Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-g78kv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-25T18:43:45.528Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Between Death and Judgment: Conflicting Images of the Afterlife in Late Seventeenth-Century English Eulogies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 June 2011

William M. Spellman
William M. Spellman
Affiliation:
University of North Carolina at Asheville
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

One of the more troublesome issues facing Protestant reformers after the abolition of the Roman Catholic purgatory in the early sixteenth century was the need to explain the status of body and soul in the interim between death and resurrection. Eager to identify the precise destination of the whole person after bodily expiration but before the general judgment, preachers sought to bring comfort to bereaved survivors of the recently departed by formulating an acceptable counterpoise to the centuries-old Roman Catholic geography of the other world. Unlike the authors of learned theological treatises on the nature of the soul and body, eulogists faced the unenviable task of interpreting the experience of death and its sequel to an audience that often lacked the sophistication required for the rigors of sustained exegesis. The task of the eulogist was to attempt to make plain the contours of postmortem existence in a manner designed both to warn and to reassure. In their efforts to define an emotionally satisfying alternative to the Roman Catholic story, however, English Protestants formulated an increasingly wide variety of disparate—and sometimes contradictory—accounts of life after death, each of which was normatively based upon a personal understanding of scripture. By the late seventeenth century, even as English funeral sermons that treated the afterlife began to reflect a broad consensus regarding the separate destinations of body and soul, there remained much confusion over the precise condition of those eternal partners before Christ's promised return. The failure to resolve this dilemma in a satisfactory manner and the inability to arrive at an acceptable consensus on a matter of central concern to believing Christians contributed to the growth of mortalist and annihilationist theories by the close of the century. Conceptual disarray within the orthodox camp, then, provided an opportunity for more innovative thinkers to step forward, persons whose understanding of eschatological time, anchored in their own unique interpretation of the Christian scriptures, negated any need for continued debate about a putative “middle place”.

Type
Research Article
Information
Harvard Theological Review , Volume 87 , Issue 1 , January 1994 , pp. 49 - 65
Copyright
Copyright © President and Fellows of Harvard College 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Goff, Jacques Le (The Birth of Purgatory [Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1980])Google Scholar places the international birth of purgatory within the Roman Catholic church in the late twelfth century. Anticipation of the doctrine, of course, can be found much earlier, particularly in the thought of Augustine (354–430) and Pope Gregory I (pontificate 590–604).

2 The most common proof texts against purgatory and postmortem penance were Eccl 9:10 and John 9:4. See, for example, Wroe, Richard, A Sermon at the Funeral of the Right Honorable Henry, Earl of Warrington (London: n.p., 1694) 14–16.Google Scholar

3 Westminster Confession of Faith (1646) chap. 32; quoted in Leith, John H., ed., Creeds of the Churches (Atlanta: Knox, 1977) 228.Google Scholar

4 See, for example, Ryther, John, A Funeral Sermon Occasioned by the Death of… James Janeway (London: n.p., 1674) 12–15Google Scholar; Taylor, Nathanael, A Funeral Sermon Occasioned by the Sudden Death of the Reverend Nathanael Vincent (London: n.p., 1692) 2Google Scholar. On the patristic writers, see Braunthal, Alfred, Salvation and the Perfect Society (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1979) 157Google Scholar.

5 On the certainty of late seventeenth-century divines regarding the centrality of judgment at the resurrection, see Malbon, Samuel, Christ's Glorious Appearance to Judgment (London: n.p., 1673)Google Scholar; and Oliver, John, The Last Judgment: or a Discourse Shewing the Reasonableness of the Belief of Such a Thing (London: n.p., 1682)Google Scholar. Oliver “proves” the truth of a final assize on the basis of three criteria: innate ideas or universal consent, common ideas regarding God's nature, and scripture.

6 John Calvin had initially addressed the problem in his Psychopannychia (in Henry Beveridge, trans., Calvin's Tracts [3 vols.; Edinburgh: n.p., 1851] 3. 435–36). He concluded that a qualitative distinction was essential.

7 Aquinas notes (Summa Contra Gentiles [trans. O'Neil, Charles J.; London: University of Notre Dame Press, 1975] 4.79 [p. 299])Google Scholar that “it is, then, contrary to the notion of the soul to be without the body.”

8 Manton, Thomas, The Blessed State of Them that Die in the Lord (London: n.p., 1656) 10Google Scholar. See also Milner, William, A Sermon at the Funeral of Mrs. Elizabeth Fisher (London: n.p., 1698) 3–4Google Scholar; Scott, John, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Dr. William Croun (London: n.p., 1684) 4–13.Google Scholar

9 Huizinga, Johan, The Waning of the Middle Ages (1924; reprinted Garden City: Doubleday Anchor, 1954) 138–51.Google Scholar

10 Baker, Herschel Clay, The Wars of Truth: Studies in the Decay of Christian Humanism in the Earlier Seventeenth Century (Gloucester, MA: Smith, 1969) 43–44Google Scholar; see also Easton, Thomas, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of John Melford (London: n.p., 1692) 10–15.Google Scholar

11 Hall, Timothy, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Robert Huntington (London: n.p., 1684) 31–32Google Scholar. This point is made by Aries, Philippe in The Hour of Our Death (trans. Weaver, Helen; New York: Penguin, 1981) 13.Google Scholar

12 Patrick, Simon, The Heart's Ease (London: n.p., 1660) 144–48Google Scholar. See also Hall, Joseph, The Remedy of Discontentment, in Wynter, Philip, ed., The Works of the Right Reverend Joseph Hall (10 vols.; 1863; reprinted New York: AMS, 1969) 6Google Scholar. 577; idem, The Art of Divine Meditation, in Wynter, Works, 6. 82–86; idem, Epistles in Six Decades, in Wynter, Works, 6. 157; Babington, Gervase, A Conference Betwixt Mans Frailtie and Faith (London: n.p., 1615) 33–37Google Scholar; Shower, John, “Of Mourning for the Dead,” in Wright, Timothy and Fleming, R., eds., The Mourner's Companion (London: n.p., 1692) 1–67.Google Scholar

13 See, for example, Reeve, Thomas, Lazarus His Rest (London: n.p., 1647) 22Google Scholar; Stillingfleet, Edward, “Sermon Preached before the King and Queen at Hampton Court” (1689), in The Works of Dr. Edw. Stillingfleet (6 vols.; London: Heptinstall, 1704–10) 1. 537Google Scholar; Shower, John, Death and Deliverance (London: n.p., 1693) 51Google Scholar; Isham, Zacheus, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Reverend John Scott (London: n.p., 1695) 14–15.Google Scholar

14 Dobson, John, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Honorable the Lady Mary Farmor (London: n.p., 1670) 38Google Scholar. See also Pierce, Thomas, Death Considered as a Door to a Life of Glory (London: n.p., 1690) 7Google Scholar; Laxton, Thomas, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Honorable Christopher Sherard (London: n.p., 1682) 15Google Scholar. This view was adopted early in the century by Perkins, William (A Salve for a Sicke Man [London: n.p., 1603] 594).Google Scholar

15 Bolton, Robert, The Four Last Things (London: n.p., 1631) 8Google Scholar. See Donne, John, “Sermon Preached at Whitehall, 29 February 1627,” in Gill, Theodore A., ed., The Sermons of John Donne (New York: Meridian, 1958) 249.Google Scholar

16 Calamy, Edward, The Happiness of Those Who Sleep in Jesus (London: n.p., 1662) 10, 11.Google Scholar

17 Ibid., 9, 10.

18 Bates, William, A Funeral Sermon Preached Upon the Death of… Dr. Thomas Manton (London: n.p., 1678) 2Google Scholar; Fowler, Matthew, God's Esteem of the Death of His Saints (London: n.p., 1656) 19Google Scholar. See also Gibbs, William, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Reverend Edward Reynolds (London: n.p., 1699) 24.Google Scholar

19 Bolton, Four Last Things, 9.

20 Stillingfleet, Works, 1. 544; Pearson, John, An Exposition of the Creed (London: n.p., 1659) 39Google Scholar. See also Woolnough, Thomas, The Dust Returning to the Earth (London: n.p., 1669) 2Google Scholar; Bates, William, A Funeral Sermon Preached Upon the Death of Mr. Thomas Gouge (London: n.p., 1681) 4Google Scholar; Allen, Richard, A Gainful Death at the End of a Truly Christian Life (London: n.p., 1700) 22Google Scholar; Massey, Christopher, Microcosmography, or, Speculum Mundi: Being a Glass for Worldlings (London: n.p., 1650) 18Google Scholar. Rust, George (Funeral Sermon Preached at the Obsequies of… Jeremy, Lord Bishop of Down [London: n.p., 1668] 6)Google Scholar describes bodies as “prisons and dungeons of our Heaven-born souls.”

21 Alighieri, Dante, Paradise (trans. Musa, Mark; Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1984)Google Scholar canto 3, line 90. On Augustine, see Redle, M. J., “Beatific Vision,” New Catholic Encyclopedia 2 (1967) 190.Google Scholar

22 Pearson, Exposition, 477.

23 Bates, A Funeral Sermon Preached Upon the Death of… Dr. Thomas Manton, 64.

24 Joseph Hall, The Balm of Gilead: or The Comforter, in Wynter, Works, 7. 99; , E. G., Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Sir Matthew Hale (London: n.p., 1677) 6Google Scholar. See also Watson, Thomas, The Fight of Faith Crowned (London: n.p., 1678) 15Google Scholar; Jenkyn, William, Exodus, or, the Decease of the Holy Man and Ministers (London: n.p., 1675) 41Google Scholar; Bates, William, A Funeral Sermon for… Richard Baxter (London: n.p., 1692) 19, 47Google Scholar; Franklin, R., Death in Triumph Over the Most Desirable Ones (London: n.p., 1683) 10Google Scholar; Wright, Timothy, The Mourner's Memorial (London: n.p., 1692)Google Scholar epistle dedicatory, iii; Resbury, Richard, Paul's Soul Panting for a Better Life (London: n.p., 1655) 4Google Scholar. Dolittle, Thomas (The Saints Convoy to Heaven [London: n.p., 1697])Google Scholar goes into considerable detail concerning the soul's escort into heaven by angels.

25 Browne, Thomas, Religio Medici (1643; reprinted London: Dent, 1959) 55.Google Scholar

26 Calamy, The Happiness of Those Who Sleep in Jesus, 4. See also Watson, Thomas, The Fight of Faith Crowned (London: n.p., 1678) 15Google Scholar; Joseph Hall, The Invisible World Discovered to Spiritual Eyes, in Wynter, Works, 8. 175. John Shower refused to accept (“The Saints Desire to be with Christ,” in Wright and Fleming, The Mourner's Companion, 13) that the life with Christ after death “will in any thing be defective.”

27 Sherlock, William, A Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Richard Meggot, Late Dean of Winchester (London: n.p., 1693) 11.Google Scholar

28 Browne, Religio Medici, 55.

29 Perkins, William, The Golden Chaine: or the Description ofTheologie (Cambridge: n.p., 1603) 101Google Scholar; Calvin, John, Institutes of the Christian Religion (trans. Allen, John; 2 vols.; Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Christian Education, 1844) 2.3.25.6.Google Scholar

30 Dobson, Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Honorable the Lady Mary Farmor, 5–6.

31 Stevens, Joseph, The Whole Parable of Dives and Lazarus, Explain'd and Apply'd (London: n.p., 1697) 91.Google Scholar

32 Taylor, Nathanael, A Funeral Sermon on the Decease of the Reverend Mr. Richard Mayo (London: n.p., 1695) 12Google Scholar; Rust, George, A Funeral Sermon Preached at the Obsequies of Jeremy Lord Bishop of Down (London: n.p., 1668) 7Google Scholar. For additional examples, see Tomlyns, Samuel, The Faith of the Saints as to a Future House and Happiness in the Other World (London: n.p., 1680) 18Google Scholar; Dent, Edward, Everlasting Blessedness (London: n.p., 1692) 3Google Scholar; Shower, John, Death a Deliverance (London: n.p., 1693) 61Google Scholar; Isham, Sermon Preached at the Funeral of the Reverend John Scott, 19.

33 The Diary of John Evelyn (ed. de Beer, E. S.; 6 vols.; Oxford: Clarendon, 1955) 5. 114–15Google Scholar. See also Milner, Funeral of Mrs. Elizabeth Fisher, 9.

34 Burnet, Gilbert, Exposition of the Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England (London: n.p., 1699) 221.Google Scholar

35 Burnet, Gilbert, Select Sermons (Glasgow: n.p., 1742) 135.Google Scholar

36 Stillingfleet, Works, 1. 750. This view was seconded by Dunton, John in The Mourning Ring, In Memory of Your Departed Friend ([London: n.p., 1692] 35)Google Scholar. Wanley, Nathaniel, in his Peace and Rest for the Upright ([London: n.p., 1681] 12)Google Scholar, contradicted this position, insisting instead that the living find each other again in heaven after death.

37 Stevens, The Whole Parable of Dives and Lazarus, 90.

38 Ibid., 110.

39 Hall, Invisible World, in Wynter, Works, 8. 211.

40 Shippen, William, The Christians Triumph Over Death (Oxford: n.p., 1688), 29Google Scholar; See also The Diary of John Evelyn, 5. 115.

41 Quoted in Hardy, Nathaniel, The Pilgrims Wish, or the Saints Longing (London: n.p., 1659) 10.Google Scholar

42 Shower, Death a Deliverance, 61; Dunton, House of Mourning, 250.

43 Copleston, Frederick Charles, Aquinas (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1982) 156–62, 167Google Scholar. See also Pegis, Anton C., St. Thomas and the Problem of the Soul in the Thirteenth Century (1943; reprinted Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, 1978) 180–87Google Scholar. Krumm, John M., Modern Heresies (Greenwich, CT: Seabury, 1961) 172Google Scholar. McManners, John indicates (Death and the Enlightenment [New York: Oxford University Press, 1986] 120)Google Scholar that for French Roman Catholic theologians in the eighteenth century, the soul was the principle of individuality, the essential “I.” My survey of Protestant sermons in this essay does not exhibit the same point of view.

44 Wanley, Peace and Rest for the Upright, 14. John Donne's 1630 sermon Death's Duel or, A Consolation to the Soule Against the Dying Life, and Living Death of the Body (in Gill, Sermons, 269) provides an early seventeenth-century example of this position.

45 Copleston, Aquinas, 173. This point is made anew by Davis, Stephen T., Risen Indeed: Making Sense of the Resurrection (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1993) 86–90.Google Scholar

46 Slater, Samuel, The Saints Readiness for the Lord's Coming (London: n.p., 1688) 17.Google Scholar

47 Overton, Richard, Man Wholly Mortal (London: n.p., 1655) 59Google Scholar. See also Browne, Religio Medici, 13. John Scott claimed that time will cease only at the judgment day, after time “like fire hath devoured all it can prey on” (Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Dr. William Croun [London: n.p., 1684] 16Google Scholar). On Luther's idea of the sleeping soul, see Althaus, Paul, The Theology of Martin Luther (trans. Schultz, Robert C.; Philadelphia: Fortress, 1966) 410–25.Google Scholar

48 Milton, John (A Treatise on Christian Doctrine, in Patterson, Frank, ed., The Works of John Milton [18 vols.; New York: Columbia University Press, 1931–38] 15. 241–43)Google Scholar points out that according to Aristotle, the dead have no sense of time. On Christian mortalism and its sixteenth-century background, see Burns, Norman T., Christian Mortalism from Tyndale to Milton (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1972)Google Scholar; and Williams, George Hunston, The Radical Reformation (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1962) 20–24, 104–6, 580–92.Google Scholar

49 Locke, John, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (ed. Nidditch, Peter; Oxford: Clarendon, 1975) 2.1Google Scholar. On the mortalists of the Restoration period, see Wright, Leonard, “Christian Mortalism in England, 1643–1700” (Ph.D. diss., University of Texas, 1939).Google Scholar

50 Coward, William, Second Thoughts Concerning the Human Soul; quoted in John Redwood, Reason, Ridicule and Religion: The Age of Enlightenment in England, 1660–1750 (London: Thames & Hudson, 1976) 140.Google Scholar

51 Redwood, Reason, Ridicule and Religion, 58, 141.

52 Hill, Christopher, “Irreligion in the Puritan Revolution,” in McGregor, J. F. and Recy, B., eds., Radical Religion in the English Revolution (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984) 201–4Google Scholar; Redwood, Reason, Ridicule and Religion, 30.

53 Stanhope, George, Sermon Preached at Whitehall (London: n.p., 1695) 12Google Scholar. See also Taylor, A Funeral Sermon Occasioned by the Sudden Death of the Reverend Nathanael Vincent, 2–3; and Robert Fleming, “A Funeral Sermon,” in Wright and Fleming, The Mourner's Companion, 71.

54 Quoted in Freeman, Samuel, A Sermon Preach'd at the Funeral of Sir Thomas Bludworth (London: n.p., 1682) 3Google Scholar; see also 14–15. Freeman disputes Socianian soul sleeping throughout the sermon.

55 Cullman, Oscar, Christ and Time: The Primitive Christian View of Time and History (trans. Filson, Floyd V.; Philadelphia: Westminster, 1950) 45–49, 52–53Google Scholar; Peters, Ted, Futures: Human and Divine (Atlanta: Knox, 1978) 88–89, 101, 103Google Scholar; Baker, Wars of Truth, 67.

56 Dunton, , The Mourning Ring, iii. As Horton Davies has indicated in Worship and Theology in England from Andrewes to Baxter and Fox, 1603–1690 ([Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975] 134)Google Scholar the normal purpose of the seventeenth-century sermon was “to unfold divine revelation… with a view to instruction and correction of the mind, and the encouragement of the will in the ways of God.”

57 See, for example, Pleydell's, JosiasA Sermon Preached at the Funeral of Mr. Joseph Glanvil ([London: n.p., 1681] 15)Google Scholar, where the eulogists places the authority of scripture before the claims of reason.

58 Freeman, Samuel, Sermon at the Funeral of Sir Thomas Bludworth (London: n.p., 1682)Google Scholar

59 Willey, Basil, in his The Seventeenth-Century Background ([New York: Columbia University Press, 1934] 3–4)Google Scholar, discusses how a “valid” explanation merely satisfies the needs felt by a given culture at a particular time.