Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-t6hkb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-13T23:41:34.781Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Just Not in the Neighbourhood: China's Views on the Application of the Responsibility to Protect in the DPRK

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 June 2020

Courtney J. Fung*
Affiliation:
Department of Politics and Public Administration, University of Hong Kong. Email: cjfung@hku.hk.

Abstract

Much has been written about China's active engagement and progressive approach to the “responsibility to protect,” a norm that reframes state sovereignty not as a right but as a responsibility. China's response to the “Report of the UN Commission of Inquiry on human rights in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK),” which invokes the norm, however, challenges existing literature. China flatly refuses to uphold the responsibility to protect in the case of the DPRK, despite using previously supported standards to invoke the norm elsewhere and the report's dozens of consensual recommendations. This article is the first to systematically investigate how China has responded to the report. It shows that China's responses are shaped by its exceptionalism and concerns that the responsibility to protect could lead to regime change. I conclude with implications for the broader question of China's engagement with international norms in its near abroad. In my discussion, I draw on interviews with Korean and Chinese foreign policy elites, UN and US officials and DPRK human rights advocates, as well as primary and secondary documents.

摘要

摘要

「保护的责任」是一个将国家主权演释为责任、而非权力的规范。不少研究着笔于中国对其探取积极参与和进取的态度。但就「朝鲜民主主义人民共和国人权状况调查委员会报告」提及该规范,中国的反应却与现有文献有所落差。虽然是次朝鲜案例引用了先前中国支持的标准来提及「保护的责任」,「报告」亦指出数十项和解的建议,中国却断然拒绝「保护的责任」被应用于朝鲜。本文首次有系统地调查中国如何对该「报告」作出回应。本文亦会描述「中国例外论」及对于「保护的责任」有可能导致政权更迭并塑造行为的担忧。我会以中国对在周边地区实行国际规范的取态作结。充分的一手及二手资讯,将辅以与韩国及中国外交精英、联合国官员、朝鲜人权倡导者的访问。

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © SOAS University of London, 2020.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Badescu, Cristina G., and Weiss, Thomas G.. 2010. “Misrepresenting R2P and advancing norms: an alternative spiral?International Studies Perspectives 11(4), 354374.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bellamy, Alex J. 2005. “Responsibility to protect or Trojan horse? The crisis in Darfur and humanitarian intervention after Iraq.Ethics and International Affairs 19(2), 3154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bellamy, Alex J. 2011. Global Politics and R2P: From Words to Deeds. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bellamy, Alex J. 2013. “The responsibility to protect: added value or hot air?Cooperation and Conflict 48(3), 333–57.10.1177/0010836713482448CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bellamy, Alex J. 2015. “A chronic protection problem: the DPRK and the responsibility to protect.International Affairs 91(2), 225244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chen, Titus C., and Hsu, Chia-hao. 2018. “Double-speaking human rights: analyzing human rights conception in PRC politics (1989–2015).Journal of Contemporary China 27(112), 534553.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chow, Jonathan T. 2017. “North Korea's participation in the Universal Periodic Review of Human Rights.Australian Journal of International Affairs 71(2), 146163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cohen, Roberta. 2014. “China's forced repatriation of North Korean refugees incurs UN censure.International Journal of Korean Studies 18(1), 5990.Google Scholar
Congressional-Executive Commission on China. 2012. “Hearing on China's repatriation of North Korean refugees,” 112th Congress second session, 5 March, https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/CHRG-112hhrg74809/html/CHRG-112hhrg74809.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Easley, Leif-Eric, and Park, In Young. 2016. “China's norms in its near abroad: understanding Beijing's North Korea policy.Journal of Contemporary China 25(101), 651668.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foot, Rosemary. 2016. “The state, development, and humanitarianism: China's shaping of the trajectory of the responsibility to protect.” In Bellamy, Alex and Dunne, Tim (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of the Responsibility to Protect. New York: Oxford University Press, 932947.Google Scholar
Fung, Courtney J. 2018. “Separating intervention from regime change: China's diplomatic innovations at the UN Security Council regarding the Syria crisis.The China Quarterly 235, 693712.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fung, Courtney J. 2019a. China and Intervention at the UN Security Council: Reconciling Status. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780198842743.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fung, Courtney J. 2019b. “Rhetorical adaptation and international order-making: China's advancement of the responsibility to protect.Cooperation and Conflict, https://doi.org/10.1177/0010836719858118.Google Scholar
Garwood-Gowers, Andrew. 2016. “China's ‘responsible protection’ concept: re-interpreting the responsibility to protect (R2P) and military intervention for humanitarian purposes.Asian Journal of International Law 6(1), 89118.10.1017/S2044251314000368CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gladstone, Rick. 2014. “UN Council takes up question of rights in North Korea.” The New York Times, 18 April, https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/18/world/asia/un-council-takes-up-question-of-rights-in-north-korea.html?_r=0. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Haggard, Stephan. 2014. “The Commission of Inquiry: the Arria meeting,” The Peterson Institute for International Economics, 21 April, https://piie.com/blogs/north-korea-witness-transformation/commission-inquiry-arria-meeting. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Havel, Vaclav, Bondevik, Kjell and Wiesel, Elie. 2006. Failure to Protect: A Call for the UN Security Council to Act in North Korea. New York: DLA Piper/US Committee for Human Rights in North Korea.Google Scholar
Havel, Vaclav, Bondevik, Kjell and Wiesel, Elie. 2008. Failure to Protect: The Ongoing Challenge of North Korea. New York: DLA Piper/US Committee for Human Rights in North Korea/The Oslo Center.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 1991. “Human rights in China: White Paper of the PRC government,” www.china.org.cn/e-white/7/index.htm.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 1995. “White Paper: the progress of human rights in China,” http://www.china-un.org/eng/zt/rqwt/t28671.htm.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 1997. “Progress in China's human rights cause in 1996,” http://www.china.org.cn/e-white/prhumanrights1996/index.htm.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 2000. “Fifty years of progress in China's human rights,” http://www.china.org.cn/e-white/3/index.htm.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 2012. “National human rights action plan of China (2012–2015),” http://www.china.org.cn/government/whitepaper/node_7156850.htm.Google Scholar
Information Office of the State Council of the PRC. 2016. “National human rights action plan of China (2016–2020),” http://english.gov.cn/archive/publications/2016/09/29/content_281475454482622.htm.Google Scholar
International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty. 2001. The Responsibility to Protect: Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty. Ottawa, ON: International Development Research Centre.Google Scholar
Job, Brian L., and Shesterinina, Anastasia. 2014. “China as a global norm-shaper: institutionalization and implementation of the responsibility to protect.” In Betts, Alexander and Orchard, Phil (eds.), Implementation and World Politics: How International Norms Change Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 144159.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon. 2016. “Activities of the UN Human Rights Council and their impact on the human rights issues in North Korea.” East Asian Institute Issue Briefing, 26 February, http://www.eai.or.kr/data/bbs/kor_report/2016041415351020.pdf.Google Scholar
Kim, Hun Joon. 2018. “The prospects of human rights in US–China relations: a constructivist understanding.International Relations of the Asia-Pacific 20(1), 91118.Google Scholar
Kim, Jawoon, and Bloomfield, Alan. 2017. “Argumentation, impact, and normative change: responsibility to protect after the Commission of Inquiry report into human rights in North Korea.Global Responsibility to Protect 9(2), 173201.10.1163/1875984X-00902004CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kinzelbach, Katrin. 2012. “Will China's rise lead to a new normative order? An analysis of China's statements on human rights at the UN (2000–2010).Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights 30(2), 299332.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kondoch, Boris. 2012. “The responsibility to protect and Northeast Asia: the case of North Korea.The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis 24(4), 433448.Google Scholar
Kondoch, Boris. 2016. “North Korea.” In Bellamy, Alex and Dunne, Tim (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of the Responsibility to Protect. New York: Oxford University Press, 825839.Google Scholar
Lee, Hochul. 2013. “China in the North Korean nuclear crises: ‘interest’ and ‘identity’ in foreign behavior.Journal of Contemporary China 22(80), 312331.10.1080/10670564.2012.734085CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Shin-wha. 2012. “The responsibility to protect (R2P) in humanitarian emergencies: from Libya to North Korea?” East Asia Institute, Seoul, Asia Security Initiative Working Paper No. 22, http://www.eai.or.kr/data/bbs/kor_report/20120514142079.pdf.Google Scholar
Liang-Fenton, Debra. 2007. “Failing to protect: food shortages and prison camps in North Korea.Asian Perspective 31(2), 4774.10.1353/apr.2007.0021CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lin, Zhi. 2010. “Security Council to open thematic debate on cooperation between UN, regional organizations.” Xinhua, 6 January, http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2010-01/06/content_12761317.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Liu, Tiewa, and Zhang, Haibin. 2014. “Debates in China about the responsibility to protect as a developing international norm: a general assessment.Conflict, Security and Development 14(4), 403427.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luck, Edward C. 2009. “Implementing the responsibility to protect at the UN.” Lecture given at the University of Queensland, 3 August.Google Scholar
McMillan, Nesam, and Mickler, David. 2013. “From Sudan to Syria: locating ‘regime change’ in R2P and the ICC.Global Responsibility to Protect 5(3), 283316.10.1163/1875984X-00503004CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nathan, Andrew J. 1994. “Human rights in PRC foreign policy.The China Quarterly 139, 622643.10.1017/S0305741000043071CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nebehay, Stephanie. 2018. “UN investigator: human rights must be part of any talks with North Korea.” Reuters, 12 March, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-north-korea-rights/u-n-investigator-human-rights-must-be-part-of-any-talks-with-north-korea-idUSKCN1GO0TP. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Permanent Mission of the PRC to the UN. 2009. “Statement by Ms LIU Lingxiao of the PRC delegation at the third committee of the 64th session of the GA at the dialogue with the special rapporteur on the right to food,” 21 October, http://www.china-un.org/eng/chinaandun/socialhr/rqwt/t621895.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Permanent Mission of the PRC to the UN. 2018a. “China's position paper on the post-2015 development agenda,” 18 May, http://www.china-un.org/eng/hyyfy/t1264867.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Permanent Mission of the PRC to the UN. 2018b. “Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lu Kang's regular press conference on March 13, 2018,” 13 March, https://www.china-un.org/eng/fyrth/t1542047.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Reilly, James. 2014. “China's economic engagement in North Korea.The China Quarterly 220, 915935.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, Courtney J. 2011. “A responsible power? China and the UN peacekeeping regime.International Peacekeeping 18(3), 286297.10.1080/13533312.2011.563082CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Risse-Kappen, Thomas, Ropp, Stephen C. and Sikkink, Kathryn (eds.). 1999. The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ruan, Zongze. 2012. “Responsible protection.” China Daily, 15 March, http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/opinion/2012-03/15/content_14838556.htm. Accessed 8 April 2020Google Scholar
Sun, Yun. 2012. “Syria: what China has learned from its Libya experience.Asia Pacific Bulletin 152, https://www.eastwestcenter.org/sites/default/files/private/apb152_1.pdf.Google Scholar
Teitt, Sarah. 2008. China and the Responsibility to Protect. Brisbane: Asia-Pacific Centre for the Responsibility to Protect.Google Scholar
Teitt, Sarah. 2009. “Assessing polemics, principles and practices: China and the responsibility to protect.Global Responsibility to Protect 1(2), 208236.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thakur, Ramesh. 2006. The United Nations, Peace and Security: From Collective Security to the Responsibility to Protect. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
UN Commission on Human Rights. 2003. “Commission on Human Rights Resolution 2003/10: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (E/CN.4/RES/2003/10), 16 April.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2005. “2005 World Summit outcome” (A/RES/60/1), 24 October.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2009. “Implementing the responsibility to protect: report of the secretary-general” (A/63/677), 12 January.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2012a. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/67/370), 13 September.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2012b. “Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 19 December 2011: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/66/174), 29 March.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2013a. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/RES/22/13), 9 April.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2013b. “Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 20 December 2012: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/67/181), 20 March.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2014a. “Report of the Commission of Inquiry on human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/25/63), 7 February.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2014b. “Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 18 December 2013: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/68/183), 4 February.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2014c. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/25/L.17), 26 March.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2014d. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/69/548), 24 October.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2014e. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/C.3/69/L.63), 13 November.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2015a. “Summary record of the 46th meeting” (A/C.3/69/SR.46), 14 January.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2015b. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/69/188), 15 January.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2015c. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/28/L.18), 27 March.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2015d. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/C.3/70/L.35), 30 October.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2015e. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (S/PV.7575), 10 December.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2016a. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/31/L.25), 21 March.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2016b. “Seventy-first session, 65th plenary meeting” (A/71/PV.65), 19 December.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017a. “Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 19 December 2016: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/71/202), 26 January.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017b. “Seventy-second session, 73rd plenary meeting” (A/72/PV.73), 19 December.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017c. “Report of the group of independent experts on accountability” (A/HRC/34/66/Add.1), 24 February.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017d. “Report of the special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/34/66), 22 February.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017e. “Resolution adopted by the Human Rights Council on 24 March 2017: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/RES/34/24), 3 April.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2017f. “Situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/72/394), 18 September.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2018a. “Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 19 December 2017: situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/RES/72/188), 19 January.Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2018b. “Report of the special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/37/69), 9 March.Google Scholar
UN Human Rights Council. 2014. “Report of the detailed findings of the Commission of Inquiry on human rights in the DPRK” (A/HRC/25/CRP.1), 7 February.Google Scholar
UN Meetings Coverage. 2016. “Security Council narrowly adopts procedural vote to authorize discussion on human rights situation in DPRK” (SC/12615), 9 December.Google Scholar
UN Meetings Coverage. 2017. “Security Council 1718 Sanctions Committee underlines humanitarian exemptions pursuant to paragraph 26 of Security Council Resolution 2375 (2017)” (SC/13113), 8 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2006a. “Resolution 1653 (2006)” (S/RES/1653).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2006b. “Resolution 1706 (2006)” (S/RES/1706).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2006c. “Resolution 1674 (2006)” (S/RES/1674).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2006d. “5577th meeting” (S/PV.5577), 4 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2006e. “5476th meeting” (S/PV.5476), 28 June.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2007a. “United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and United States of America: draft resolution” (S/2007/14), 12 January.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2007b. “5619th meeting” (S/PV.5619), 12 January.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2009. “Security Council, in presidential statement, reaffirms commitment to protection of civilians in armed conflict” (SC/9571), 14 January.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2010. “6427th meeting” (S/PV.6427), 22 November.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2011a. “Resolution 1970 (2011)” (S/RES/1970).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2011b. “Resolution 1975 (2011)” (S/RES/1975).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2011c. “Resolution 1996 (2011)” (S/RES/1996).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2011d. “Resolution 2014 (2011)” (S/RES/2014).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2011e. “Resolution 1973 (2011)” (S/RES/1973).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2012. “Resolution 2085 (2012)” (S/RES/2085).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2013. “Resolution 2093 (2013)” (S/RES/2093).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2014a. “Resolution 2165 (2014)” (S/RES/2165).Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2014b. “Letter dated 11 July 2014 from the permanent representatives of Australia, France and the United States of America to the UN addressed to the president of the Security Council” (S/2014/501), 17 July.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2014c. “7353rd meeting” (S/PV.7353), 22 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2015. “7575th meeting” (S/PV.7575), 10 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2016. “7830th meeting” (S/PV.7830), 9 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2017a. “8130th meeting” (S/PV.8130), 11 December.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2017b. “8042nd meeting” (S/PV.8042), 11 September.Google Scholar
UN Security Council. 2017c. “8019th meeting” (S/PV.8019), 5 August.Google Scholar
UN Web TV. 2014a. “ID Commission of Inquiry on DPRK – 31st meeting 25th regular session of Human Rights Council,” 17 March, http://webtv.un.org/watch/id-commission-of-inquiry-on-dprk-31st-meeting-25th-regular-session-of-human-rights-council/3350537719001/?term=&lan=PRC#player. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
UN Web TV. 2014b. “A/HRC/25/L.17 vote item: 4 – 55th meeting, 25th regular session Human Rights Council,” 28 March, http://webtv.un.org/watch/ahrc25l.17-vote-item4-55th-meeting-25th-regular-session-human-rights-council/3402181350001/?term=#player.Google Scholar
Walker, Peter. 2014. “North Korea human rights abuses resemble those of the Nazis, says UN inquiry.” The Guardian, 18 February, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/17/north-korea-human-rights-abuses-united-nations. Accessed 8 April 2020.Google Scholar
Yeo, Andrew, and Chubb, Danielle (eds.). 2018. North Korean Human Rights: Activists and Networks. New York: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/9781108589543CrossRefGoogle Scholar
You, Ji. 2001. “China and North Korea: a fragile relationship of strategic convenience.Journal of Contemporary China 10(28), 387398.Google Scholar
Zhao, Jun. 2015. “China and the uneasy case for universal human rights.Human Rights Quarterly 37, 2952.CrossRefGoogle Scholar