Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Acknowledgements
- Notes on Contributors
- List of Abbreviations
- The Crusades, the Latin East and Medieval History-Writing: An Introduction
- 1 History-Writing and Remembrance in Crusade Letters
- 2 A ‘swiðe mycel styrung’: The First Crusade in Early Vernacular Annals from Anglo-Norman England
- 3 To Bargain with God: The Crusade Vow in the Narratives of the First Crusade
- 4 ‘The Lord has brought eastern riches before you’: Battlefield Spoils and Looted Treasure in Narratives of the First Crusade
- 5 Foundation and Settlement in Fulcher of Chartres’ Historia Hierosolymitana: A Narratological Reading
- 6 After Ascalon: ‘Bartolf of Nangis’, Fulcher of Chartres and the Early Years of the Kingdom of Jerusalem
- 7 Repurposing a Crusade Chronicle: Peter of Cornwall's Liber Revelationum and the Reception of Fulcher of Chartres’ Historia Hierosolymitana in Medieval England
- 8 Between Chronicon and Chanson: William of Tyre, the First Crusade and the Art of Storytelling
- 9 History and Politics in the Latin East: William of Tyre and the Composition of the Historia Hierosolymitana
- 10 ‘When I became a man’: Kingship and Masculinity in William of Tyre's Chronicon
- 11 Laments for the Lost City: The Loss of Jerusalem in Western Historical Writing
- 12 The Silences of the Itinerarium Peregrinorum 1
- 13 The Natural and Biblical Landscapes of the Holy Land in Jacques de Vitry's Historia Orientalis
- 14 The Masculine Experience and the Experience of Masculinity on the Seventh Crusade in John of Joinville's Vie de Saint Louis
- 15 Writing and Copying History at Acre, c. 1230–91
- Index
8 - Between Chronicon and Chanson: William of Tyre, the First Crusade and the Art of Storytelling
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 February 2024
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Acknowledgements
- Notes on Contributors
- List of Abbreviations
- The Crusades, the Latin East and Medieval History-Writing: An Introduction
- 1 History-Writing and Remembrance in Crusade Letters
- 2 A ‘swiðe mycel styrung’: The First Crusade in Early Vernacular Annals from Anglo-Norman England
- 3 To Bargain with God: The Crusade Vow in the Narratives of the First Crusade
- 4 ‘The Lord has brought eastern riches before you’: Battlefield Spoils and Looted Treasure in Narratives of the First Crusade
- 5 Foundation and Settlement in Fulcher of Chartres’ Historia Hierosolymitana: A Narratological Reading
- 6 After Ascalon: ‘Bartolf of Nangis’, Fulcher of Chartres and the Early Years of the Kingdom of Jerusalem
- 7 Repurposing a Crusade Chronicle: Peter of Cornwall's Liber Revelationum and the Reception of Fulcher of Chartres’ Historia Hierosolymitana in Medieval England
- 8 Between Chronicon and Chanson: William of Tyre, the First Crusade and the Art of Storytelling
- 9 History and Politics in the Latin East: William of Tyre and the Composition of the Historia Hierosolymitana
- 10 ‘When I became a man’: Kingship and Masculinity in William of Tyre's Chronicon
- 11 Laments for the Lost City: The Loss of Jerusalem in Western Historical Writing
- 12 The Silences of the Itinerarium Peregrinorum 1
- 13 The Natural and Biblical Landscapes of the Holy Land in Jacques de Vitry's Historia Orientalis
- 14 The Masculine Experience and the Experience of Masculinity on the Seventh Crusade in John of Joinville's Vie de Saint Louis
- 15 Writing and Copying History at Acre, c. 1230–91
- Index
Summary
The Chronicon of Archbishop William of Tyre is not only a source of unparalleled significance for historians of the Latin East, it is also one that offers an important window onto historical writing in twelfth-century Christendom. Comprising over 1,000 pages of Latin text in the modern critical edition, its twenty-three books span (roughly) the period of Latin Christian involvement in the Levant and Syria from the genesis of the First Crusade in 1095 through to the mid-1180s. The text reflects an extensive writing process, one that most historians argue began c. 1170 and lasted until the period immediately preceding the author's death c. 1184/86. Unsurprisingly for such a lengthy and important work, the Chronicon and its author have attracted widespread interest. However, except for Peter Edbury and John Rowe's 1988 study, scholars have rarely taken a broad-ranging approach to the Chronicon. Instead, recent work has largely focused on examining specific elements or themes of the text, with a growing interest in William's authorial strategies mirroring the emergence of literary approaches to crusade narratives. The Chronicon's first eight books, which account for over a third of the entire work and include the author's retelling of the First Crusade, have nevertheless either been ignored, largely because they are viewed as derivative and of little value in tracing William's authorial voice or ideological standpoints, or approached only to confirm arguments regarding related texts, especially Albert of Aachen's Historia Ierosolimitana and the so-called ‘Lost Lotharingian Chronicle’.
Some recent work has begun to redress this, but a close, careful and detailed analysis of William's account of the First Crusade remains necessary, especially given Edbury and Rowe's somewhat offhand – or at least not fully explored – concluding remark that ‘only in the story of the First Crusade did [William’s] narrative achieve a genuine homogeneity’. Such a study is vital to achieving a better understanding of the author and his text, for these sections offer the best opportunity to trace William's historical method by pinpointing his use and adaptation of other sources to craft his own version of events. But re-examining William's account of the First Crusade is also valuable because it will help to situate the Chronicon more firmly within the wider flourishing of history creation during the twelfth century and beyond, in both a crusading and non-crusading context.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Crusade, Settlement and Historical Writing in the Latin East and Latin West, c. 1100-c. 1300 , pp. 155 - 173Publisher: Boydell & BrewerPrint publication year: 2024