Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nmvwc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-05T22:19:46.322Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Some Opinions on Exemption from Military Service in Nineteenth-Century Europe

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2009

Nuria Sales de Bohigas
Nuria Sales de Bohigas
Affiliation:
Centre Nationale de la Recherche Scientifique
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In strong contrast with twentieth-century prevailing forms of military obligation (by which service, whenever exacted, is individual, uncommutable for money, untransferable, no social status or fortune providing a legal basis by itself for exemption), nineteenth-century standards as imposed for the first time in revolutionary France after 1792–1793, were based on principles such as those stated in 1776 in Massachusetts: “That no rank or station in life, employment or office … shall excuse or exempt any person from serving in arms for the defence of his country either by himself or some able-bodied effective man in his stead … or from paying the fine.” As the brokers who made it their business to provide substitutes put it, more crudely, “le conscrit paye sa dette de sa personne ou par celle de l'homme qu'il achete”. Whatever the reasons invoked to justify “rich man's money and poor man's blood”, “l'impôt de sang pour le pauvre, impôt d'argent pour le riche“ the basis for this bastard form of equality in face of military obligation, from a juridical point of view, could be defined as a transition between Old Regime frank inequality and post-1870 personl, uncommutable, untransferable obligation. It was best summed up in Napoleon's words: “Chez un peuple dont Pexistence repose sur l'inegalite des fortunes il faut laisser aux riches la faculte de se faire remplacer.”

Type
Public Opinion
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 10 , Issue 3 , April 1968 , pp. 261 - 289
Copyright
Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1968

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Act dated November 14, 1776, quoted from Vollmer, A., Backgrounds of Selective Service Military Obligation: The American Tradition. Special Monograph no. 1, v. II, part 6,Google ScholarMassachusetts Enactments in The Selective Service System (Washington, 1947), p. 230.Google Scholar

2 “Pétition à MM. les Députés des Départements sur les Garanties nouvelles offertes par les Intermédiates Civils des Remplacements Militaires”, 15th May 1829, quoted from N. Sales de Bohigas, “Service Militaire et Société en France et en Belgique au XIXe siècle. -Remplaçants, remplacés, marchands d'hommes et assurances contre le service militaire” (Paris, 1964, 2 vols, typewritten), vol. 2, p. 20. Hereafter referred to as “Remplaçants, remplacés”.

3 A motto on 1863 draft riot banners, quoted from Sandburg, C., Abraham Lincoln, v. 2 (1926–39 edition), p. 362.Google Scholar A similar slogan in the Confederacy, against “rich man's war and poor man's fight”.

4 See Janssen's and Gerret's speeches in session of 6th February 1868, of the Chamber of Representatives of Belgium, transcr. in Annates et Documents Parlementaires de la Belgique, for that date.

5 Quoted from Thibaudeau, A. C., Mémoires sur le Consulat (Paris, 1827), p. 108.Google Scholar

6 Estimates from Merlet, “Recherches analytiques et examen général des ordonnances du roy concernant la milice” (Bibliothéque Nationale de Paris, Mss. Fr. 11297, written in the early 1780's); also Corvisier, A., L'Armée Française de la fin du XVIle siecle au ministère de Choiseul, t. 1 (Paris, 1964), pp. 62, 99, 110–11;Google ScholarGebelin, J., Histoire des Milices Provinciates, 1688–1791 (Paris, 1882);Google ScholarClode, Charles M., Military Forces of the Crown, 2 vols. (London, 1869), vol. 2, pp. 592 ff.;Google ScholarHansard Parliamentary Debates, Old Series, 39, pp. 988 ff.Google Scholar

7 Roosevelt, Th., National Strength and International Duty (Princeton University Press, 1917), pp. 103, 415.Google Scholar Much pre-World War I British and American propaganda chose similar mottoes.

8 Taine, H., Les origines de la France contemporaine: Le Régime Moderne, t. 1 (Paris, 1891 edition), p. 289.Google Scholar

9 Estimates from “Remplaçants, remplacés”, t. 1, pp. 72–74.

10 Western, J., The English Militia in the XVIIIth century (London and Toronto, 1965).Google Scholar

11 Dubois-Crancé address of 12-12-1789 to the National Assembly. Ibid. in Mémoires mr le moyen d'établir des rapports entre les troupes soldées et les milices nationales. Réponse au comte de la Tour du Pin (Paris, 1790).Google Scholar

12 Speech by the Minister of War to the Chamber of Representatives of Belgium, Annates Parlementaires de la Belgique, 18th April 1871.Google Scholar

13 Th. Janssen's address, ibid., 6th February 1868.

14 Ibid.

15 Gerrets' address, ibid.

18 Printed proclamation by General Baldrich in the name of General Prim, 16th August 1867.

17 Quoted by Sandburg, C., op. cit., v. 2, p. 362 ff.Google Scholar

18 M. W. Bossier, of Brussels, had the kindness to send me this song and translate it.

19 Merlet, cit. manuscript.

20 Ibid.

21 Ibid.

22 Ibid.

23 Speech of 2nd March, 1818. Reproduced in Opinion de M. le Vicomte de Chateaubriand sur le projet de loi relative au recrutement de l'armée (Paris, 1818).Google Scholar

24 De Bonald, , Théorie du Pouvoir Politique et Religieux, vol. 2 (Paris, Lecrère edition, 1854), p. 487.Google Scholar

25 Speech of Baron Pasquier to French House of Peers, 5-3-1818. Reprinted in Discours prononcé par M. le Garde des Sceaux, le baron Pasquier, sur la loi de Recrutement de l'Armée (Paris, 1818).Google Scholar

26 Hulqvist, Per, Forsvarsorganisationen, värnplikten och skatterna i svenska riksdags-politik, 1868–1878 (Göteborg, 1959).Google Scholar

27 Speech by Martínez de Tejada, 7th September 1811, in the Cortes de Cádiz, Diario de Sesiones de las Cortes Generates y Extraordinarias del Reino, of that date.

28 Quoted from “Remplagants, remplacds”, vol. 1, p. 134.

29 Ibid., p. 132.

30 Ibid., vol. 2, p. 20.

31 Quoted by Wanty, E., in Le milieu militaire beige de 1831 à 1914 (Brussels, 1957), p. 127.Google Scholar

32 Memoria sobre el modo de verificar el reemplazo del ejército, anon, report which obtained first prize from municipal authorities in Barcelona in 1834. Quoted in “Remplaçants, remplacés”, vol. 1, p. 33.Google Scholar

33 Letter from Victor Hugo, 1848 deputy in the National Assembly, to Moniteur Universel, 21st October 1848.

34 Speech by deputy Petitti in 1851, Atti del Parlamento Subalpino, vol. 1Google Scholar: Documenti, p. 607;Google Scholar quoted from Pieri, Piero, Forze annate nell'età delta Destra (Milano, 1962), p. 93,Google Scholar and from Pischedda, Carlo, Problemi dell'unificazione italiana (Modena, 1963), p. 66.Google Scholar

35 Unsigned article in Le Constitutionnel, 11th September 1848.

36 Speech by Escosura, , 29th October 1855, in Diario de Sesiones de Cortes Españotas, of that date.Google Scholar

37 Speech by Cánovas del Castillo, 7th March 1888, ibid., of that date.

38 Quoted by Per Hulqvist from a speech in the 1870 Riksdag, Swedish in “Karl I Sitt Stalle”, Dagens Nyheter, 6th March 1966.Google Scholar

39 See above, note 37.

40 Quoted by Froment, A., Vingt millions de combattants (Paris, 1888).Google Scholar

41 Unsigned article in L'évènement, 22nd. October 1848.Google Scholar

42 Ibid.

43 Quoted from Mañé y Flaqué, Artículos Dominicales (Barcelona).Google Scholar

44 Speech by Bourbousson, 21st October 1848, printed in Moniteur Universel, of that date.

45 Speech by Romero Robledo, 15th March 1888, in Diarios de Sesiones de Cortes Españolas, of that date.

46 Speech by Jové Hevia, 4th February 1873, ibid.

47 Speech by Cánovas del Castillo, 7th March 1888, ibid.

48 Quoted by Wanty, E., op. cit., pp. 183–84.Google Scholar

49 Thiers, 21st October 1848, Moniteur Universel, of that date.Google Scholar

50 Ibid., same date.

51 General Prim's speech in Diario de Sesiones de las Cortes Españolas, 1869.Google Scholar

52 Debates in Assemblée Nationale, France, publ. by Moniteur Universel, 21st October 1848.Google Scholar

53 Ibid.

54 Ibid.

55 L'Ere nouvelle, 22nd October 1848.Google Scholar

56 See above, n. 52.

57 Speech by Sicilia, 30th October 1872, Diario de Sesiones de Cortes Españolas, of that date. Examples of ruin or stagnation due to the privilege of commutation, in Proudhon, Qu'est-ce que la propriete?; in Le Play, Les Ouvriers Europeens, vol. 6 (second edition), p. 119; in Cochon, J., “Un remplacement militaire dans les dernières années du premier empire”, Carnets de la Sabretache (1897).Google Scholar

58 Estimates for 1818–1870 France in “Remplañants, remplacés”; for Napoleonic wars, France, G. Vallee, La conscription dans le département de la Charente (Paris, 1937);Google ScholarDesert, G., “Le remplacement dans le Calvados sous l'Empire et les monarchies censitaires’, Revue d'histoire économique et sociale, 1965, no. 1, pp. 66–85;Google ScholarDufraisse, R., “La population de la rive gauche du Rhin et le service militaire’, Revue Historique, 1962, no. 1, pp. 102–40.Google Scholar For Belgium, I am indebted to M. J. R. Lecomte, director of the Musée Royal de l'Armee, in Brussels, for estimates. Spanish estimates come from the annual publications, Memorias dirigidas al Exmo. Sr. Ministro de la Guerra Redención y Enganches del Ejército and from Estadísticas del Reclutamiento y Reemplazo del Éjército. For Russia, estimates from The Times, London, 24th January 1877.

59 M. Frére et M. Thonissen ou le Remplacement et le Service Obligatoire (Brussels, 1873).Google Scholar Much fun about “généraux brochuriers” in May 1873 sessions of the Chamber of Representatives of Belgium.

60 Quoted in “Remplasants, remplacés”, vol. 1, p. 68.

61 Ibid.

62 Quoted by Monteilhet, J., Les Institutions Militaires de la France (Paris, 1932), pp. 57–62.Google Scholar

63 Col. Weimerskisch, Th., Sur les Remplañants (Brussels, 1885).Google Scholar

64 Speech by M. Thonissen in 1871 to the Chamber of Representatives of Belgium, quoted by Wanty, , op. cit., p. 128.Google Scholar

65 Speech by Minister of War, of 16th April 1871, Annates Parlementaires de la Belgique, of that date;Google Scholar see also General Brialmont's speech cited in Abolition du Remplacement Militaire, anon. (Brussels, 1872).Google Scholar

66 Thiers, A., L'Armée de la France (Paris, 1872), p. 72.Google ScholarIbid.