Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-8zxtt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T04:37:35.977Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Exhibits at Ballots

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 November 2011

Abstract

Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Exhibits at Ballots
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1 Hart, R., The Antiquities of Norfolk … (Norwich, 1844), pp. iii–viiiGoogle Scholar, 2 pls; G. K. Blyth, per Smith, C. R., Arch. J. I (1845), 381–2Google Scholar; J. Gunn, ibid. iii (1846), 247–9; G. E. Fox, ibid. xlvi (1889), 360; Haverfield, F. in V.C.H., Norfolk, I (1901), pp. 307–9Google Scholar; British Museum, Guide to Antiquities of Roman Britain (1951), pl. v, 29 (cauldron), pl. XXIV, 2 (choice of bronzes); Gilbert, Hazel M., Bull. Bd. Celt. Stud. XXVIII (1980), 159–87Google Scholar, illus. The head, ibid. pls. III–IV, and Toynbee, J. M. C., Art in Roman Britain (London, 1962)Google Scholar, pl. 47; etc. (cf. Braemer, F., Revue archéologique, 1968, pt. 2, 327–54Google Scholar; 1969, pt. 1, 81–102, ‘sculptures en metal battu et repoussé …’ for comparanda not incl. this head). See also my ‘Some Romano-British domestic shrines and their inhabitants’ in Rome and Her Northern Provinces. Papers presented to Sheppard Frere …, ed. Hartley, B. and Wacher, J. (Gloucester, 1983), pp. 48f., nn. 78–81.Google Scholar

2 Acc. no. 25.6.10. I am grateful to our Fellows, Dr. Ian Longworth, Keeper of the Department of Prehistoric and Romano-British Antiquities, for permission to exhibit the rattle to the Society, Dr. Timothy Potter, Assistant Keeper in charge of the Roman collections, and especially for her help and interest Miss C. M. Johns, Senior Research Assistant in the Department.

3 See note 1.

4 Musgrave, W., Belgium Britannicum (Exeter, 1719), pp. 123–52Google Scholar, pls. reproduced in my note in Menzel, H. (ed.), ‘Bericht über die Tagung “RömischeToreutik”, 1972’, Jahrb. des Römisch-Germanischen Zentral-Museums, Mainz, xx (1973), 265–9Google Scholar. The interesting question of damaged figurines, etc., is considered in my paper, cited note 1.

5 See note 1.

6 E.g. Sir Fox, Cyril, Pattern and Purpose (Cardiff, 1958), fig. 60.Google Scholar

7 A. King, in litt. 6th December, 1982. Mr. Soffe kindly arranged for me to see the balls.

8 For divination by hazelnuts dropped into wine, see Petronius, Satyricon, 137.10. The bowl used might also be significant; cf. a note by Davis, S. in Man, LV (1955), 132–5, for some ethnographic instances and some parallels in the ancient world.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9 For his life and career generally see Strype, J., The Life of the Learned Sir Thomas Smith, Knight (1698; Oxford edn. 1820)Google Scholar; Dewar, M., Sir Thomas Smith (London, 1964).Google Scholar

10 All information on the architectural history of Hill Hall is taken from Drury, P. J., ‘A Fayre House, buylt by Sir Thomas Smith: the development of Hill Hall, Essex, 1557–81’, J.B.A.A. cxxxvi (1983).Google Scholar

11 Simpson, R., ‘Sir Thomas Smith and the wall paintings at Hill Hall, Essex: scholarly theory and design in the sixteenth century’, J.B.A.A. CXXX (1977), 120.Google Scholar

12 I am grateful to all those D.O.E. staff connected with the monument for their cooperation, especially the Inspector concerned, Juliet Allan, who initiated the project. The illustrations are by John Callaghan, Chelmsford Archaeological Trust.

13 I am grateful to Justine Bayley of the Ancient Monuments Laboratory for investigating the glaze and colourants by X-ray fluorescence, and to Marjorie Hutchinson of the Laboratory for conserving the material.

14 Associated with the insertion of a new great staircase in the south-east tower.

15 Quoted from the grant to Sir Thomas Smith's father, printed by Strype, op. cit. (n. 9), 1820 edn., p. 182.

16 Eames, E. S., Catalogue of Medieval Lead-Glazed Earthenware Tiles in the Department of Medieval and Later Antiquities, British Museum (1980), pp. 43–4.Google Scholar

17 See, e.g., Baggs, A. P., ‘Sixteenth-century terracotta tombs in East Anglia’, Arch. J. CXXV (1968), 297301Google Scholar; also (with reservations) Floyer, J. Kestell, ‘English brick buildings: Henry VII–VIII’, Arch. J. LXXX (1923), 291304Google Scholar; Wight, J. A., Brick Building in England (London, 1972), pp. 178–97.Google Scholar

18 Garner, F. H. and Archer, M., English Delftware (London, 1972), pp. 15.Google Scholar

19 Drury, op. cit. (n. 10).

20 See especially the products, both tinglazed and lead-glazed, of Hans Kraut of Villingen: Strauss, K., Die Kachelkunst des 15. und 16. Jahrhunderts (Strasbourg, 1966), pp. 104–41.Google Scholar

21 Gebelin, F., Les châteaux de la Renaissance (Paris, 1927), pp. 1920Google Scholar, 145–9 and pls. 192, 219; and especially Laborde, Le Comte de, Le Château du Bois de Boulogne dit Château de Madrid (Paris, 1855), brought to my attention by David Thompson.Google Scholar

22 For details see Dewar, op. cit. (n. 9).

23 Biddle, M., ‘Nicholas Bellin of Modena’, J.B.A.A. 3rd ser., XXVIII–XXIX (19651966), 106–21.Google Scholar

24 The context is described by G.W., the gem by M.H. We are grateful to our Fellow, Robert Wilkins, for photographs of the gem, and to Dr. C. E. King for discussing numismatic parallels and providing photographs of coins in the Ashmolean. The intaglio's site record number is SF 5118.

25 Deposit WB 90 116.

26 Actual gem described, as on photographs.

27 Richter, G. M. A., The Portraits of the Greeks, III (London, 1965), pp. 259–69Google Scholar; Kyrieleis, H., Bildnisse der Ptolemäer, Deutsches Arch. Institut, Arch. Forschungen, 2 (Berlin, 1975).Google Scholar

28 Richter, op. cit., p. 266, fig. 1837b (also fig. 1841, where Ptolemy wears the doublecrown of Egypt); Kyrieleis, op. cit., pp. 62–3, pl. 46, 5. He suggests that the subject might be Philometor's son Ptolemy VII (145 B.C.). Of course these rings might themselves portray Ptolemy Auletes.

29 ibid., pp. 75–8, pl. 68, 3 and 4 (sealings), 1 and 2 (coins).

30 On Caesar's portraits see Vollenweider, M. L., Die Porträtgemmen der römischen Republik, Text (Mainz, 1974), pp. 120–35Google Scholar, Katalog und Tafeln (Mainz, 1972)Google Scholar, pls. 75–86. Crawford, M. H., Roman Republican Coinage (Cambridge, 1974), pp. 487–95, pls. LVI–LVII. Our coin (pl. LXIIId) corresponds to Type 480/5.Google Scholar

31 On the suggestion that the gem-cutter Heius worked for Caesar see Vollenweider, M. L., ‘Un symbole des buts politiques de César’, Genava, n.s. xviii (1970), 4961.Google Scholar See Smith, R. R. R., ‘Greeks, foreigners and Roman Republican portraits’, J.R.S. LXXI (1981), 2438Google Scholar, on the different approach of Greek artists to portraying Greeks and Romans (to them, foreigners).

32 Henig, M., A Corpus of Roman Engraved Gemstonesfrom British Sites, B.A.R. Brit. Ser. 8, 2nd edn. (Oxford, 1978), nos. 289 (Caerleon: Nereid) and 467 (Edinburgh: Alexander the Great).Google Scholar

33 ibid., nos. 355 (Serapis) and 359 (Isis: see Boon, G., ‘An Isiac intaglio from Wroxeter rediscovered’, Antiq. J. LXII (1982), 356).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

34 The context is described by T.T.-B., the coin by J.P.C.K. and the firesteel by M.W. The objects were kindly exhibited by Dr. Richard Reece, F.S.A.

35 Reinhart, W., ‘Die Münzen des tolosanischen Reiches der Westgoten’, Deutsches Jahrbuch für Numismatik (1938), 107–35Google Scholar; Gentilhomme, P. le, ‘Le monnayage et la circulation monétaire dans les royaumes barbares en Occident (Ve–VIIIe siècle)’, Revue numismatique (1943), 45112Google Scholar; Lafaurie, J., ‘Numismatique romaine et médiévale’, in Ann. de l'École Pratique des Hautes Études (1973), 326–9.Google Scholar

36 Kent, J. P. C., ‘Un monnayage irrégulier du début du Ve siècle de notre ère’, Bulletin du Cercle d'Études Numismatiques (Jan.—Mar. 1974), 23–9.Google Scholar

37 Majorian, Novel VII, 14.

38 Sidonius Apollinaris, Carmina, 23.

39 Bruce-Mitford, R., The Sutton Hoo Ship-Burial, I (London, 1975), pp. 665–6, nos. 21–4.Google Scholar

40 Revd.Douglas, J., Nenia Britannica (1793), pp. 610Google Scholar, pl. 2; these coins have also a garbled entry in R. Bruce-Mitford, op. cit., p. 667, no. 43a. For this Gallic coinage, see Kent, J. P. C., ‘The end of Roman Britain: the literary and numismatic evidence reviewed’, in Casey, P. J. (ed.), The End of Roman Britain, B.A.R. Brit. Ser. 71 (Oxford, 1979), p. 25.Google Scholar

41 Brown, D., ‘Firesteels and pursemounts again’, Banner Jahrbb. CLXXVII (1977), 451–77, at 460–1, fig. 7.Google Scholar

42 Welch, M., contribution to ‘The Finds’, in Cunliffe, B. (ed.), Excavations at Porchester Castle, II, Saxon, Res. Rep. Soc. Antiq. London, XXXIII (1976), pp. 195–7Google Scholar, fig. 129, pl. XVIIIa opp. p. 84, fig. 63; Dickinson, T. M., ‘On the origin and chronology of the Early Anglo-Saxon disc brooch’, in Hawkes, S. C., Brown, D. and Campbell, J. (eds.), Anglo-Saxon Studies in Archaeology and History, I, B.A.R. Brit. Ser. 72 (Oxford, 1979), pp. 3980.Google Scholar

43 Brown, op. cit. (n. 41), 461; Evison, V. I., ‘Early Anglo-Saxon inlaid metalwork’, Antiq. J. XXXV (1955) 2045, at 39, no. 24, pl. VIf.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

44 Evison, V. I., The Fifth-century Invasions South of the Thames (London, 1965), p. 51, fig. 23b—e.Google Scholar

45 Brown, op. cit. (n. 41), 461–2, fig. 4.

46 Pirling, R., Das römische-fränkische Gräberfeld von Krefeld-Gellep (Berlin, 1966), p. 209, pl. X.Google Scholar

47 Evison, op. cit. (n. 43), 38–9, no. 19, pl. VIa; Swanton, M. J., The Spearheads of the Anglo-Saxon Settlements (London, 1973)Google Scholar, fig. 83a—c; Welch, M., Early Anglo-Saxon Sussex, B.A.R. Brit. Ser. 112 (Oxford, 1983), fig. 94a—c.Google Scholar

48 Brown, op. cit. (n. 41), 460, fig. 6.

49 Golvin, L., ‘Sur quelques mortiers de bronze trouvés récemment à proximité de la côte oranaise’, Annales de l'Institut des Études Orientales de l'Université d'Alger, XX (1962), 241–76.Google Scholar

50 Antiq.J. LXI (1981), 339–40.Google Scholar

51 J. Paul Getty Journal, x (1982)Google Scholar: B. B. Fredericksen, 21–38, and J. Fletcher, 39–44.

52 Apollo (Feb. 1982), 87–93.

53 I am grateful to Mr. J. K. Burras of the Botanic Garden, Oxford, for confirming the identification of pomegranate.

54 Lefroy of Cambray, a Supplement (1961), p. 72, privately printed.

55 For Cnidian Relief Ware and lamps see Heres, G. in Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Forschungen und Berichte, X (1968), 185211CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bailey, D. M. in R.C.R.F. Acta, XIV–XV (19721973), 1125Google Scholar and xix–xx (1979), 257–72; Hayes, J. W., Late Roman Pottery (London, 1972), pp. 411–12.Google Scholar

56 Gallia, XX (1962), 688, figs. 3 and 4, from Sénèmes (Aix-en-Provence).Google Scholar

57 Bailey, D. M. in Antike Kunst, XVIII (1975), 6771.Google Scholar

58 Several of these are published in the paper mentioned in nte 57 above; others include A.J.A. LXXVII (1973), 415Google Scholar, n. 7, from Cnidus; Bull. Inst. Class. Stud., xxv (1978)Google Scholar, pl. 1, from Datça; Opuscula Atheniensia, VI (1965), pl. x, 217Google Scholar, from Cyprus; Oziol, T., Salamine de Chypre, VII, Les lampes du Musée de Chypre (Paris, 1977)Google Scholar, nos. 645–6; inv. no. 15.2.27 from the Kerameikos in Athens, unpublished; Adelt, xxvii (1972)Google Scholar, pl. 58, from Chalcis; Jahrbuch für Altertümskunde, IV (1910), 22Google Scholar, fig. 22 from Zara; Williams, H., Kenchreai, v, The Lamps (Leiden, 1981)Google Scholar, no. 467; Bernabo-Brea, L. and Cavalier, M., Meligunìs-Lipára, II (Palermo, 1965), pl. CCXXXI, 29Google Scholar, from Lipari; complete and fragmentary examples in Ostia Museum, unpublished; Carandini, A. (ed.), L'lnstrumentum Domesticum di Ercolano e Pompei (Rome, 1977), pl. XLIX, from Herculaneum.Google Scholar

59 For example, one from Cnidus (A.J.A. LXXVII (1973), 415, n. 7); one from Herculaneum (Carandini, op. cit.); British Museum reg. no. 1973.4–14.1.Google Scholar

60 Antiq. J. xxxvii (1957), pl. XIII, 35.Google Scholar

61 Crane, F., Extant Medieval Musical Instruments: a Provisional Catalogue of Types (Iowa City, 1972).Google Scholar

62 E.g. Hinton, D. A., Medieval Pottery of the Oxford Region (Oxford, 1973), p. 14.Google Scholar

63 Hurst, J. G., ‘Imported pottery from the Saintonge’, in Evison, V. I., Hodges, H. and Hurst, J. G. (eds.), Medieval Pottery from Excavations (London, 1974), pp. 253–4.Google Scholar

64 Lincoln Archaeological Trust prepared a full note on the microscopic inclusions of the fabric, and this will be lodged with the whistle itself in Lincoln Museum.

65 R. H. Healey, ‘Medieval and Sub-Medieval Pottery in Lincolnshire’, unpublished M. Phil, thesis, University of Nottingham, pp. 18–38.

66 Smith, C. Roach, Catalogue of the Museum of London Antiquities (London, 1854), p. 118Google Scholar, no. 603; Hobson, R. L., Catalogue of the Collection of English Pottery in the Department of British and Medieval Antiquities and Ethnography of the British Museum (London, 1903), p. 84, no. B228.Google Scholar

67 S. Moorhouse, personal communication.

68 Hellebrandt, H., ‘Raerener Steinzeug’, Aachener Beiträge für Baugeschichte und Heimatkunst, IV (1977), 153–4.Google Scholar

70 Boels, P.C.J.A., Friesland tot de elfde eeuw (2nd edn., The Hague, 1951), pp. 450 and 549.Google Scholar

71 Dunning, G. C., ‘The trade in medieval pottery around the North Sea', in Renaud, J. G. N. (ed.), Rotterdam Papers, I (1968), pp. 3558, at 36–38.Google Scholar

72 Hurst, op. cit. (note 63).

73 Mytum, H., ‘A pottery bird whistle from Warwick’, Post-Med. Arch. XII (1978), 129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

74 Platt, C. and Coleman-Smith, R., Excavations at Medieval Southampton 1953–1969 (Leicester, 1975), p. 973, no. 1090.Google Scholar

75 Brears, P. C. D., The Collector's Book of English Country Pottery (Newton Abbot, 1974), pp. 172–5.Google Scholar

76 Butler, L. A. S., ‘A bird whistle from Roche Castle, Carmarthenshire’, Med. Arch. XVII (1973), 134–5 and fig. 54.Google Scholar

77 Martensson, A. W., ‘Legökar’, Kulturen (1960), 5571.Google Scholar

78 Hurst, J. G., ‘Langerwehe stoneware of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries’, in Apted, M. R., Gilyard-Beer, R. and Saunders, A. D. (eds.), Ancient Monuments and their Interpretation: Essays Presented to A. J. Taylor (London, 1977). pp. 219–38, at p. 234.Google Scholar

79 Douce, F., Illustrations of Shakespear and of Ancient Manners: with Dissertations on the Clowns and Fools of Shakespear…, 2 vols. (London, 1807)Google Scholar, pls. 2–7; Chambers, E. K., The Medieval Stage, I (Oxford, 1903), p. 384.Google Scholar

80 Collier, J. P. (ed.), Fools and Jesters: with a Reprint of Robert Armin's Nest of Ninnies of 1608 (London, Shakespear Society, 1842)Google Scholar; F. Bobertag (ed.), Sebastian Brant's Narrenschiff (Berlin, n.d.); Pompen, Fr. Aurelius, The English Versions of the Ship of Fools (London 1925).Google Scholar

81 E.g. The Seven Deadly Sins (c. 1475), or The Ship of Fools (c. 1480–90).

82 E.g. The Flight between Carnival and Lent (1559), and on his drawings, illustrated in Hughes, R., The Complete Paintings of Bruegel (London, 1969)Google Scholar and Münz, L., Bruegel: the Drawings (London, 1961).Google Scholar

83 Chambers, loc. cit. (note 79). (The use of this uniform or habit de fou appears to have been restricted to the court or professional fool and was not a part of the mock ceremonial of the ecclesiastical or guild ‘Feast of Fools’ celebrated on or near New Year's Day: ibid., pp. 372–89.)

84 Doran, J., History of Court Fools (London, 1858), pp. 311 and 325.Google Scholar

85 Chambers, op. cit. (note 79), p. 385.

86 British Museum, A Guide to the Medieval Room (Oxford, 1907), p. 44 and fig. 37.Google Scholar

87 Rix, M. M., ‘The metal head of a jester's bauble’, Trans. Birmingham Warwicks. Arch. Soc. LXXIV (1956), 62, n. ii.Google Scholar

88 Welsford, E., The Fool (London, 1935), p. 144: from the Douce portfolio 142, leaf 478 no. 480.Google Scholar

89 We wish to thank Mr. David Neal, F.S.A., for his drawing of the Raeren whistle, Mr. Tim Grogan of the Department of Geography, Birmingham University, for drawing the others. Dr. P. C. Buckland, Dr. L. Adams-Gilmour, Dr. G. C. Coppack, F.S.A., Dr. P. Dixon, F.S.A., Mr. S. Moorhouse and Mrs. J. Young for their comments.

90 Schmidt, P. K. and Burgess, C. B., The Axes of Scotland and Northern England, Prähistorische Bronzefunde, IX, 7 (Munich, 1981), pp. 191–7.Google Scholar

91 Eogan, G., ‘The Bronze Age in Ireland in the light of recent research’, P.P.S. XXX (1964), 268351, at p. 293.Google Scholar

92 Hartmann, A., ‘Irish and British gold types and their West German counterparts’, in Ryan, M. (ed.), The Origins of Metallurgy in Atlantic Europe: Proceedings of the Fifth Atlantic Colloquium (Dublin, 1978), pp. 215–28, at p. 222.Google Scholar

93 MacLaren, J. M., ‘The occurrence of gold in Great Britain and Ireland’, Trans. Inst. Mining Engineers, XXV (1903), 435508Google Scholar; Taylor, J. J., Bronze Age Goldwork of the British Isles (Cambridge, 1980), p. 141.Google Scholar

94 Benton, S., ‘The Excavation of the Sculptor's Cave, Covesea, Morayshire’, Proc. Soc. Antiq. Scot., LXV (1931), 177216, at pp. 182–4.Google Scholar

95 Blundell, J. D. and Longworth, I. H., ‘A Bronze Age hoard from Portfield Farm, Whalley, Lancashire’, Brit. Mus. Quart. XXXII (1968), 814.Google Scholar

96 Britton, D. and Longworth, I. H., ‘Late Bronze Age finds in the Heathery Burn Cave, Co. Durham’, Inv. Arch. 9th set: G.B. 55 (1968), sheet 1, no. 5.Google Scholar

97 , V.C.H., Kent, I (1908), p. 338 and pl. opp. p. 336 (wrongly captioned).Google Scholar

98 Armstrong, E. C. R., Catalogue of Irish Gold Ornaments in the Collection of the Royal Irish Academy (Dublin, 1920), p. 94 and pl. XVIII, no. 384.Google Scholar

99 Hartmann, A., Prähistorische Goldfunde aus Europa (Berlin, 1970), pp. 92–3, no. AU 1105.Google Scholar

100 Eluère, C., L'âge du Bronze en France, II, Les ors préhistoriques (Paris, 1982), p. 112 and figs. 131–2, 170.Google Scholar

101 Daugas, J. P., ‘Les civilizations de l'âge du Bronze dans le Massif Central’, in Guilaine, J. (ed.), La préhistoirefrançaise, II (Paris, C.N.R.S., 1976), p. 514 and pl. 5, p. 517; Eluère, op. cit., fig. 109, p. 93.Google Scholar

102 I am indebted to the Coroner for the West Clwyd District, Mr. Bryan Lewis; his officer, Sergeant Ron Williams; the finder, Mr. Colin Keeley; and the landowner, Mr. John Floyd, for their assistance with my investigation of the circumstances of discovery. Dr. Ian Longworth, F.S.A., kindly made arrangements for the gold finds to be analysed by Mr. Michael Cowell in the British Museum's Research Laboratory. I am indebted also to Dr. Peter Northover for his analysis of the bronze axe. Mrs. Sheila Hopkin, Mr. Stuart Needham, Dr. Colin Shell, Mr. B. J. N. Edwards, F.S.A., and Dr. Glenys Lloyd-Morgan, F.S.A., have all given help and advice in the preparation of this note. The drawings were executed by Paul Hughes and Paul White.

103 Petersen, J., De Norske Vikingesverd (Oslo, 1919), pp. 156–67.Google Scholar