Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2011
  • Online publication date: June 2012

2 - Fiction, Myth, and Reality


Saul Kripke's insightful and penetrating work on names from fiction and myth, though unpublished, has generated a great deal of discussion. Kripke's account illuminates and yet exacerbates the chestnut of negative existentials. On Kripke's account, use of the name 'Sherlock Holmes' to refer to the fictional character is in a certain sense parasitic on a prior, more fundamental use not as a name for the fictional character. The use of 'Sherlock Holmes' represented by 'Holmes', as the name for what is in reality an abstract artifact, is the same use it has according to the Holmes stories, except that according to the stories, that use is one on which it designates a man. The alleged thoroughly nondesignating use of 'Sherlock Holmes' by Conan Doyle, as a pretend name for a man, is a myth.
Margalit, A.Meaning and UseDordrechtD. Reidel 1979
Salmon, N.Soames, S.Propositions and AttitudesOxfordOxford University Press 1988
Donnellan, KeithSpeaking of NothingThe Philosophical Review 83 1974 3
Evans, GarethThe Varieties of DesignationOxfordOxford University Press 1982
Stalnaker, RobertSyntax and Semantics, 9: SemanticsNew YorkAcademic Press 1978
Thomasson, AmieFiction and MetaphysicsCambridgeCambridge University Press 1999
Adams, F.Fuller, G.Stecker, R.The Semantics of Fictional NamesPacific Philosophical Quarterly 78 1997 128
Braun, DavidEmpty NamesNoûs 27 1993 449
Caplan, BenEmpty Names: An Essay on the Semantics, Pragmatics, Metaphysics, and Epistemology of Empty Names and Other Directly Referential ExpressionsAmerican Philosophical Quarterly 41 2004 331
Currie, GregoryThe Nature of FictionCambridgeCambridge University Press 1990
Fine, KitThe Problem of Non-Existence: I. InternalismTopoi 1 1982 97
Pavel, Thomas G.Fictional WorldsCambridgeHarvard University Press 1986
Thomasson, AmieFiction, Modality and Dependent AbstractaPhilosophical Studies 84 1996 295
Wolterstorff, NicholasWorks and Worlds of ArtOxfordOxford University Press 1980
Everett, A.Hofweber, T.Empty Names, Fiction and the Puzzles of Non-ExistenceStanford, CACSLI Publications 2000
McCormick, P.Reasons of ArtOttawaUniversity of Ottawa Press 1985
Campbell, J.O’Rourke, M.Shier, D.Meaning and TruthNew YorkSeven Bridges Press 2002
Reimer, M.Bezuidenhout, A.Descriptions and BeyondOxfordOxford University Press 2004