Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-vfjqv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T01:25:21.044Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Sacred Trust”: Rethinking Late British Decolonization in Indigenous Canada

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 July 2019

Joel Hebert
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article considers the political activism of Canada's Indigenous peoples as a corrective to the prevailing narrative of British decolonization. For several decades, historians have described the end of empire as a series of linear political transitions from colony to nation-state, all ending in the late 1960s. But for many colonized peoples, the path to sovereignty was much less straightforward, especially in contexts where the goal of a discrete nation-state was unattainable. Canada's Indigenous peoples were one such group. In 1980, in the face of separatism in Quebec, Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau pledged to renew the Canadian Confederation by bringing home the constitution, which was still retained by the British Parliament. But many Indigenous leaders feared that this final separation of powers would extinguish their historic bilateral treaties with the British crown, including the Royal Proclamation of 1763 that guaranteed Indigenous sovereignty in a trust relationship with Britain. Indigenous activists thus organized lobbying campaigns at Westminster to oppose Trudeau's act of so-called patriation. This article follows the Constitution Express, a campaign organized by the Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs in 1981. Maneuvering around the nuances of British political and cultural difference, activists on the Constitution Express articulated and exercised their own vision of decolonization, pursuing continued ties to Britain as their best hope for securing Indigenous sovereignty in a federal Canada.

Type
Original Manuscript
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 58 , Issue 3 , July 2019 , pp. 565 - 597
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The statute devolved all legislative powers over domestic and foreign affairs to the dominions. Sheppard, Robert and Valpy, Michael, The National Deal: The Fight for a Canadian Constitution (Toronto, 1982), 199–200Google Scholar.

2 The nature and extent of the dominions’ links to Britain in the postwar period has generated much debate among historians. See Tsokhas, Kosmas, “Dedominionization: The Anglo-Australian, 1939–1945,” Historical Journal 37, no. 4 (1994): 861–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Curran, James and Ward, Stuart, The Unknown Nation: Australia after Empire (Melbourne, 2010)Google Scholar; Potter, Simon J., Broadcasting Empire: The BBC and the British World, 1922–1970 (Oxford, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Buckner, Phillip, ed., Canada and the End of Empire (Vancouver, 2005)Google Scholar.

3 Russell, Peter H., Canada's Odyssey: A Country Based on Incomplete Conquests (Toronto, 2017), 362–72Google Scholar.

4 Sheppard and Valpy, National Deal, 205.

5 The National Archives (hereafter TNA), PREM 19/143, Pierre Trudeau, “Extract from Prime Minister's meeting with Mr. Pierre Trudeau Prime Minister of Canada,” 25 June 1980.

6 Unless otherwise specified, I use the term “Indigenous” in this article for its inclusivity in referring to Indian, Inuit, and Métis peoples. See Vowel, Chelsea, Indigenous Writes: A Guide to First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Issues in Canada (Winnipeg, 2016)Google Scholar, chap. 1.

7 Thrush, Coll, Indigenous London: Native Travelers at the Heart of Empire (New Haven, 2017), 215Google Scholar. See also Carlson, Keith Thor, “Rethinking Dialogue and History: The King's Promise and the 1906 Aboriginal Delegation to London,” Native Studies Review 16, no. 2 (2005): 1–38Google Scholar; Woodward, Michael and George, Bruce, “The Canadian Indian Lobby of Westminster, 1979–1982,” Journal of Canadian Studies 18, no. 3 (Fall 1983): 119–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 119–20. Three hundred chiefs had descended on London in the summer of 1979 to protest their continued exclusion by the federal government from ongoing constitutional talks. National Indian Brotherhood, Chiefs Visit to London (Ottawa: National Indian Brotherhood, 1979).

8 Russell, Canada's Odyssey, 387. See also Bastien, Frédéric, The Battle of London: Trudeau, Thatcher, and the Fight for Canada's Constitution, trans. Homel, Jacob (Toronto, 2014)Google Scholar.

9 Jonathan Aitken, “Amending Canada's Constitution,” letter to the editor, Times (London), 31 October 1980.

10 Knickerbocker and Nickel describe these visions as “multiple expressions of sovereignty.” Madeline Rose Knickerbocker and Sarah Nickel, “Negotiating Sovereignty: Indigenous Perspectives on the Patriation of a Settler Colonial Constitution, 1975–83,” BC Studies, no. 190 (Summer 2016): 67–87, at 68. For a discussion of “nested sovereignties” in settler states, and the tensions among them, see Simpson, Audra, Mohawk Interruptus: Political Life across the Borders of Settler States (Durham, 2014), 10–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 For Glen Coulthard, Indigenous activism in the 1970s and 1980s was characterized by a “recognition-based approach.” Instead of organizing to achieve genuine self-determination, Indigenous peoples found themselves trapped in a cycle of “symbolic gestures of political inclusion and recognition”—a smokescreen for continued colonialism. Coulthard, Glen Sean, Red Skin, White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition (Minneapolis, 2014), 162CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For a more sanguine view of Indigenous achievements in this period, especially through the court system, see Henderson, James Youngblood, First Nations Jurisprudence and Aboriginal Rights (Saskatoon, 2006), 7–8Google Scholar.

12 For a vision of sovereignty that contrasted with recognition-based approaches, see TNA, FCO 82/830, Joseph Phillips to Edward Schreyer, 20 August 1980. Phillips of the Mohawks of Kahnawà:ke argued that historic treaties that ceded Indigenous lands to settlers contravened Gayanerekowa, the centuries-old constitution of the Iroquois Six Nations Confederacy, and were thus null and void. See also Simpson, Mohawk Interruptus.

13 Mandell, Louise and Pinder, Leslie, “Tracking Justice: The Constitution Express to Section 35 and Beyond,” in Patriation and Its Consequences, ed. Harder, Lois and Patten, Steve (Vancouver, 2015), 180–202Google Scholar, at 181.

14 “Who? Adolph Trudeau or Pierre Hitler?” Indian World 4, no. 4 (December 1981): 12.

15 For a selection of this work, see Morris, Jan, Farewell the Trumpets: An Imperial Retreat (London, 1978)Google Scholar; Gallagher, John, The Decline, Revival and Fall of the British Empire: The Ford Lectures and Other Essays (Cambridge, 1982)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Darwin, John, Britain and Decolonization: The Retreat from Empire in the Post-War World (London, 1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Butler, L. J., Britain and Empire: Adjusting to a Post-Imperial World (London, 2002)Google Scholar; Rothermund, Dietmar, The Routledge Companion to Decolonization (London, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hyam, Ronald, Britain's Declining Empire: The Road to Decolonization, 1918–1968 (Cambridge, 2006)Google Scholar; Darwin, John, The Empire Project: The Rise and Fall of the British World-System, 1830–1970 (Cambridge, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Darwin, John, Unfinished Empire: The Global Expansion of Britain (New York, 2012)Google Scholar.

16 Russell, Peter H., “Aboriginal Nationalism and Quebec Nationalism: Reconciliation through Fourth World Decolonization,” Constitutional Forum 8, no. 4 (1994): 110–18Google Scholar, at 111.

17 Historians have habitually invoked marine metaphors to describe these people and places. For Morris, the so-called remnants of empire were “flotsam on the beach of history.” Morris, Farewell the Trumpets, 532. For Darwin, they were “limpets.” Darwin, Britain and Decolonization, 307.

18 For works that have questioned the established timelines of decolonization, see Henderson, James Youngblood, Indigenous Diplomacy and the Rights of People: Achieving UN Recognition (Saskatoon, 2008)Google Scholar; White, Luise, Unpopular Sovereignty: Rhodesian Independence and African Decolonization (Chicago, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kennedy, Dane, Decolonization: A Very Short Introduction (New York, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Collins, Michael, “Nation, State and Agency: Evolving Historiographies of African Decolonization,” in Britain, France and the Decolonization of Africa: Future Imperfect?, ed. Smith, Andrew W. M. and Jeppesen, Chris (London, 2017), 17–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Cooper, Frederick, Citizenship between Empire and Nation: Remaking France and French Africa, 1945–1960 (Princeton, 2014), 25Google Scholar.

20 Henderson, Indigenous Diplomacy, 23–24; Simpson, Mohawk Interruptus, 11–12.

21 Slattery, Brian, “The Royal Proclamation of 1763 and the Aboriginal Constitution,” in Keeping Promises: The Royal Proclamation of 1763, Aboriginal Rights, and Treaties in Canada, ed. Fenge, Terry and Aldridge, Jim (Montreal, 2015), 14–32Google Scholar, at 22.

22 “Royal Proclamation—October 7, 1763,” Avalon Project, Yale University Law School, 2008, http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/proc1763.asp.

23 Tennant, Paul, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics: The Indian Land Question in British Columbia, 1849–1989 (Vancouver, 1990), 10–12Google Scholar.

24 Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 217; Slattery, “Royal Proclamation,” 24.

25 Borrows, John, “Wampum at Niagara: The Royal Proclamation, Canadian Legal History, and Self-Government,” in Aboriginal and Treaty Rights in Canada: Essays on Law, Equity, and Respect for Difference, ed. Asch, Michael (Vancouver, 1997), 155–72Google Scholar, at 155.

26 Borrows, “Wampum at Niagara,” 164.

27 TNA, FCO 82/830, P. G. Baldwin to Brian Berry and Martin Berthoud, “Call by Mr. Madahbee, Union of Ontario Indians on 5 November,” 10 November 1980.

28 Sanders, , “‘Prior Claims’: An Aboriginal People in the Constitution of Canada,” in Beck, Stanley M. and Bernier, Ivan, eds., Canada and the New Constitution: The Unfinished Agenda, 2 vols. (Montreal, 1983), 1:244Google Scholar.

29 Cardinal, Harold, The Unjust Society: The Tragedy of Canada's Indians (Edmonton, 1969), 28Google Scholar.

30 Wayne Christian, kukpi7 (chief), Splatsin Nation, interview with the author, Splatsin Community Centre, Enderby, BC, 12 May 2017. Available at the Shuswap Tribal Council Archive, Kamloops, BC. See also Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 217; Patricia Margaret Hutchings, “The Argument for the Application of the Royal Proclamation of 1763 to British Columbia, Its Force and Effects” (LLM thesis, University of British Columbia, 1987).

31 Christian, interview.

32 Mandell, Louise, “Sovereign Nations: The Legal Case,” Indian World 3, no. 8 (November 1980): 31–33Google Scholar; my italics. For a discussion of similar language in article 22 of the League of Nations Covenant, see Henderson, Indigenous Diplomacy, 24–25.

33 White, Richard, The Middle Ground: Indians, Empire, and Republics in the Great Lakes Region, 1650–1815 (New York, 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Miller, J. R., “Petitioning the Great White Mother: First Nations’ Organizations and Lobbying in London,” in Canada and the End of Empire, ed. Buckner, Philip (Vancouver, 2004): 299–318Google Scholar, at 304–5.

35 Government of Canada, Section 91(24), Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982, http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/Const/page-4.html.

36 Government of Canada, Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples, vol.1, Looking Forward, Looking Back (Ottawa, 1996), 278–82; Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 45–46.

37 “The Substance of Great Britain's Obligations to the Indian Nations, Presented at the Fourth Russell Tribunal, Rotterdam, Netherlands,” November 1980, 1, UBCIC Constitution Express Digital Collections, http://constitution.ubcic.bc.ca/node/486.

38 “The Substance of Great Britain's Obligations to the Indian Nations.”

39 Union of British Columba Indian Chiefs, “Aboriginal Rights Position Paper,” 1979, 5, Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs Resource Centre (hereafter UBCIC RC).

40 Arthur Manuel, quoted in “Proceedings (Original), Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs, 14th Annual General Assembly, Williams Lake, BC,” 26–28 October 1982, p. 81, Fourteenth Annual General Assembly Meeting Minutes and Resolutions Binder, UBCIC RC.

41 “Status Indians” were recognized by the federal government under the terms of the Indian Act. Sanders, “Prior Claims,” 1:253.

42 TNA, FCO 82/830, Pierre Trudeau to Del Riley, 30 October 1980.

43 Russell, Canada's Odyssey, 321–22.

44 Pierre Trudeau, quoted in Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs, “Submissions to the Russell Tribunal,” in Strange Visitors: Documents in Indigenous-Settler Relations in Canada from 1876, ed. Keith D. Smith (Toronto, 2014), 339.

45 Henderson, First Nations Jurisprudence, 19.

46 Coulthard sees 1969 as the moment when the Canadian state pivoted away from a policy of assimilation toward the state-sponsored politics of recognition. He argues that the state's goal nevertheless remained the same: the dispossession of Indigenous peoples. Coulthard, Red Skin, White Masks, 5.

47 Sarah Ann Nickel, “‘United We Stand, Divided We Perish:’ Negotiating Pan-Tribal Unity in the Union of BC Indian Chiefs” (PhD diss., Simon Fraser University, 2015), 59–61, 75–76; Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 151–55. For Indigenous politics in British Columbia, see also Palmer, Bryan D., Canada's 1960s: The Ironies of Identity in a Rebellious Era (Toronto, 2009), 395–411CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tennant, Paul, “Native Indian Political Organization in British Columbia, 1900–1969: A Response to Internal Colonialism,” BC Studies, no. 55 (Autumn 1982): 3–49Google Scholar; Galois, R. M., “The Indian Rights Association, Native Protest Activity and the ‘Land Question’ in British Columbia, 1903–1916,” Native Studies Review 8, no. 2 (1992): 1–34Google Scholar; Tennant, , “Aboriginal Peoples and Aboriginal Title in British Columbia Politics,” in Politics, Policy, and Government in British Columbia, ed. Carty, Kenneth (Vancouver, 1996), 45–64Google Scholar; Foster, Hamar, “Honoring the Queen's Flag: A Legal and Historical Perspective on the Nisga'a Treaty,” BC Studies, no. 120 (Winter 1998/99): 11–35Google Scholar; Foster, Hamar, “We Want a Strong Promise:” The Opposition to Indian Treaties in British Columbia, 1850–1990,” Native Studies Review 18, no. 1 (2009): 113–37Google Scholar.

48 “State of Emergency,” Indian World 3, no. 7 (October 1980): 4Google Scholar.

49 Manuel, George and Posluns, Michael, The Fourth World: An Indian Reality (New York, 1974)Google Scholar.

50 “Indians Create Colorful Scene at Train Depot,” Prince George Herald, 24 November 1980.

51 “Constitution Express,” 5 November 1980, Bulletins, UBCIC Constitution Express Digital Collections, http://constitution.ubcic.bc.ca/node/155.

52 See also Sarah A. Nickel, “(Re)Occupied: #OccupyINAC and British Columbia's 1975 Militant May,” Active History, 26 April 2016, http://activehistory.ca/2016/04/reoccupied-occupyinac-and-british-columbias-1975-militant-may/; Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 175; Rutherford, Scott, “Canada's Other Red Scare: The Anicinabe Park Occupation and Indigenous Decolonization,” in The Hidden 1970s: Histories of Radicalism, ed. Berger, Dan (New Brunswick, 2010): 77–94Google Scholar; Nickel, “‘United We Stand,’” 193–229.

53 Christian, interview.

54 Nickel, Sarah A., “‘I Am Not a Women's Libber Although Sometimes I Sound Like One:’ Indigenous Feminism and Politicized Motherhood,” American Indian Quarterly 41, no. 4 (Fall 2017): 299–335CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 322–25.

55 Christian, Wayne, “A Great Indian Power Is Created,” Indian World 4, no. 1 (April 1981): 12–13Google Scholar, at 12.

56 Stanley Stump, “Aboard the Constitution Express,” Coyoti Prints, December 1980, 4.

57 “A Journey to Nationhood,” Indian World 3, no. 8 (November 1980): 4–6Google Scholar, at 6.

58 Stump, “Aboard the Constitution Express,” 5.

59 George Manuel, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly of Union of BC Indian Chiefs,” 14–15 May 1981, n.p., Thirteenth Annual General Assembly Meeting Kit Binder, UBCIC RC.

60 Christian, interview.

61 TNA, FCO 82/830, George Manuel, “Petition and Bill of Particulars on the Political Standing of Indigenous Tribes and Bands under the Protection of the British Government in the Face of Impending Canadian Independence,” December 1980. See also Venne, Sharon, “Indian Nations Seek World Support,” Indian World 3, no. 9 (January 1981): 4–5Google Scholar; “BC Indians Want the UN to Chair Constitution Talks,” Vancouver Sun, 10 November 1981.

62 Venne, “Indian Nations Seek World Support”; Elaine Thomas, “The Experience of My Trip to New York and the Purpose of Our Visits to the United Nations,” Neskainlith News, January 1981.

63 Christian, interview.

64 For the long history of Indigenous lobbying in international forums, see Henderson, Indigenous Diplomacy.

65 “Trudeau Finally Gets to Meet ‘Unpredictable’ Nigerian,” Vancouver Sun, 9 January 1981; Simpson, “Trials of Trudeau: Now It's a No-Show from Nigeria's President,” Globe and Mail, 9 January 1981. See also Ben Tierney, “Trudeau's Tour: A No-Show Road Show,” Vancouver Province, 9 January 1981.

66 “Tribal Chiefs’ Greeting Dazzles PM in Nigeria,” Vancouver Province, 11 January 1981; Simpson, “Nigeria Seeks Trudeau's Help in Redistributing World's Wealth,” Globe and Mail, 10 January 1981.

67 Manuel, George, “Constitution Express Re-awakened Our Nations,” Indian World 3, no. 9 (January 1981): 6–7Google Scholar, at 7.

68 Manuel, “Constitution Express Re-awakened Our Nations,” 6–7, at 6.

69 Christian, interview.

70 Wayne Christian, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

71 Michael Valpy, “The Myth of Canada as Global Peacekeeper,” Globe and Mail, 28 February 2007. For a discussion of peacekeeping and Canadian national identity, see McCullough, Colin, Creating Canada's Peacekeeping Past (Vancouver, 2016)Google Scholar.

72 “Constitution Express,” Indian World 3, no. 7 (October 1980): 5Google Scholar.

73 Christian, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

74 “Chiefs Council: If We're a Nation We Have to Act Like One,” Indian World 3, no. 9 (January 1981): 30Google Scholar.

75 “We Are Still in a State of Emergency: Constitution Express Potlatch,” Indian World 3, no. 11 (March 1981): 12Google Scholar.

76 Government of Canada, Looking Forward, Looking Back, 74–5; Tennant, Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, 8; Manuel and Posluns, Fourth World, 44.

77 “We Are Still in a State of Emergency,” 12. The Kamloops potlatch saw the birth of the activist feminist group Concerned Aboriginal Women, whose members would later occupy the Department of Indian Affairs regional headquarters in downtown Vancouver. Press release, 21 July 1981, F-111-7-2-6, Concerned Aboriginal Women—Occupation of DIAND, 1978–81, Women's Bookstore collection, University Archives, Simon Fraser University.

78 Christian, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

79 Mary Thomas, “Activity Report,” Coyoti Prints, January 1982.

80 “Constitution Express #2,” October 1981, Bulletins, UBCIC Constitution Express Digital Collection, http://constitution.ubcic.bc.ca/node/158.

81 Christian, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

82 For the central position of Indigenous women activists in British Columbia from the 1950s to the 1980s, see Nickel, “‘I Am Not a Women's Libber.’”

83 Wilf Adam, “Band Manager's Report,” Lake Babine News, November 1981, 3.

84 For a discussion of the Brandt Commission, see Vijay Prashad, The Poorer Nations: A Possible History of the Global South (London, 2014), chap. 1.

85 Kerra Lockhart, “BC Indians Berate PM in Europe,” Vancouver Province, 8 November 1981; Christian, interview. Many Germans held romantic views of North America's Indigenous peoples owing to the popularity of the nineteenth-century German author Karl May, who wrote novels about a fictional Apache hero, Winnetou. See Penny, H. Glenn, Kindred by Choice: Germans and American Indians since 1800 (Chapel Hill, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 Christian, interview; Adam, “Band Manager's Report,” 5.

87 Adam, “Band Manager's Report,” 5.

88 “Des Indiens à Paris,” Le Monde, 8 November 1981.

89 Adam, “Band Manager's Report,” 7. For Indigenous soldiers in the First World War, see Winegard, Timothy C., For King and Kanata: Canadian Indians and the First World War (Winnipeg, 2012)Google Scholar. See also “Indian Heroes of World War II,” Stó:lō Nation News, 6, no. 67 (November–December 1981): 18–19Google Scholar.

90 Christian, interview.

91 TNA, FCO 82/1069, telegram from Canadian Embassy, Oslo, to Canadian High Commission, London, 11 November 1981, forwarded to Vivien Hughes, North American Desk, FCO, n.d.; Christian, interview.

92 TNA, FCO 82/1069, Canadian High Commission telegram, “Constitution Express in Neths,” 11 November 1981.

93 Marilyn Belleau, “1981 U.B.C.I.C. Assembly,” Alkali Speaks, November 1981, 14.

94 See O'Brien, Jean, Firsting and Lasting: Writing Indigenous Peoples out of Existence in New England (Minneapolis, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Thrush, Coll, Native Seattle: Histories from the Crossing-Over Place (Seattle, 2008)Google Scholar; Thrush, Indigenous London; Culhane, Dara, “Their Spirits Live within Us: Aboriginal Women in Downtown Eastside Vancouver Emerging into Visibility,” in Keeping the Campfires Going: Native Women's Activism in Urban Communities, ed. Krouse, Susan Applegate and Howard, Heather A. (Lincoln, NE, 2009), 76–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

95 Manuel, Vera, “Concerned Aboriginal Women Return Home from Europe,” Indian World 4, no. 4 (December 1981): 10–11Google Scholar, at 10.

96 Russell, Canada's Odyssey, 382–84.

97 The January 1981 agreement would later form the basis for Section 35 of the draft constitution. Manuel, Arthur and Derrickson, Grand Chief Ronald M., Unsettling Canada: A National Wake-Up Call (Toronto, 2015), 70–71Google Scholar. See also Sanders, “Prior Claims,” 1:232–36; Sanders, Douglas, “The Indian Lobby,” in And No One Cheered: Federalism, Democracy, and the Constitution Acts, ed. Banting, Keith and Simeon, Richard (Toronto, 1983): 301–32Google Scholar, at 315–16; Woodward and George, “Canadian Indian Lobby of Westminster,” 125; Henderson, First Nations Jurisprudence, 32–33.

98 “Patriation Pact Like New-Born Babe—Pierre,” Vancouver Province, 6 November 1981.

99 See Alexander Panetta, “Pierre Trudeau, Ivanka Trump, and How the White House Meeting Got Set Up,” 14 February 2017, CTV News, http://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/pierre-trudeau-ivanka-trump-and-how-the-white-house-meeting-got-set-up-1.3284298.

100 See, for example, TNA, FCO 82/1069, Willen Bijleveld et al. to Lord Carrington, n.d.[ca. November 1982].

101 TNA, FCO 82/1069, Jubal T. Mason to Margaret Thatcher, n.d., received 29 October 1981.

102 Richard Luce, Answers to Written Questions, House of Commons, 1 April 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 21, col. 165W. Presumably some of these correspondents wrote in favor of patriation.

103 Bruce George, Speech to the House of Commons, 8 March 1982, Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 6th series, vol. 19, col. 667–68.

104 TNA, FCO 82/1069, Martin Berthoud, “Canadian Indians,” 12 November 1981.

105 TNA, FCO 82/1056, Pierre Trudeau, quoted in “Transcript of the Prime Minister's News Conference in the National Press Theatre, Ottawa,” 18 November 1981.

106 “Native Leaders Are Disgusted by Amendments,” Vancouver Province, 6 November 1981.

107 TNA, FCO 82/1069, “Canada: Patriation and the Indians,” n.d. [ca. November 1981]. For the unified Indigenous front in Canada, see Sheppard and Valpy, National Deal, 307; Renee Ne-Geah-Ga Taylor, “Rights Abrogated,” Tse’-Ka-Lum 2 (December 1981): 1–2, at 2.

108 Mark Wolfson, Speech to the House of Commons, 17 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, cols. 359–60.

109 “Churchill Enjoys a Pow-Wow,” Daily Mirror (UK), 7 December 1981.

110 TNA, FCO 82/1069, Patrick Madahbee to Robert Banks MP, 6 November 1981.

111 Unnamed member of the House of Lords, quoted in Mandell and Pinder, “Tracking Justice,” 191.

112 Terry Waite to Edward Scott, archbishop of Canada, 16 November 1981, Runcie/ACP/1981/4, doc. no. 12, Robert Runcie papers, Lambeth Palace Library.

113 Lockhart, “Indians Take Gift to Queen,” Vancouver Sun, 19 November 1981.

114 Mandell, Louise, “The Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs Fights Patriation,” Socialist Studies/Etudes Socialistes: A Canadian Annual, no. 2 (1984): 164–95Google Scholar, at 182. For the ban on potlatch, see Cole, Douglas and Chaikin, Ira, An Iron Hand upon the People: The Law against Potlatch on the Northwest Coast (Seattle, 1990)Google Scholar; Loo, Tina, “Dan Cranmer's Potlatch: Law as Coercion, Symbol, and Rhetoric in British Columbia, 1884–1951” Canadian Historical Review 73, no. 2 (1992): 125–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Carlson, Keith Thor, The Power of Place, the Problem of Time: Aboriginal Identity and Historical Consciousness in the Cauldron of Colonialism (Toronto, 2010)Google Scholar, chap. 7.

115 “Native Hopes Fading,” Vancouver Province, 17 November 1981; “Indian Anger Costs PM Charm,” Calgary Herald, 17 November 1981. The chiefs performed this same ceremony on the campus of the University of British Columbia the following week. Glen Sanford, “Indians Make Stand in UBC Museum,” Ubyssey, 20 November 1981.

116 Mandell and Pinder, “Tracking Justice,” 192.

117 Christian, interview.

118 Louise Mandell, interview by Vicki Lynn George, Vancouver, 6 March 2006, “Constitution Express—A Multimedia History,” https://archive.org/details/ConstitutionExpress-AMultimediaHistory-LouiseMandell.

119 TNA, FCO 82/1069, John James, Truro Peace Pipe Lodge, to John Nott, 2 November 1981. See also Paul Yockney, “AFC Bonanza: The Peace Pipe Lodge,” 30 July 1983, Azook Community Interest Company, http://cornishmemory.com/item/YOCN_5_635.

120 Wayne Christian, interview by Vicki Lynne George, Vancouver, 1 February 2006, “Constitution Express—A Multimedia History,” https://archive.org/details/ConstitutionExpress-AMultimediaHistory-WayneChristian

121 Mandell, interview by George.

122 TNA, FCO 82/1069, J. M. Creswell to Martin Berthoud, 10 November 1981.

123 TNA, FCO 82/1073, Michael Jopling to Humphrey Atkins, 23 November 1981.

124 TNA, FCO 82/1073, Atkins to Jopling, 18 December 1981.

125 Woodward and George, “Canadian Indian Lobby of Westminster,” 133.

126 Arthur Manuel, quoted in “Proceedings (Original), Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs, 14th Annual General Assembly,” 26–28 October 1982, p. 81, Fourteenth Annual General Assembly Meeting Minutes and Resolutions Binder, UBCIC RC.

127 George Manuel, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

128 Wayne Christian, “Chiefs Council Meeting,” 10 September 1981, p. 6, 1981 Chiefs Councils Binder, UBCIC RC.

129 Christian, interview.

130 Ivor Crewe, “The Most Unpopular Prime Minister since Polls Began,” Times (London), 9 October 1981.

131 Charles Moore, Margaret Thatcher: The Authorized Biography, from Grantham to the Falklands (New York, 2013), 481.

132 Wayne Christian, “13th Annual General Assembly Meeting Minutes,” 28–30 October 1981, p. 59, Thirteenth Annual General Assembly Minutes Binder, UBCIC RC.

133 Bob Manuel, “Chiefs Council Meeting,” 10 September 1981, p. 7, 1981 Chiefs Councils Binder, UBCIC RC.

134 Beckett, Andy, We Promised You a Miracle: Why 1980–82 Made Modern Britain (London, 2015), 119–25Google Scholar.

135 Beckett, We Promised You a Miracle, 128.

136 “Mrs. Thatcher Called Britain's Most Unpopular Leader since WWII,” UPI, 19 December 1981, http://www.upi.com/Archives/1981/12/18/Mrs-Thatcher-called-Britains-most-unpopular-leader-since-WW-II/7728377499600/.

137 Christian, “13th Annual General Assembly Meeting Minutes,” 28–30 October 1981, p. 59, Thirteenth Annual General Assembly Minutes Binder, UBCIC RC.

138 Lippman, Matthew, “The Debate over a Bill of Rights in Great Britain: The View from Parliament,” Universal Human Rights 2, no. 4 (October–December 1980): 25–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 30–31.

139 UK Conservative Party, 95th Conservative Conference [booklet], 51, NVA 2/2/41, Conservative Party Archive (hereafter CPA), Bodleian Library, Oxford.

140 Francis Pym, Speech to the Conservative Party Conference, 13 October 1977, 94th Conservative Conference Blackpool 11th–14th October 1977 Verbatim Report, 120, NVA 2/1/81, CPA.

141 Michael Havers, “Bill of Rights,” 16 July 1976, LCC 1/3/12, CPA.

142 Margaret Thatcher, quoted in “The Benefits of Free Competition,” London Evening News, 25 April 1979, Margaret Thatcher Foundation, http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/104041.

143 TNA, FCO 82/1055, Lord Moran to Martin Berthoud, “The Charter of Rights and Freedoms,” 5 October 1981 (emphasis in original).

144 Enoch Powell, Speech in the House of Commons, 3 March 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 19, col. 364.

145 Enoch Powell, Speech in the House of Commons, 23 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, col. 830.

146 Margaret Thatcher, Oral Answers to Questions, House of Commons, 11 December 1979, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 975, col. 1073.

147 TNA, PREM 19/826, Willie Whitelaw to Margaret Thatcher, “Cabinet: Home and Social Affairs Committee, A Bill of Rights,” 21 May 1981.

148 TNA, PREM 19/132, Margaret Thatcher, quoted in Michael Alexander to Paul Lever, “Patriation of the Canadian Constitution,” 6 October 1980, Margaret Thatcher Foundation, http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/118158.

149 TNA, FCO 82/822, Telegram from Lord Carrington to Sir John Ford, UK High Commissioner to Canada, 28 October 1980.

150 Derek Walker Smith, Speech to the House of Commons, 17 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, col. 308.

151 Bernard Braine, Speech to the House of Commons, 23 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, col. 772.

152 Bruce George, Speech to the House of Commons, 23 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, col. 813.

153 George, Speech to the House of Commons, col. 348.

154 TNA, FCO 82/1040, Francis Pym, quoted in “Patriation of the Canadian Constitution: Note of Meeting with Canadian High Commissioner,” 23 January 1981.

155 Moore, Margaret Thatcher, 378.

156 Clive Linklater et al., “The Constitution Story,” Saskatchewan Indian, April 1982, 8.

157 Donald Steward, Speech to the House of Commons, 17 February 1982, Parliamentary Debates, 6th series, vol. 18, col. 343.

158 Linklater et al., “Constitution Story,” 8.

159 TNA, FCO 82/1069, M. A. Macleod to Margaret Thatcher, 3 November 1981.

160 “Did You See the Two Red Indians Last Sunday?,” Sunday Post (Scotland), 15 November 1981.

161 TNA, FCO 82/1069, North America Department, “Remembrance Sunday: The Cenotaph Ceremony,” n.d. [ca. 6 November 1981].

162 Red Indians was the common British term for Indigenous peoples from North America, as opposed to “Indians” from South Asia. Oxford English Dictionary Online, s.v. “Red Indian, n.”

163 “Did You See the Two Red Indians?”

164 TNA, FCO 82/1070, Chris J. Jones to Margaret Thatcher, 18 November 1981.

165 TNA, FCO 82/1070, Chris J. Jones to Margaret Thatcher, 18 November 1981.

166 Kate Williams, “Cyd-Safiad (Standing Together): The Politics of Alliance of Welsh and American Indian Rights’ Movements, 1960s–Present” (PhD diss., University of Minnesota, 2012), chap. 4.

167 Williams, “Cyd-Safiad,” 196.

168 Dafydd Williams, quoted in Williams, “Cyd-Safiad,” 199.

169 “IRA Switches Attack,” Vancouver Province, 27 October 1981.

170 Gareth Parry, “Yard's Biggest Hunt Yet to Find IRA Explosives,” Guardian (UK), 17 November 1981.

171 George Manuel, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

172 Christian, quoted in “Summarized Minutes of 6th Special General Assembly.”

173 John George, “Chiefs Council Meeting,” 10 September 1981, p. 6, 1981 Chiefs Councils Binder, UBCIC RC.

174 Christian, “Chiefs Council Meeting,” 10 September 1981, p. 6.

175 Adam, “Band Manager's Report,” 2.

176 “Bonn: Constitution Express to London via Europe,” Coyoti Prints, December 1981, 7.

177 Patrick Keatley, “Violence Warning by Chief,” Guardian (UK), 5 November 1981.

178 “Thatcher Sidesteps Issue,” Vancouver Sun, 4 November 1981, A2.

179 “Indians Study Court Action against UK,” Vancouver Province, 12 November 1981.

180 Russell, Canada's Odyssey, 301–2.

181 “Canada House Evacuated,” Vancouver Province, 28 October 1981.

182 Sanders, “Prior Claims,” 1:235.

183 “Natives Leave UBC Museum,” Kamloops News, 20 November 1981.

184 Conversation with Moya Waters, associate director, Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver, 6 April 2017.

185 George Manuel, quoted in “UBC Museum Occupied in Indian ‘War’ for Rights,” Vancouver Sun, 19 November 1981.

186 George Manuel, quoted in “Protesters Urge Indians to Fight for Their Rights,” Globe and Mail, 20 November 1981.

187 “Protesters Urge Indians.”

188 Bob Manuel, quoted in “Chief Happy with Protests,” Vancouver Sun, 25 November 1981.

189 Wayne Christian could not say for sure whether the Constitution Express had established links with IRA contacts. But he did not discount the possibility, noting that the UBCIC had discussed contacting the Gaddafi regime in Libya, a plan they quickly dropped owing to the strong opposition of Jewish staff and allies. Christian also recalled that his phone was routinely tapped by Canadian intelligence, and as a result, the leadership refrained from sharing sensitive information with him for fear of it leaking to the authorities. Christian, interview. In his 1993 biography of George Manuel, which was based on interviews with key Indigenous leaders, including the late Bob Manuel, Peter McFarlane writes that a “well-disciplined contingent from the IRA carrying banners in support of the First Nations’ cause in Canada” joined the Constitution Express on its march through Paris. Peter McFarlane, Brotherhood to Nationhood: George Manuel and the Making of the Modern Indian Movement (Toronto, 1993), 292. However, Christian did not remember this, and McFarlane was unable to substantiate the story. Personal correspondence with Peter McFarlane, 23 April 2017.

190 Editorial, Indian Voice, November/December 1981, 4.

191 Christian, interview.

192 Deb van der Gracht, “Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau Didn't Realize How Close His … ,” UPI, 24 November 1981, http://www.upi.com/Archives/1981/11/24/Prime-Minister-Pierre-Trudeau-didnt-realize-how-close-his/5184375426000/.

193 Taylor, “Rights Abrogated,” 2.

194 “Trudeau Takes Tough Line over Rights Lies Challenge,” Vancouver Sun, 23 November 1981.

195 Christian, interview.

196 “Aboriginal Rights Reinstated,” Vancouver Province, 27 November 1981. See also Henderson, First Nations Jurisprudence, 33.

197 Section 35 quoted in Erin Hanson, “Constitution Act, 1982, Section 35,” Indigenous Foundations, University of British Columbia, http://Indigenousfoundations.arts.ubc.ca/constitution_act_1982_section_35/.

198 See Ardith Walkem and Halie Bruce, eds., Box of Treasures or Empty Box? Twenty Years of Section 35 (Penticton, 2003).

199 Woodward and George, “Canadian Indian Lobby of Westminster,” 129; Henderson, First Nations Jurisprudence, 34. Denning was forced to retire later in 1982 after publishing libelous comments about the inability of black jurors to be impartial. Like other British political grandees, his sympathetic role in the Indigenous constitutional drama might best be ascribed to colonial paternalism. Alan Rusbridger, “Lord Denning Sets Date for Retirement,” Guardian (UK), 29 May 1982; David Leigh, “Denning Will Apologize,” Observer (UK), 30 May 1982.

200 Mandell and Pinder, “Tracking Justice,” 194.

201 TNA, FCO 82/1156, Louise Mandell to Margaret Thatcher, 29 January 1982.

202 Mandell and Pinder, “Tracking Justice,” 196.

203 Lord Morris, Speech to the House of Lords, 25 March 1982, Parliamentary Debates, vol. 428, col. 1073. See also William Hickey, “The Ermine Flies in the Lords … ,” Daily Express, 31 March 1982, 15.

204 See Henderson, First Nations Jurisprudence.

205 See Manuel and Derrickson, Unsettling Canada; Coulthard, Red Skin, White Masks; Simpson, Mohawk Interruptus.