Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-tn8tq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-25T20:32:52.893Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Why Are Returns to Education Higher for Women than for Men in Urban China?*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 July 2013

Emily Hannum*
Affiliation:
Department of Sociology, University of Pennsylvania.
Yuping Zhang
Affiliation:
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Lehigh University.
Meiyan Wang
Affiliation:
Institute of Population and Labor Economics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.
*
Email: hannumem@soc.upenn.edu (corresponding author).

Abstract

It is well established that returns on education are higher for women than for men in urban China. We argue that this finding, while accurate, is misleading owing to its individualist perspective. The income to which most working-age women and men have access includes not only their own income, but also spouse income. Furthermore, decisions about participation and investment in the labour force, both consequential for income trajectories, are likely to be made with partner income and potential income in mind. To our knowledge, no research in China has explored the returns to education enjoyed via spouse income, or the implications of pooling couple income, for illuminating the returns to schooling difference for women and men. In this article, using data from the China Urban Labour Survey (2001), we argue that the returns for women, conventionally defined, are higher than for men because many women trade their own income for spouse income, and this is particularly true among less educated women. We demonstrate, first, that women who are more educated are less likely to get married, while the reverse is true for men. Second, we show that among couples there is evidence of a trade-off in investments in careers. Moreover, among couples, the less educated the woman and the more educated the man, the less likely the couple is to depend heavily on her income. Finally, we show that among couples there is a compensating reverse pattern of returns differences by sex when income is conceptualized as spouse income. Thus, in terms of total couple income, there are no returns differences by sex.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The China Quarterly 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The authors received grants from the International Centre for the Study of East Asian Development (Kitakyushu, Japan) and the Penn Research Foundation to defray part of the costs of designing and analysing a literacy assessment module (the China Adult Literacy Survey) as part of the China Urban Labour Survey.

References

Appleton, Simon, Knight, John, Song, Lina and Xia, Qingjie. 2009. “The economics of Communist Party membership: the curious case of rising numbers and wage premium during China's transition.” Journal of Development Studies 45(2), 256275.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Astrom, Johanna. 2009. “The effects of spousal education on individual earnings: a study of married Swedish couples,” working paper, http://www.econ.umu.se/digitalAssets/25/25665_ues788.pdf. Accessed 1 August 2010.Google Scholar
Benham, Lee. 1974. “Benefits of women's education within marriage.” Journal of Political Economy 82, S57S71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bian, Yanjie, Logan, John and Shu, Xiaoling. 2000. “Wage and job inequalities in the working lives of men and women in Tianjin.” In Entwisle, Barbara and Henderson, Gale (eds.), Re-Drawing Boundaries: Work, Households, and Gender in China. Berkeley: University of California Press, 111133.Google Scholar
Bianchi, Suzanne, and Milkie, Melissa. 2010. “Work and family research in the first decade of the 21st century.” Journal of Marriage and Family 72(June), 705725.Google Scholar
Brynin, Malcolm, and Schupp, Jurgen. 2000. “Education, employment and gender inequality amongst couples: a comparative analysis of Britain and Germany.” European Sociological Review 16(4), 349365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cao, Yang, and Nee, Victor. 2005. “Remaking inequality: institutional change and income stratification in urban China.” Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy 10(4), 463485.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chi, Wei, and Li, Bo. 2007. “Glass ceiling or sticky floor? Examining the gender income differential across the income distribution in urban China, 1987–2004.” Journal of Comparative Economics 36(2), 243263.Google Scholar
Demurger, Sylvie, Fournier, Martin and Yi, Chen. 2007. “The evolution of gender earnings gaps and discrimination in urban China: 1988–1995.” The Developing Economics 45(1), 97121.Google Scholar
Ding, Sai, Dong, Xiao-yuan and Li, Shi. 2009. “Women's employment and family income inequality during China's economic transition.” Feminist Economics 15(3), 163190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DiPrete, Thomas Albert, and Buchmann, Claudia. 2006. “Gender-specific trends in the value of education and the emerging gender gap in college completion.” Demography 43(1), 124.Google Scholar
Ferree, Mara Marx. 2010. “Filling the glass: gender perspectives on families.” Journal of Marriage and Family 72(June), 420439.Google Scholar
Giles, John, Hannum, Emily, Park, Albert and Zhang, Juwei. 2003. “Life-skills, schooling, and the labor market in urban China: new insights from adult literacy measurement,” http://www.icsead.or.jp/download/data/2003-21.zip. Accessed 15 November 2007.Google Scholar
Goldin, Claudia. 1992. “The meaning of college in the lives of American women: the past 100 years.” Working Paper 4099. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldin, Claudia. 2004. “The long road to the fast track: career and family.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 596, 2035.Google Scholar
Grossbard-Shechtman, Shoshana, and Neuman, Shoshana. 1991. “Cross-productivity effects of education and origin on income: are they really reflecting productivity?” In Frantz, Roger, Singh, Herinder and Gerber, James (eds.), Handbook of Behavioral Economics. Greenwich: JAI Press, 129149.Google Scholar
Gustafsson, Bjorn, and Li, Shi. 2000. “Economic transformation and the gender income gap in urban China.” Journal of Population Economics 13, 305329.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Han, Hongyun. 2010. “Trends in educational assortative marriage in China: from 1970 to 2000.” Demographic Research 22(24), 733770.Google Scholar
Heckman, James, and Li, Xuesong. 2004. “Selection bias, comparative advantage and heterogeneous returns to education: evidence from China in 2000.” Pacific Economic Review 9(3), 155171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoffman, S.D. 2009. “The changing impact of marriage and children on women's labor force participation.” Monthly Labor Review 132, 314.Google Scholar
Huang, Chong, Li, Hongbin, Pak Wai Liu and Zhang, Junsen. 2009. “Why does spousal education matter for earnings? Assortative mating or cross productivity.” Journal of Labor Economics 27, 633652.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hughes, James, and Maurer-Fazio, Margaret. 2002. “Effects of marriage, education and occupation on the female/male wage gap in China.” Pacific Economic Review 7(1), 137157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jepsen, Lisa. 2005. “The relationship between wife's education and husband's income: evidence from 1960 to 2000.” Review of Economics of the Household 3(2), 197214.Google Scholar
Lefgren, Lars, and McIntyre, Frank. 2006. “The relationship between women's education and marriage outcomes.” Journal of Labor Economics 24(4), 787830.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, Haizheng. 2003. “Economic transition and returns to education in China.” Economics of Education Review 22(3), 317328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, Shi, and Gustafsson, Bjorn. 2008. “Unemployment, earlier retirement, and changes in the gender income gap in urban China.” In Gustafsson, Bjorn, Li, Shi and Sicular, Terry (eds.), Inequality and Public Policy in China. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 243266.Google Scholar
Mare, Robert. 1991. “Five decades of educational assortative mating.” American Sociological Review 56, 1532.Google Scholar
Maurer-Fazio, Margaret. 1999. “Income and education in China's transition to a market economy: survey evidence from 1989 and 1992.” China Economic Review 10(1), 1740.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maurer-Fazio, Margaret. 2007. “In books one finds a house of gold: education and labor market outcomes in urban China.” In Hannum, Emily and Park, Albert (eds.), Education and Reform in China. London and New York: Routledge, 260276.Google Scholar
Maurer-Fazio, Margaret, and Hughes, James. 2002. “The effects of market liberalization on the relative income of Chinese women.” Journal of Comparative Economics 30(4), 683708.Google Scholar
McDowell, Allen, and Cox, Nicholas J.. 2004. “How do you fit a model when the dependent variable is a proportion?” http://www.stata.com/support/faqs/stat/logit.html. Accessed 19 July 2008.Google Scholar
Neuman, Shoshana, and Ziderman, Adrian. 1992. “Benefits of women's education within marriage: results for Israel in dual labor market context.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 40, 413426.Google Scholar
Papke, L. E., and Wooldridge, J.. 1996. “Econometric methods for fractional response variables with an application to 401(k) plan participation rates.” Journal of Applied Econometrics 11, 619632.Google Scholar
Parish, William, and Busse, Sarah. 2000. “Gender and work.” In Tang, Wenfang and Parish, William (eds.), Chinese Urban Life under Reform. London: Cambridge University Press, 232272.Google Scholar
Parish, William, and Farrer, James. 2000. “Gender and family.” In Tang, Wenfang and Parish, William (eds.), Chinese Urban Life Under Reform. London: Cambridge University Press, 209231.Google Scholar
Rossetti, Stefania, and Tanda, Paola. 2000. “Human capital, wages, and family interactions.” Labour 14(1), 534.Google Scholar
Song, Lijun. 2009. “The effect of the Cultural Revolution on educational homogamy in urban China.” Social Forces 88(1), 257270.Google Scholar
Shu, Xiaoling, and Bian, Yanjie. 2003. “Market transition and gender gap in income in urban China.” Social Forces 81(3), 1107–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smits, Jeroen, and Park, Hyunjoon. 2009. “Decades of educational assortative mating in 10 East Asian societies.” Social Forces 88(1), 227255.Google Scholar
Stone, P. 2007. Opting Out? Why Women Really Quit Careers and Head Home. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Tiefenthaler, Jill. 1997. “The productivity gains of marriage: effects of spousal education on own productivity across market sectors in Brazil.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 45, 633650.Google Scholar
van der Lippe, Tanja, and van Dijk, Liset. 2002. “Comparative research on women's employment.” Annual Review of Sociology 28, 221241.Google Scholar
Wang, Feng. 2008. Boundaries and Categories: Rising Inequality in Post-socialist Urban China. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Wong, Yue-chim. 1986. “Entrepreneurship, marriage, and income.” Review of Economics and Statistics 68, 693–669.Google Scholar
Wooldridge, J. M. 2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Boston: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Wu, Xiaogang, and Xie, Yu. 2003. “Does the market pay off? Income returns to education in urban China.” American Sociological Review 68 (3), 425442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xie, Yu, and Hannum, Emily. 1996. “Regional variation in income inequality in reform-era urban China.” American Journal of Sociology 101 (4), 950992.Google Scholar
Xie, Yu, and Raymo, James M.. 2003. “Economic potential and entry into marriage and cohabitation.” Demography 40(2), 351367.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Yamamura, Eiji, and Mano, Yukichi. 2010. “The relationship between the effects of a wife's education on her husband's earnings and her labor participation,” http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/22439/1/MPRA_paper_22439.pdf. Accessed 17 July 2010.Google Scholar
Zhang, Junsen, Liu, Pak-Wai and L., Yung 2007. “The Cultural Revolution and returns to schooling in China: estimates based on twins. Journal of Development Economics 84(2), 631693.Google Scholar
Zhang, Junsen, Han, Jun, Liu, Pak-Wai and Zhao, Yaohui. 2008. “Trends in the gender income differential in urban China, 1988–2004.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 61(2), 224243.Google Scholar
Zhang, Junsen, Zhao, Yaohui, Park, Albert and Song, Xiaoqing. 2005. “Economic returns to schooling in urban China, 1988 to 2001.” Journal of Comparative Economics 33(4), 730752.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yuping, and Hannum, Emily. 2013. “Marriage, parenthood and labor outcomes for women and men in contemporary China.” In Besharov, Douglas J. and Baehler, Karen (eds.), Chinese Social Policy in a Time of Transition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yuping, Hannum, Emily and Wang, Meiyan. 2008. “Gender-based employment and income differences in urban China: considering the contribution of marriage and parenthood.” Social Forces 86(4), 1529–60.Google Scholar
Zhou, Xueguang. 2000. “Economic transformation and income inequality in urban China: evidence from panel data.” American Journal of Sociology 105(5), 1135–74.Google Scholar
Zhou, Xueguang, and Moen, Phyllis. 2001. “Job-shift patterns of husbands and wives in urban China.” In Blossfeld, Hans-Peter and Drobnic, Sonja (eds.), Careers of Couples in Contemporary Societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 332370.Google Scholar