Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-v5vhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-28T18:56:48.217Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Effect of Southern State Bond Repudiation and British Debt Collection Efforts on Anglo-American Relations, 1840–1940

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 May 2013

V. Markham Lester
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

British officials' largely negative impression of the United States caused by America's intransigence in allowing renegotiation of Britain's First World War debts must be viewed against a backdrop of a longstanding debtor-creditor relationship between the two nations. Since the mid-nineteenth century, British creditors, largely through the efforts of the London-based Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, vigorously yet unsuccessfully attempted to collect large debts on repudiated American state bonds. This article provides greater understanding of this history and shows that the nineteenth-century debt controversy might well have been avoided to the economic benefit of the British and particularly the American South.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 2 , April 2013 , pp. 415 - 440
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Payments on the debt ceased in 1934. By June 1939, the total principal and interest on the debt totaled $5,466 million, an amount all agreed could not be paid without American concessions. Self, Robert, Britain, America and the War Debt Controversy: The Economic Diplomacy of an Unspecial Relationship, 1917–1941 (London, 2006), 15, 203CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Ibid., 213.

3 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts of the Southern States of the United States of America: Extracts from the Annual Reports of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders (London, 1925), 32Google Scholar; Howland, C. P., “Our Repudiated Debts,” Foreign Affairs 6 (April 1928): 395–407CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Glasgow News, 26 December 1874; Saturday Review, 3 March 1877. Unless otherwise stated, all newspaper articles referenced are from Council of Foreign Bondholders, The Newspaper Cuttings Files of the Council of Foreign Bondholders, United States (General) 1871–1901, 1913–1931. Financier, 21 August 1922, estimated only £585,000 ($2,925,000) of Southern state debt had been traced to Britain. There was no explanation as to how this estimate was calculated. This figure is almost certainly incorrect in light of earlier estimates and, as will be seen, in the level of concern voiced in Britain over the defaulted indebtedness.

5 Cain, P. J. and Hopkins, A. G., British Imperialism: Innovation and Expansion, 1688–1914 (London, 1993)Google Scholar.

6 Financial Times, 16 March 1920.

7 Allen, H. C., Great Britain and the United States: A History of Anglo-American Relations (1783–1952) (New York, 1955), 755Google Scholar.

8 Dorfman, Joseph, “A Note on the Interpretation of Anglo-American Finance, 1837–1841,” Journal of Economic History 11 (Spring 1951): 147CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Dunning, J. H., Studies in International Investment (London, 1970), 151 (table 2)Google Scholar.

10 Lipson, Charles, Standing Guard: Protecting Foreign Capital in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries (Berkeley, 1985), 5Google Scholar.

11 English, William B., “Understanding the Costs of Sovereign Default: American State Debts in the 1840s,” American Economic Review 86 (March 1996): 261Google Scholar.

12 Kim, Namsuk and Wallis, John Joseph, “The Market for American State Government Bonds in Britain and the United States, 1830–43,” Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 58 (November 2005): 737–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 US Constitution, amend. 14, sec. 4.

14 Jenks, Leland Hamilton, The Migration of British Capital to 1875 (New York, 1927), 73Google Scholar; Platt, D. C. M., Foreign Finance in Continental Europe and the United States, 1815–1870: Quantities, Origins, Functions and Distribution (London, 1984), 144–45Google Scholar.

15 Wilkins, Mira, The History of Foreign Investment in the United States to 1914 (Cambridge, 1989), 54, 66Google Scholar; Cottrell, P. J., British Overseas Investment in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1975), 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Cottrell, British Overseas Investment, 21.

17 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 87–88.

18 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 70, 100; McGrane, Reginald C., Foreign Bondholders and American State Debts (New York, 1935), 382–83Google Scholar.

19 Bishop, John C., “The Repudiation of State Debts, 1836–1845,” Southern Studies 3 (Summer 1992): 79Google Scholar.

20 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 99, 104.

21 Quoted in Reginald C. McGrane, Foreign Bondholders, 268.

22 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 70–71.

23 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 100; US Congress, House Report No. 296, 27th Cong., 3rd Sess., 559 (1843).

24 Bishop, “Repudiation of State Debts,” 82.

25 Michael D. Bardo, Agnieska Markiewicz, and Lars Jonung, “A Fiscal Union for the Euro: Some Lessons from History,” Working Paper 17930, National Bureau of Economic Research, September 2011, 25.

26 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 75, 77.

27 Summers, Mark W., Railroads, Reconstruction, and the Gospel of Prosperity: Aid Under the Radical Republicans, 1865–1877 (Princeton, 1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Foner, Eric, Reconstruction: America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863–1877 (New York, 1988), 379–82Google Scholar.

28 Summers, Railroads, 202; Ratchford, B. U., American State Debts (Durham, 1941), 174Google Scholar.

29 Moore, James T., “Redeemers Reconsidered: Change and Continuity in the Democratic South, 1870–1900,” Journal of Southern History 44 (August 1978): 370Google Scholar.

30 C. P. Howland, “Our Repudiated Debts,” 395; Ratchford, American State Debts, 178.

31 Dunning, Studies, 147.

32 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 282; Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 112–13.

33 Anglo-American Times, 11 April 1876.

34 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 79.

35 McGrane, Foreign Bondholders, 282.

36 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 112, table 4.6.

37 17th Annual circular of Thomas Denny & Co., New York, January 1874, 26–37, Council of Foreign Bondholders, The Newspaper Clippings Files of the Council of Foreign Bondholders, United States (General), 1871–1901, 1913–1931, 1:26–37.

38 Raymond, William L., American and Foreign Investment Bonds (Boston, 1916), 137–38Google Scholar.

39 Report of the Treasurer of the State of Alabama for the Fiscal Year Ending 30 Sept. 1874 (Montgomery, 1874), 61.

40 Report of the Treasurer of the State of Alabama to the Governor for the years 1866 –7, 1867–8, 1868–9, Ending 30 Sept. 1869 (Montgomery, 1869), 113.

41 Bond, Horace Mann, “Social and Economic Forces in Alabama Reconstruction,” Journal of Negro History 23 (1938): 341CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Fleming, Walter L., Civil War and Reconstruction in Alabama (New York, 1905), 583Google Scholar.

43 Bond administration files (1862–1919), SG 8096, Alabama Department of Archives and History (hereafter ADAH).

44 Ibid., claim no. 96.

45 Ibid., claim no. 72.

46 Davis, Lance E. and Huttenback, Robert A., Mammon and the Pursuit of Empire: The Political Economy of British Imperialism, 1860–1912(Cambridge, 1986)Google Scholar; Cain and Hopkins, British Imperialism.

47 Ibid., 200.

48 Fleming, Civil War and Reconstruction, 584.

49 Bond, “Social and Economic Forces,” 341.

50 Report of the State Auditor of Alabama for the Fiscal year Ending 30 Sept. 1876 (Montgomery, 1877), 5.

51 McGrane, Foreign Bondholders, 282–381, provides an excellent summary of each individual Southern state's bond issuance and repudiation.

52 Anglo-American Times, 20 March 1875.

53 Bacon, Nathanial T., “American International Indebtedness,” Yale Review 9 (1900): 265–85, 268Google Scholar; Ratchford, B. U., American State Debts (Durham, 1941), 192Google Scholar.

54 Winkler, Max, Foreign Bonds, An Autopsy: A Study of Defaults and Repudiations of Government Obligations (Philadelphia, 1933), 203Google Scholar.

55 Quoted in Borchard, Edwin M., State Insolvency and Foreign Bondholders: Volume 1, General Principles (New Haven, 1951), 203Google Scholar.

56 Jenks, Migration of British Capital, 286, 288; Platt, D. C. M., Finance, Trade, and Politics in British Foreign Policy, 1815–1914 (Oxford, 1968), 53Google Scholar.

57 Quoted in McGrane, Reginald C., “Some Aspects of American State Debts in the Forties,” American Historical Review 38 (July 1933): 682CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

58 Behr, A., “Isidor Gerstenberg (1821–76): Founder of the Council of Foreign Bondholders,” Transactions, Jewish Historical Society of England 17 (1953 for 1951–52): 207Google Scholar.

59 Borchard, State Insolvency, 206–7.

60 Platt, Finanace, Trade, and Politics, 51.

61 The Daily Recorder, 3 June 1874.

62 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, English Committee of Alabama 8 Per Cent Gold State Bonds of 1870, The Hill Country of Alabama, U.S.A.; or the Land of Rest (London, 1878) quoted in The Times, 23 June 1876.

63 Circular of Henry Clews & Co., Wall Street, New York, June 25, 1873, Council of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, The Newspaper Cuttings Files of the Council of Foreign Bondholders, United States (General) 1871–1901, 1:13.

64 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investment, 578.

65 Ratchford, “The North Carolina Public Debt,” North Carolina Historical Review 10 (January 1933): 15Google Scholar.

66 Saturday Review, 3 March 1877.

67 Standard, 8 July 1876.

68 Money Market Review, 7 July 1883.

69 Quoted in Borchard, State Insolvency, 6.

70 For an excellent summary of the development of American law regarding bondholders' cases against repudiating states, see Orth, John V., The Judicial Power of the United States: The Eleventh Amendment in American History (New York, 1987)Google Scholar.

71 “The Judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States by Citizens of another State, or by Citizens or Subjects of any Foreign State.” US Constitution, amend. 11.

72 Board of Liquidation v. McComb, 92 U.S. 531 (1876).

73 Louisiana ex rel. Elliot v. Jumel, 107 U.S. 711 (1882).

74 McGahey v. Virginia 135 U.S. 662 (1890); see also Poindexter v. Greenhow, 114 U.S. 269 (1885).

75 North Dakota v. North Carolina, 192 U.S. 286 (1904).

76 Orth, Judicial Power, 84.

77 Raymond, W. L., State and Municipal Bonds (Boston, 1923), 12–13Google Scholar.

78 Council of Foreign Bondholders, The International Aspect of the Debts of the State of Mississippi Repudiated Before the Civil War, (London, 1931), 6.

79 US Congress, Arbitration treaty with Great Britain, 58th Cong. 3rd sess., S. Doc. 161, 26.

80 US Congress, Report of the Committee on Foreign Relations . . . general arbitration treaties with Great Britain and France . . ., 62nd Cong., 2nd sess., S. Doc. 98, 29.

81 The Times, 1 November 1880; Money, 13 June 1883.

82 Hyde Clarke to the Commission, 25 March 1875, Bond administration files, SG 8096, ADAH.

83 Hyde Clarke to the Commission, 8 May 1875, Bond administration files, SG 8096, ADAH.

84 James Spear to Commission, January, 1876, Bond administration files, SG 8096, ADAH.

85 Duncan Sherman & Co. to Governor David P. Lewis, 7 April 1883, Bond administration files, SG 8096, ADAH.

86 Morgan, Victor E. and Thomas, W. A., The Stock Exchange: Its History and Functions (London, 1962), 93Google Scholar.

87 McGrane, Foreign Bondholders, 302.

88 “The Honour of Mississippi” (pamphlet signed by Financial Times), Council of Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, The Newspaper Cuttings Files of the Council of Foreign Bondholders, Untied States (General) 1871–1901, 1913–1931, 10:54.

89 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts of the Southern States of the United States: Extracts from the Annual Reports of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders (London, 1925), 12.

90 Ibid., 19.

91 Borchard, State Insolvency, xxiv.

92 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts, 18.

93 Financial Times, 4 April 1913.

94 Daily Dispatch, 2 April 1913; Financial Times, 22 April 1913.

95 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts, 20.

96 Quoted in Daily Telegraph, 21 May 1914.

97 The Times, 5 May 1921.

98 Self, Britain, America and the War Debt Controversy, 15, 18.

99 James Cooper to Marcus H. Burnstein, 26 August 1919, Correspondence of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, USA, Correspondence out letters, item 3 (1919–1926), MS 34806, Guildhall Library.

100 James Cooper to T. Oldroyd, 8 August 1922, Correspondence of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Correspondence out letters, item 3 (1919–1926), MS 34806, Guildhall Library.

101 Morning Post, 3 May 1921.

102 Daily Express, 16 March 1922.

103 John Bull, 26 March 1921.

104 James Cooper to Maj. Gen. F. Lorn Campbell, 11 July 1923, Correspondence of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Correspondence out letters, item 3 (1919–1926), MS 34806, Guildhall Library.

105 James Cooper to Marcus H. Burnstine, 23 April 1923, Correspondence out letters, item 3 (1919–1926), MS 34806, Guildhall Library.

106 Turner, Raymond, “Repudiation of Debts by States of the Union,” Current History (January 1926): 475–83Google Scholar.

107 Financial News, 23 September 1926.

108 de Roulhac Hamilton, J. G., “Those Southern Repudiated Bonds,” Virginia Quarterly Review 3 (1927): 501, 504–05Google Scholar.

109 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts, 30.

110 The Times, 24 April 1926; Minutes of the Council of Foreign Bondholders, vol. 7 (1917–1929), MS15749, Guildhall Library (hereafter cited as CFB Minutes 1917–1929), April 29, 1926, 242–43.

111 Financial Times, 26 September 1926.

112 Minutes of Council of Foreign Bondholders, vol. 8 (1929–1938), MS15749, Guildhall Library (hereafter cited as CFB Minutes 1929–1938), 30 April 1932, 66–67.

113 Ibid., 30 October 1930, 48.

114 Daily Express, 23 May 1928; Chicago Daily Tribune, 15 February 1928.

115 Ernest F. Barry to D. Reid, 2 December 1930, Correspondence of the Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, file 3 (1930–1931), MS 34818, Guildhall Library (hereafter cited as CFB Correspondence 1930–1931).

116 Howland, “Our Repudiated Debts.”

117 CFB Minutes 1917–1929, 25 October 1928, 321–22.

118 Ibid.

119 A. W. Wallace to Ernest F. Barry, 23 December 1930, CFB Correspondence (1930–1931).

120 Ernest F. Barry to D. Reid, 1 January 1930, CFB Correspondence (1930–1931).

121 The Times, 24 March 1930.

122 Council of Foreign Bondholders, The Federal Aspect of the Debts of the State of Mississippi Repudiated Before the Civil War (London, 1930), 7.

123 Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 5th series, vol. 76 (1930), cols. 862–66.

124 Morning Post (London), 15 March 1930.

125 Council of Foreign Bondholders, Federal Aspect, 1–2.

126 Ernest F. Barry to George James, United States Treasury, 20 August 1930, CFB Correspondence 1930–1931.

127 Ernest F. Barry to D. Reed, 1 July 1930, CFB Correspondence 1930–1931.

128 Ernest F. Barry to D. Reid, 15 July 1930, CFB Correspondence 1930–1931.

129 Ernest F. Barry to D. Reid, 9 December 1930, CFB Correspondence 1930–1931.

130 Parliamentary Debates, 5th ser., vol. 261 (1932), cols. 1025–26.

131 Parliamentary Debates, 5th ser., vol. 278 (1933), col. 30.

132 Council of Foreign Bondholders, International Aspect of the Debts, 3.

133 CFB Minutes 1929–1938, 24 April 1930, 26–27.

134 Ibid.

135 Corporation of Foreign Bondholders, Defaulted Debts, 3.

136 CFB Minutes 1917–1929, 25 April 1917, 11–12.

137 Financial Times, 12 April 1928; CFB Minutes 1917–1929, 26 July 1928, 309–10.

138 Republic of Cuba v. State of North Carolina, 242 U.S. 665 (1917).

139 Ratchford, American State Debts, 240; Orth, Judicial Power, 86.

140 CFB Minutes 1917–1929, 26 April 1928, 297–98.

141 CFB Minutes 1929–1938, 31 October 1929, 16.

142 CFB Minutes 1929–1938, 21 July 1932, 104.

143 Ibid.

144 Principality of Monaco v. State of Mississippi, 292 U.S. 313 (1933).

145 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investments, 137, 187.

146 The National Emergency Council, Report on Economic Conditions of the South (Washington, 1938), 52.

147 Wilkins, History of Foreign Investments, 156, 618.

148 Ratchford, B. U.. “Public Debts in the South,” Southern Economic Journal 2 (January 1936): 15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

149 Platt, Finance, Trade, and Politics, 41.

150 McGrane, Foreign Bondholders, 384. Even as late as 1939, the defaulted bonds were still mentioned in works concerning debts and foreign policy. See Gantenbein, James W., Financial Questions in United States Foreign Policy (New York, 1939)Google Scholar.

151 Dutton, David, Neville Chamberlain (London, 2001), 166Google Scholar.

152 Self, Robert, Neville Chamberlain: A Biography (Aldershot, 2006), 190Google Scholar.