Wheat grain is milled commercially to produce refined white flour using processes that separate the starchy endosperm from the outer bran fraction. The bran, which accounts for 15–16 % of the whole grain, is much higher in minerals, vitamins and other potentially bioactive components than whole-grain wheat( Reference Buri, von Reding and Gavin 1 ). Furthermore, these components, which include folate, choline and betaine, are concentrated in the aleurone layer. Aleurone is a metabolically active cell layer that, botanically, is part of the endosperm, but which comprises 45–50 % of the bran produced in commercial milling( Reference Buri, von Reding and Gavin1 – Reference Brouns, Hemery and Price 6 ). Folate, choline and betaine are physiological methyl donors, which play important roles in one-carbon metabolism( Reference Niculescu and Zeisel7 – Reference Ueland, Holm and Hustad 9 ) and DNA methylation( Reference Niculescu and Zeisel 7 ). Furthermore, betaine is an osmolyte and can act as a lipotrope (preventing or reducing fat accumulation in the liver)( Reference Craig 10 ), while choline is involved in neurotransmission and lipid cholesterol transport( Reference Zeisel and Blusztajn 8 ), and folate is necessary for DNA synthesis( Reference Scott and Weir 11 ).
Folate, choline and betaine in whole-grain wheat products may be factors contributing to the decreased risks of chronic diseases associated with high intakes of whole grain, which have been observed in epidemiological studies( Reference Kelly, Summerbell and Brynes12 – Reference Sahyoun, Jacques and Zhang 14 ). Furthermore, two large prospective studies have found inverse associations between not only whole grain intake but also bran intake and the incidence of heart diseases in men( Reference Jensen, Koh-Banerjee and Hu 15 ) and women( Reference Liu, Stampfer and Hu 16 ). The components and mechanisms by which whole grains confer this protection are not fully understood( Reference Fardet 17 ), and whole-grain intervention studies have yielded equivocal results( Reference Seal and Brownlee 18 ). However, a 4-week intervention with aleurone-rich foods by our group( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 ) and a 2-week intervention with whole-grain foods by Ross & Bruce( Reference Ross and Bruce 20 ) have resulted in increased intakes and plasma concentrations of betaine that were associated with improvements in a number of biomarkers of health, including decreased plasma total homocysteine (tHcy) and LDL-cholesterol concentrations. These studies have suggested that betaine and the other methyl donors, folate and choline, may play roles in the health benefits of wheat-based whole-grain foods.
Previous postprandial studies with human subjects have demonstrated the uptake of folate from a cereal made from aleurone flour( Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 2 ) and of betaine from a mixed meal that included wheat bran( Reference Atkinson, Elmslie and Lever 21 ). However, to date, no studies have assessed postprandial plasma betaine, folate and choline responses following the consumption of wheat bran or aleurone fractions, or aleurone incorporated into a bread product. Thus, we conducted two randomised, controlled, human postprandial studies. The primary aims were to evaluate and compare postprandial plasma betaine and other methyl donor-related responses following the consumption of 50 g portions of wheat bran or wheat aleurone that were minimally processed by adding sugar, mixing with water and boiling (study A), and 50 g portions of wheat aleurone that were incorporated into a traditional Irish, yeast-free bread (study B).
Experimental methods
Participants
For each study, a separate group of fourteen healthy participants (seven males and seven females) were recruited by advertisements at the University of Ulster, Coleraine. The participants met the following inclusion criteria: age ≥ 18 and ≤ 40 years; BMI ≥ 18 and ≤ 35 kg/m2; non-smokers; consuming a normal mixed diet; not intolerant to wheat or gluten; not pregnant or lactating; no chronic diseases; not taking any prescribed medication or supplements. These studies were conducted according to the guidelines laid down in the Declaration of Helsinki, and all procedures involving human participants were approved by the Research Ethical Committee of the University of Ulster. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants. These trials were registered at http://www.controlled-trials.com as ISRCTN09560399 and ISRCTN27269236.
Study design and treatments
Both postprandial studies used a participant-blinded, within-participant, cross-over design with a 1-week washout between each test day. Uptake of phenolics from the treatments was assessed as part of a wider project; thus, the participants were asked to avoid foods with high phenolic content (i.e. whole grains, fruit, vegetables, sauces, chocolate, tea, coffee, fruit juices, beer and red wine) for 2 d before each test day. Within-participant standardised selections of foods with low phenolic content (i.e. refined grain products, meat, fish and dairy products) were provided.
On each test day, the participants attended the University of Ulster, Coleraine, between 08.00 and 09.00 hours, having fasted from 22.00 hours the previous night. On arrival, baseline blood samples were taken and the participants were asked to consume the treatments within 15 min. In study A, treatments were (1) minimally processed wheat bran (50 g), (2) minimally processed wheat aleurone (50 g) and (3) control. In study B, treatments were (1) aleurone bread (50 g wheat aleurone incorporated into bread) and (2) control bread, based on white wheat flour. The participants were provided with uncarbonated bottled water for consumption during the postprandial sampling period. Compliance to the treatments was assessed directly by weighing residues.
To improve palatability, sugar was offered with the treatments in study A, and butter was offered with the treatments in study B. Discretionary intakes of sugar and butter, which ranged from 0 to 25 g and 0 to 40 g, respectively, were standardised within the participants across the test days.
Preparation and analysis of the treatments
The bran and aleurone fractions that were produced by dry milling from the hard white winter wheat cultivar Tiger (Triticum aestivum L.) were supplied by Bühler AG, Uzwil, Switzerland, and had the following composition (g/100 g), respectively: DM, 86·7, 90·0; fibre, 54·0, 46·9; protein, 13·2, 17·8; carbohydrate, 11·5, 11·1; ash, 6·1, 10·2; fat, 2·9, 4·1.
The treatments were batch prepared and formulated to balance macronutrient and fibre contents using refined wheat fibre, wheat starch, wheat protein and vegetable fat, and composition data from the suppliers (Table 1). The bran and aleurone fractions were minimally processed by bulk-mixing dry ingredients, adding water, blending, boiling (10 min), portioning and storing (–18°C). The breads were prepared using a traditional Irish, yeast-free, soda bread recipe, with sodium bicarbonate as the leavening agent, where the ingredients were mixed (5 min) to form a dough, portioned, baked (25 min; 200°C), cooled and stored (–18°C). Before each test day, the treatments were thawed overnight at room temperature and subsequently served warm on test mornings. DM contents of the treatments were determined by oven-drying (104°C; 24 h) and samples were freeze-dried (Heto PowerDry PL6000; Thermo Scientific), ball-milled and stored at − 70°C until subsequent analysis for betaine and choline concentrations by NMR spectroscopy( Reference Corol, Ravel and Raksegi 22 ) and for folate concentrations by microbiological assay( Reference Piironen, Edelmann and Kariluoto 23 ).
Table 1 Formulation and composition of the treatments
* Fresh-weight basis.
† Bühler AG, Uzwil.
‡ Vitacel® 600; J. Rettenmaier & Söhne GmbH, Rosenberg.
§ Gluten AG110; Syral, Aalst.
∥ Meritena 200; Syral, Aalst.
¶ Cookeen™; Princes Limited, Liverpool.
** White granulated sugar, local store.
†† Federal Research Centre for Nutrition and Food (BFEL), Karlsruhe.
‡‡ Liquid remaining after churning cream into butter (Dale Farm Limited, Ballymena).
§§ Salt (1·2 g), sodium bicarbonate (0·8 g) (both from local stores) and calcium carbonate (0·5 g) (Dr Paul Lohmann GmbH KG, Emmerthal).
Blood sampling and analysis
Blood samples, at baseline and at 0·5, 1, 2 and 3 h after eating commenced, were taken from an antecubital vein into dipotassium EDTA vacutainers for the analysis of betaine and choline concentrations and into lithium heparin tubes for the analysis of folate concentrations. Plasma was separated by centrifugation (1000 g , 15 min, 4°C), aliquoted and stored at − 70°C until subsequent batch analysis. Plasma betaine, dimethylglycine (DMG), choline, tHcy and methionine concentrations were determined by liquid chromatography–tandem MS/MS at the laboratory of Bevital AS (http://www.bevital.no)( Reference Midttun, Kvalheim and Ueland 24 ). Plasma folate concentration was determined by microbiological assay( Reference Molloy and Scott 25 ).
Statistical analyses
Statistical analyses were performed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (version 11.5; SPSS, Inc.). Plasma measures were analysed using general linear model repeated-measures ANOVA, and where significant differences were found, post hoc comparisons were made using Bonferroni's test for multiple comparisons for study A and paired t test for study B. Baseline folate and tHcy data deviated from normality and were, thus, logarithmically transformed before statistical analyses. The following pharmacokinetic parameters were derived directly from the data: baseline-corrected peak concentration (C max, corr); time taken to reach peak concentration (t max); baseline-corrected AUC (AUCcorr) from 0 to 3 h calculated by the trapezoidal method( Reference Schwab, Torronen and Meririnne 26 ). Differences between baseline measures and between the pharmacokinetic parameters were tested using ANOVA, and post hoc comparisons were made by Bonferroni's test for study A and paired t tests for study B. Independent t tests were used for secondary analyses of sex differences in baseline measures and pharmacokinetic parameters for betaine. Data are presented as means with their standard errors of the mean, and differences were considered significant at P< 0·05.
Results
Composition of the treatments
The analyses showed that energy, macronutrient and fibre contents across the minimally processed bran, aleurone and control treatments (study A) and across the aleurone and control breads (study B) were similar (Table 1). However, compared with the control, minimally processed bran was much higher in betaine, choline and folate concentrations, and minimally processed aleurone provided the highest amounts of these components. Furthermore, the aleurone bread was substantially higher in betaine, choline and folate concentrations than the control bread. Both minimally processed aleurone and the aleurone bread contained almost twice as much betaine as wheat bran (Table 1). In the minimally processed treatments, folate content was higher in aleurone than in wheat bran, while choline was found at similar concentrations in both wheat aleurone and wheat bran.
Completion and compliance
Study A was completed by all the participants (seven males; seven females; age 27·8 (sem 1·7) years; BMI 22·7 (sem 0·7) kg/m2), and there were no significant differences in compliance (P= 0·21), which was 93·4 (sem 4·1), 96·1 (sem 1·8) and 100 % for bran, aleurone and control, respectively. However, one male participant withdrew from study B for personal reasons unrelated to the study (data not included); thus, statistical analyses were performed on thirteen participants (six males; seven females; age 33·9 (sem 1·7) years; BMI 25·0 (sem 1·0) kg/m2). In study B, there were no significant differences in compliance (P= 0·10), which was 96·1 (sem 2·3) and 100·0 % for the aleurone and control breads, respectively.
Plasma responses in study A (minimally processed treatments)
Compared with baseline, plasma betaine concentrations were significantly increased at all time points (0·5, 1, 2 and 3 h; P< 0·001) following the consumption of both bran and aleurone; however, no significant changes were observed following consumption of the control (Fig. 1(a)). Compared with the control, plasma betaine concentrations were significantly higher following the consumption of bran and aleurone from the first sampling (0·5 h) to the last sampling (3 h), when plasma betaine concentrations remained significantly above baseline for both fractions (Fig. 1(a)). Furthermore, plasma betaine concentrations were significantly higher following the consumption of aleurone compared with bran from 0·5 h to 3 h. The pharmacokinetic data reflected these results: the C max, corr and AUCcorr values for plasma betaine concentrations were significantly higher following the consumption of bran and aleurone compared with the control (Table 2) . In addition, the C max, corr and AUCcorr values for aleurone were significantly and substantially higher than those for bran (Table 2). The values of C max, corr for plasma betaine concentrations were 1·1 and 1·8 times the baseline levels, and the t max values for bran and aleurone were 1·0 and 1·2 h, respectively. The secondary analyses showed that mean baseline plasma betaine concentrations were higher in males than in females (37·9 v. 24·2 μmol/l; P <0·001). However, no significant differences were observed between males and females for values of the baseline-corrected area under the treatment effect curve (62·8 (sem 7·6) v. 65·9 (sem 9·3) μmol/l per h; P =0·80 and 123·2 (sem 6·9) v. 116·5 (sem 14·9) μmol/l per h; P =0·69) following the consumption of bran and aleurone, respectively.
Fig. 1 Plasma concentrations of (a) betaine, (b) choline, (c) folate and (d) dimethylglycine (DMG) after consumption of minimally processed fractions. Values are means, with their standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 13). ***Mean value for aleurone (♦) was significantly different from that for control (▲) (P< 0·001). Mean value for aleurone was significantly different from that for wheat bran (■): †P< 0·05, †††P< 0·001. Mean value for wheat bran was significantly different from that for control: ‡P< 0·05, ‡‡P< 0·01, ‡‡‡P< 0·001.
Table 2 Pharmacokinetic data after consumption of the treatments (Mean values with their standard errors)
C max, corr, baseline-corrected peak concentration; AUCcorr, baseline-corrected area under the postprandial concentration–time curve; DMG, dimethylglycine.
a,b,cFor each study, mean values within a row with unlike superscript letters were significantly different (P< 0·05).
* P values were obtained by ANOVA.
† P values were obtained by t test.
Compared with the control, no significant changes were observed in the plasma concentrations of choline, folate or DMG following the consumption of bran and aleurone (Fig. 1(b)–(d)). However, plasma DMG concentrations showed non-significant increases up to the last sampling (3 h) following the consumption of both aleurone and bran, and this was more pronounced for aleurone (Fig. 1(d)). These differences were reflected in the pharmacokinetic data: the C max, corr value for plasma DMG concentrations following the consumption of aleurone and bran was significantly higher than that of the control, and the C max, corr value following the consumption of aleurone was significantly higher than that after consumption of bran (Table 2). No significant effects of treatment on the plasma concentration of tHcy (P= 0·96) or methionine (P= 0·97) were observed (data not shown).
Plasma responses in study B (breads)
Compared with baseline and the control bread, plasma betaine concentrations following consumption of the aleurone bread were significantly (P< 0·001) higher from the first sampling at 0·5 h through to the last sampling (3 h), when plasma betaine concentrations were still substantially elevated (Fig. 2(a)). These effects were reflected in the pharmacokinetic data: the C max, corr and AUCcorr values for plasma betaine concentrations were significantly and substantially higher following consumption of the aleurone bread, compared with the control bread (Table 2). The value of C max, corr for plasma betaine concentrations was 1·7 times the baseline levels (Table 2), with the t max value being 2·1 h. As in study A, the secondary analyses showed that baseline plasma betaine concentrations were higher in males than in females (38·3 v. 32·7 μmol/l; P =0·017); however, no significant differences were observed between males and females for values of the baseline-corrected area under the treatment effect curve (123·1 (sem 12·1) v. 109·0 (sem 8·9) μmol/l per h; P =0·83).
Fig. 2 Plasma concentrations of (a) betaine, (b) choline, (c) folate and (d) dimethylglycine (DMG) after consumption of breads. Values are means, with their standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 13). *Mean value for aleurone (♦) was significantly different from that for control (▲): **P< 0·01, ***P< 0·001.
Compared with the control bread, plasma choline concentrations were higher following consumption of the aleurone bread, and the effect of treatment approached significance (P= 0·058; Fig. 2(b)). However, no significant differences from baseline or between the treatments in plasma choline concentrations were observed. Furthermore, no significant differences between the C max, corr and AUCcorr values for plasma choline concentrations were observed, although both pharmacokinetic responses were higher for the aleurone bread than for the control bread, and the differences approached significance (P= 0·07 and P= 0·10, respectively; Table 2). Overall, no significant effects of treatment on plasma folate concentrations (P= 0·89; Fig. 2(c)) were observed; however, both C max, corr and AUCcorr values were significantly higher for the aleurone bread than for the control bread; however, these differences were small (Table 2).
The effect of treatment did not reach significance (P= 0·084) for plasma DMG concentrations. However, plasma DMG concentrations following consumption of the aleurone bread showed non-significant increases with sampling time compared with the control bread (Fig. 2(d)). Furthermore, although the differences were relatively small, the C max, corr and AUCcorr values were significantly higher for plasma DMG concentrations following consumption of the aleurone bread compared with the control bread (Table 2). No significant effects of treatment on the plasma concentration of tHcy (P= 0·58) or methionine (P= 0·94) were observed (data not shown).
Discussion
The present results show that consumption of 50 g portions of minimally processed wheat bran led to substantial postprandial increases in plasma betaine concentrations. Furthermore, consumption of minimally processed wheat aleurone increased plasma betaine concentrations to a greater extent than wheat bran, and the increase in plasma betaine concentrations was similar to that when the same amount of wheat aleurone was incorporated into bread. However, other plasma methyl donor-related responses were generally small and non-significant.
As may be expected for a water-soluble component, plasma betaine concentrations increased relatively rapidly following ingestion, and the t max values for plasma betaine concentrations were 1·0, 1·2 and 2·1 h following the consumption of minimally processed bran, minimally processed aleurone and aleurone bread, respectively. Previous results, obtained following consumption of a meal composed of extruded wheat bran cereal, wheat bran and whole-grain toast and which had a very similar betaine content (560 mg) to both the minimally processed aleurone and the aleurone bread used here (515 and 564 mg, respectively), have shown peak plasma betaine concentrations at 2·6 h, in contrast to 1·8 h following consumption of a 500 mg betaine supplement( Reference Atkinson, Elmslie and Lever 21 ). Furthermore, with consumption of betaine supplements ranging from 1 to 6 g, the t max value for plasma betaine concentrations ranged between 0·7 and 1·3 h( Reference Schwab, Torronen and Meririnne 26 , Reference Schwahn, Hafner and Hohlfeld 27 ). Overall, these results indicate that processing of bran fractions into more complex food matrices by baking or by extrusion reduces the release and absorption rates of betaine.
Previous results with consumption of betaine supplements have shown that the C max, corr values for plasma betaine concentrations increased from 239 to 966 μmol/l when betaine doses increased from 1 to 6 g( Reference Schwab, Torronen and Meririnne 26 ). Dose-dependent increases in the C max, corr values (33, 57 and 60 μmol/l) were also found in the two present studies (study A and study B) in which betaine intakes were much lower (minimally processed bran, 301 mg; minimally processed aleurone, 515 mg; aleurone bread, 564 mg). Furthermore, in the two studies, the C max, corr values were similar to those found by Atkinson et al. ( Reference Atkinson, Elmslie and Lever 21 ) following consumption of a meal composed of bran cereal, wheat bran and whole-grain toast (39 μmol/l).
The results of the two studies suggested that there may be little difference in the effects of minimally processed aleurone or aleurone incorporated into bread on plasma betaine responses, as the values of C max, corr and AUCcorr for plasma betaine concentrations were similar. However, the results of the two studies were not directly comparable. In both studies, plasma betaine concentrations remained significantly and substantially elevated up to the last sampling time (3 h). The results from the study by Atkinson et al. ( Reference Atkinson, Elmslie and Lever 21 ) with a meal containing similar levels of betaine to those used here indicated that plasma betaine concentrations may remain significantly elevated until 8 h; thus, it may be useful to extend sampling times in future studies. It is important to note that plasma betaine concentrations reflect the balance between absorption, metabolism to DMG, synthesis from choline, storage and elimination. There are no extant data on the rate at which betaine is metabolised or relocated to other tissues; however, betaine is present at much higher concentrations in muscle, liver and kidney tissues than in plasma( Reference Slow, Lever and Chambers 28 ), and urinary postprandial excretion is limited( Reference Schwab, Torronen and Meririnne 26 ). Thus, uptake of betaine is likely to be higher than indicated by plasma measurements. In a study by Schwahn et al. ( Reference Schwahn, Hafner and Hohlfeld 27 ), consumption of betaine supplements (3–5 g) led to small, but significant, increases at 3 h in the plasma concentrations of the betaine metabolite, DMG, which reached a maximum at 9 h. However, the small increases observed in plasma DMG concentrations in both studies (study A and study B) suggested that metabolism of betaine may occur relatively rapidly after uptake.
Plasma choline concentrations did not show significant changes following the consumption of minimally processed bran or aleurone. Nevertheless, very small changes were observed following consumption of the aleurone bread, which approached significance. There are no previous reports on the effects of dietary choline intake from cereal sources on plasma choline concentrations. It is noteworthy that the amount of choline provided by the treatments in both studies was relatively low compared with rich dietary sources, such as eggs( Reference Patterson, Bhagwat and Williams 29 ).
There were no significant effects of treatment on plasma folate concentrations in either study; however, consumption of the aleurone bread led to small, but significant, increases in the values of C max, corr and AUCcorr for plasma folate concentrations. In a previous postprandial study carried out in Australia, plasma folate concentrations have been found to be significantly increased following consumption of 100 g cereal made from an aleurone flour( Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 2 ); however, the amount of folate in the cereal in that study (515 μg/portion) was much higher than that in the minimally processed aleurone or the aleurone bread (56 and 87 μg/portion, respectively) in the present studies. The reasons for the substantially higher folate content of aleurone in the Australian study are unclear; however, it may be due to variations in genotype and growing conditions( Reference Kariluoto, Edelmann and Piironen 30 ).
Significant decreases in plasma tHcy concentrations, which persisted for at least 7 h, have been reported following the consumption of betaine supplements of 3 or 6 g, but not 1 g( Reference Schwab, Torronen and Meririnne 26 ). However, Atkinson et al. ( Reference Atkinson, Elmslie and Lever 21 ) have found small, but significant, decreases in plasma tHcy concentrations at 6 h following consumption of a meal containing about 560 mg betaine, but not following consumption of a 500 mg betaine supplement. Overall, these reports suggest that the lack of significant changes in plasma tHcy or methionine concentrations in both studies could be due to the lower amounts of betaine provided (301–564 mg), combined with the relatively short duration of sampling (3 h).
In contrast, the results from three longer-term interventions( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 , Reference Ross and Bruce 20 , Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 31 ) have shown that diets rich in aleurone or whole grains led to increased fasting plasma betaine concentrations, which, in two studies, was associated with decreased plasma tHcy concentrations( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 , Reference Ross and Bruce 20 ). In the first of these interventions, consumption of the aleurone bread (38·5 g aleurone/d) for >8 weeks significantly lowered plasma tHcy concentrations to a similar degree to that found with consumption of a folic acid supplement (500 mg)( Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 31 ). However, these authors have attributed the decreased tHcy concentration to the high folate content of the aleurone bread( Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 31 ); however, betaine and choline concentrations present in aleurone may also have contributed to the decrease. The second study was a 4-week intervention by our group using aleurone-rich foods that provided 27 g aleurone/d (containing 279 mg betaine/d), which resulted in significant increases in plasma betaine concentrations and decreases in plasma tHcy concentrations that were attributed to the increased dietary betaine intake( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 ). The third study was a 2-week intervention with whole-grain cereals (providing 119 mg betaine/d), which resulted in significant increases in plasma betaine concentrations; however, plasma tHcy concentration was not affected( Reference Ross and Bruce 20 ). Overall, despite the variations in duration, these longer-term studies have suggested that aleurone, which is rich in betaine and other bioactive components, may be effective at ameliorating biomarkers such as tHcy.
In order to maximise any potential postprandial responses, the amount of bran and aleurone fractions used in these studies was relatively large (50 g), and some of the treatments may have had low palatability. However, in the two previous longer-term intervention studies outlined above( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 , Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 31 ), aleurone was successfully included in diets at 38·5 g/d for 16 weeks( Reference Fenech, Noakes and Clifton 31 ) and at 27 g/d for 4 weeks, by incorporation into breads and ready-to-eat cereals( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 ). Thus, bran and aleurone, which contain about 600 and 1000 mg betaine/100 g, respectively (Table 1), could be used as ingredients in the production of consumer foods whose consumption may substantially increase current habitual betaine intakes (100–314 mg/d)( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 19 , Reference Bidulescu, Chambless and Siega-Riz 32 , Reference Detopoulou, Panagiotakos and Antonopoulou 33 ). Betaine insufficiency has been associated with the metabolic syndrome( Reference Konstantinova, Tell and Vollset 34 ), lipid disorders( Reference Lever, George and Dellow 35 ), vascular disease( Reference Alfthan, Tapani and Nissinen 36 ), age-related macular disease( Reference Seddon, Reynolds and Shah 37 ), cognitive decline( Reference Eussen, Ueland and Clarke 38 ) and colorectal cancer risk( Reference Nitter, Norgård and de Vogel 39 ); thus, such foods could potentially offer a number of beneficial health effects.
In conclusion, these results showed that consumption of minimally processed wheat bran, and in particular wheat aleurone, yielded substantial postprandial increases in plasma betaine concentrations. Furthermore, these effects appear to be maintained when aleurone was incorporated into bread.
Acknowledgements
The present study was financially supported by the European Commission in the Communities 6th Framework Programme Project, HEALTHGRAIN (FP6-514008). This publication reflects only views of the authors and the Community is not liable for any use that may be made of the information contained in this publication. The European Commission had no role in the design and analysis of the study or in the writing of this article. Rothamsted Research receives strategic funding from the Biotechnological and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC). Bühler AG, Uzwil, Switzerland, provided bran and aleurone fractions and associated data.
The contributions of the authors are as follows: E. M. K., L. L. H., R. K. P., J. M. W. W. and R. W. W. designed the research with advice from H. M., M. W. and J. J. S.; L. L. H., E. M. K. and R. K. P. conducted the trials; W. v. R. supplied the wheat fractions and associated proximate analysis data; V. P. performed the folate analyses of the foods; P. R. S. and J. L. W. performed the betaine and choline analyses of the foods; A. M. M. performed the plasma folate analyses; P. M. U. performed the analyses of plasma betaine and other methyl donor-related metabolites; L. L. H., E. M. K., R. K. P., J. M. W. W. and R. W. W. analysed the data; E. M. K., R. K. P., J. M. W. W. and R. W. W. wrote the manuscript. All authors contributed to the interpretation of the data and critically revised the final manuscript. Preliminary reports of parts of study A were given at Nutrition Society meetings at Coleraine, UK, July 2007( Reference Price, Keaveney and Hamill 40 ), and Dublin, Republic of Ireland, June 2008( Reference Keaveney, Hamill and Price 41 ).
W. v. R. is working for Bühler AG, Uzwil, Switzerland; Bühler provides services and equipments for food processing. All the other authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
