Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-22dnz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T02:22:10.724Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

BROTHERLY RIVALS: TEMPLARS, HOSPITALLERS AND THE ARCHITECTURAL EXPANSION OF THE TEMPLE CHURCH IN LONDON

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 November 2020

Zachary Stewart
Zachary Stewart*
Affiliation:
Department of Architecture, Texas A&M University, TAMU 3137, College Station, TX77843, USA. Email: zstewart@arch.tamu.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Temple Church, founded as the chapel of the motherhouse of the English Templars around 1160, is among the most intriguing medieval churches in London. Utilising a wide range of textual, archaeological and architectural evidence, this paper provides a new account of the evolution of the ecclesiastical complex from the mid-twelfth century to the mid-thirteenth century, focusing in particular on the form and the function of a series of now largely obliterated auxiliary structures. It argues that one of the driving forces for the construction of these buildings was a competition for both patrons and prestige that existed between the two preeminent military orders of the period: the Templars and the Hospitallers.

Keywords

Knights TemplarLondon Temple Churchecclesiastical architecture
Type
Research paper
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 101 , September 2021 , pp. 235 - 268
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Society of Antiquaries of London

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Manuscript sources

BL, Cotton ms Nero E vi Google Scholar
TNA, E 358/20, rot 3Google Scholar

Primary printed sources

Calendar Charter Rolls. Vol. I: Henry III, AD 1226–1257, HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar
Curzon, H de (ed) 1886. La règle du Temple, Renouard, H Laurens, ParisGoogle Scholar
Delaville Le Roulx, J (ed) 1897. Cartulaire général de l’Ordre des Hospitaliers de Saint Jean de Jérusalem (1100–1310). Tome deuxième (1201–1260), E Leroux, ParisGoogle Scholar
Dugdale, W (ed) 1846. Monasticon Anglicanum, vi, pt ii, J Bohn, LondonGoogle Scholar
Inderwick, F A (ed) 1896. A Calendar of the Inner Temple Records. Vol I: 21 Hen. VII. (1505)–45 Eliz. (1603), H Sotheran, LondonGoogle Scholar
Inderwick, F A (ed) 1898. A Calendar of the Inner Temple Records. Vol II: 1 James I. (1603)–Restoration (1660), H Sotheran, LondonGoogle Scholar
Ingpen, A R (ed) 1910. Master Worsley’s Book on the History and Constitution of the Honourable Society of the Middle Temple, Chiswick, LondonGoogle Scholar
Luard, H R (ed) 1877. Chronica Majora. Vol IV: AD 1240 to AD 1247, Longman, LondonGoogle Scholar
Raine, J (ed) 1872. The Register, or Rolls, of Walter Gray, Lord Archbishop of York, with Appendices of Illustrative Documents, Surtees Society lvi, DurhamGoogle Scholar
Rymer, T (ed) 1816. Foedera. Vol. I, pt. II: 1272–1307, LondonGoogle Scholar
Stow, J 1603. A Survey of London, 2nd edn, LondonGoogle Scholar
Vetusta Monumenta, v, 1835Google Scholar
Woods, H G (ed) 1905. Register of Burials at the Temple Church, 1628–1853, H Sotheran, LondonGoogle Scholar

Secondary printed sources

Addison, C G 1842. The History of the Knights Templars, the Temple Church, and the Temple, Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, London Google Scholar
Barber, M 1994. The New Knighthood: a history of the Order of the Temple, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar
Baylis, T H 1913. The Temple Church and Chapel of St Ann, etc, 4th edn, G Philip and Son, London Google Scholar
Billings, R W 1838. Architectural Illustrations and Account of the Temple Church, London, T and W Boone, London Google Scholar
Bilson, J 1895. ‘On the discovery of some remains of the chapter-house of Beverley Minster’, Archaeologia, 54, 425–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Binski, P 2004. Becket’s Crown: art and imagination in Gothic England, 1170–1350, Yale University Press, New Haven and London Google Scholar
Binski, P 2014. Gothic Wonder: art, artifice and the decorated style 1290–1350, Yale University Press, New Haven and London Google Scholar
Bond, F 1913. An Introduction to English Church Architecture from the Eleventh to the Sixteenth Century, H Milford, London Google Scholar
Bony, J 1979. The English Decorated Style: Gothic architecture transformed, 1250–1350, Cornell University Press, Ithaca Google Scholar
Borg, A 2018. ‘The military orders and the idea of the Holy Sepulchre’, in Griffith-Jones and Fernie 2018, 338–51Google Scholar
Britton, J 1807. The Architectural Antiquities of Great Britain, Vol. 1, Longman, Hurst, Rees and Orme, London Google Scholar
Butler, J 2005. Saxons, Templars and Lawyers in the Inner Temple: archaeological excavations in Church Court and Hare Court, Pre-Construct Archaeol Limited Monogr 4, LondonGoogle Scholar
Camden, W 1610. Britain (trans by P Holland), LondonGoogle Scholar
Clapham, A W 1934. English Romanesque Architecture after the Conquest, Clarendon, Oxford Google Scholar
Cockburn, J S, King, H P F and McDonnell, K G T 1969. The Victoria History of the County of Middlesex. Vol. 1, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Curzon, H de 1888. La maison du Temple de Paris, Hachette, Paris Google Scholar
Draper, P 2006. The Formation of English Gothic: architecture and identity, Yale University Press, New Haven and London Google Scholar
Essex, W R H and Smirke, S 1845. Illustrations of the Architectural Ornaments and Embellishments, and Painted Glass, of the Temple Church, London, J Weale, London Google Scholar
Fernie, E 2000. The Architecture of Norman England, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Forey, A 1992. The Military Orders: from the twelfth to the early fourteenth centuries, Macmillan, Houndmills, Basingstoke CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gardam, C M L 1990. ‘Restorations of the Temple Church, London’, in Grant, L (ed), Medieval Art, Architecture and Archaeology in London, Brit Archaeol Ass Conf Trans x, 101–17, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Gentleman’s Magazine, 1824, new ser, 17 (2), 127–8, 408–10Google Scholar
Gervers, M 1972. ‘Rotundae Anglicanae’, in Évolution générale et développements régionaux en histoire de l’art (Acts of the 22nd International Congress of the History of Art, Budapest, 1969), vol. 1, 359–76, Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest Google Scholar
Gervers, M 2002. ‘The commandery as an economic unit in England’, in Luttrell, A and Pressouyre, L (eds), La Commanderie: institution des ordres militaires dans l’Occident médiéval, 245–60, Comité des travaux historiques et scientifiques, Paris Google Scholar
Gervers, M 2018. ‘The use and meaning of the twelfth- and thirteenth-century round churches of England’, in Griffith-Jones and Fernie 2018, 376–86Google Scholar
Gilchrist, R 1995. Contemplation and Action: the other monasticism, Leicester University Press, London and New York Google Scholar
Godfrey, W H 1953. ‘Recent discoveries at the Temple, London, and notes on the topography of the site’, Archaeologia, 95, 123–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Griffith-Jones, R 2008. The Temple Church: a history in pictures, self-published, LondonGoogle Scholar
Griffith-Jones, R 2018. ‘The Temple Church in the Crusades’, in Griffith-Jones and Fernie 2018, 429–56Google Scholar
Griffith-Jones, R, and Fernie, E (eds) 2018. Tomb and Temple: re-imagining the sacred buildings of Jerusalem, Boydell, Woodbridge Google Scholar
Griffith-Jones, R and Park, D (eds) 2010. The Temple Church in London: history, architecture, art, Boydell, Woodbridge Google Scholar
Hamonic, N 2018. ‘Jerusalem in London: the New Temple church’, in Griffith-Jones and Fernie 2018, 387–412Google Scholar
Harrison, S and Barker, P 1999. ‘Ripon Minster: an archaeological analysis and reconstruction of the 12th-century church’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 152, 49–78 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harvey, R O (ed) 2011. History of the Middle Temple, Hart, Oxford and Portland, OR Google Scholar
Holder, N 2017. The Friaries of Medieval London: from foundation to dissolution, Boydell, Woodbridge Google Scholar
Honeybourne, M 1969. ‘The Temple precinct, London, in the days of the Knights Templars’, Trans Anc Monuments Soc, 16, 33–6Google Scholar
Hope, W H St John 1908. ‘The round church of the Knights Templars at Temple Bruer, Lincolnshire’, Archaeologia, 61, 177–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hope, W St John 1918. ‘Round-naved churches in England and their connexion with the orders of the Temple and of the Hospital of St John of Jerusalem’, Archaeol Cantiana, 33, 63–70 Google Scholar
Hundley, C E 2018. ‘The English round church movement’, in Griffith-Jones and Fernie 2018, 352–75Google Scholar
Jansen, V 2010. ‘Light and pure: the Templars’ new choir’, in Griffith-Jones and Park 2010, 45–71Google Scholar
Kedar, B Z 1982. ‘The patriarch Eraclius’, in Kedar, B Z, Mayer, H E and Smail, R C (eds), Outremer: studies in the history of the Crusading Kingdom of Jerusalem presented to Joshua Prawer, 177–204, Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi Institute, Jerusalem Google Scholar
Krautheimer, R 1942. ‘Introduction to an “iconography of mediaeval architecture”’, J Warburg Courtauld Inst, 5, 1–33 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewer, D and Dark, R 1997. The Temple Church in London, Historical Publications, London Google Scholar
Luxford, J M 2005. The Art and Architecture of English Benedictine Monasteries, 1300–1500: a patronage history, Boydell, Woodbridge Google Scholar
McDowall Esdaile, K A 1933. Temple Church Monuments, Being a Report to the Two Honourable Societies of the Temple, G Barber and Son, London Google Scholar
Milner, L 2013. ‘The Canterbury vestiarium: why did it combine the roles of treasury and cemetery arch?’, in Bovey, A (ed), Medieval Art, Architecture and Archaeology at Canterbury, Brit Archaeol Ass Conf Trans xxxv, 217–27, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Milner, L 2016. ‘St Faith’s chapel at Westminster Abbey: the significance of its design, decoration and location’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 169, 71–94 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Milner, L 2017. ‘Lincoln Cathedral treasure house’, Antiq J, 97, 205–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicholson, H 1993. Templars, Hospitallers and Teutonic Knights: images of the military orders, 1128–1291, Leicester University Press, Leicester Google Scholar
Nicholson, H 2001. The Knights Hospitaller, Boydell, Woodbridge Google Scholar
Nicholson, H 2010. ‘At the heart of medieval London: the New Temple in the Middle Ages’, in Griffith-Jones and Park 2010, 1–18Google Scholar
Nicholson, H J 2013. ‘The military religious orders in the towns of the British Isles’, in Carraz, D (ed), Les Ordres Militaires dans la ville médiévale (1100–1350), 113–26, Presses Universitaires Blaise-Pascal, Clermont-Ferrand Google Scholar
Page, W 1909. The Victoria History of the County of London. Vol. 1, Constable and Company, London Google Scholar
Park, D 2010. ‘Medieval burials and monuments’, in Griffith-Jones and Park 2010, 67–91Google Scholar
Parker, T W 1963. The Knights Templars in England, University of Arizona Press, Tucson Google Scholar
RCHME 1959. City of Cambridge, Roy Comm Hist Monuments Engl Inventories, HMSO, London Google Scholar
RCHME 1985. County of Northamptonshire, Volume V: archaeology and churches in Northampton, Roy Comm Hist Monuments Engl Inventories, HMSO, London Google Scholar
Richardson, E 1843. The Monumental Effigies of the Temple Church, with an Account of Their Restoration, in the Year 1842, Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, London Google Scholar
Riley-Smith, J 2012. The Knights Hospitaller in the Levant, c 1070–1309, Palgrave Macmillan, London CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sandys, A 1925. ‘The financial and administrative importance of the London Temple in the thirteenth century’, in Little, A G and Powicke, F M (eds), Essays in Medieval History Presented to Thomas Frederick Tout, 147–62, printed for the subscribers, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
Sloane, B and Malcolm, G 2004. Excavations at the Priory of the Order of the Hospital of St John of Jerusalem, Clerkenwell, London, MoLAS monogr 20, London Google Scholar
Stein-Kecks, H 2004. ‘“Claustrum” and “capitulum”: some remarks on the façade and interior of the chapter house’, in Klein, P K (ed), Der mittelalterliche Kreuzgang: Architektur, Funktion und Programm, 157–89, Schnell and Steiner, Regensburg Google Scholar
Stewart, Z 2019. ‘A lesson in patronage: King Henry III, the Knights Templar, and a royal mausoleum at the Temple Church in London’, Speculum, 94 (2), 334–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Telfer, A 2002. ‘Locating the first Knights Templar church’, London Archaeol, 10 (1), 3–6 Google Scholar
Thompson, A H 1913. English Monasteries, Cambridge University Press, London Google Scholar
Weever, J 1631. Ancient Funeral Monuments, London Google Scholar
Williams, E 1927. Early Holborn and the Legal Quarter of London: a topographical survey of the beginnings of the district known as Holborn and of the Inns of Court and of Chancery, 2 vols, Sweet and Maxwell, London Google Scholar
Williamson, J B 1924. The History of the Temple, London, from the Institution of the Order of the Knights of the Temple to the Close of the Stuart Period, J Murray, London Google Scholar
Wilson, C 2010. ‘Gothic architecture transplanted: the nave of the Temple Church in London’, in Griffith-Jones and Park 2010, 19–43 Google Scholar
Worley, G 1911. The Church of the Knights Templars in London, 2nd edn, G Bell and Sons, London Google Scholar