Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-r6qrq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T21:06:26.369Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Rule of Law in a Chinese Way: Social Diversification and Reconstructing the System of Authority

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 July 2014

Weidong JI
Weidong JI*
Affiliation:
KoGuan Law School, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Against the background of increasing social diversification in a market economy, this paper examines the challenges confronting China’s existing power structure and system of authority. Both to overcome the legitimation crisis of ruling and to achieve a soft landing of the political reform depend on reconstructing the authority of the rule of law through judicial reform as the breakthrough point. For this very reason, the top-level design of regime transition can follow a two-step strategy of building a rule of law country first, to be followed by restructuring power, so as to achieve democracy via the rule of law. It also proposes a conception to institutionalize the rule of law, emphasizing that the alternative three-review mechanism is both necessary and feasible, in that a top-level design of judicial review can contribute to our strivings for judicial fairness, an implementation of budget review and accountability review at the grassroots level for fiscal democracy, and the synergy of high-level and grassroots powers for a virtuous circle between the rule of law authority and democratic polity in mutual enhancement. There also comes the moment for plural efforts to both drive and achieve the rule of law based on the three-review mechanism.

Keywords

rule of law authorityrule of law democracybudget parliamentalismbudget reviewaccountability reviewjudicial reviewlocal self-government
Type
Research Article
Information
Asian Journal of Law and Society , Volume 1 , Issue 2 , November 2014 , pp. 305 - 338
Copyright
© Cambridge University Press and KoGuan Law School, Shanghai Jiao Tong University 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Professor and Dean of KoGuan Law School, Shanghai Jiao Tong University.

References

Ashibe, Nobuyoshi (1981) The Contemporary Development of Constitutional Litigation (Kenbo Sosho no Gendaiteki Tenkai ), Tokyo: Yuhikaku .Google Scholar
Bao, Geda (3 July 2002) “To Solve the Issue of Private Housing Should Respect the Constitution and the Civil Code and Protect Human Rights (jiejue sifang wenti yinggai zunzhong xianfa, minfa, baohu renquan ),” online: <http://article.chinalawinfo.com/ArticleHtml/Article_2900.shtml> (last accessed 20 August 2012).+(last+accessed+20+August+2012).>Google Scholar
Bao, Wanchao (1998) “To Establish a Parallel Review Mechanism of the Constitutional Committee and the Chamber on Constitutional Review Inside the PRC Supreme Court: An Alternative Idea to Improve Constitutional Review in China (sheli xianfa weiyuanhui he zuigao fayuan weixian shenchating bingxing de fuhe shencha zhi—wanshan woguo weixian shencha zhidu de lingyizhong silu ).” 4 Legal Science (faxue ) 11–15.Google Scholar
Cai, Dingjian (1991) On National Oversight (guojia jiandu zhidu ), Beijing: China Law Press (zhongguo fazhi chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Campbell, John C. (1977) Contemporary Japanese Budget Politics, Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Chen, Yunsheng (1988) New Tides in Constitutionalism—Theory and Practice in Constitutional Oversight (minzhu xianzheng xinchao—xianfa jiandu de lilun yu shjian ), Beijing: People’s Publishing House (renmin chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Crozier, Michel, Huntington, Samuel P.& Watanuki, Joji (1989) The Crisis of Democracy (trans. Ma Dianjun , Huang Sujuan , and Deng Mei ), Beijing: Qiushi Publishing House (qiushi chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Dahl, Robert A. (1999) On Democracy (trans. Li Baiguang & Lin Meng ), Taipei: Tapei Lianching Publisher (taibei lianjing chuban shiye gongsi ).Google Scholar
Editorial Board (2013) “The Constitution Is the Consensus for Political Reform (xianfa shi zhengzhi tizhi gaige de gongshi ).” 1 Yanhuang Chunqiu () 1.Google Scholar
He, Weifang, Hong Sheng, Gui Shen, Han Xiao, & Haibo He (2003) “Proposal to the NPCSC on Initiating the Special Investigation Procedure on the Sun Zhigang Case and the Implementation of the Rehabilitation Mechanism (tiqian quanguo renda changweihui jiu sun zhigang an ji shourong qiansong zhidu shishi zhuangkuang qidong tebie diaocha chengxu de jianyishu ),” online: <http://article.chinalawinfo.com/Article_Detail.asp?ArticleID=23230> (last accessed 10 October 2013).+(last+accessed+10+October+2013).>Google Scholar
Hirota, Masao, & Nukatsuka, Yasue (1994) “The Significance of European Charter on Local Self-Government and IULA Worldwide Declaration of Local Self-Government (Europa Chiho Jichi Kensho, Sekai Chiho Jichi Sengen no Igi ).” 66 Law Times (Horitsu Jiho ) 42–51.Google Scholar
Hu, Jinguang (1985) “On Constitutional Oversight (lun xianfa jiandu zhidu ).” 1 China Legal Science (zhongguo faxue ) 72–79.Google Scholar
Jhering, Rudolf von (2007) The Struggle for Law (trans. Zheng Yongliu ), Beijing: Law Press (falü chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Ji, Weidong (1998) “China: Towards Democracy via the Rule of Law (zhongguo: tongguo fazhi maxiang minzhu ).” 4 Strategy and Management (zhanlue yu guanli ) 1–10.Google Scholar
Ji, Weidong (2001) “The Possibility of Rule of Law in China—An Interpretation of and Reflection on China’s Cultural Traditions (fazhi zhongguo de kenengxing—jian lun dui zhongguo wenhua chuantong de jiedu he fansi ).” 5 Strategy and Management (zhanlue yu guanli ) 1–15.Google Scholar
Ji, Weidong (2002) “Constitutional Review and the Enhancement of Judicial Power (hexianxing shencha he sifaquan de qianghua ).” 2 Social Sciences in China (zhongguo shehui kexue ) 4–16.Google Scholar
Ji, Weidong (2003) “Another Treatise on Constitutional Review—The Topology of Power Networks and the Contestation of Institutional Transformations (zailun hexianxing shencha—quanli guanxiwang de tuopu yu zhidu bianqian de boyi ).” 5 Open Times (kaifang shidai ) 6–23.Google Scholar
Ji, Weidong (2005) A New Treatise on Constitutionalism—Law and Social Transition in the Age of Globalisation (xianzheng xinlun—quanqiuhua shidai de fa yu shehui bianqian ), Beijing: Peking University Press (beijing daxue chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Jiang, Ping, & Ji, Weidong (2010) “Dialogue on the Spirit of Modern Rule of Law (duitan: xiandai fazhi de jingshen ).” 1 Shanghai Jiaotong University Law Journal (jiaoda faxue ) 1–21.Google Scholar
Kimura, Takumaro (2003a) “Changes in Fiscal Oversight (Part A)—Preliminary Remarks to a Research Centred upon the Congress and the Accounting Office (Zaisei Tousei no Heiyo (Jyou)—Kokkai to Kaikei Kennsainn no Kinou wo Tyuushinn toshita Kennkyuu Josetu ).” 79 Research on Autonomy (Jichi Kennkyuu ) 91–112.Google Scholar
Kimura, Takumaro (2003b) “Changes in Fiscal Oversight (Part B)—Preliminary Remarks to a Research Centred upon the Congress and the Accounting Office (Zaisei Tousei no Heiyo (Ka)—Kokkai to Kaikei Kennsainn no Kinou wo Tyuushinn toshita Kennkyuu Josetu ).” 79 Research on Autonomy (Jichi Kennkyuu ) 44–61.Google Scholar
Kimura, Takumaro (2004) “Trends in French Reforms in Budget Accounting: Revelations for the Japanese Law (France ni okeru Yosann Kaikei Kaikaku no Doukou—Niponho he no Shisa wo tsutomete ).” 106 Journal on Administrative Management Researches (Kikann Gyousei Kannri Kennkyuu ) 20–40.Google Scholar
Kimura, Takuma (2008) A Legal Theory of Governance—On the Connection of Administration and Finance in Modern and Contemporary Times (Governance no Ho Riron—Gyousei, Zaisei wo meguru Koten to Gendai no Setsugou ), Tokyo: Keiso Press (Keiso Shobo ).Google Scholar
Kornai, János (1986) Economics of Scarcity (trans. Zhang, Xiaoguang Li, Zhenning , and Huang, Weiping ), Beijing: Economic Science Publishing House (jingji kexue chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Lewis, W. Arthur (1954) “Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour.” 22 Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies 139–191.Google Scholar
Li, Zhong (1999) On Constitutional Oversight (xianfa jiandu lun ), Beijing: Social Sciences Documentation Press (shehui kexue wenxian chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Liang, Huixing (2002) “An Analysis on the PRC Supreme Court’s Response No. (2001) 25 on the Case of Violating the Right to Education (zuigao fayuan guanyu qinfan shoujiaoyu quan an de fashi (2001) 25 hao pifu pingxi [2001] 25),” online: <http://www.law-thinker.com/detail.asp?id=1340> (last accessed 4 May 2012).+(last+accessed+4+May+2012).>Google Scholar
Liebman, Benjamin L. (1998) “Class Action Litigation in China.” 111 Harvard Law Review 1523–1541.Google Scholar
Lippmann, Walter (1991) Public Opinion, New Brunswick and London: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
Monaghan, Henry (1973) “Constitutional Adjudication: The Who and When.” 82 Yale Law Journal 1363–1397.Google Scholar
PRC Supreme Court (2001) The Bulletin of the PRC Supreme Court—One-Volume Edition of 2001 (zhonghua renmin gongheguo zuigao renmin fayuan gongbao—2001 nian hedingben ), Beijing, People’s Court Press (renmin fayuan chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Rodriguez, Daniel B., McCubbins, Mathew D.& Weingast, Barry R. (2013) “The Rule of Law Unplugged.” 2 Comparative Studies (bijiao ) 21–38.Google Scholar
Sugihara, Yasuo (1994) “Local Autonomy and Local Devolution (Chiho Jichi to Chiho Bunken ).” 66 Law Times (Horitsu Jiho ) 28–33.Google Scholar
Sun, Ying (2012) “NDRC on New Urbanisation and Almost All Mayors Against Household Registration Reforms (fagaiwei yuniang xinxing chengzhenhua—hugai jihu zaoyu suoyou shizhang fandui ),” online: <http://house.people.com.cn/n/2012/0820/c164220-18784330.html> (last accessed 18 October 2013).+(last+accessed+18+October+2013).>Google Scholar
Tanaka, Hideo, & Takeuchi, Akio (1987) The Role of Individuals in Legal Applications (Ho no Jiggen ni okeru Shijin no Yakuwari ), Tokyo: Tokyo University Press (Tokyo Daigaku Syuppannkai ).Google Scholar
Wang, JiafuLiu, Haijun, eds. (1998) Encyclopaedia on Human Rights in China (zhongguo renquan baike quanshu ), Beijing: Encyclopaedia Sinica Press (zhongguo dabaike quanshu chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Wang, Lei (2003) “New Explorations of Implementing the Constitution—Several Constitutional Issues on the Case of Qi Yuling (xianfa shishi de xin tansuo—qi yuling an de jige xianfa wenti ).” 2 Social Sciences in China (zhongguo shehui kexue ) 29–35.Google Scholar
Wang, Shan (12 December 2002) “The Trial Record of China’s First Case on Constitutional Right to Equality (zhongguo xianfa pingdengquan diyi an tingshen shilu “),” online: <http://www.law.com.cn/pg/newsShow.php?Id=6457> (last accessed 12 November 2013).+(last+accessed+12+November+2013).>Google Scholar
Wang, Shuwen (1992) “On the Safeguard of Implementing the Constitution (lun xianfa shishi de baozhang ).” 6 China Legal Science (zhongguo faxue ) 15–22.Google Scholar
World Bank (2007) An East Asian Renaissance, Washington: International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/World Bank.Google Scholar
Wu, Jinglian, & Ma, Guochuan (2013) Restarting the Reform Agenda: Twenty Talks on China’s Economic Reform (chongqi gaige yicheng: zhongguo jingji gaige ershi jiang ), Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company (shenghuo dushu xinzhi sanlian shudian ).Google Scholar
Xia, Yong (2003) “Several Basic Theoretical Issues in China’s Constitutional Reform (zhongguo xianfa gaige de jige jiben lilun wenti ).” 2 Social Sciences in China (zhongguo shehui kexue ) 4–17.Google Scholar
Yamamoto, Keizo (2000) A Reconstruction on the Theory of Public Order (Koujoryouzokuron no Saikousei ), Tokyo: Yuhikaku .Google Scholar
Yang, Quanming (1990) On Constitutional Protection (xianfa baozhang lun ), Chengdu: Sichuan University Press (sichuan daxue chubanshe ).Google Scholar
Zhang, Wenxian (1994) “A Preliminary Discussion on Market Economy and the Spirit of Modern Law (shichang jingji yu xiandai fa de jingshen lunlue ).” 6 China Legal Science (zhongguo faxue ) 5–12.Google Scholar
Zhao, Dingxin (2012) “Revolution in Contemporary China? (dangjin zhongguo huibuhui fasheng geming? ?).” 12 The 21st Century (ershiyi shiji ) 4–16.Google Scholar