Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-n9wrp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-21T11:01:33.405Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Law and Mystery: Calling the Letter to Life Through the Spirit of the Law of State Constitutions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 April 2015

Emily Fowler Hartigan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

If law is anything today, it is dispirited. It lacks life, vitality, enchantment, vision. Neither law nor its practitioners sing—or even hum. My students tell me that they know this but want to hope for more. This article tries to suggest something more, which is already present in America's state constitutions if we can dare turn to hear it. It is the voice of the spirit of the laws of the land. It sings of a vision, and this article is an attempt to tell enough of the story of that vision so that you, too, may hear “an echo of the infinite, a glimpse of its unfathomable process, a hint of the universal law.”

To listen for the spirit, we can best attend to (in addition to the language of law texts) language of the spirit, language in which humankind has lived in hopes of relating to Ultimate Reality for millennia. The spirit we hope to tap is not necessarily theistic, but there is some correspondence among ideas of spirit, consciousness and God. As with the best of such language, we must speak not only of belief but also of doubt and mystery beyond necessary reason.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Law and Religion , Volume 6 , Issue 2 , 1988 , pp. 225 - 277
Copyright
Copyright © Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Holmes, O.W., The Path of the Law, in Collected Legal Papers 170 (1920)Google Scholar.

2. Moore, S., Let This Mind Be In You (1985)Google Scholar, (esp. Ch. 10 and 11).

3. Sherry, , The Founders' Unwritten Constitution, 54 U. Chi. L. Rev. 1127 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Grey, , Origins of the Unwritten Constitution: Fundamental Law in American Revolutionary Thought, 30 Stan. L. Rev. 843, 852 (1978)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4. See, e.g., Symposium: The Emergence of State Constitutional Law, 63 Tex. L. Rev. 959 (1985)Google Scholar.

5. For a discussion of naturalism, see Perry, M., Morality, Politics and Law (1988)Google Scholar.

6. Collins, & Skover, , The Future of Liberal Legal Scholarship, 87 Mich. L. Rev. 216 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7. Nagel, T., The View From Nowhere (1986)Google Scholar.

8. MacIntyre, A., Whose Justice? Which Rationality? (1988)Google Scholar; Walzer, M., Interpretation and Social Criticism (1987)Google Scholar; Geertz, C., Works and Lives (1988)Google Scholar.

9. Tracy, D., Plurality and Ambiguity (1987)Google Scholar.

10. Rosenblum, N., Another Liberalism (1988)Google Scholar.

11. See, e.g., one attempt at this pure particularism, Rorty, R., Contingency, Irony and Solidarity (1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12. Unger, R., Passion (1984)Google Scholar.

13. Cover, Foreword: Nomos and Narrative, 97 Harv. L. Rev. 4 (1983)Google Scholar; Messianic Law in Nomos XXX: Law Religion and Morality (Chapman, and Pennock, eds. 1988)Google Scholar; Cover, , Obligation: A Jewish Jurisprudence of the Social Order, 5 J. Law & Relig. 65 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14. Note 38 infra.

15. See, e.g., Ackerman, B., Social Justice and the Liberal State (1980)Google Scholar; Gutmann, A., Liberal Equality (1980)Google Scholar.

16. E.g., Teachout, , The Soul of the Fugue: An Essay on Reading Fuller, 70 Minn. L. Rev. 1073 (1986)Google Scholar.

17. Sandel, M., Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1985)Google Scholar.

18. Gilligan, C., In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development (1982)Google Scholar.

19. Card, , Women's Voices and Ethical Ideals: Must We Mean What We Say?Ethics 125 (10 1988)Google Scholar; Critical Inquiry, Volume 8 No. 2: Writing and Sexual Difference (1981)Google ScholarPubMed; Belenky, M.F., Clinchy, B.M., Goldberger, N.R., and Tarule, J.M., Women's Ways of Knowing: The Development of Self, Voice and Mind (1986)Google Scholar.

20. Scales, , The Emergence of a Feminist Jurisprudence, 95 Yale L.J. 1373 (1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21. Vining, J., The Authoritative and the Authoritarian 596 (1986)Google Scholar.

22. Lippmann, W., The Public Philosophy (1955)Google Scholar.

23. Heschel, A.J., Quest for God (1954)Google Scholar.

24. Berman, , “Religious Freedom and the Challenge of the Modern State”, Williamsburg Charter Nat'l Symposium on Religion Liberty Clauses in American Public Life, at 107 (1988)Google Scholar.

25. Tracy, supra note 9, at 20.

26. Grey, , The Constitution as Scripture, 37 Stan. L. Rev. 7 (1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27. 62 Tex. L. Rev. 949 (1984)Google Scholar.

28. Bodo, M., Juniper: Friend of Francis, Fool of God (1983)Google Scholar.

29. Id. at 69.

30. Id. at 70.

31. Id. at 87.

32. Id. at 88.

33. A. Simpleman (a.k.a P.R. Teachout), Sentimental Metaphors, review of Ball, M.S., Lying Down Together: Law, Metaphor and Theology, 34 Ucla L. Rev. 537 (1986)Google Scholar.

34. Brennan, W.J. Jr., Reason, Passion, and ‘The Progress of the Law’, 42#8 Rec Abnyc 948 (1988)Google Scholar; also see Nouwen, H., Lifesigns: Intimacy, Fecundity and Ecstasy In Christian Perspective (1986)Google Scholar; Moore, S., Let This Mind Be in You (1985)Google Scholar; Scales, , The Emergence of a Feminist Jurisprudence, 95 Yale L.J. 1373 (1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fraser, , What's Love Got To Do With It? Cls, Feminist Discourse, and an Ethic of Solidarity, 11 Harv. Women's L.J. 53 (1988)Google Scholar; Cornell, , Post-Structuralism, the Ethical Relation, and the Law, 9 Cardozo L. Rev. 1587 (1988)Google Scholar.

35. See Jurrow, , Untimely Thoughts, XIX American Journal of Legal History 265 (1975)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Berger, , Law of the Land Reconsidered, 74 Nw. U.L. Rev. 1 (1979)Google Scholar; Law of the Land, 3 Encyclopedia of the American Constitution 1130Google Scholar; Rembar, C., The Law of the Land (1980)Google Scholar.

36. Cover, supra note 13.

37. Levinson, S., Constitutional Faith (1988)Google Scholar.

38. Tushnet, , Federalism and the Traditions of American Political Theory, 19 Ga. L. Rev. 981 (1985)Google Scholar; Epstein, , Self-interest and the Constitution, J. Legal Ed. (1986)Google Scholar; Garcia v. San Antonio Metro. Transit Auth., 469 U.S. 528, 557 (1985) (Powell, J., dissenting).

39. See discussions of “paradoxical logic” in Benjamin, J., Bonds of Love (1988)Google Scholar; Moore, S., Let This Mind Be In You (1985)Google Scholar; Ricoeur, P., E.G., History and Truth 21–81 (1965)Google Scholar.

40. Eliot, T.S., “The Dry Salvages” V, “East Coker” V, from The Four Quartets, Collected Poems 1909–1962 198, 189 (1963)Google Scholar.

41. Fuller, L., The Law in Ouest of Itself 77–84 (1940)Google Scholar; Vining, J., The Authoritative and the Authoritarian 187 (1986)Google Scholar; Shklar, J., Legalism: Law, Morals and Political Trials (1964)Google Scholar.

42. Chopp, R.S., The Praxis of Suffering (1986)Google Scholar; Ellis, M., Toward a Jewish Theology of Liberation (1987)Google Scholar; Lewis, C.S., The Abolition of Man (1947)Google Scholar.

43. Dunne, J., The House of Wisdom (1986)Google Scholar.

44. Eliot, supra note 40, at 209.

45. Leff, , Unspeakable Ethics, Unnatural Law, 79 Duke L.J. 1229 (1979)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

46. Cover, , The Bonds of Constitutional Interpretation of the Word, the Deed, and the Role, 20 Ga. L. Rev. 815 (1986)Google Scholar; Cover, , Violence and the Word, 95 Yale. L.J. 1601 (1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, Cover, , Forward: Nomos and Narrative, 97 Harv. L. Rev. 4 (1983)Google Scholar.

47. Berger, supra note 35, at 1; McIlwain, , Due Process of Law in Magna Carta, 14 Colum. L. Rev. 24 (1914)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Corwin, , The Doctrine of Due Process of Law Before the Civil War, 24 Harv. L. Rev. 366, 460 (1911)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48. See Rogge, , Concept of Ordered Liberty, 47 Calif. L. Rev. 238 (1959)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Howard, A., The Road from Runnymede: Magna Carta and Constitutionalism in America (1968)Google Scholar.

49. Berger, supra note 35; Rogge, supra note 48.

50. Supra note 35; Mott, R., Due Process of Law (1926)Google Scholar; McIlwain, Ch., Constitutionalism: Ancient and Modern (1958)Google Scholar; Pococke, J.G.A., The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law (1957)Google Scholar.

51. 24 Mich. 44.

52. 10 Tenn (2 Yer.) 599.

53. 37 Me. 171.

54. 9 G & J 365.

55. 7 Cal 1.

56. 60 Me. 509.

57. 6 Neb. 37.

58. 150 N.Y. 459.

59. 55 Neb. 480.

60. Sherry, , The Founders' Unwritten Constitution, 54 U. Chi. L. Rev. 1127 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61. Grey, , Origins of the Unwritten Constitution: Fundamental Law in American Revolutionary Thought, 30 Stan. L. Rev. 843, 852 (1978)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62. Sherry, supra note 60, at 1167.

63. Id. at 1129.

64. 10 Us (6 Cranch) 87.

65. Currie, , The Constitution in the Supreme Court: State and Congressional Power, 1801-1835, 49 U. Chi. L. Rev. 887, 892–894 (1982)Google Scholar.

66. Sherry, supra note 60, at 1176.

67. See Note, The Partisan Battle Over the Constitution: Meese's Jurisprudence of Original Intention, and Brennan's Theory of Contemporary Ratification, 70 Marq. L. Rev. 389 (1987)Google Scholar.

68. Moores, 55 Neb. at 489.

69. Id. at 489.

70. Id. at 521.

71. Hurlbut, supra note 51.

72. Id. at 47.

73. Id. at 109.

74. Id. at 110.

75. Rathbone, 150 N.Y. at 460.

76. Id. at 467.

77. Billings, 7 Cal. at 16Google Scholar.

78. Douglas, , Federalism and State Constitutions, 13 Vt. L. Rev. 128, 131–35 (1988)Google Scholar; State v. Jewett, 146 Vt. 221, 500 A.2d 233, at 235 (1985).

79. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 106.

80. Id. at 107.

81. Fuller, supra note 41, at 79.

82. Corwin, , Higher Law, 42 Harv. L. Rev. 149, 365 (1928)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

83. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 90.

84. Id. at 107.

85. Moores, 55 Neb. at 489.

86. Id. at 493, quoting People v. Morris, 13 Wend. (N.Y.) 325.

87. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 106-07.

88. Id. at 107.

89. Id.

90. Id.

91. Id. at 87.

92. Goebel, , Law and Practice at 289Google Scholar, cited in Sherry.

93. See Joel Handler, “Dependent People, the State and the Modern/Postmodern Search for the Dialogic Community,” Institute for Legal Studies (Madison, WI) (Spr-19).

94. Sherry, supra note 60, at 1137-38.

95. Rawls, J., A Theory of Justice (1971)Google Scholar.

96. Heller, Sosna and Wellbery eds. (1986).

97. Supra note 12.

98. 81 Nw. U.L. Rev. 589, 590 (1987)Google Scholar.

99. Hauerwas, S., A Community of Character (1981)Google Scholar; MacIntyre, A., After Virtue (1981)Google Scholar.

100. Perry, supra note 5, at 591.

101. Billings, 7 Cal. at 12.

102. Michael Sandel, “The Crisis of Liberal Political Theory,” Williamsburg Charter, supra note 24, at 36-41 (1988).

103. Billings, 7 Cal. at 12 (quoting John Locke).

104. Id. at 13.

105. Billings, 7 Cal. at 14.

106. Id. at 8-15.

107. Grey, , Origins of the Unwritten Constitution: Fundamental Law in American Revolutionary Thought, 30 Stan. L. Rev. 843, 852 (1978)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

108. Regents of the University of Maryland v. Williams, 9 G & J 365, 412 (1838).

109. Baty, 6 Neb. at 43.

110. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 87.

111. Baty, 6 Neb. at 41.

112. Id., citing Cooley. Con. Lim., 37.

113. Id. at 41.

114. Cooper, 10 Tenn (2 Yer) at 614.

115. Regents of the University of Maryland v. Williams, 9 G & J 365, 408 (1838).

116. Eliot, supra note 40, at 208.

117. Soper, P., A Theory of Law (1986)Google Scholar.

118. See 3 Unger, R., Politics: A Work In Constructive Social Theory (1988)Google Scholar.

119. State vs Doherty, 60 Me. 504, 511, (1872). This is not restricted in import to the Judeo-Christian tradition. As commentators like Ruth Colker and Paul Savoy discuss, other traditions have a similar notion of legalism. Savoy quotes a Zen commentator:“ ‘Koans appear bewildering to people who cherish the letter above the spirit.’” (at 811). Ruth Colker, Review of Catherine Mackinnon's, Feminism Unmodified, 68 B.U.L. Rev. 217 (1988)Google Scholar and Savoy, , The Spiritual Nature of Equality: Natural Principles of Constitutional Law, 28 How. L.J. 809 (1985)Google Scholar.

120. Herzog, , As Many As Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast, 75 Calif. L. Rev. 609 esp. 625–630 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

121. Id. at 510.

122. Baty, 6 Neb. at 47.

123. Id. at 43.

124. Id. at 42.

125. Regents of the University of Maryland v. Williams, 9 G & J 365, 409 (1838).

126. Id. at 410.

127. Billings, 7 Cal. at 15.

128. Id. at 16.

129. Id.

130. Id. at 13.

131. Id. at 20.

132. Id. at 18. Quoting California constitution.

133. Id. at 19.

134. Id.

135. Id.

136. Id.

137. Id. at 23.

138. Sherry, supra note 60.

139. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 100.

140. Id. at 98.

141. Id. at 98-99 (citing Lieber, Civil Liberties & Self-Government, Chapter 21).

142. Id. at 98.

143. Id. at 102.

144. Id. at 102.

145. Id. 101-102.

146. Rathbone, 150 N.Y. at 475.

147. Id. at 467.

148. Id. at 506.

149. Moores, 55 Neb. at 520.

150. Id. at 521.

151. Levinson, supra note 37, at 27ff.

152. Rathbone, 150 N.Y. at 480.

153. Id. at 481.

154. Id.

155. Id. at 484.

156. Id. at 485.

157. Id. at 483.

158. Id. at 490.

159. Id. at 487.

160. See Barber, B., Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age (1984)Google Scholar. One recent rendition of this theme has come, somewhat unexpectedly, from the American Catholic bishops in their pastoral on the economy, Economic Justice for All: Pastoral Letter on Catholic Social Teaching and the U.S. Economy (1986), Chap. 1.

161. Greenhouse, C., Praying For Justice: Faith, Order and Community in an American Town (1986)Google Scholar.

162. Id. at 25.

163. Id. at 31.

164. Lippman, supra note 22. For the limits on that radicalism, see Wilson Carey Mcwilliams' discussion of Lippman as philosophical liberal in The Idea of Fraternity in America (1973).

165. Lippman at 77.

166. Id. at 77, quoting Ernest Barker.

167. Id. at 78.

168. Id. at 136.

169. Id. at 136.

170. Neuhaus, R.J., The Naked Public Square (1981)Google Scholar; Bellah, R.et al., Habits of the Heart (1985)Google Scholar; Will, G., Statecraft as Soulcraft (1983)Google Scholar.

171. Bodo, supra note 28, at 13.

172. Id. at 15.

173. ¶19, Philosophical Investigations (2nd ed. 1958).

174. Id. ¶371, 373.

175. Id. ¶431.

176. Id. ¶432.

177. Id. ¶435.

178. May, G., Spirit & Will (1983)Google Scholar.

179. Philosophical Investigations (2nd ed., 1958), Part II, iv.

180. Id. Part II, iv.

181. Lippmann, supra note 22, at 29, 34.

182. Id. at 23-32.

183. Id. at 135.

184. Hurlbut, 24 Mich, at 107.

185. The Symposium 202 (Jowett, translation, Stephanus, edition)Google Scholar.

186. Palmer, P., To Know as We Are Known/A Spirituality of Education 9 (1983)Google Scholar.

187. Heschel, supra note 23, at 25.

188. Id. at 127.

189. Id. at 27.

190. Miller, J. Hillis, The Ethics of Reading 127 (1987)Google ScholarPubMed.

191. See Hauerwas, supra note 99.

192. Id. at 64.

193. Id. at 64.

194. Id. at 65.

195. Id. at 65.

196. Id. at 65.

197. Unger, R., Politics: A Work in Constructive Social Theory (Social Theory; False Necessity; Plasticity Into Power) (1988)Google Scholar.

198. Id. at 65.

199. Id. at 66.

200. Id. at 136; Cover, , Obligation: A Jewish Jurisprudence of the Social Order, 5 J. Law & Relig. 65 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

201. Id. at 137.

202. Id. at 25.

203. Ochs, C., An Ascent to Joy: Transforming Deadness of Spirit (1986)Google Scholar.

204. Heschel, supra note 23, at 25.

205. Luke, H., Woman: Earth and Spirit 80–92 (1986)Google Scholar.

206. Id. at 80-81.

207. Id. at 82.

208. Palmer, P., To Know as We Are Known 26 (1983)Google Scholar.

209. Luke, supra note 205, at 64.

210. Id. at 65.

211. Id. at 67.

212. “United States Technology and Adult Commitment,” Studies in the Spirituality of Jesuits, January 1987, at 1, 20-21.

213. Id. at 23.

214. Id. at 23.

215. Dame Julian of Norwich, Showings, Chapter XIII.

216. Poems and Prose of Gerard Manley Hopkins 61 (Gardner, W.H. ed. 1953)Google Scholar.

217. Nouwen, H., Clowning in Rome 14 (1979)Google Scholar.

218. Weber, C. Lore, Womanchrist 54 (1987)Google Scholar.

219. See, e.g., Carr, A., Transforming Grace (1989)Google Scholar; McFague, S., Models of God (1987)Google Scholar; R. Colker, “Feminism, Theology and Abortion: Towards Love, Compassion and Wisdom” (forthcoming).

220. Fuller, L., The Morality of Law 40–43, 184–86 (1969)Google Scholar.

221. Baty, 6 Neb. at 46.

222. Id. at 42.

223. Luke, supra note 205, at 69.

224. Frost, R., The Gift Outright in Collected Poems 348Google Scholar.

225. Bonhoffer, D., Meditating on the Word (Gracie, D. trans. 1987)Google Scholar.

226. Id.

227. Mosk, , State Constitutionalism: Both Liberal and Conservative, 63 Texas L. Rev. 1081 (1985)Google Scholar; Gormley, , Ten Adventures in State Constitutional Law, Emerging Issues in State Constitutional Law 31–35 (1988)Google Scholar.

228. Fish, , Liberalism Doesn't Exist, 87 Duke L.J. 997 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

229. Sandel, supra note 17; Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972).

230. Eliot, “Ash Wednesday” supra note 40, 87-88.

231. Shaffer, T., On Being A Christian and a Lawyer (1981)Google Scholar; Perry, M., Morality, Politics and the Law (1988)Google Scholar; Walzer, M., Interpretation and Social Criticism (1987)Google Scholar.

232. See Cavell, S., The Uncanniness of the Ordinary (1988)Google Scholar esp. chap. 6.

233. Herzog, supra note 120, at 625 (praising liberal law's autonomy); Weinrib, , Legal Formalism: On the Immanent Rationality of the Law, 97 Yale L.J. 949 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

234. Tracy, supra note 9, at 108.

235. Treatises and Sermons of Meister Eckhart 130–31 (Clark, J. and Skinner, J. trans. 1983)Google Scholar.

236. Herzog, supra at note 120, at 624.

237. Shawn Elliott, 3rd year, University of Nebraska, College of Law.

238. Holmes, O.W., Collected Legal Papers (1920)Google Scholar; See Grey, , Holmes and Legal Pragmatism, 41 Stan. L. Rev. 787 (1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

239. Id., “The Path of the Law” at 167, 170.

240. Towne v. Eisner, 245 U.S. 418, 425 (1918).

241. Abrahamson, , Criminal Law and State Constitutions, 65 Tex. L. Rev. 1141, 1181 (1985)Google Scholar.

242. See Putnam, H., Reason, Truth and History 50 (1981)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

243. Burt, , Constitutional Law and the Teaching of Parables, 93 Yale L.J. 455 (1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

244. Cover, Obligation, supra note 200, at 74.