The Health Technology Assessment (HTA) of esthetic procedures was performed by the French National Authority for Health (HAS), at the request of the French Ministry of Health (MoH), and under a new regulatory framework enabling the government to ban esthetic procedures considered harmful or potentially harmful to patients and consumers by HAS. Objectives: Describe HAS’ seven year experience with the safety assessment of four esthetic procedures.

This is an HAS review of its methods used in four HTAs for the following evaluated techniques: lipolysis; cryolipolysis; esthetic mesotherapy; and, ultraviolet (UV) radiation in tanning devices. The review aimed to describe how these assessments have been undertaken and information sources used, from 2010 to 2017, to appreciate the safety profile of these procedures.

A systematic literature review (SRL) and analysis was performed for all four HTAs. Since findings did not allow for thorough appreciation of safety, additional sources of information were consulted to address evidence gaps. Sources may have included any combination of the following: i) National and international health care authority data and alerts ii) Legal and ethical frameworks iii) Public consultation iv) Expert opinion v) Patient-consumer association opinion vi) Economic analysis

An adaptation of the HTA methodology was necessary to meet the specific requirements of these assessments. Despite sources accumulated and consulted within the seven year period, quantitative data were found insufficient to fully appreciate the safety profile for any one of the studied esthetic procedures. National regulatory reinforcement on the reporting of adverse events, with implementation of a centralized online tool, is expected to generate and capture reliable data on the frequency and severity of adverse events associated with esthetic procedures. Recent European Union (EU) regulatory requirements on the safety and performance of medical devices include equipment used for esthetic procedures, indicating agreement and alignment on national and EU-level monitoring efforts.