No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Apostasy of a Prince: Hans Herzl and the Boundaries of Jewish Nationalism
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 April 2018
Abstract
When Hans Herzl, son of Theodor Herzl, converted to Christianity in 1924 and committed suicide in 1930, he challenged the boundaries of the Zionist movement. Zionist responses to Hans's conversion and suicide reveal underlying and conflicting assumptions regarding the religious, cultural, and ethnic boundaries of Jewish nationalism, both in the 1920s and 1930s, as well as in future Israeli state policy. This article traces responses in the press and among leadership of the World Zionist Organization to Hans's conversion, as well as subsequent reactions to his suicide. To some, Hans's anomalous life threatened Jewish unity and the Zionist movement; to others, Hans deserved not only a biography but a meaningful place in Zionist discourse. These conflicting definitions and priorities of Zionism in the 1920s and 1930s resurface within the legal and bureaucratic institutions of Israeli statehood, particularly in the 1962 Supreme Court case Rufeisen v. Ministry of the Interior.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Association for Jewish Studies 2018
References
1. Hans Herzl, “A Last Word,” Theodor Herzl Collection, H1\2365-18, Central Zionist Archive (CZA), Jerusalem.
2. Stern, Arthur, “The Genetic Tragedy of the Family of Theodor Herzl,” Israel Annals of Psychiatry and Related Disciplines 3 (April 1965): 99–116Google ScholarPubMed.
3. Hertz, Deborah, How Jews Became Germans (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2007), 199Google Scholar.
4. Ellenson, David, “The Orthodox Rabbinate and Apostasy,” in Jewish Apostasy in the Modern World, ed. Endelman, Todd M. (New York: Homes and Meier, 1987), 166Google Scholar.
5. Todd Endelman, introduction to Jewish Apostasy in the Modern World, 11.
6. Magnes, Shulamit, “Good Bad Jews: Converts, Conversion and Boundary Redrawing in Modern Russian Jewry, Notes toward a New Category,” in Boundaries of Jewish Identity, ed. Glenn, Susan A. and Sokoloff, Naomi B. (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2010)Google Scholar; Michael Stanislawski, “Jewish Apostasy in Russia: A Tentative Typology,” in Endelman, Jewish Apostasy, 189–205; and Schainker, Ellie, Confessions of the Shtetl: Converts from Judaism in Imperial Russia, 1817–1906 (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2006), 23Google Scholar.
7. Endelman, Jewish Apostasy, 11. Endelman notes, “it is impossible to be more precise.” Ruppin, Arthur, The Jews of Today (New York: Henry Holt, 1913), 183–84Google Scholar, estimated that there were more than 204,500 conversions in the nineteenth century.
8. Schainker, Confessions of the Shtetl.
9. Shenhav, Yehouda, “Modernity and the Hybridization of Nationalism and Religion: Zionism and the Jews of the Middle East as a Heuristic Case,” Theory and Society 36 (2001): 1–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar. As Talal Asad, Yehouda Shenhav, and Rogers Brubaker (among others) have demonstrated, religion and nationalism are by no means mutually exclusive, nor are they determinative. While the “modernization theory” posits that nationalism rose as a result of the diminution of religion, or its relegation to the private sphere, theorists like Talal Asad and Craig Calhoun have discredited this by demonstrating that the secular is as much a modern construct as the religious. Therefore, we cannot simply use “modernity” as an explanation for the origin or character of nationalism, let alone its relationship to religion. See Asad, Talal, Formations of the Secular: Christianity, Islam, Modernity (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2003)Google Scholar. For more on the complex functioning of religion and ethnicity in nationalist contexts, see Brubaker, Rogers, “Religion and Nationalism: Four Approaches,” Nations and Nationalism 18 (2012): 2–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar, Shenhav, Yehouda, Arab Jews: A Postcolonial Reading of Nationalism, Religion and Ethnicity (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2006)Google Scholar, and Zubrzycki, Genevieve, The Crosses of Auschwitz: Nationalism and Religion in Post-Communist Poland (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10. Viswanathan, Gauri, Outside the Fold: Conversion, Modernity and Belief (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1998), xiGoogle Scholar.
11. Viswanathan, Outside the Fold, 87.
12. Lamont, Michele and Molnar, Virag, “The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences,” Annual Review of Sociology 28 (2002): 167–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13. Luz, Ehud, “The Cultural Controversy,” in Parallels Meet: Religion and Nationalism in the Early Zionist Movement, trans. Schramm, Lenn J. (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1988)Google Scholar.
14. Shapiro, Yonatan, The Formative Years of the Israeli Labour Party: The Organization of Power 1919–1930 (London: Sage, 1976), 14Google Scholar.
15. Kimmerling, Baruch, “Religion, Nationalism, and Democracy in Israel,” Constellations 6 (1999): 347CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
16. Kimmerling, Baruch, “Between Hegemony and Dormant Kulturkampf in Israel,” Israel Affairs 4 (2007): 51–52Google Scholar.
17. For more on diversity of Zionist thought, see Shimoni, Gideon, The Zionist Ideology (Hanover, NH: University Press of New England for Brandeis University Press, 1995)Google Scholar; Avineri, Shlomo, The Making of Modern Zionism (New York: Basic Books, 1981)Google Scholar; and Hertzberg, Arthur, The Zionist Idea (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1959)Google Scholar.
18. Shimoni, Zionist Ideology, especially “Zionism as Secular Jewish Identity.” For an analysis of secular reconfigurations of the category “Israel” see Biale, David, Not in the Heavens: The Tradition of Jewish Secular Thought (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
19. Almog, Shmuel, Zionism and History (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1987), 45Google Scholar.
20. Govrin, Nurit, “Me'oraʿ Brenner”: Ha-ma'avak ‘al ḥofesh ha-bituy (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 1985)Google Scholar.
21. Biale, Not in the Heavens, 163.
22. Ibid.
23. Hoffman, Matthew, From Rebel to Rabbi: Reclaiming Jesus and the Making of Modern Jewish Culture (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2007)Google Scholar.
24. Herzl, Theodor, The Complete Diaries of Theodor Herzl, ed. Patai, Raphael (New York: Herzl Press and Thomas Yoseloff, 1960), 57Google Scholar.
25. Pawel, Ernst, The Labyrinth of Exile: A Life of Theodor Herzl (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1989), 464Google Scholar.
26. Sternberger, Ilse, Princes without a Home: Modern Zionism and the Strange Fate of Theodor Herzl's Children, 1900–1945 (San Francisco, CA: International Scholars Publishing, 1994), 122–25Google Scholar.
27. Nedva, Joseph, “The Tragedy of the House of Herzl,” Ha-boker, June 11, 1959Google Scholar, in H1\3397, CZA.
28. Pawel writes that there is no record of Hans's bar mitzvah, but Sternberger reports otherwise. See Pawel, Labyrinth of Exile, 534, and Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 106.
29. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 192.
30. Selig Brodetsky to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
31. Ibid.
32. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 163–64.
33. Selig Brodetsky to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
34. For more on the influence of racial theory and ideology on Zionism, see Efron, John M., Defenders of the Race: Jewish Doctors and Race Science in Fin-de-Siècle Europe (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1994)Google Scholar; Hart, Mitchell B., Social Science and the Politics of Modern Jewish Identity (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2000)Google Scholar; and Bloom, Etan, Arthur Ruppin and the Production of Pre-Israeli Culture (Leiden: Brill, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
35. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 339; Joseph Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” Yohanan Krementzky Collection, A72\4, CZA.
36. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 339.
37. Ibid., 344; Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
38. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
39. Hans Herzl to Cyril Piccioto, H1\2348, CZA.
40. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 351.
41. Day was a Jesuit missionary who wrote many articles and tracts, many of a somewhat unsavory character. (For instance, he openly calls himself a “Jew-baiter.”) Arthur Day's 1943 book Our Friends, the Jews: Or, the Confessions of a Proselytizer includes twelve topical chapters, none of which are about individuals, except the chapter devoted entirely to Hans Herzl.
42. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
43. Marcel Sternberger, “Hans Herzl,” Joseph Leftwich Collection, A330\143, CZA; Letters to Hans Herzl, H1\2374, CZA.
44. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 253–54.
45. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
46. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 357, 362.
47. Ibid., 362.
48. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
49. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 413.
50. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
51. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 427.
52. Hans Herzl, “National Home for the Jews: An Expedient No Longer Needed,” The Universe, March 20, 1925, 6. He makes similar points in a 1926 letter to Lucien Wolf, H1\2354, CZA.
53. Hans Herzl, “A Last Word,” H1\2365, CZA. For more on Richard N. Koudenhove-Kalergi, see Anita Prettenhaler-Ziegerhofer, “Richard Nikolaus Koudenhove-Kalergi, Founder of the Pan-European Union, and the Birth of a ‘New’ Europe,” in Europe in Crisis: Intellectuals and the European Idea, 1917–1957, ed. Mark Hewitson and Matthew D'Auria (New York: Berghahn, 2012).
54. Hans Herzl to Lucien Wolf, H1/2353, CZA.
55. Hans Herzl to the Undersecretary of State, HO 144/5489, The National Archives of the UK (TNA).
56. Ibid.
57. Ibid.
58. Hans Herzl to Lucien Wolf, A77\41, CZA.
59. Gerl-Falkovitz, Hanna-Barbara, “‘His Whole Life Consisted of a Search for Religious Truth’: Edith Stein in Conversation with John Henry Newman,” in Contemplating Edith Stein, ed. Berkman, Joyce Avrech (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2006), 156–57Google Scholar.
60. See Edith Stein to Hugo Bergmann, Schwad 01 21 89, Abraham Shvadron Autograph Collection, National Library of Israel.
61. In fact, her family insisted that she keep her conversion secret from her nieces and nephews. They found out she converted only at the same time they discovered she was leaving to enter a convent. See Ernst L. Biberstein, “Aunt Edith/St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross,” unpublished talk, August 10, 1999. I thank Mr. Biberstein for sharing this talk with me via email. For Stein's autobiography, see Stein, Edith, Life in a Jewish Family, trans. Koeppel, Josephine, OCD (Washington, DC: Institute of Carmelite Studies Publications, 1986)Google Scholar.
62. Miron, Ronny, “Faith and Radicalism: Edith Stein vis-à-vis Yeshayahu Leibowitz,” The Review of Rabbinic Judaism 19 (2016): 119CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
63. Joyce Avrech Berkman, “The German-Jewish Symbiosis in Flux: Edith Stein's Complex National/Ethnic Identity,” in Contemplating Edith Stein, 182.
64. Ibid., 177–78.
65. Silverman, Emily Leah, “On the Frontiers of Faith: Edith Stein Encounters Herself as a Burnt Offering,” Hebrew Studies 51 (2010): 376Google Scholar.
66. Berkman, “German-Jewish Symbiosis,” 177.
67. Gerl-Falkowitz, “Search for Religious Truth,” 158, and Berkman, “German-Jewish Symbiosis,” 177.
68. Berkman, Joyce Avrech, “Esther and Mary: The Uneasy Jewish/Catholic Dynamic in the Work and Life of Edith Stein,” Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 32 (2016): 60, 68–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
69. Ibid., and Silverman, “Frontiers of Faith,” 377–78.
70. Nancy Fuchs-Kreimer, “Sister Edith Stein: A Rabbi Reacts,” in Never Forget: Christian and Jewish Perspectives on Edith Stein, ed. Waltraud Herbstrith (Washington, DC: Institute of Carmelite Studies Publications, 1998), 160.
71. Silverman, “Frontiers of Faith,” 376.
72. Hans Herzl to Pierre von Passen, H1\2346, CZA.
73. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 427.
74. Pawel, Labyrinth of Exile, 535.
75. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 355–56; Hans Herzl to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, H1\2373, CZA.
76. “Hans Herzl ha-masit,” Do'ar Ha-yom, February 7, 1925, accessed June 1, 2014, http://jpress.nli.org.il/Olive/APA/NLI/SharedView.Article.aspx?parm=Pcxu%2FJU5pmxaRSjuLt2mGA1YLyoD3KqXMxa4d84ClMHNjn97qtaC0QIQp6Pm7fHhYw%3D%3D&mode=image&href=DHY%2F1925%2F02%2F08&page=2.
77. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 356.
78. Ibid.
79. For more on Wise's sermon, see Goldman, Shalom, Zeal for Zion: Christians, Jews and the Idea of the Promised Land (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2009), 149Google Scholar.
80. Steven Wise to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
81. Ibid.
82. Unnamed to Hans Herzl, H1\2352, CZA.
83. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA; Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 369.
84. Hans Herzl to Leftwich, A330\226, CZA.
85. Stanislawski, Michael, Zionism and the Fin de Siècle: Cosmopolitanism and Nationalism from Nordau to Jabotinsky (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001)Google Scholar.
86. Herzl, Theodor, Altneuland, trans. Arnold, Paula (Haifa: Haifa Publishing Company, 1960), 135Google Scholar.
87. Ibid., 192.
88. Bein, Alex, Theodor Herzl: A Biography (1942; Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society and Meridian, 1962), 90–91Google Scholar.
89. State of Israel, the Supreme Court, Judgment: High Court Application of Oswald Rufeisen v. The Minster of the Interior (Jerusalem: Ministry of Justice, 1963), 41Google Scholar.
90. Herzl, Theodor, The Jewish State (New York: Scopus, 1943), 100Google Scholar.
91. Israel Zangwill to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, A330\153, CZA. Zangwill also uses the fact that since “the proposed university [is] purely scientific” those like Hans cannot be excluded from the Jewish people.
92. Quoted in Hart, Mitchell B., ed., Jews and Race: Writings on Identity and Difference, 1880–1940 (Waltham, MA: Brandeis University Press, 2011), 261Google Scholar.
93. Richard Gottheil to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA; letters from Lucien Wolf to Hans Herzl, H1\2353, CZA.
94. Jacob de Haas to Hans Herzl, H1\2374, CZA.
95. Ibid.; Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 418.
96. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
97. Marcel and Ilse Sternberger Family Papers, LIB 74.3, box 2761, the Magnes Collection.
98. Leftwich wedding invitation, H1\2374, CZA.
99. Selig Brodetsky to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
100. Hans Herzl to Arthur Day, H1\2373, CZA.
101. Hans Herzl to Pierre von Passen, H1\2346, CZA.
102. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 414.
103. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
104. Louis Zangwill to Trude Neumann (Herzl), H1\2404–36, CZA.
105. Stephen W. Wyatt to Trude Neumann (Herzl), H1\2404–27, CZA.
106. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA; “Hans Herzl, Son of Theodor Herzl, Commits Suicide after Funeral of Sister Paulina,” September 18, 1930, Jewish Telegraphic Agency Archive, accessed June 1, 2014, http://www.jta.org/1930/09/18/archive/hans-herzl-son-of-theodor-herzl-commits-suicide-after-funeral-of-sister-paulina.
107. Y. Dawnd to Trude Neumann (Herzl), H1\2404–38, CZA.
108. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 438.
109. This language evokes Shulamit Magnes's formulation of “good bad Jews,” or Jewish converts who were viewed as “good” versions of “bad” Jews because they intervened for the benefit of their former coreligionists. See Magnes, “Good Bad Jews.”
110. Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA; Stephen W. Wyatt to Joseph Leftwich, A330\140, CZA.
111. Selig Brodetsky to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
112. For more on Sternberger's interesting biography, see Marcel and Ilse Sternberger Family Papers, ephemera box 6, folder 22, LIB 74.3, box 2760, the Magnes Collection.
113. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 440.
114. Trude Neumann (Herzl) to Joseph Leftwich, A330\141, CZA; Leftwich, “Hans Herzl,” A72\4, CZA.
115. Sternberger, Princes without a Home, 441.
116. “Albert Einstein on the Tragedy of Theodor Herzl's Son,” September 8, 1932, accessed June 1, 2014, http://www.shapell.org/manuscript.aspx?einstein-on-jewish-identity-assimilation-and-herzl-son-conversion-and-suicide.
117. Edward E. Grusd to Joseph Leftwich, A330\140, CZA.
118. Ibid. Emphasis added.
119. Stephen Wise to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
120. Richard Gottheil to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
121. Selig Brodetsky to Marcel Sternberger, H1\2371, CZA.
122. Martin Buber Archive, ARC. Ms. Var. 350 008 779k, National Library of Israel.
123. Marcel and Ilse Sternberger Family Papers, folder 22, LIB 74.3, box 2760, the Magnes Collection.
124. Judith Weinshall Lieberman, My Life into Art: An Autobiography (Booklocker.com, 2007), 32, 215–16, accessed June 1, 2014, http://archive.org/stream/mylifeintoartau00libe/mylifeintoartau00libe_djvu.txt. See Weinshall, Jacob, ‘Anakim ba-midbar (Tel Aviv: Shalach, 1952)Google Scholar and Weinshall, Jacob, Parshiyot ‘alumot be-toldotenu (Tel Aviv: Avraham, 1973)Google Scholar.
125. “Ben ha-nesher,” Ha-mashkif, July 19, 1945, accessed October 20, 2015, http://jpress.nli.org.il/Olive/APA/NLI/SharedView.Article.aspx?parm=yaNsXsmRzSk4RGLRH5qZUI1IIMqEBMfuv1uVQYNUVgSWoxx7z%2FwI5f3kq6VbXQBiYw%3D%3D&mode=image&href=HMF%2F1945%2F07%2F20&page=.
126. Ibid.
127. Ibid.
128. Kimmerling, Baruch, “Between Hegemony and Dormant Kulturkampf in Israel,” Israel Affairs 4, no. 3–4 (1998): 66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
129. Judgment: High Court Application of Oswald Rufeisen v. The Minster of the Interior, 32.
130. Ibid., 35.
131. Gad Barzilai, “Who Is a Jew? Categories, Boundaries, Communities, and Citizenship Law in Israel,” in Glenn and Sokoloff, Boundaries of Jewish Identity, 31. For more on hybridity of Zionism and nationalism in the Zionist context, see Shenhav, “Modernity and Hybridization of Nationalism and Religion.”
132. Tec, Nechama, In the Lion's Den: The Life of Oswald Rufeisen (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008)Google Scholar, and Goldman, Shalom, “Apostasy and Citizenship: The Case of Brother Daniel (Oswald Rufeisen, 1922–1988),” in Jewish-Christian Difference and Modern Jewish Identity: Seven Twentieth-Century Converts (Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2015)Google Scholar.
133. Judgment: High Court Application of Oswald Rufeisen v. The Minster of the Interior, 68.
134. Oswald Rufeisen, “Ve-’eno ben dat ’aḥeret,” Politika, October 1987.
135. Goldman, Zeal for Zion, 135. See also “Herzl's Children Buried alongside Their Father in Jerusalem,” Haaretz, September 20, 2006, accessed May 1, 2017, http://www.haaretz.com/news/herzl-s-children-buried-alongside-their-father-in-jerusalem-1.197723.