Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Are homalozoans echinoderms? An answer from the extraxial-axial theory

  • Bruno David (a1), Bertrand Lefebvre (a2), Rich Mooi (a3) and Ronald Parsley (a4)

Abstract

Homalozoans include four classes of non-pentamerous Paleozoic echinoderms: Homostelea (cinctans), Ctenocystoidea (ctenoid-bearing homalozoans), Homoiostelea (solutes), and Stylophora (cornutes and mitrates). Their atypical morphologies have historically made it difficult to relate them to other classes. Therefore, their systematic positions have been represented by two hypotheses (H): as stem taxa to echinoderms (H1) or as stem taxa to chordates (H2). These conclusions rest on previous inability to recognize synapomorphies with more crownward echinoderms, resulting in a forcing of the homalozoans down the phylogenetic tree that is more artifactual than evolutionary. The Extraxial-Axial Theory (EAT) identifies body-wall homologies, common ontogenetic patterns, and major events in bodyplan evolution. Therefore, the EAT can identify synapomorphies among even the most disparate of echinoderms. Application of the EAT undermines both H1 and H2 and strongly suggests that the bizarre asymmetry of homalozoans is a derived characteristic, and not indicative of plesiomorphic morphology for either chordates or echinoderms. Each of the four homalozoan clades and their major features are reexamined using the EAT. New findings are presented concerning homologies of thecal body wall, but we focus on stems, arms, and brachioles, which are recognized as very distinct products of independent evolutionary events. The results support a new interpretation (H3) of homalozoans as a polyphyletic assemblage that can be parsed out into other, clearly echinoderm clades. The Homoiostelea and Homostelea share the blastozoan synapomorphy of a brachiole. The enigmatic Ctenocystoidea also seem to have brachioles. The Stylophora have an arm as in crinoids. H3 is also more congruent with the known fossil record. Although they are stratigraphically early echinoderms, homalozoans are not indicative of the plesiomorphic morphology of the phylum.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Ausich, W. I., and Babcock, L. E. 1998. The phylogenetic position of Echmatocrinus brachiatus, a probable octocoral from the Burgess Shale. Palaeontology 41:193202.
Bather, F. A. 1913. Caradocian Cystidea from Girvan. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 49:359529.
Bather, F. A. 1929. Une classe d'échinodermes sans trace de symétrie rayonnée. Association Française pour l'Avancement des Sciences:435438.
Bather, F. A. 1930. A class of Echinodermata without trace of radiate symmetry. Archivio Zoologico Italiano 14:431439.
Beaver, H. H., Caster, K. E., Durham, J. W., Fay, R. O., Fell, H. B., Kesling, R. V., Macurda, D. B. Jr., Moore, R. C., Ubaghs, G., and Wanner, J. 1967. Echinodermata. 1. Part S ofMoore, R. C., ed. Treatise on invertebrate paleontology. Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, New York.
Beisswenger, M. 1994. A calcichordate interpretation of the new mitrate Eumitrocystella savilli from the Ordovician of Morocco. Paläontologische Zeitschrift 68:443462.
Breimer, A. 1978. General morphology Recent crinoids. Pp. T9T58in Ubaghs, et al. 1978.
Breimer, A., and Macurda, D. B. Jr. 1972. The phylogeny of the fissiculate blastoids. Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen 26:1390.
Carnevali, M. D., and Bonasaro, F. 1999. Echinoderm research 1998. Balkema, Rotterdam.
Caster, K. E. 1967. Homoiostelea. Pp. S581S627 in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Caster, K. E. 1983. A new Silurian carpoid echinoderm from Tasmania and a revision of the Allanicytidiidae. Alcheringa 7:321335.
Chauvel, J. 1941. Recherches sur les cystoïdes et les carpoïdes armoricains. Mémoires de la Société Géologique et Minéralogique de Bretagne 5:1286.
Chauvel, J. 1981. Etude critique de quelques échinodermes stylophores du Massif armoricain. Bulletin de la Société Géologique et Minéralogique de Bretagne C 13:67101.
Chen, J.-Y., Huang, D.-Y., and Li, C.-W. 1999. An Early Cambrian craniate-like chordate. Nature 402:518522.
Cripps, A. P. 1990. A new stem-craniate from the Ordovician of Morocco and the search for the sister group of the Craniata. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 100:2771.
Cripps, A. P. 1991. A cladistic analysis of the cornutes stem chordates. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 102:333366.
Daley, P. E. J. 1992. Two new cornutes from the Lower Ordovician of Shropshire and Southern France. Palaeontology 25:127148.
Daley, P. E. J. 1995. Anatomy, locomotion and ontogeny of the solute Castericystis vali from the Middle Cambrian of Utah. Geobios 28:585615.
Daley, P. E. J. 1996. The first solute which is attached as an adult: a Mid-Cambrian fossil from Utah with echinoderm and chordate affinities. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 117:405440.
David, B., and Mooi, R. 1996. Embryology supports a new theory of skeletal homologies for the phylum Echinodermata. Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences de Paris, série 3, 319:577584.
David, B., and Mooi, R. 1998. Major events in the evolution of Echinoderms viewed by the light of embryology. Pp. 2128 in Mooi, and Telford, 1998.
David, B., and Mooi, R. 1999. Comprendre les échinodermes: la contribution du modèle extraxial-axial. Bulletin de la Société Géologique de France 170:91101.
Dominguez, P. 1999. The early evolution of echinoderms: the class Ctenocystoidea and its closest relatives revisited. Pp. 263268 in Carnevali, Candia and Bonasoro, 1999.
Dzik, J., and Orlowski, S. 1995. Primitive ctenocystoid echinoderm from the earliest Middle Cambrian of Poland. Annales de Paléontologie 81:1735.
Ettensohn, F. R. 1975. The autecology of Agassizocrinus lobatus. Journal of Paleontology 49:10441061.
Ettensohn, F. R. 1980. Paragassizocrinus: systematics, phylogeny and ecology. Journal of Paleontology 54:9781007.
Fatka, O., and Kordule, V. 1985. Etoctenocystis bohemica gen. et sp. nov., new ctenocystoid from Czekoslovakia (Echinodermata, Middle Cambrian). Vestnik Ustredniho Ustavu Geologického 60:225229.
Frest, T. J. 1988. Functional morphology and homologies in cornute and mitrate echinoderms. Pp. 797 in Burke, R. D., Mladenov, P. V., Lambert, P., and Parsley, R. L., eds. Echinoderm biology. Balkema, Rotterdam.
Friedrich, W. P. 1993. Systematik und Funktionmorphologie mittle Kambrischer Cincta (Carpoidea, Echinodermata). Beringeria 7:1190.
Gee, H. 1996. Before the backbone, views on the origin of the vertebrates. Chapman & Hall, London.
Gil Cid, M. D., Dominguez, P. A., Silvan Pobes, E., and Escribano, R. M. 1996. Bohemiaecystis jefferiesi n. sp.; primer Cornuta para el Ordovicio español. Estudios Geologicos 52:313326.
Gill, E. D., and Caster, K. E. 1960. Carpoid echinoderms from the Silurian and Devonian of Australia. Bulletins of American Paleontology 41:171.
Gislén, T. 1930. Affinities between the Echinodermata, Enteropneusta and Chordonia. Zoologiska Bidrag från Uppsala 12:199304.
Guensburg, T. E., and Sprinkle, J. 1994. Revised phylogeny and functional interpretation of the Edrioasteroidea based on new taxa from the Early and Middle Ordovician of western Utah. Fieldiana (Geology) 29:143.
Guensburg, T. E., and Sprinkle, J. 1999. Origin of crinoid arms. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs 31:A44.
Heinzeller, T., and Welsch, U. 1994. Crinoidea. Pp. 9148in Harrison, F. W. and Ruppert, E. W., eds. Microscopic anatomy of invertebrates, Vol. 14. Echinodermata. Wiley, New York.
Hotchkiss, F. H. C. 1993. A new Devonian ophiuroid (Echinodermata: Oegophiurida) from New York State and its bearing on the origin of ophiuroid upper arm plates. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 106:6384.
Jaekel, O. 1901. Uber Carpoideen: eine neue Klasse von Pelmatozoen. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Geologische Gesellschaft 52:661677.
Jaekel, O. 1918. Phylogenie und System der Pelmatozoen. Paläontologische Zeitung 3:1128.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1967. Some fossil chordates with echinoderm affinities. Zoological Society of London, Symposium 20:163208.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1968. The subphylum Calcichordata (Jefferies, 1967), primitive fossil chordates with echinoderm affinities. Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History) Geology 16:243339.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1981. In defence of the calcichordates. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 73:351396.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1986. The ancestry of the vertebrates. British Museum (Natural History), London.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1990. The solute Dendrocystoides scoticus from the Upper Ordovician of Scotland and the ancestry of chordates and echinoderms. Palaeontology 33:631679.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1991. Two types of bilateral symmetry in the Metazoa: chordate and bilateralian. Pp. 94127in Bock, G. R. and Marsch, J., eds. Biological asymmetry and handedness (Ciba Foundation Symposium No. 62). Wiley, New York.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1997a. A defence of the calcichordates. Lethaia 30:110.
Jefferies, R. P. S. 1997b. How chordates and echinoderms separated from each other and the problem of dorso-ventral inversion. Pp. 249266in Waters, and Maples, 1997.
Jefferies, R. P. S., Brown, N. A., and Daley, P. E. J. 1996. The early phylogeny of chordates and echinoderms and the origin of chordate left-right asymmetry and bilateral symmetry. Acta Zoologica (Stockholm) 77:101122.
Jell, P. A., Burett, C. F., and Banks, M. R. 1985. Cambrian and Ordovician echinoderms from eastern Australia. Alcheringa 9:183208.
Kesling, R. V. 1967. Cystoids. Pp. S85S267in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Kolata, D. R., and Jollie, M. 1982. Anomalocystitid mitrates (Stylophora: Echinodermata) from the Champlainian (Middle Ordovician) Guttenberg Formation of the Upper Mississippi Valley Region. Journal of Paleontology 56:631653.
Kolata, D. R., Strimple, H. L., and Levorson, C. O. 1977. Revision of the Ordovician carpoid family Iowacystidae. Palaeontology 20:529557.
Kolata, D. R., Frest, T. J., and Mapes, R. H. 1991. The youngest carpoid: occurrence, affinities and life mode of a Pennsylvanian (Morrowan) mitrate from Oklahoma. Journal of Paleontology 65:844855.
Lefebvre, B., and Vizcaino, D. 1999. New Ordovician cornutes (Echinodermata, Stylophora) from Montagne Noire and Brittany (France) and a revision of the order Cornuta Jaekel 1901. Geobios 32:421458.
Lefebvre, B., Racheboeuf, P., and David, B. 1998. Homologies in stylophoran echinoderms. Pp. 103109in Mooi, and Telford, 1998.
Lowe, C. J., and Wray, G. A. 1997. Radical alterations in the roles of homeobox genes during echinoderm evolution. Nature 389:718721.
Mooi, R., and David, B. 1997. Skeletal homologies of echinoderms. Pp. 305335in Waters, and Maples, 1997. Geobiology of echinoderms.
Mooi, R., and David, B. 1998. Evolution within a bizarre phylum: homologies of the first echinoderms. American Zoologist 38:965974.
Mooi, R., and David, B. 2000. What a new model of skeletal homologies tells us about asteroid evolution. American Zoologist (in press).
Mooi, R., and Telford, M., eds. 1998. Echinoderms San Francisco. Balkema, Rotterdam.
Mooi, R., David, B., and Marchand, D. 1994. Echinoderm skeletal homologies: classical morphology meets modern phylogenetics. Pp. 8795in David, B., Guille, A., Féral, J. P., and Roux, M., eds. Echinoderms through time (Echinoderms Dijon). Balkema, Rotterdam.
Nichols, D. 1960. The histology and activities of the tube-feet of Antedon bifida. Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 101:105117.
Nichols, D. 1962. Echinoderms. Hutchinson University Library, London.
Nichols, D. 1972. The water-vascular system in living and fossil echinoderms. Palaeontology 15:519538.
Parsley, R. L. 1972. The Belemnocystitidae: solutan homeomorphs of the Anomalocystitidae. Journal of Paleontology, 46:341347.
Parsley, R. L. 1988. Feeding and respiratory strategies in Stylophora. Pp. 347361in Paul, C. R. C. and Smith, A. B., eds. Echinoderm phylogeny and evolutionary biology. Clarendon, Oxford.
Parsley, R. L. 1990. Aristocystites, a recumbent diploporid (Echinodermata) from the Middle and Late Ordovician of Bohemia, CSSR. Journal of Paleontology 64:278293.
Parsley, R. L. 1991. Review of selected North American mitrate stylophorans (Homalozoa, Echinodermata). Bulletins of American Paleontology 100:554.
Parsley, R. L. 1997. The echinoderm classes Stylophora and Homoiostelea: non Calcichordata. Pp. 225248in Waters, and Maples, 1997.
Parsley, R. L. 1998. Taxonomic revision of the Stylophora. Pp. 111117in Mooi, and Telford, 1998.
Parsley, R. L. 1999. The Cincta (Homostelea) as Blastozoans. Pp. 369375in Echinoderm Research 1998. Carnevali, Candia and Bonasoro, 1999.
Parsley, R. L., and Caster, K. E. 1965. North American Soluta (Carpoidea, Echinodermata). Bulletins of American Paleontology 49:109174.
Parsley, R. L., and Mintz, L. W. 1975. North American Paracrinoidea: (Ordovician: Paracrinozoa, new: Echinodermata). Bulletins of American Paleontology 68:1115.
Paul, C. R. C., and Smith, A. B. 1984. The early radiation and phylogeny of echinoderms. Biological Reviews 59:443481.
Peterson, K. J. 1995. A phylogenetic test of the calcichordate scenario. Lethaia 28:2538.
Philip, G. M. 1979. Carpoids: echinoderms or chordates? Biological Reviews 54:439471.
Raff, R. A. 1996. The shape of life: genes, development, and the evolution of animal form. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Robison, R. A., and Sprinkle, J. 1969. Ctenocystoidea: a new class of primitive echinoderms. Science 166:15121514.
Roux, M. 1997. Classification et ontogenèse chez les crinoïdes: une révision nécessaire de la hiérarchie des caractères. Bulletin de la Société Zoologique de France 122:371378.
Rozhnov, S. V., and Jefferies, R. P. S. 1996. A new stem-chordate solute from the Middle Ordovician of Estonia. Geobios 29:91109.
Ruta, M. 1997. A new mitrate from the Lower Ordovician of southern France. Palaeontology 40:363383.
Ruta, M. 1999. Brief review of the stylophoran debate. Evolution & Development 1:123135.
Smith, A. B. 1984. Classification of the Echinodermata. Palaeontology 27:431459.
Sprinkle, J. 1973. Morphology and evolution of blastozoan echinoderms. Special publication, Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard University, Cambridge.
Sprinkle, J. 1975. The “arms” of Caryocrinites, a rhombiferan cystoid convergent on crinoids. Journal of Paleontology 49:10621073.
Sprinkle, J. 1980. An overview of the fossil record. In Broadhead, T. W. and Waters, J. A., eds. Echinoderms: notes for a short course. Studies in Geology 3:1526. Department of Geological Sciences, University of Tennessee, Knoxville.
Sprinkle, J. 1982. Palaeocystitids. In Sprinkle, J., ed. Echinoderm faunas from the Bromide Formation (Middle Ordovician) of Oklahoma. University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions 1:289296.
Sprinkle, J. 1992. Radiation of Echinodermata. Pp. 375398in Lipps, J. H. and Signor, P. W., eds. Origin and early evolution of the Metazoa. Plenum, New York.
Sprinkle, J., and Collins, D. 1998. Revision of Echmatocrinus from the Middle Cambrian Burgess Shale of British Columbia. Lethaia 31:269282.
Sprinkle, J., and Guensburg, T. E. 1997. Early radiation of echinoderms. Pp. 205224in Waters, and Maples, 1997.
Sprinkle, J., and Robison, R. A. 1978. Ctenocystoids. Pp. T998T1002in Ubaghs, et al. 1978.
Sumrall, C. D. 1993. Thecal designs in isorophinid edrioasteroids and their taxonomic implications. Lethaia 26:289302.
Sumrall, C. D. 1997. The role of fossils in the phylogenetic reconstruction of Echinodermata. Pp. 267288in Waters, and Maples, 1997.
Termier, H., and Termier, G. 1973. Les Echinodermes Cincta du Cambrien de la Montagne Noire (France). Geobios 6:243265.
Ubaghs, G. 1967a. General characters of Echinodermata. Pp. S3S60in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Ubaghs, G. 1967b. Eocrinoidea. Pp. S455S495in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Ubaghs, G. 1967c. Stylophora. Pp. S495S565in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Ubaghs, G. 1967d. Homostelea. Pp. S565S581in Beaver, et al. 1967.
Ubaghs, G. 1971. Diversité et spécialisation des plus anciens échinodermes que l'on connaisse. Biological Reviews 46:157200.
Ubaghs, G. 1975. Early Paleozoic echinoderms. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 3:7998.
Ubaghs, G. 1978. Origin of crinoids. Pp. T275T281in Ubaghs, et al. 1978.
Ubaghs, G. 1981. Réflexions sur la nature et la fonction de l'appendice articulé des “carpoïdes” Stylophora (Echinodermata). Annales de Paléontologie Invertébrés 67:3348.
Ubaghs, G. 1987. Echinodermes nouveaux du Cambrien moyen de la Montagne Noire (France). Annales de Paléontologie 73:127.
Ubaghs, G. 1999. Echinodermes nouveaux du Cambrien supérieur de la Montagne Noire (France méridionale). Geobios 31:809829.
Ubaghs, G., and Robison, R. A. 1985. A new homoiostelean and a new eocrinoid from the Middle Cambrian of Utah. University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions, Paper 115:114.
Ubaghs, G., and Robison, R. A. 1988. Homalozoan echinoderms of the Wheeler Formation (Middle Cambrian) of western Utah. University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions, Paper 120:117.
Ubaghs, G., Moore, R. C., Wienberg Rasmussen, H., Lane, N. G., Breimer, A., Strimple, H. L., Brower, J. C., Jeffords, R. M., Sprinkle, J., Peck, R. E., Macurda, D. B. Jr., Meyer, D. L., Roux, M., Sieverts-Doreck, H., Fay, R. O., and Robison, R. A. 1978. Echinodermata 2. Part T ofMoore, R. C., ed. Treatise on invertebrate paleontology. Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, Boulder, Colo.
Waters, J. A., and Maples, C. G., eds. 1997. Geobiology of echinoderms. Paleontological Society Papers No. 3.
Whitehouse, F. W. 1941. Early Cambrian echinoderms similar to larval stages of Recent forms. Memoirs of the Queensland Museum 11:128.
Wray, G. A. 1999. Genes involved in the evolution of echinoderm morphology. Pp. 232in Carnevali, Candia and Bonasoro, 1999.

Are homalozoans echinoderms? An answer from the extraxial-axial theory

  • Bruno David (a1), Bertrand Lefebvre (a2), Rich Mooi (a3) and Ronald Parsley (a4)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed