Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-8zxtt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-10T21:53:56.277Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Some Impending Legal Problems for Social Workers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2024

Frank Bates*
Affiliation:
University of Tasmania

Abstract

Many areas of the law with which social workers are required to deal are particularly dynamic and, in order to meet the challenges they present, it is necessary to look ahead. Developments in the United States often provide a useful means of predicting developments in Australia. The paper examines three areas, proceedings, social security law, and mental health – where change is becoming, or likely to become, apparent, in the first topic, there has been a marked change in both the issues with which the courts have had to deal and the methodology which they have adopted to attempt to resolve them. In social security law, decisions of the Administrative Tribunal have illustrated anomalies and deficiencies in the legislation, and social workers in their daily practice may notice others. All of that might well lead to a necessary review of the legislation. In the area of mental health legislation, a draft bill in Victoria contains a number of disquieting features which should cause social workers, as well as lawyers, concern. The paper concludes by noting that the legal relationship between social workers and the law has never been more subject to scrutiny in a wide variety of situations, and mutual respect between the two disciplines must continue to increase.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

McClean, J.D., (1980) The Legal Context of Social Work (2nd Ed.) Butterworth, at pp. 4 at pp. 185, 186.Google Scholar
Livermore, J., (1984) Legal Aspects of Marketing (4th Ed.)Google Scholar
Chisholm, R. and Petre, C., (1976) “Of Children Custody and ClichesA.C.L.D. 233.Google Scholar
Bromley, P.M. (1981) Family Law (6th Ed.) Butterworth.Google Scholar
Musgrove, F. (1966) The Family, Education and Society Routledge and Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Bates, F. (1982), “Some Educational Considerations in Recent Family Law CasesU. Tas. L.R. 7, 222.Google Scholar
Bates, F. (1983), “Joint Custody in Australian Law: A Broad PerspectiveAust. L.J. 57, 343.Google Scholar
Lehmann, G., (1984), “Legal Craftsmanship in Custody Cases or a Joint Custody Presumption?Melb. U.L.R. 14, 442.Google Scholar
Folberg, H.J. (1984), “Joint Custody-The Second WaveJ. Fam. L. 23, 1.Google Scholar
Bratt, C. (1978), “Joint CustodyKentucky L.J. 67, 271.Google Scholar
Robinson, H. (1983), “Joint Custody: A Idea Whose Time Has ComeJ. Fam. L. 21, 641.Google Scholar
Bates, F. (1978), “Religious Extremists and Child Law: Some Recent DevelopmentsOttawa LR. 10, 299.Google Scholar
Glendon, M.A., Gordon, M.W., Osakwe, C. (1982), Comparative Legal Traditions West, at p. 10.Google Scholar
Chisholm, R. (1985), Aboriginal Legal Bulletin 13, 10.Google Scholar
Sackville, R. (1978), “Social Security and Family Law in AustraliaInternational and Comparative LQ. 27, 127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mendelsohn, R. (1982), Fair Go: Welfare Issues in Australia Penguin.Google Scholar
Partington, M. (1983), “Late Claims for Social Security BenefitsSocial Security Reporter 14, 136.Google Scholar
Szasz, T. (1970), The Manufacture of Madness Routledge and Kega Paul at p.278,Google Scholar
Williams, G. (1983) Textbook of Criminal Law (2nd Ed.) Stevens at p.642 ff.Google Scholar
Richards, C. (1985), “Mental Health Under the Civil Libertarian Carpet”, Legal Service Bulletin 10, 201.Google Scholar
Stone, O.M. (1974), “Hard Cases and New Law for Children in England and Wales”, Fam. LQ. 8, 351.Google Scholar
Bates, F. (1983), “The Developing Legal Responsiblity of Social Workers: Some Recent Hints from the U.S.Legal Service Bulletin 8, 224.Google Scholar
Bates, F. Blackwood, J.B., Davidson, A.P. and Mackie, K.F., (1985) The Australian Social Worker and the Law (2nd Ed.) Law Book Co. at p.14.Google Scholar
Bates, F. (1982), “The Social Worker as Expert Witness in Modern Australian LawAust. L.J. 56, 330.Google Scholar