Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-n9wrp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-19T22:17:01.199Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Rule of Agustín de Iturbide: A Reappraisal

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 February 2009

Timothy E. Anna
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

After a struggle of eleven years, and the loss, according to the conservative estimate of Carlos María de Bustamante, of 2000,0000 lives, Mexico awoke in September 1821 an independent nation. For months before the culmination of independence there was no doubt who would rule the nation – that is, who was the de facto chief of state, at least for the moment. Agustin de Iturbide, author of the Plan of Iguala, conceiver of the idea of the Three Guarantees that united all factions in favor of independence, chief of the Army of the Three Guarantees, signatory on Mexico's part of the Treaties of Cordoba that granted independence de jure (in Mexico's view), was the undisputed leader. Incorruptible, invincible, wise, Christian, the consummate politician, the salvation of the Church, the Protector of Spaniards in Mexico, the Hero of Iguala, the Liberator, the Father of the Nation, Iturbide had broken the yoke of the Lion of Castile. Mexicans, of all political persuasions, rallied around the demigod in a euphoria of rejoicing and hope that has no equal in the history of the country.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Latin American Studies , Volume 17 , Issue 1 , May 1985 , pp. 79 - 110
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Carlos, María de Bustamante, ‘Manifiesto histórico á las naciones y pueblos del Anáhuac, leído en la sesion pública del Soberano Congreso del 15 de abril de 1823’ (Mexico City, 1823), Benson Latin American Collection, University of Texas at Austin (hereafter cited as BLAC), Alamán papers.Google Scholar

2 Javier, Ocampo, Las ideas de un día: El pueblo mexicano ante la consumación de su independencia (Mexico City, 1969), p. 66.Google Scholar

3 José, María Miquel i Vergés, Diccionario de Insurgentes (Mexico City, 1969), p. 301;Google ScholarJosé, C. Valadés, Orígenes de la república mexicana (Mexico City, 1972), p. 11.Google Scholar

4 ‘Manifiesto que el Soberano Congreso Constituyente hizo a los pueblos en los momentos de publicarse el Acta Constitutiva de la Federación’, Mexico City, 31 January 1824, Archivo General de la Nación, Mexico City (hereafter cited as AGN), Gobernación, Legajo 486, Exp. 4.

5 Mier's opus is composed chiefly of a mass of pamphlets contemporary with the events. His Historia de la revolución de Nueva Espa˜a (facsimile of London edition, 1813, 2 vols., Mexico City, 1921)Google Scholar terminates at 1813. For a modern summary of his views see John, V. Lombardi, The Political IdeoIogy of Fray Servando Teresa de Mier (Cuernavaca, 1968).Google Scholar Bustamante's work, too, is highly dispersed, consisting of many contemporary pamphlets, his important periodicals La Abispa de Chilpancingo and Voz de la Patria, and his Continuaciń, del cuadro histórico de la revolución mexicana, (3 vols., Mexico, 1954), which is a re-compilation of diverse articles. He was the most prolific of the writers.Google ScholarLorenzo, de Zavala, Obras: Ensayo crítico de las revoluciones de México desde 1808 hasta 1830 (prologue and notes by Manuel González Ramírez, Mexico City, 1969).Google ScholarAnastacio, Zerecero, Memorias para la historia de las revoluciones en México (Mexico City, 1869).Google Scholar

6 Lucas, Alamán, Historia de Méjico desde los primeros movimientos que prepararon su independencia en el año de 1808 hasta la época presente (5 vols., 1849–52, reprint, Mexico City, 1942). Alamán's vol. 5 deals with the Iturbide period.Google ScholarHenry, George Ward, Mexico in 1827 (2 vols., London 1828).Google ScholarJoel, R. Poinsett, Notes on Mexico, Made in the Autumn of 1822 by a Citizen of the United States (Philadelphia, 1824). Both Ward and Poinsett left extensive views in their many reports to their home governments, which have been published in various forms.Google Scholar

7 Charles, A. Hale, Mexican Liberalism in the Age of Mora, 1821–1853 (New Haven, 1968), p. 25.Google Scholar

8 José, Maria Bocanegra, Memorias para la historia de México independiente, 1821–1841 (2 vols,, Mexico City, 1892–7).Google ScholarJosé, María Tomel y Mendívil, Breve rese˜a histórica de los acontecimientos más notables de la nación mexicana desde el año de 1821 hasta nuestros días (Mexico City, 1852).Google ScholarJosé, María Luis Mora, México y sus revoluciones (3 vols., Paris, 1836),Google Scholar and Obras sueltas (2nd ed., Mexico City, 1963).Google ScholarVicente, Riva Palacio (ed.), México a través de los siglos (5 vols., Mexico City, 1888–1889).Google ScholarFrancisco, de Paula Arrangoiz y Berzábal, Méjico desde 1808 basta 1867 (4 vols., Madrid, 1871).Google ScholarNiceto, de Zamacois, Historia de México, desde sus tiempos mas remotos hasta nuestros dias (18 vols., Barcelona, 1876–88).Google Scholar

9 William, Spence Robertson, Iturbide of Mexico (Durham, 1952).Google ScholarEzequiel, A. Chávez, Agustin de Iturbide: Libertador de México (Mexico City, 2nd ed., 1962).Google ScholarMariano, Cuevas, Historia de la Nación Mexicana, (3rd ed., Mexico City, 1967), Cuevas says of Iturbide's election: ‘Never in the Mexican nation has there been seen a more popular and unanimous election’ (p. 520), which is an overstatement, no matter how one views Iturbide or Mexican electoral democracy.Google Scholar

10 Timothy, E. Anna, The Fall of the Royal Government in Mexico City (Lincoln, 1978), pp.205–9.Google Scholar

11 Vicente, Guerrero, ‘Manifiesto patriótico que hizo siendo comandante General de la primera division del Ejército de las Tres Garantías’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, García collection.Google Scholar

12 Servando, Teresa de Mier, ‘Mernoria político-instructiva, enviada desde Filadelfia en agosto de 1821 a los gefes independientes del Anáhuac’ (Mexico City, 1822), BLAC, García collection.Google Scholar

13 El Sol, 15 05 1823 and 2 04 1823.Google Scholar

14 ‘Amor o aborrecimiento, no quita conocimiento’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.Google Scholar

15 ‘Dictamen de la comisión especial encargada por el soberano congreso de examinar los puntos de abdicación de la corona’ (Mexico City, 1823), BLAC, García collection.Google Scholar

16 Alamán, , Historia, vol. 5, p. 297.Google Scholar

17 Decree of Sovereign Junta, Mexico City, 14 November, 1821, Biblioteca del Instituto Nacional de Antropología y Historia, Mexico City (hereafter cited as INAH), T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

18 Regency to Iturbide, Mexico City, 22 February 1822, BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection; Iturbide to Regency, Mexico City, 7 December 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

19 Ocampo, , Las ideas, pp. 331–2.Google Scholar

20 ‘Marcha dedicada á la Sra. Da. Ana María Huarte’, (Mexico City, n.d.), BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.

21 ‘Solemnes exequias de la Señora Doña María Josefa Aramburu de Iturbide’ (Mexico City, 1822). BLAC, Alamán papers.

22 Regency to Iturbide, Mexico City, 22 February 1822. BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.

23 ‘Proclama del Excmo. Señor Agustin de Iturbide’ (Mexico City, 1821), pp. 246–7 in Sutro Branch, California State University, Catalogue of Mexican Pamphlets in the Sutro Collection, 1623–1822 (San Francisco, 1939).Google Scholar

24 ‘Acta de Independencia del Imperio’, Mexico City, 28 09 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.Google Scholar

25 Decree of the Sovereign Junta, Mexico City, 15 December 1821; Decree of the Sovereign Congress, Mexico City, 24 February 1822; and Decree of the Sovereign Congress, Mexico City, 17 September 1822, all in INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

26 Francisco, Lagranda, ‘Consejo prudente sobre una de las garantías’ (Mexico, 1821), BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection; ‘Representación de los Generales y Gefes del Ejército…a fin de proceder legalmente contra el autor del papel intitulado Consejo prudente…’ Mexico City, 11 12 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.Google Scholar

27 Decree of Regency, Mexico City, 22 October 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

28 El Sol, 22 12 1821.Google Scholar

29 ‘Callen unos y hablen otros’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

30 Circular of Iturbide, Mexico City, 8 December 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

31 ‘Los Europeos piden el Castillo de San Juan de Ulúa, en Representación que hacen al Sr. General Dávila que lo defiende’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

32 ‘Ni están todos los que son, ni son todos los que están’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, García collection.

33 ‘No paga Iturbide con condenarse’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, García collection.

34 ‘El ciudadano en campaña con entusiasmo patriótico’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

35 ‘Sermon predicado en la Santa Inglesia Metropolitana de Megico el dia 21 de julio de 1822 por…Antonio Joaquín Pérez’ (Puebla, 1839), BLAC, García collection.

36 Fray Bernardo, Bishop of Sonora, to Iturbide, Culiacán, November 1821, INAH, T-2, 10, Colección Antigua.

37 ‘El importante voto de un ciudadano’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

38 ‘Derechos convincentes para elegir emperador americano’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, García collection.

39 ‘Contestación de un americano al Manifiesto del Señor D. Agustín de Iturbide’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

40 El Amigo de la paz y de la patria, 19 05 1822.Google Scholar

41 ‘Contestación de un americano al Manifiesto del Seín de Iturbide’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

42 Letters to Iturbide from Santa Anna, Veracruz, 15 April 1822; Primo, Querétaro, 19 April, 1822; Lariz, , Aguascalientes, 13 04 1822, BLAC, Iturbide papers.Google Scholar

43 Actas del congreso constituyente mexicano (Mexico City, 1822), vol. I, pp. 286–301.Google Scholar See Robertson's, footnote on the vote, Iturbide, p. 175.Google Scholar It is worth noting that in the Second Constituent Congress when the vote was taken to declare Iturbide subject to execution if he should ever set foot again in Mexico, 62 deputies voted for the motion. Admittedly, the Second Constituent Congress was established on a different electoral base than the First and was smaller, but the fact remains that more deputies voted for his accession to the throne than for his execution, Alamán, , Historia, vol. 5, p. 502.Google Scholar

44 Robertson, , Iturbide, p. 182.Google Scholar

45 ‘El unipersonal de Don Agustín de Iturbide, emperador que fue de Mexico’, (Mexico City, 1823), BLAC, García collection.

46 Zavala, , Ensayo critico, p. 128.Google Scholar

47 Ibid., pp. 107 and 132.

48 The Eagle: The Autobiography of Santa Anna (ed. Ann, Fears Crawford, Austin, 1967), p. 15.Google Scholar

49 El amigo de la paz y de la patria, 19 05 1822.Google Scholar

50 El Hombre Libre, 17 05 1822.Google Scholar

51 Iturbide, , ‘Memoria de Livorno’, 27 09 1823,Google Scholar BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection. I used the handwritten first draft English translation by Michael Joseph Quin. BLAC also possesses the apparent handwritten original by Iturbide, the original Italian translation in manuscript, two other handwritten copies in Spanish, and another copy by Carlos María de Bustamante with his critical footnotes. An English translation published under the title Memoirs of Agustin de Iturbide (Washington, D.C., 1971) is decidedly inferior to Quin's translation. For a published copy in Spanish, but without the many documents and notes attached to the original,Google Scholar see Agustín, de Iturbide, Sus memorias escritas desde Liorna (27 de septiembre de 1823) (Mexico City, 1973).Google Scholar

52 Gaceta del Gobierno Imperial de Mexico, 20 06 1822.Google Scholar

53 Testimony of Antonio, Bartres, Mexico City, 9 06 1823, INAH, I serie, Legajo 48; ‘Razón de las cantidades que han ministrado por esta Tesorería general…para los gastos de la casa Imperial’, BLAC, García collection.Google Scholar

54 Budget for 1823, Mexico City, 21 December 1822, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

55 Gaceta del Gobierno Imperial de Mexico, 14 12 1822.Google Scholar

56 ‘Callen unos y hablen otros’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

57 Zavala, , Ensayo critico, p. 133.Google Scholar

58 ‘Sentimientos de los oficiales del ejército imperial trigarante en la provisión de los empleos’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, García collection.

59 ‘Reclamo a favor de los heroes trapientos’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

60 ‘Critica del Hombre Libre’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

61 ‘Proyecto de la policía para la cuidad de México’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection; ‘Dictamen de las comisiones unidas de constitución y legislación sobre el proyecto de ley, consuitado al gobierno por el consejo de estado’ (Mexico City, 1822), BLAC, García collection; ‘Manifiesto…que hace la Audiencia…sobre su conducta en la administración de justicia’ Mexico City, 25 November 1822 AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 20, exp. I.

62 ‘Dictamen de la comisión de esclavos’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

63 Colonization decree, Mexico City, 4 January 1823, AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 21, exp.34.

64 Decree of Congress, Mexico City, 11 March 1822; Decree of Emperor, Tucubaya, 22 August 1822, both in INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

65 Decrees of Congress, Mexico City, 16 March and 16 April, 1822; Decree of Junta Nacional Instituyente, Mexico City, 5 November 1822, all in INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

66 Circular of Antonio de Medina, Minister of Hacienda, Mexico City, 20 December 1822, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

67 Decree of Emperor, Mexico City, 21 December 1822, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

68 ‘Quejas del pueblo contra el papel moneda’ (Mexico City, 1823), BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.

69 Extraordinary session of Council of State, Tacubaya, 2 August 1822, AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 13–4, exp. 2.

70 Decree of Emperor, Mexico City, 21 December 1822, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua.

71 ‘Idea de la conspiración descubierta en la capital del imperio mexicano en 26 de agosto de este año’ (Mexico City, 1822), BLAC, García collection.

72 ‘Representación del Brigadier D. Felipe de La Garza al emperador’ (Mexico City, 1822), BLAC, García collection.

73 Gaceta del Gobierno Imperial de Mexico, 5 11, 1822;Google Scholar Decree of Emperor, Mexico City, 31 October 1822, AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 11, exp. 9. Even in a matter as straightforward as this, there is some historiographical confusion. Jesús, Reyes Heroies, El liberalismo mexicano ( 3 vols., revised 2nd ed., Mexico City, 1982) vol. 1, p. 141 says: ‘Many of the members of the Junta belonged to the first Constituent Congress’. In fact they all did.Google Scholar

74 ‘Lista de los Sres. Diputados designado por S.M.I. para que compongan la Junta que ha de substituir al extinguido Congreso’, Mexico City, 1 November 1822, AGI, Gobernación, Legajo 11, exp, 9.

75 Manuscript poem of Mier, BLAC, Mier papers.

76 ‘Acta de instalación de la Junta Nacional Instituyente’ (Mexico City, 1822), BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.

77 ‘Manda nuestro emperador que ninguno le obedezca’ (Puebla, 1823), BLAC, Hernández y D´valos collection.

78 ‘Estado que manifiesta los Diputados proprietarios y suplentes, que se han de nombrar para el Congreso constituyente del Imperio Mexicano’ (Mexico City, 1821), BLAC, W. B. Stephens collection.

79 Decree of Sovereign Junta, Mexico City, 17 November 1821, INAH, T-3, 35, Colección Antigua. For Nueva Vizcaya (Durango) and Valladolid the word used was ‘labrador’, but this obviously meant the owner of some factory, since Nueva Vizcaya sent a titled noble, the conde del Valle del Suchil, as its ‘labrador’.

80 ‘Disolución del Soberano Congreso’, Mexico City, October 1822, AGN, Gobcrnación, Legajo 10, exp. 11.

81 Alamán, , Historia, vol. 5, pp. 417–18.Google Scholar

82 Bustamante, ‘Copia de carta en que se narran los sucesos occurridos en México durante el gobierno de Iturbide’, Mexico City, 14 August 1832, INAH, Colección Bustamante, vol. 17−5.

83 Santa, Anna, The Eagle, p. 16.Google Scholar

84 ‘Proclamas del Brigadier Santana a los habitantes y tropa de Veracruz’, Veracruz, 2 December 1822, BLAC, Santa Anna papers. ‘Plan del pronunciamiento en Veracruz y reformas que se le hicieron’, Veracruz, 2 and 6 December 1822, BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection. I used the handwritten copy of this document made by Hernández y Dávalos, but the document is printed in many sources, including Carlos María, de Bustamante, Cuadro históico de la revolución mexicana (2nd ed., Mexico City, 1844), vol. 6, pp. 64–71,Google Scholar and Vicente, Riva Palacio (ed.), México a través de los siglos, vol. 4, pp. 86–7. Santa Anna to Iturbide, Veracruz, 6 December 1822, BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection. Note that, with the letter, Hernández y Dávalos inscribed the title ‘Carta a Iturbide manifestandole los fundamentos por los que ha promovido su desconocimiento como Emperador y proclamando la republica’, yet the letter itself does not proclaim a republic. This suggests the source of some of the confusion about the content of Santa Anna's uprising; Hernández y Dávalos knew that the effect of the uprising was to create a republic, and did not pause to reflect that the letter in question did not mention a republic.Google Scholar

85 Bravo to Berdejo, Chilapa, 13 January 1823, INAH, T-2, 10, Colección Antigua.

86 Iturbide, ‘Memoria de Livorno’, BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.

87 Echávarri to Rayón, Campo de Casa Mata, 1 February 1823, INAH, T-2, 10, Colección Antigua.

88 Act of Casa Mata, Cuartel General de Casa Mata, 1 February 1823, INAH, T-2, 10, Colección Antigua.

89 Circular of José Manuel Herrera, minister of Relations, Mexico City, 18 February 1823, AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 21, exp, 23.

90 Provincial Deputation of Mexico to Vivanco, Mexico City, 26 February 1823; Same to Emperor, Mexico City, 1 March 1823, both in INAH, Colección Bustamante, vol. 17–4.

91 Alamán, , Historia, vol. 5, p. 466.Google Scholar

92 Quintana Roo to Alvarez, Mexico City, 23 February 1823, INAH, T-2, 10, Colección Antigua.

93 Circular of José del Valle, Mexico City, 26 February 1823, INAH, T-3, 36, Colección Antigua.

94 Bustamante, ‘Copia de carta en que se narran’, INAH, Colección Bustamante, vol. 17−5.

95 Nettie, Lee Benson, ‘The Plan of Casa Mata’, Hispanic American Historical Review, vol. 25, no. 1 (02 1945), pp. 45–56.Google Scholar

96 Decree of Sovereign Congress, Mexico City, 8 April 1823, AGN, Gobernación, Legajo 486, exp. 4.

97 Mier to Ambrosito, Toluca, 9 March 1823, copying letter of Crescencio Rejón, BLAC, Mier papers.

98 Fernández, de Lizardi, ‘Perdonesele a Iturbide y mueran los traidores’ (Mexico City, 1823), pp. 410–12 in Sutro, Catalogue.Google Scholar

99 ‘El Payo del Rosario a la grata memoria de Iturbide’ (Mexico City, 1826), BLAC, García collection.

100 Iturbide, ‘Memoria de Livorno’, BLAC, Hernández y Dávalos collection.