Book contents
- Front matter
- Contents
- Preface
- Source notes
- Introduction
- PART I MATHEMATICS
- 1 Numbers and ideas
- 2 Why I am not a nominalist
- 3 Mathematics and Bleak House
- 4 Quine, analyticity, and philosophy of mathematics
- 5 Being explained away
- 6 E pluribus unum: plural logic and set theory
- 7 Logicism: a new look
- PART II MODELS, MODALITY, AND MORE
- Annotated bibliography
- References
- Index
1 - Numbers and ideas
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2009
- Front matter
- Contents
- Preface
- Source notes
- Introduction
- PART I MATHEMATICS
- 1 Numbers and ideas
- 2 Why I am not a nominalist
- 3 Mathematics and Bleak House
- 4 Quine, analyticity, and philosophy of mathematics
- 5 Being explained away
- 6 E pluribus unum: plural logic and set theory
- 7 Logicism: a new look
- PART II MODELS, MODALITY, AND MORE
- Annotated bibliography
- References
- Index
Summary
REALISM VS NOMINALISM
Philosophy is a subject in which there is very little agreement. This is so almost by definition, for if it happens that in some area of philosophy inquirers begin to achieve stable agreement about some substantial range of issues, straightaway one ceases to think of that area as part of “philosophy,” and begins to call it something else. This happened with physics or “natural philosophy” in the seventeenth century, and has happened with any number of other disciplines in the centuries since. Philosophy is left with whatever remains a matter of doubt and dispute.
Philosophy of mathematics, in particular, is an area where there are very profound disagreements. In this respect philosophy of mathematics is radically unlike mathematics itself, where there are today scarcely ever any controversies over the correctness of important results, once published in refereed journals. Some professional mathematicians are also amateur philosophers, and the best way for an observer to guess whether such persons are talking mathematics or philosophy on a given occasion is to look whether they are agreeing or disagreeing.
One major issue dividing philosophers of mathematics is that of the nature and existence of mathematical objects and entities, such as numbers, by which I will always mean positive integers 1, 2, 3, and so on. The problem arises because, though it is common to contrast matter and mind as if the two exhausted the possibilities, numbers do not fit comfortably into either the material or the mental category.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Mathematics, Models, and ModalitySelected Philosophical Essays, pp. 23 - 30Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2008
- 1
- Cited by