Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-m9kch Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-17T13:20:10.427Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Policy Issues Regarding the Japanese Economy – the Great Recession, Inequality, Budget Deficit and the Aging Population

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 May 2012

YUTAKA HARADA
YUTAKA HARADA*
Affiliation:
Professor, Waseda Universityyutaka.harada@aoni.waseda.jp
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

During 1980–90, Japan's annual real GDP growth rate was 4.6%, but which declined to 1.2% in the 1990s. While the drop in itself is a problem, at the same time it exacerbated many other problems, namely inequality, budget deficits, and the increasing burden of an aging society.

Society is not concerned about income distribution when the economy is growing, but begins to worry about inequality when an economic slump shows no signs of ending. Moreover, prolonged recession magnifies inequality. With the employment situation surrounding young people worsening, there arose an inequality between those finding jobs and those unemployed. And, the prolonged recession led to a huge budget deficit and the accumulation of government debt. Tax revenue shrank, and the government repeatedly increased public investment in the form of economic stimulus measures, but the Japanese economy did not recover in a sustained fashion.

Japan's low growth has already continued for 20 years. Incomes of the younger and middle-aged segments of the population have not increased. Additionally, Japan is an aging society. The aged need pensions, and medical treatment and care, costs which must be borne by younger and middle-aged segments of the population, in fact those who have not experienced Japan's prosperous times.

This paper discusses issues relating to the Great Recession, inequality, and the budget deficit and burden of an aging population.

Japan's Great Recession is basically explained by monetary shocks. Just the bubble and its bursting are not solely responsible for the prolonged slump. There is no empirical evidence for the assertion that certain structural problems lessened the efficiency of the Japanese economy in the 1990s. TFP (total factor productivity) in the 1990s did not decline compared with the early 1980s. Fiscal policy and the diminution of the financial intermediary function can only explain the Great Recession in small part.

The absence of any real monetary policy hampered economic growth through the channels of stock prices and improvement in bank balance sheets. Using vector autoregressive models, the exchange rate was not found to be an important channel of monetary policy, but there is some evidence that it significantly affected output.

On inequality problems, that among younger generations is important since it will increase inequality in the future. Japan's economy will stagnate for a long time if the young are not employed and cannot garner skills.

Another important point is that the way of maintaining social stability and alleviating inequality in Japan is extremely inefficient. To construct useless dams, roads, ports, and airports is extremely costly just to give jobs to the unemployed. It would be much better to give direct assistance to those in need.

There is some reason to think that a budget deficit is not so serious a problem as generally believed, and that the important thing is to cut wasteful government expenditure and not raise government revenue. While I admit this argument carries some weight, there is nevertheless good reason to think that it is necessary to reduce the budget deficit.

Before the global financial crisis, Japan's budget deficit was controlled, and declining, but subsequently became uncontrollable. Additionally, and more importantly, an aging population demands more social security expenditure, which causes serious budget problems, but Japan does not seem ready to cope with such problems.

The selection of these topics is subjective, but I believe that these are reflected in the Japanese concerns now. Japanese academic circles do not necessarily respond to the interests of the society, but I have tried to select papers on these topics to the extent possible.

Type
Research Article
Information
Japanese Journal of Political Science , Volume 13 , Special Issue 2: Japanese Studies in Japan and its Vicinities: Economics and Sociology , June 2012 , pp. 223 - 253
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Harada, Yutaka, Nihon no Ushinawareta 10 Nen (Japan's Lost Decade), Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha, 1999Google Scholar

2 This section partly comes from Iida, Yasuyuki and Yutaka Harada, ‘Japan's Great Stagnation: An Interpretation using Vector Autoregression Models’, submitted to ESRI International Workshop ‘Beginning of the New Growth’ in Tokyo, 3 September 2004.

3 Low interest rates in the Great Recession occasioned theoretical interest among many economists as to how to make monetary policy effective, and produced many studies such as Krugman, P., ‘It's Baaack: Japan's Slump and the Return of the Liquidity Trap’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, No. 2: 137–205, 1988; Svensson, Lars E. O. ‘Escaping from a Liquidity Trap and Deflation: The Foolproof Way and Others’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 17 (4): 145–66, 2003CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Bernanke, B. S. and Reinhart, V. R., ‘Conducting Monetary Policy at Very Low Short-term Interest Rates’, American Economic Review, 94 (2): 85–90, 2004CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Moreover, the Great Recession occasioned interest in the Great Depression of the 1930s – Japanese economists compared both, trying to find lessons applicable to the current situation from the Great Depression (called Showa Kyoukou [Showa Depression] in Japan). This paper does not cover these studies. Refer to Ito, T. and H. Mishkin, ‘Two Decades of Japanese Monetary and the Deflation Problem’, NBER Working Paper, No. 10878, 2004, regarding the former topic; Iwata, Kikuo (ed.), Shouwa Kyoukou no Kenkyuu (Studies on the Shouwa Depression), Toyo Keizai Shinpousha, 2003Google Scholar; and Iwata, Kikuo, Okada, Yasushi, Adachi, Seiji, and Iida, Yasuyuki, ‘Lessons from the Inoue Zaisei and the Takahashi Zaisei’, Keizai Ronshuu (Gakushuin University) (Gakushuin Economic Paper), 45 (3) (No. 139), August 2008Google Scholar.

4 See Callen, Tim and Ostry, Jonathan, Japan's Lost Decade: Policies for Economic Revival, International Monetary Fund, 2003Google Scholar; Iwata, Kikuo and Miyagawa, Tutomu (eds.), Ushinawareta 10 nen no Shin-in ha Nanika (What Really Caused the ‘Lost Decade’?), Toyo Keizai Shinpousha, 2003Google Scholar; Harada, Yutaka and Iwata, Kikuo (eds.), Defure Fukyou no Jisshou Bunseki (Empirical Analysis of Deflation-Depression), Toyoukeizai Shinpousha, 2002Google Scholar; Hamada, Koichi and Horiuchi, Akiyoshi (eds.), Ronsou Nihon Keizai no Kiki (Debates on the Crisis of the Japanese Economy), Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha, 2004Google Scholar; Saxonhouse, Gary and Stern, Robert (eds.), Japan's Lost Decade Origins, Consequences and Prospects for Recovery, Blackwell, 2004Google Scholar.

5 Reinhart, C. and Rogoff, K., This Time is Different, Princeton University Press, 2009, Chapter VGoogle Scholar

6 Hayashi, F. and Prescott, E. C., ‘The 1990s in Japan: A Lost Decade’, Review of Economic Dynamics, 5: 206–35, 2002CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Inui, Tomohiko and Hyeog Ug Kwen, ‘Survey: Did the TFP Growth Rate in Japan Decline in the 1990s?’, ESRI Discussion Paper, No. 115, Economic and Social Research Institute, Cabinet Office; and Kwan, K. and Fukao, K. ‘Usinawareta 10 Nen ni TFP Joshoritu wa naze Teitai sitaka?’ (Why did increase rate in TFP decline in the lost decade?), in Hayashi, F. (ed.), Keizai Teitai no Genin to Seido (Reasons behind Economic Stagnation and Systems), Keiso Shobo, 2007Google Scholar.

8 Some argue that an increase in public investment and extending loans to inefficient firms are inefficiency shocks, but these cannot explain the Great Recession. This is discussed in detail in Sections 1.4 and 1.5.

9 This figure was originally used by Dr. Barry Bosworth of the Brookings Institution and by Professor Dale W. Jorgenson at the International Forum, organized by the Economic and Social Research Institute, Japan, 17–19 February 2003.

10 Inui and Kwan, ‘Survey’ and Kwan and Fukao, ‘Why did increase rate in TFP decline in the lost decade?’.

11 Motohashi, Kazuyuki, ‘Nihon Keizai no Jouhouka to Seisannsei ni Kansuru Beikoku tono Hikaku Bunseki’ (Information Orientation and Productivity of the Japanese Economy: A Comparative Analysis with the US), RIETI Discussion Paper Series 02-J-018, 2002.

12 Nakajima, Takanobu, Soukyu Kasuya, Tomomi Saida, and Tomoki Tanemura, ‘Sekutaa Betsu Seisansei Henka no Bunseki to Kouzou Henka no Kenshou’ (Analysis of Productivity Change by Industrial Sector and Evidence of Structural Change), Working Paper Series, Bank of Japan, January 2001

13 Fukao, K, T. Inui, H. Kawai, and T. Miyagawa ‘Sectoral Productivity and Economic Growth in Japan, 1970–98: An Empirical Analysis Based on JIP Database’, ESRI Discussion Paper, No. 68, 2003.

14 Jorgenson, D. W. and Motohashi, K., ‘Information Technology and the Japanese Economy’, Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 19: 460–81, 2005CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Kawamoto, Takuji, ‘What Do the Purified Solow Residuals Tell Us about Japan's Lost Decade?’, Bank of Japan IMES Discussion Paper Series, no.2004-E-5, Bank of Japan, Tokyo, 2004.

16 Miyagawa, Tsutomu, ‘“Ushinawareta 10 nen” to Sangyou Kouzou no Tenkan’ (The Lost Decade and Transformation of Industrial Structure), in Iwata and Miyagawa (eds.) What Really Caused the ‘Lost Decade’?

17 Miyagawa, Tsutomu, ‘Seisansei no Keizaigaku’ (Economics of Productivity), Bank of Japan Working Paper Series, No. 06-J-06, March 2006.

18 The difference between Miyagawa, ‘The Lost Decade’ and Miyagawa ‘Economics of Productivity’, does not seem important, and can be explained by difference in capital utilization adjustment methods and slight differences in estimation periods.

19 Kalra, Sanjay, ‘Fiscal Policy: An Evaluation of Its Effectiveness’, in Callen and Ostry, Japans Lost Decade.

20 Ihori, Toshihiro, Toru Nakazato, and Masumi Kawade, ‘Japan's Fiscal Policies in the 1990s’, in Saxonhouse and Stern, Japan's Lost Decade Origins.

21 Kuttner, Ken and Adam Posen, ‘The Great Recession: Lessons for Macroeconomic Policy from Japan’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, No. 2, pp. 93–185, 2001.

22 For example, Yanba, Y. ‘Tyouki Teitaiki ni okeru Zaisei Seisaku no Koka ni tsuite’ (On the effect of fiscal policy in the period of long stagnation), in Hamada and Horiuchi, Debates on the Crisis of the Japanese Economy.

23 Matsuoka, M. ‘Daremo Shiteki shinai Ito sezaru Kinyu Hikishime’ (Unintended monetary contraction that nobody points out), The Daiyamondo, 8 July 2000.

24 Kameda, K., ‘Nihon ni okeru hi keinzu koka no hassei kanosei’ (Possibility of Occurrence of ‘Non-Keynesian effect’ in Japan), in Ihori, T. ed. Zaisei Seisaku to Shakai Hosho (Fiscal Policy and Social Security), University of Keio Press, 2009Google Scholar.

25 Private capital stock and fixed assets of general government, System of National Accounts, Cabinet Office. Private capital stock at 2000 prices, fixed assets of general government at nominal figures, but this rough calculation does not produce any significant difference.

26 Assuming an ordinary Cobb–Douglas function, GDP = AL0.7K0.3, GDP decreases by 2.2% (1–(1–0.066)0.3 = 0) because of a decline of 6.6% (= 89/1346) in K.

27 Miyao, Ryuzou, ‘Ginko Kino no Teika to 90 Nendai Iko no Defure Teitai’ (Declining function of banks and deflationary stagnation since 1990s), in Hamada and Horiuchi, Debates on the Crisis of the Japanese Economy.

28 Woo, D. ‘In search of capital crunch: supply factors behind the credit slowdown in Japan’, IMF Working Paper 99/3, 1999.

29 Horie, Y. ‘Waga Kuni no ‘Kashi Shiburi’ Bunseki’ (Analysis of Japan's Credit Crunch), Keizaigaku Kenkyu, 65 (6): 1–31, University of Kyushu, 1999Google Scholar.

30 Fukao, Mitsuhiro and Japan Center for Economic Research, Kinyu Fukyo no Jisshou Bunseki (Empirical Analysis of Depression), Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha, 2000Google Scholar.

31 Sakuragawa, M.Kinyu Kiki no Keizai Bunseki (Economic Analysis on Financial Crisis), The University of Tokyo Press, 2002Google Scholar.

32 Kobayashi, K., T. Saida, and T. Sekine ‘Iwayuru “Oigashi’ ni tsuite”’ (On so-called ‘Extending Loans to Non Profitable Firms’), Working Paper 02–02, Bureau of Research and Statistics, Bank of Japan, 2002.

33 Sugihara, S. and Fueda, I. ‘Furyo Saiken to Oigashi’ (Non-Performing Debts and Extending Loans to Non-Profitable Firms), Nihon Keizai Kenkyu (Studies on the Japanese Economy), 44: 63–87, 2002Google Scholar.

34 Sugihara, S. and T. Ota, ‘Shisan Kakaku no Geraku to Kigyo no Baransu Shiito Chosei’ (Decline in Asset Prices and Adjustment of Balance Sheets of Firms), in Harada and Iwata, Empirical Analysis of Deflation-Depression.

35 Hosono, K. and M. Sakuragawa, ‘Soft Budget Problems in the Japanese Credit Market’, Nagoya City University Discussion Paper Series in Economics 345, 2003.

36 Assuming an ordinary Cobb–Douglas function, GDP = AL0.7K0.3, GDP decreases by 0.8% (1–(1–0.025)0.3 = 0) because of a decline of 2.5% (= 33/1346) in K.

37 Bayoumi, Tamin, ‘The Morning After: Explaining the Slowdown in Japanese Growth in the 1990s’, Journal of International Economics, 53: 241–59, 2001CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Miyao, Ryuzou, ‘The Effects of Monetary Policy in Japan’, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 34 (2), 2002CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

39 Nakazawa, Masahiko, Onishi, Shigeki, and Harada, Yutaka, ‘Zaisei Kinyuu Seisaku no Koka’ (Effect of Fiscal and Monetary Policies), Financial Review (Journal in Japanese), Fiscal Policy Institute of Ministry of Finance, No. 66, December 2002Google Scholar.

40 Baig, Tamiur, ‘Monetary policy in a deflationary Environment’, in Callen and Ostry, Japans Lost Decade.

41 Iida and Harada, ‘Japan's Great Stagnation’.

42 Miyao, Ryuzou, ‘The Effects of Monetary Policy in Japan,’ Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 34, No. 2, May 2002CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

43 Nakazawa, Masahiko, Onishi, Shigeki, and Harada, Yutaka, ‘Zaisei Kinyuu Seisaku no Koka (Effect of Fiscal and Monetary Policies),’ Financial Review (journal in Japanese), Fiscal Policy Institute of Ministry of Finance, No. 66, December 2002Google Scholar.

44 Baig, Tamiur, ‘Monetary policy in a deflationary Environment,’ in Callen, Tim and Ostry, Jonathan, Japan's Lost Decade: Policies for Economic Revival, International Monetary Fund, 2003Google Scholar.

45 Hori, M. ‘Ajia no Htten to Nihon Keizai’ (Development of Asian and Japanese Economies), in Fukao, K. (ed.), Makuro Keizai to Sangyo Kozo (Macroeconomy and Industrial Structure), University of Keio Press, 2009Google Scholar.

46 Kobayashi, Ken-ichiro and Inada, Masaru, ‘Business Cycle Accounting for the Japanese Economy’, Japan and the World Economy, 18 (4), 2006CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47 Fukuda, Shin-ichi and Owen, Robert, ‘Human Capital and Economic Growth: Dynamic Implications of Insider–Outsider Problem for Macroeconomics’, Public Policy Review, 4(1), Policy Research Institute, Ministry of Finance, Japan, 2008Google Scholar

48 Kimura, T., H. Kobayashi, J. Muranaga, and H. Ugai (2002), ‘Effect of Increase in Monetary Base on Japan's Economy at Zero Interest Rates: An Empirical Analysis’, Bank of Japan, IMES Discussion Paper Series, No. 2002-E-22.

49 Fujiwara, I., ‘Evaluating Monetary Policy When Nominal Interest Rates are Almost Zero’, Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 20 (3): 434–53, 2006CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Mihira, T., N. Yamasawa, H. Seitani and J. Saito (2006), ‘Was Quantitative Easing Policy Effective? An Empirical Analysis of Monetary Policy in Japan during 2001–06’, presented at ESRI (Economic and Social Research Institute) International Conference on ‘Changes in the Japanese Economy during the So-called Lost Decade and Recovery.’

51 Honda, Y., Kuroki, Y., and Tachibana, M. (2007), ‘An Injection of Base Money at Zero Interest Rates: Empirical Evidence from the Japanese Experience 2001–06’, Discussion Papers in Economics and Business 07–08, Graduate School of Economics and Osaka School of International Public Policy (OSIPP), Osaka UniversityGoogle Scholar.

52 Harada, Yutaka and Masujima, Minoru, ‘Kinyuu no ryouteki kanwa wa dono keiro de keizai wo kaizen shitanoka’, in Yoshikawa, Hiroshi, ‘Effectiveness and Transmission Mechanisms of Japan's Quantitative Monetary Easing Policy’, The Japanese Economy, 36 (1): 2009Google Scholar.

53 Matsuoka ‘Unintended monetary contraction that nobody points out’.

54 Harada, Yutaka, Daiteitai Dakkyaku no Keizaigaku (Economics of getting rid of the Great Recession), PHP Kenkyuujo, 2004, Chapter 6, Section 2Google Scholar

55 Fukao, Mitsuhiro, ‘Japan's Lost Decade and its Financial System’, in Saxonhouse and Stern, Japan's Lost Decade Origins.

56 Tachibanaki, T., Nihon no Keizai kakusa (Economic Inequality in Japan), Iwanami Shoten, 1998Google Scholar.

57 Sato, T., Fubyoudo Shakai Nihon (Japan– Inequal Society), Chuou Koronsha, 2000Google Scholar.

58 Yamada, M., Kibo Kakusa Shakai (Inequal Society in Hope), Chikuma Shobo, 2004Google Scholar

59 Otake, F.Nihon no Fubyoudou (Inequality in Japan), Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha, 2005Google Scholar.

60 Ota, K., ‘Furita no Zouka to Rodo Shotoku Kakusa no Zodai’ (Increase in Part-Time Workers and Widening Inequality in Labor Incomes), ESRI Discussion Paper, No. 140, Economic and Social Research Institute, Cabinet Office, May 2005.

61 Ota, K, ‘Nihon no Shotoku Kakusa’ (Income Inequality in Japan), Business and Economic Review (a Journal in Japanese), The Japan Research Institute, Limited. October 2006Google Scholar.

62 OECD, Economic Survey of Japan 2006, OECD, 2006Google Scholar.

63 Ota, ‘Increase in Part-Time Workers’.

64 Honda, Y., Uchida, T., and Goto, K., Niito tte Yuna (Don't say NEET), Kobunsha, 2006Google Scholar.

65 Ota, ‘Income Inequality in Japan’, Chart 10–1.

66 Otake, Inequality in Japan, Chapter 6.

67 Yamamoto, T., ‘Impact of International Trade on Wage Inequality in Japanese Manufacturing Industries’, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Hawaii, 2004.

68 Toyoukeizai, Nihonjin no Mirai Kyuuryou (Future Salaries of Japanese), Shuukan Toyoukeizai, 6 October 2007.

69 Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare, Roudou Keizai Hakusho (White Paper on the Labor Economy) 2010, Chapter 3, Section 3.

70 Tachibanaki, T., Kakusa Shakai (Unequal Society), Iwanami Shoten, 2006, Chapter 5Google Scholar.

71 OECD, Economic Survey of Japan 2006.

72 Förster, Michael and d'Ercole, Marco Mira, ‘Income Distribution and Poverty in OECD Countries in the Second Half of the 1990s’, OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Paper 22, February 2005CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

73 This fact may have been firstly pointed out by Ota, ‘Income Inequality in Japan’, Table 4.

74 Tachibanaki, Unequal Society, p. 18

75 This problem should be formally discussed as the Barro-Ricardo Equivalence Theorem. Regarding empirical studies on the subject, refer to Hatano, Toshiya, Zaisei Akaji to Zaisei Unei no Keizai Bunseki (Economic Analysis of Budget Deficit and Fiscal Policy), Yuuhikaku, 2009, Chapters 3 and 4Google Scholar.

76 Broda, C. and Weinstein, D.E., ‘Happy News from the Dismal Science: Reassessing Japanese Fiscal Policy and Sustainability’, in Ito, Takatoshi, Patrick, Hugh, and Weinstein, David E. (eds.), Reviving Japan's Economy, The MIT Press, 2005, pp. 39–78Google Scholar.

77 Doi, Takeo, ‘Seifu Saimu no Jizoku Knosei wo Tanpo suru Kongo no Zaisei Unei no Arikata ni Kansuru Shimyureshon Bunseki’ (Simulation Analysis on Fiscal Policy Assuring Sustainability of Government Liability), RIETI Discussion Paper Series, 06-J-032.

78 Suzuki, Hitoshi and Yutaka Harada, ‘Zaisei wo ijisuru niwa Shakai Hoshou no Yokusei ga Hitsuyo’ (Restraint of social security expenditure is needed to maintain budget stability), Daiwa Institute of Research, 29 December 2010.