Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-c9gpj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-11T12:20:42.744Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Exeter Cathedral: A Conjectural Restoration of the Fourteenth-Century Altar-Screen,1 Part I

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 January 2012

Extract

The early years of the fourteenth century were memorable ones in the history of Exeter Cathedral, for work on the new presbytery, or novum opus as it is called in the Fabric Rolls, was in progress. When Bishop Bytton died, in 1307, building operations had reached an advanced stage, and the task of completing the work devolved upon his successor, Walter de Stapledon, a Devon man and at the time of his election precentor of the cathedral. At that date the presbytery vaulting was finished, with the exception of its colouring, and the windows were glazed. The transformed chancel of the Norman church was nearly ready to receive the stalls, but the Norman apse still separated the old and new parts of the building. In 1309–10 ‘John of Glastonbury’ was engaged in removing the stalls to the new quire, but we find no record of the date when the linking-up of the Norman building with the new work took place. The Fabric Roll of the following year records a visit of ‘Master William de Schoverwille’, master mason of Salisbury, to inspect the new work: from this we may infer that a stage had been reached when important decisions were pending—the furnishing of the chancel, the building of the altar-screen, and the addition of a triforium arcade and clerestory gallery to the newly built presbytery—and it may have been these undertakings which prompted the chapter to seek expert advice.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1943

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 122 note 2 Episcopal Registers (ed. Hingeston-Randolph), Stapledon, pref., p. ix.

page 122 note 3 Fabric Roll (F., p. 76). Dr. Oliver's version of this—‘To John of Glaston, for removing the former walls’ (F.R., O., p. 380) is evidently an oversight in proof reading: ‘stip. mag. Joh. de Glaston ad removend. stallos per 14 sept., 52s. 6d.’

page 123 note 1 F.R., 1310–11 (Sir W. H. St. J. H.).

page 123 note 2 When first built the clerestory windows in the presbytery had deep splayed sills, but they were altered ‘within a year or so’ by the addition of a clerestory gallery. Traces of the alterations are still visible (The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 41).

page 123 note 3 Ibid., pp. 52–3.

page 123 note 4 Abstract of the Chapter Acts, Rev. H. E. Reynolds, pp. 22–63.

page 123 note 5 3 and 4 Edw. VI, cap. x.

page 123 note 6 Abstract Chapter Acts (ut supra), p. 52.

page 124 note 1 Trans. Exeter Diocesan Architectural Society, vol. i, p. 34. Letter from Elizabeth's Commissioners to the D. and C. of Bristol, 21 Dec. 1561 (printed in The Principles of Gothic Architecture, Bloxham, pp. 223–4).

page 124 note 2 D. and C. Act Book, p. 125.

page 124 note 3 ‘… in capella fere de novo constructa juxta capellam beate Marie in ecclesia nostra cathedrali Exonie ex parte australi, ubi locum elegimus sepulture’ (D. and C. Records, Hist. MSS. Com. Report, p. 71).

page 124 note 4 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 83.

page 124 note 5 ‘Caput vero episcopi missum fuit dominae reginae apud Bristolliam’ (Annales Paulini, Chronicles of Edw. I and Edw. II, vol. i, p. 316).

page 124 note 6 ‘… ductum fuit ad quandam ecclesiam Sanctorum Innocentium quae prope fuit praedictam ecclesiam Sancti Clementis [Dacorum], derelictam et omnino destructam, et ibidem fuit sine capite humatum. Sed postea, ex procuratione decani et capituli Exoniensis, dictum corpus exhumatum fuit ex praedicto loco et deportatum Exoniam, videlicet xiii Kalendas Martii’ (Annales Paulini, Chronicles of Edw. I and Edw. II, vol. i, p. 316).

page 124 note 7 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, p. 62.

page 125 note 1 Episcopal Registers (ed. H.-R.), Stapledon, pref., pp. xxxii–iii.

page 125 note 2 E.D.A.S., Trans., iii, 145.

page 125 note 3 Bartholomew de Sancto Laurencio (Episcopal Registers, ed. H.-R., Grandisson, pt. i, pref., p. vii).

page 125 note 4 Ibid., pt. iii, p. xi.

page 125 note 5 Appointed custodian of spiritualities and commissioned to institute to all vacant benefices (Episcopal Registers, ed. H.-R., Grandisson, pt. i, pref., p. xi).

page 125 note 6 About 25th March 1327: died 24th June 1327, and left no register (ibid., pt. i, pref., p. xi).

page 125 note 7 Ibid., pt. iii, p. 172.

page 125 note 8 Ibid., pt. iii, pref., p. xxii.

page 126 note 1 An illustration in Parker's Glossary (1840), pl. 64, has the interrogatory caption, ‘Bishop Stapledon? Exeter Cathedral’. It shows the effigy of a bishop, apparently Stapledon, under the canopy of Sir Richard Stapledon's tomb, with feet towards the west. Britton (1826), pl. xvii, shows Sir Richard's tomb and the attendant figures as they exist to-day.

page 126 note 2 Possibly by Kendall: ‘additional work at the base of the stalls [sedilia] and tomb’ is mentioned in the account for his altar-screen (p. 253).

page 128 note 1 Stapledon was Lord Treasurer in Edward II's reign. An ‘Ordinance by the Dean and Chapter admitting Edward II and Isobella his queen and their children to the fraternity of the church’, 25 March 1315, is noted in the Report on the D. and C. Records, Hist. MSS. Com., p. 75.

page 128 note 2 History of the Cathedral Church, Exeter, p. 135 and note. The preface of the book suggests a probable explanation: Britton complains of discourtesy experienced in Exeter, and returned to London leaving his three helpers to complete the investigations for his book. Britton may never have seen the figure and have trusted the description given him.

page 129 note 1 Shown in pl. ix, History of the Cathedral Church, Exeter, Britton. These walls were removed by Sir Gilbert Scott by direction of the dean and chapter, but much against his will.

page 129 note 2 The objects were: pieces of the vine-leaf cresting of the tomb; a small fragment of a late rendering of a trefoil leaf, probably fourteenth century; a small fragment of a medieval glazed paving tile (too small to distinguish the pattern or date); a carved acorn (stone) about 2 in. long; several cusp terminations sawn off the parclose screen; a small piece of deal with a charred end, and a fragment of rush similar to those used for seating chairs.

page 129 note 3 F.R. (O., p. 390).

page 130 note 1 History of Exeter, p. 257. Jenkins writes as if the entablature still existed in 1806, but he was frequently inaccurate. Stapledon's Inn and Hart's Hall, Oxford, afterwards Exeter College, were founded by Stapledon (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 57).

page 130 note 2 History of Devon, vol. ii, pp. 5, 6.

page 130 note 3 Op. cit., 4707.

page 130 note 4 Op. cit., p. 60. This MS. is in the possession of Mr. D. R. Palmer, formerly head verger of the cathedral, to whom we are indebted for the use of it. Jones was a well-known local antiquary; his MS. is dated 1787, but marginal notes, signed and dated 1805, were added. Jones died in 1821 (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, pref., p. vi, note).

page 130 note 5 Ibid., p. 56.

page 130 note 6 Jones MS., p. 60.

page 131 note 1 Ibid.

page 131 note 2 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 56.

page 131 note 3 The celebrant sat nearest to the altar; the others in the order named. After the Council of Trent the order was modified: ‘In missa item solemni celebrans medius inter diaconum et sub-diaconum sedere potest a cornu epistolae juxta altare cum cantatur Kyrie eleison, Gloria in excelsis, et Credo.’ (Quoted in Gothic Architecture, Bloxham, p. 183.)

page 131 note 4 Laud's Works, vol. v, pt. ii, p. 495.

page 131 note 5 Gleanings, Cotton, pt. ii, pp. 8–9.

page 131 note 6 ‘A Short Survey of the Western Counties’ (Chope's Tours in Devon and Cornwall p. 89).

page 132 note 1 Freeman, it has been suggested, was mistaken in his translation of ‘frettenda’: Baxter and Johnson, Med. Lat. Word List, where fretto = ‘embroider’, ‘ornament’.

page 132 note 2 The Architectural History of Exeter Cathedral, p. 39.

page 132 note 3 The word cathedra is used in the 1506 Inventory to describe the chairs for the directors of the quire—‘4 cathedre ligni volubiles cooperta cum coreo’, ‘pro rectoribus chori’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 329).

page 132 note 4 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 54.

page 132 note 5 ‘The Travels of Cosmo III, Grand Duke of Tuscany, through England’, L. Magalotti, 1669 (Chope's Tour, p. 108). The chair has now been replaced by a reading desk.

page 132 note 6 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, pp. 55, 56.

page 132 note 7 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, p. 389.

page 132 note 8 The Architectural History of Exeter Cathedral, p. 41.

page 132 note 9 F.R. 1323–4 (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 133 note 1 The Architectural History of Exeter Cathedral, pp. 40, 41.

page 133 note 2 F.R. 1323–4 (W. H. St.J. H.).

page 133 note 3 Op. cit., p. 3.

page 133 note 4 D. and C.N. and Q., xv, 266–7.

page 133 note 5 Archaeologia, lxvi, 377 et seq.; Wells, The Cathedral Church and See, Dearmer, p. 127.

page 134 note 1 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 98.

page 134 note 2 The full report is not yet published.

page 134 note 3 Op. cit., fo. 5b.

page 134 note 4 The painting of the masonry makes the jointing difficult to follow in places.

page 135 note 1 English Church Monuments, A.D. 1150–1550, Crossley, p. 163. The date of the Harewell tomb is given as 1386, or about 60 years later than the Exeter lions.

page 135 note 2 Note given to the author by Prebendary Bishop.

page 135 note 3 Letter dated 17th January 1937.

page 135 note 4 Devonshire, Thomas Dugdale, vol. ii, p. 132.

page 136 note 1 Pl. xxii in Kendall's book, An Elucidation of the Principles of English Architecture, shows a fragment of a moulded arch, but it is drawn most unconvincingly.

page 137 note 1 Laud's Works, vol. v, pt. ii, p. 495.

page 137 note 2 D. and C. Act Book, 1639, p. 155.

page 137 note 3 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 61.

page 137 note 4 The Ancient Diocese of Exeter, Reynolds, p. 292.

page 137 note 5 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 210.

page 137 note 6 The Building of Exeter Cathedral (ut supra), p. 57.

page 137 note 7 Op. cit., pls. XIX–XXIII.

page 137 note 8 Op. cit., p. 179.

page 137 note 9 Devon Evening Express, 7th October 1872.

page 138 note 1 Western Times, 5th May 1873; Exeter Gazette, 19th October 1877.

page 138 note 2 Op. cit., p. 160.

page 138 note 3 In the possession of Prebendary Bishop.

page 138 note 4 Chope's Tours, p. 89.

page 138 note 5 History of Exeter Cathedral, p. 40.

page 139 note 1 F.R. 1319–20 (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 139 note 2 Ibid., 1317–18 (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 139 note 3 History of Exeter Cathedral, p. 40.

page 139 note 4 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, p. 53.

page 139 note 5 F.R. (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 139 note 6 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 112.

page 140 note 1 See illustration in the original script of paper.

page 140 note 2 The Cathedral Churches of England, Hamilton Thompson, p. 116.

page 140 note 3 The Cathedral Church of Exeter, Hewett, p. 29.

page 140 note 4 Ancient Holy Week Ceremonial, Feasey, p. 136 (reference kindly given by Miss Lega-Weekes).

page 140 note 5 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 59.

page 140 note 6 Op. cit., 3678, fo. 56.

page 142 note 1 Hist. Cathedral Church, Exeter, Britton, note, p. 98.

page 142 note 2 F.R. (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 142 note 3 Abstract Chapter Acts (ed. Reynolds), p. 88. The offerings for four days in Whitsun week, 1524, amounted to 3d.; of which the chapter clerk had 1d., and the minor officials ‘fractions of the same’.

page 142 note 4 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 322.

page 142 note 5 Devonshire Association, Transactions, xix, 676.

page 142 note 6 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 209.

page 142 note 7 Leland's Itinerary, vol. iii, p. 66.

page 142 note 8 ‘Tres cruces nove deaurate et emalate, quarum una est cum tabula argenti ultra magnum altare’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 311).

page 142 note 9 ‘How Exeter Cathedral was Built’ (Architectural Review, xiii, pp. 114–15).

page 142 note 10 Privy Council Acts, N.S., 1542–7, p. 539.

page 143 note 1 ‘1 pixis auri cooperati pendens super magnum altare pro Corpore Dominico intus pervando [sic], ponderis 3 uncias et dimidium quartern’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 320). ‘1 capa argentea et deaurata pro dicta pixida coŏperienda, ponderis 26 unc.’ (ibid.).

page 143 note 2 F.R. (O., p. 385).

page 143 note 3 F. R. (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 143 note 4 Op. cit., iii, 197. ‘Practical Considerations on the Gothic or English Altar and certain Dependent Ornaments’, J. N. Comper.

page 143 note 5 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 323.

page 143 note 6 Ibid., p. 324.

page 143 note 7 F.R. (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 143 note 8 Durham Cathedral, Greenwell, p. 63.

page 143 note 9 Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 324.

page 143 note 10 F.R., 1505–6 (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 144 note 1 Abstract Chapter Acts (ed. Reynolds), p. 56 (1388).

page 144 note 2 Ibid.

page 144 note 3 Ibid., p. 58 (1398).

page 144 note 4 ‘1 fronta cum frontella cum tuello eidem annexo de manuali opere aureo unius secte, cum Ymagine beate Marie in medio dicti frontis ac diversis aliis ymaginibus, cum armis Johannis de Grandissono in utroque fine, pro summo altare in festis principalibus’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, pp. 325–6; 1906 inventory).

page 144 note 5 ‘1 fronta de albo satino pro eodem altari, operata cum quinque ymaginibus episcoporum ac octoarmis predicti Johannis de Grandissono, ex dono ejusdem’ (ibid., p. 326). ‘1 frontella de panno aureo operata cum leonibus et undecim armis predicti Johannis de Grandissono, cum tuello eidem annexo’ (ibid.).

page 144 note 6 ‘1 fronta de rubio satino operata cum quindecim diversis ymaginibus aureis et 28 armis diversorum Dominorum, ex dono Walteri Stapledon’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, pp. 325–6).

page 144 note 7 ‘Unum frontale rubrum cum ymaginibus Sancte Trinitatis et 12 Apostolorum, pro memorali Domini Walteri de Stapledon, nuper Exoniensis Episcopi, pro magno altari’ (ibid., p. 318; 1327 inventory).

page 144 note 8 ‘1 fronta de blodio satino cum crucifixo, Maria et Johnanne de auro in medio, operata cum diversis stellis aureis, et 1 frontella de panno aureo eidem annexa, cum 1 tuello similiter annexo’ (ibid., p. 330).

page 144 note 9 ‘1 fronta de blodio satino cum ymaginibus Sanctorum Edmundi et Thome Cantuariensis de auro, operata cum diversis stellis aureis, et 1 frontella de panno aureo cum tuella eidem annexo’ (ibid., p. 330; 1506 inventory).

page 144 note 10 ‘1 carpet, continens in longitudine 3 virgas quarteria et in latitudine i virga dimidium, ex dono Domine Elizabeth Courtenay, operis cheeky’ (ibid., p. 328).

page 145 note 1 ‘1 pannus de Arys de historia Ducis Burgundie, continens in longitudine 10 virgas dimidium et in latitudine 4 virgas, ex dono executorum Edmundi Lacey’ (Lives of the Bishops of Exeter, Oliver, p. 328).

page 145 note 2 ‘3 panni blodii cum rosis albis et armis Domini Johannis de G., pro frontispicio magni altaris tempore Quadragesimali coŏperiendo, de dono ejusdem’ (ibid.).

page 145 note 3 ‘Duo panni vocati le “Lent cloth” [sic] unius sortis cum scriptura in summitate, “Querite dominum dum”, &c.' (ibid., p. 350).

page 145 note 4 1 pila cuprea deaurata pro summo altari ad manus celebrantis califaciendas’ (ibid., p. 323).

page 145 note 5 The Cathedral Churches of England, Hamilton Thompson, p. 59.

page 145 note 6 ‘Old St. Paul's and Exeter’ (H.E.B.), Cathedral Bulletin, October 1937, p. 9.

page 146 note 1 The Building of Exeter Cathedral, Bishop and Prideaux, p. 68.

page 146 note 2 F.R. (W. H. St. J. H.).

page 146 note 3 ‘How Exeter Cathedral was Built’, Lethaby (Architectural Review, xiii, p. 176).

page 146 note 4 Durham Cathedral, Greenwell, p. 61.

page 146 note 5 Op. cit., pl. ix.

page 146 note 6 Cathedral Church of Durham.

page 146 note 7 In medieval times colour was applied heraldically; primary colours being separated by metal—gold or silver—or a black line, the appearance of mingling colours, which otherwise would have resulted from their juxtaposition, being thus avoided.

page 147 note 1 Episcopal Registers (ed. H.-R.), Grandisson, vol. i, p. 435.