Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Notes on Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Secondary Cities: Introduction to a Research Agenda
- 2 Shedding Light or Casting Shadows? Relations between Primary and Secondary Cities
- 3 Small and Medium-Sized Towns as Secondary Cities: The Case of Switzerland
- 4 From Sleepy Hollow to Winning from Second: Identity, Autonomy and Borrowed Size in an Australian Urban Region
- 5 Metropolization Processes and Intra-Regional Contrasts: The Uneven Fortunes of English Secondary Cities
- 6 Situating the Secondary City: Uneven Development and Regional Gentrification in Tacoma, WA
- 7 Borrowed Social Performance: Labour and Community Organizations in Los Angeles and Long Beach, California
- 8 Intra-Regional Relationality and Green City-Regionalism: Placing the Role of ‘Secondary Cities’
- 9 Conclusion: Advancing the Secondary City Perspective
- Index
6 - Situating the Secondary City: Uneven Development and Regional Gentrification in Tacoma, WA
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2022
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Notes on Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Secondary Cities: Introduction to a Research Agenda
- 2 Shedding Light or Casting Shadows? Relations between Primary and Secondary Cities
- 3 Small and Medium-Sized Towns as Secondary Cities: The Case of Switzerland
- 4 From Sleepy Hollow to Winning from Second: Identity, Autonomy and Borrowed Size in an Australian Urban Region
- 5 Metropolization Processes and Intra-Regional Contrasts: The Uneven Fortunes of English Secondary Cities
- 6 Situating the Secondary City: Uneven Development and Regional Gentrification in Tacoma, WA
- 7 Borrowed Social Performance: Labour and Community Organizations in Los Angeles and Long Beach, California
- 8 Intra-Regional Relationality and Green City-Regionalism: Placing the Role of ‘Secondary Cities’
- 9 Conclusion: Advancing the Secondary City Perspective
- Index
Summary
Introduction
In 2017, a local reporter opened a story on the ongoing construction boom in Tacoma, Washington, with the observation that ‘Tacoma learned long ago that it will always be second to Seattle, but the city is now embracing that as a positive. The money the city is leveraging from all the action in Seattle is a vital part of Tacoma's game plan.’ The reporter noted how local officials had for some time been preparing for the building boom with an array of public projects intended to attract developers to the city. Tacoma Economic Development Director Ricardo Noguera described the city's enthusiasm for riding Seattle's economic coat-tails, highlighting how residents priced out of Seattle and the surrounding suburbs were joining new arrivals to the region in moving to Tacoma. Characterizing 2017 as ‘the year of the crane’, Noguera outlined the city's development philosophy: ‘I can't compete with Goliath … [instead] it's feeding off of the beast. Seattle-Bellevue is the beast’ (Sullivan, 2017).
This brief news story is telling both for the way it presents Seattle as central to the economic and policy options facing Tacoma and for how this relationship is simultaneously depicted in strongly optimistic and pessimistic terms. Behind this tension is a long history of anxiety that Tacoma has already lost out or is about to be bypassed by some new wave of regional development. Much of this history, both real and imagined, is best understood through the lens of Tacoma's ‘secondary’ status relative to Seattle, which dates back to the late 19th century. As scholars grappling with the possibilities for alternative economic development in the city, we have accordingly often come up against an array of questions about just what ‘success’ for Tacoma would look like in relation to the surrounding region and in particular Seattle. In other words, we ask what regionalism looks like from a secondary city perspective: How are Tacoma's current and future conditions tied to Seattle? What are the costs and benefits of this relationship and who in Tacoma does it serve? Is there the political capacity and will in Tacoma to carve out a distinctive development future despite the varied pressures of proximity to Seattle?
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Secondary CitiesExploring Uneven Development in Dynamic Urban Regions of the Global North, pp. 133 - 156Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2021