hornick, An introduction to Indonesian law, pp. 84–6.
70 Freek Colombijn and Martine Barwegen, ‘Racial segregation in the (post) colonial city: The case of Indonesia’, Urban geography 30, 8 (2009): 838–56; Colombijn, Under construction.
71 Jaarsma using a number of examples argues the impracticality and inapplicability of making an adat land claim. Jaarsma, Grond voor den Nederlander, pp. 6–18.
72 Voorlopig ontwerp eener ordonnantie tot instelling van een Inlandsche cadaster; Jaarsma, Bewijsmiddelen van recht op grond in Nederlandsch Indie, pp. 13–18.
73 Verslag van de Commissie voor Inlandsche Rechtspersonen Ingesteld bij Besluit van den Gouverneur-Generaal van Nederlandsch-Indie van 14 Mei 1929 no. 4x.
74 Djalins, ‘Becoming Indonesian citizens’.
75 Van der Veur, ‘The Eurasians of Indonesia’.
76 Johan Winsemius, Nieuw Guinea als Kolonisatiegebied voor Europeaan en Indo-Europeaan (Pumerend: J. Muusses, 1936).
77 Bosma, ‘Nederlands Nieuw Guinea’, pp. 8–13.
78 Nederlander-Middenstander (pseud.), Empirebuilding (Surabaya: Drukkerij de Toelkomst, 1938), p. 34.
79 Anon., ‘Het XIII-de Congres van het IEV’, De Indische Courant, 29 Mar. 1932.
80 Anon., ‘De Indo uit de Kampong’, Het Algemeen Handelsblad, 24 Aug. 1935.
81 Anon., ‘Europeanen in de Kampongs, Bataviaasch Nieuwsblad, 29 Jan. 1932.
82 Anon., ‘De Indo in de Kampong’, De Nieuwe Vorstenlanden, 8 Jan. 1925.
83 Djalins, ‘Becoming Indonesian citizens’.
84 Nederlander-Middenstander, Empirebuilding, pp. 3–4.
85 Lev, Daniel S., ‘Judicial unification in post-colonial Indonesia’, Indonesia 16 (1973): 1–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
86 Djalins, ‘Becoming Indonesian citizens’.
87 Nederlander-Middenstander, Empirebuilding.
88 Veracini, ‘Settler colonialism’.
89 Leaf, Michael, ‘Legal authority in an extralegal setting: The case of land rights in Jakarta, Indonesia’, Journal of Planning Education and Research 14, 1 (1994): 12–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
90 Kusno, ‘Middling urbanism: The megacity and the kampung’.
91 Lev, Daniel S., ‘The politics of judicial development in Indonesia’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 7, 2rr (1965): 173–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
92 Lev, Daniel S., ‘Colonial law and the genesis of the Indonesian state’, in Legal evolution and political authority in Indonesia (Leiden: Brill, 2000), pp. 13–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bourchier, David, Illiberal democracy in Indonesia: The ideology of the family state (London: Routledge, 2014)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.