Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2015
  • Online publication date: November 2015

16 - Rome and Imagery in Late Antiquity: Perception and Use of Statues

from Section C - Reading Religious Iconography as Evidence for Pagan–Christian Relations

Summary

Divine statues, as objects that were thought of very differently in terms of both their nature and their use, crystallized the tensions between pagans and Christians in the fourth and fifth centuries. The “graven image” as an emblem of pagan religions gradually became the preferred target of Christians. From the second half of the second century, ideas on the link between the god and its effigy, on the type of representation based on mimicry as well as on its actual power were put forward by both Christian authors and pagan philosophers, who reflected on their conception of piety and on the religious relationship between mankind and the divine. Some of the arguments Christian writers advanced on divine statues in fact came to be used as encouragement and justification for legal decisions that limited and then prohibited their use, occasionally with a concern for protecting the work nonetheless, but little is known about the efficacy of these measures or the precise nature of the objects involved. We do not know whether all kinds of divine effigy were affected, or if these attacks targeted only consecrated images. In any case, these struggles over the approach to divine statues gradually modified the role they played in the city. As Lepelley has shown, divine statues lost their primary purpose and became real “heritage” objects. In Rome, a fairly wide range of sources, comprising inscriptions, writings by Christian or pagan authors, and archeological and iconographical data, allows us to follow the main phases of this change of status. Statues became markers of a society in transition, and they allow us to observe their complex relationship with tradition and the past in the context of the diffusion of a new culture that weakened and called into question some of the structures underpinning society, in Rome more so than elsewhere.

I:Tradition and Initial Tensions Surrounding Images

In the fourth century, Christian reticence toward divine representations was above all evident in literature, with only rare material consequences, since the tradition of erecting images to the gods in fact remained a powerful one. Effigies were still very current, to the extent that from 331 a civil servant with responsibility for statues in the city of Rome was appointed, the curator statuarum.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Arce, J. “El inventario de Roma: Curiosum y Notitia,” in Harris, W. V., ed., The Transformation of Urbs Roma in Late Antiquity, Journal of Roman Archeology, supplementary series 33 (Portsmouth, 1999), 15–22.
Bartoli, A. Curia senatus. Lo scavo e il restauro, I monumenti romani III (Rome, 1963).
Bauer, F. A. and Witschel, C.. Statuen in der Spätantike (Wiesbaden, 2007).
Beaujeu, J.A-t-il existé une direction des musées dans la Rome impériale?Comptes rendus de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles Lettres, nov.–déc. (1982): 671–88.
Belayche, N. “Realia versus leges? Les sacrifices de la religion d’État au IVe siècle,” in Georgoudi, S., Piettre, R. Koch, and Schmidt, F., eds., La cuisine et l'autel. Les sacrifices en questions dans les sociétés de la Méditerranée antique (Turnhout, 2005), 343–70.
Bidez, J. Vie de Porphyre (Zurich, 1980).
Bouffartigue, J. “Les statues divines du paganisme,” in Delattre, C., ed., Objets sacrés, objets magiques, de l'Antiquité au Moyen Age (Paris, 2007), 53–64.
Bradbury, S.Constantine and the Problem of Anti-pagan Legislation in the Fourth Century.” CIPh 89 (1994): 120–39.
Cameron, , A. “The Date and Identity of Macrobius,” Journal of Roman Studies 56 (1966): 25–38.
Canfora, F. Simmaco e Ambrogio, o di un'antica controversia sulla tolleranza e sull’ intolleranza (Bari, 1970).
Casini, N.Le discussioni sull’ ‘ara Victoriae’ nella curia romana.” Studi Romani 5 (1957): 514–17.
Chastagnol, A. La préfecture urbaine à Rome sous le Bas Empire (Paris, 1960).
Chastagnol, A. Les fastes de la préfecture de Rome au Bas-Empire (Paris, 1962).
Chuvin, P. Chronique des derniers païens: la disparition du paganisme dans l'Empire romain, du règne de Constantin à celui de Justinien (Paris, 1990).
Clerc, Ch. Les théories relatives au culte des images chez les auteurs grecs du IIe siècle après J.-C. (Paris, 1924).
Curran, J.Moving Statues in Late Antique Rome: Problems of Perspective.” Art History 17 (1994): 46–58.
Curran, J. Pagan City and Christian Capital: Rome in the Fourth Century (Oxford, 2000).
Dagron, G., Constantinople imaginaire. Etudes sur le recueil des Patria (Paris, 1984).
De Rossi, G. B.Un esplorazione sottoranea sulla via Salaria vecchia,” Bulletino di archeologia cristiana (1865): 350–51.
Demougeot, E.Sur les lois du 15 novembre 407.” RHD (1950): 403–12.
Ensoli, S. and Rocca, E. La, eds. Aurea Roma, Dalla città pagana alla città christiana (Rome, 2000).
Fazzo, V. La giustificazione delle immagini religiose, dalla tarda antichità al cristianesimo (Naples, 1977).
Fraschetti, A.Roma: spazi del sacro e spazi della politica tra IVe e Ve secolo.” Studi Storici 36 (1995): 923–44.
Gaudemet, J.La législation anti-païenne de Constantin à Justinien.” Cristianesimo nella Storia 1 (1990): 449–68.
Gaudemet, J. Siniscalco, P., and Falchi, G. L.. Legislazione imperiale e religione nel IV secolo (Rome 2000): 7–66.
Grattarola, P.Ara Deae. La prima rimozione dell'altare della Vittoria della curia romana e il suo ristabilimento.” Rendiconti Istituto Lombardo (1978): 21–31.
Janvier, Y. La Législation du Bas-Empire romain sur les édifices publics, la Pensée universitaire (Aix-en-Provence, 1969).
Jordan, H. Topographie der Stadt Rom im Alterthum, II (Berlin, 1871).
Kahlos, M.The Restoration Policy of Vettius Agorius Praetextatus.” Arctos 29 (1995): 39.
Labriolle, P. De. La réaction païenne. Etude sur la polémique antichrétienne du Ier au Vie siècle (Paris, 1937).
Lanciani, R. The Destruction of Ancient Rome (New York, 1899).
Lanciani, R. Rovine e scavi di Roma antica (Rome, 1985).
Lane-Fox, R. Pagans and Christians (New York, 1987).
Lassandre, D.L'altare della Victoria.” La ricerca sulla tarda Antichità (1984): 443–50.
Lepelley, C.Le musée des statues divines.” Cahiers archéologiques (1994): 5–15.
Lepelley, C. “Témoignages épigraphiques sur le maintien des temples et des statues des divinités dans le patrimoine et l'espace public des cités sous l'empire chrétien,” Actes de la rencontre épigraphique italo-anglo-française, BICS Suppl., forthcoming.
Les lois religieuses des empereurs romains. De Constantin à Théodose II (312–438), Text and Trans. J. Rougé, R. Delmaire (Introduction), F. Richard (Paris, 2005).
Lipani, F.La controversia sull’ Ara Victoriae.” Atene e Roma 41, nos. 2–3 (1996): 75–9.
Lizzi, R.Fra prosopografia e antichità veronesi: il ‘consularis Venetiae et Histriae’ Valerius Palladius.” RIL 122 (1988): 145–64.
Maternus, Firmicus. L'Erreur des religions païennes, Text and Trans. Turcan, R. (Paris, 1982).
Mazzarino, S., Antico, tardo-antico ed èra costantiniana (Bari, 1980).
Nieddu, G. ‘‘Il portico degli dei consenti.” Bollettino d'Arte 71 (1986): 37–52.
Panciera, S. and Fransoni, G.. Atti el Colloquio Internazionale AIEGL su Epigrafia e ordine senatorio (Rome, 14–20 mai 1981) I,4 (Rome, 1984): 658–61.
Paschoud, F. Roma aeterna: études sur le patriotisme romain dans l'occident latin a l’époque des grandes invasions (Neuchâtel, 1967).
Pohlsander, H. A.Victory: The Story of a Statue.” Historia XVIII (1969): 588–97.
Prudence, Psychomachie, Contre Symmaque, Tome III, Text and Trans. Lavarenne, 3rd ed J.-L. Charlet (Paris, 1992).
Reinach, A.Notes tarentines I: Pyrrhus et la Niké de Tarente.” Neapolis: Rivista di archeologia e scienze per l'Italia Meridionale e la Sicilia I (1913): 19–29.
Sheridan, J. J.The Altar of Victory.” Antiquité classique XXXV (1966): 186–206.
Stewart, P. “The Destruction of Statues in Late Antiquity,” in Miles, R., ed., Constructing Identities in Late Antiquity (London, New York, 1999), 159–89.
Thomas, Y. “Les ornements, la cité, le patrimoine.” Images romaines (Paris, 1998): 263–83.
Valentini, R. and Zucchetti, G.. Codice topografico della città di Roma (Rome, 1940).
Weitzmann, K., ed. The Age of Spirituality: Late Antique and Early Christian Art, Third to Seventh Century (New York, 1979).