Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on the Association Between Driving Ability and Neuropsychological Test Performances after Moderate to Severe Traumatic Brain Injury

  • Peter Egeto (a1), Shaylea D. Badovinac (a2), Michael G. Hutchison (a3) (a4), Tisha J. Ornstein (a1) and Tom A. Schweizer (a3) (a5) (a6) (a7) (a8)...

Abstract

Objectives: Guidelines on return-to-driving after traumatic brain injury (TBI) are scarce. Since driving requires the coordination of multiple cognitive, perceptual, and psychomotor functions, neuropsychological testing may offer an estimate of driving ability. To examine this, a meta-analysis of the relationship between neuropsychological testing and driving ability after TBI was performed. Methods: Hedge’s g and 95% confidence intervals were calculated using a random effects model. Analyses were performed on cognitive domains and individual tests. Meta-regressions examined the influence of study design, demographic, and clinical factors on effect sizes. Results: Eleven studies were included in the meta-analysis. Executive functions had the largest effect size (g = 0.60 [0.39–0.80]), followed by verbal memory (g = 0.49 [0.27–0.71]), processing speed/attention (g = 0.48 [0.29–0.67]), and visual memory (g = 0.43 [0.14–0.71]). Of the individual tests, Useful Field of Vision (UFOV) divided attention (g = 1.12 [0.52–1.72]), Trail Making Test B (g = 0.75 [0.42–1.08]), and UFOV selective attention (g = 0.67 [0.22–1.12]) had the largest effects. The effect sizes for Choice Reaction Time test and Trail Making Test A were g = 0.63 (0.09–1.16) and g = 0.58 (0.10–1.06), respectively. Years post injury (β = 0.11 [0.02–0.21] and age (β = 0.05 [0.009–0.09]) emerged as significant predictors of effect sizes (both p < .05). Conclusions: These results provide preliminary evidence of associations between neuropsychological test performance and driving ability after moderate to severe TBI and highlight moderating effects of demographic and clinical factors.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Correspondence and reprint requests to: Peter Egeto, 105 South Bond Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, M5B 2K3. Tele: 416-979-5000 x 4988, E-mail: peter.egeto@psych.ryerson.ca

References

Hide All
Armijo-Olivo, S., Stiles, C.R., Hagen, N.A., Biondo, P.D., & Cummings, G.G. (2012). Assessment of study quality for systematic reviews: A comparison of the cochrane collaboration risk of bias tool and the effective public health practice project quality assessment tool: Methodological research. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 18, 1218.
Army Individual Test Battery. (1944). Manual of directions and scoring. Washington, DC: War Department, Adjutant General’s Office.
Ball, K. & Owsley, C. (1992). The useful field of view test: A new technique for evaluating age-related declines in visual function. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 63, 7179.
Bernstein, J.P.K. & Calamia, M. (2018). Assessing the longer-term effects of mild traumatic brain injury on self-reported driving ability. PM & R : The Journal of Injury, Function, and Rehabilitation, 10, 11531163.
Bivona, U., D’Ippolito, M., Giustini, M., Vignally, P., Longo, E., Taggi, F., & Formisano, R. (1975). Return to driving after severe traumatic brain injury: Increased risk of traffic accidents and personal responsibility. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 27(3), 210215.
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L., Higgins, J., & Rothstein, H. (2005). Comprehensive meta-analysis version 2. Engelwood, NJ: Biostat.
Bottari, C., Lamothe, M.-P., Gosselin, N., Gélinas, I., & Ptito, A. (2012). Driving difficulties and adaptive strategies: The perception of individuals having sustained a mild traumatic brain injury. Rehabilitation Research and Practice, 2012, 837301.
Coleman, R.D., Rapport, L.J., Ergh, T.C., Hanks, R.A., Ricker, J.H., & Millis, S.R. (2002). Predictors of driving outcome after traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 83, 14151422.
Coughlan, A. & Hollows, S. (1985). The Adult Memory and Information Processing Battery (AMIPB). Leeds: St. Jame’s University Hospital.
Cox, D.J., Davis, M., Singh, H., Barbour, B., Nidiffer, F., Trudel, T., Mourant, R., & Moncrief, R. (2010). Driving rehabilitation for military personnel recovering from traumatic brain injury using virtual reality driving simulation: A feasibility study. Military Medicine, 175, 411416.
Cullen, N., Krakowski, A., & Taggart, C. (2014). ‘Early neuropsychological tests as correlates of return to driving after traumatic brain injury’: Corrigendum. Brain Injury, 28(4), 516.
Cyr, A.-A., Stinchcombe, A., Gagnon, S., Marshall, S., Hing, M.M.-S., & Finestone, H. (2009). Driving difficulties of brain-injured drivers in reaction to high-crash-risk simulated road events: A question of impaired divided attention? Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 31, 472482.
D’Elia, L.F., Satz, P., Uchiyama, C.L., & White, T. (1996). Color trails test. Odessa, FL: PAR.
Dikmen, S., Machamer, J., Powell, J., & Tempkin, N. (2003). Outcome 3 to 5 years after moderate to severe traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 84, 14491457.
Draper, K. & Ponsford, J. (2008). Cognitive functioning ten years following traumatic brain injury and rehabilitation. Neuropsychology, 22(5), 618625.
Duval, S. & Tweedie, R. (2000). Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics, 56, 455463.
Egger, M., Smith, G.D., Schneider, M., & Minder, C. (1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ, 315, 629634.
Faul, M., Xu, L., Wald, M., & Coronado, V. (2010). Traumatic brain injury in the United States: Emergency department visits, hospitalizations and deaths 2002–2006. Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control.
Formisano, R., Bivona, U., Brunelli, S., Giustini, M., Longo, E., & Taggi, F. (2005). A preliminary investigation of road traffic accident rate after severe brain injury. Brain Injury, 19(3), 159163.
Golz, D., Huchler, S., Jorg, A., & Kust, J. (2004). Beurteilung der Fahreignung [Assessment of driving ability]. Zeitschrift Fur Neuropsychologie, 15, 157168.
Gooden, J.R., Ponsford, J.L., Charlton, J.L., Ross, P.E., Marshall, S., Gagnon, S., Bédard, M., & Stolwyk, R.J. (2017). Self-awareness and self-ratings of on-road driving performance after traumatic brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 32, E50E59.
Gronwall, D. & Sampson, H. (1974). The psychological effects of concussion. Auckland, NZ: Auckland University Press.
Haselkorn, J.K., Mueller, B.A., & Rivara, F.A. (1998). Characteristics of drivers and driving record after traumatic and nontraumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 79(7), 738742.
Hird, M.A., Egeto, P., Fischer, C.E., Naglie, G., & Schweizer, T.A. (2016). A systematic review and meta-analysis of on-road simulator and cognitive driving assessment in Alzheimer’s disease and mild cognitive impairment. Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, 53(2), 713729.
Korteling, J.E. & Kaptein, N.A. (1996). Neuropsychological driving fitness tests for brain-damaged subjects. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 77, 138146.
Lee, H., Cameron, D., & Lee, A. (2003). Assessing the driving performance of older adult drivers: On-road versus simulated driving. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 35, 797803.
Lew, H.L., Poole, J.H., Lee, E.H., Jaffe, D.L., Huang, H.-C., & Brodd, E. (2005). Predictive validity of driving-simulator assessments following traumatic brain injury: A preliminary study. Brain Injury, 19(3), 177188.
Marshall, S.C., Molnar, F., Man-Son-Hing, M., Blair, R., Brosseau, L., Finestone, H.M., Lamothe, C., Korner-Bitensky, N., & Wilson, K.G. (2007). Predictors of driving ability following stroke: A systematic review. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation, 14(1), 98114.
Mathias, J.L., & Lucas, L.K. (2009). Cognitive predictors of unsafe driving in older drivers: A meta-analysis. International Psychogeriatrics, 21(4), 637653.
Mazaux, J.M., Masson, F., Levin, H.S., Alaoui, P., Maurette, P., & Barat, M. (1997). Long-term neuropsychological outcome and loss of social autonomy after traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 78(12), 13161320.
McKay, A., Liew, C., Schonberger, M., Ross, P., & Ponsford, J. (2016). Predictors of the on-road driving assessment after traumatic brain injury: Comparing cognitive tests, injury factors, and demographics. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 31, E44E52.
Michon, J.A. (1989). Explanatory pitfalls and rule-based driver models. Accident; Analysis and Prevention, 21, 341353.
Millis, S.R., Rosenthal, M., Novack, T.A., Sherer, M., Nick, T.G., Kreutzer, J.S., High, W.M. Jr., Ricker, J. (2001). Long-term neuropsychological outcome after traumatic brain injury. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation, 16, 343355.
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., & Altman, D.G. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 62, 10061012.
Nouri, F.M., Tinson, D.J., & Lincoln, N.B. (1987). Cognitive ability and driving after stroke. International Disability Studies, 9, 110115.
Novack, T.A., Alderson, A.L., Bush, B.A., Meythaler, J.M., & Canupp, K. (2000). Cognitive and functional recovery at 6 and 12 months post-TBI. Brain Injury : [BI], 14, 987996.
Novack, T., Banos, J.H., Alderson, A.L., Schneider, J.J., Weed, W., Blankenship, J., & Salisbury, D. (2006). UFOV performance and driving ability following traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury, 20, 455461.
Pietrapiana, P., Tamietto, M., Torrini, G., Mezzanato, T., Rago, R., & Perino, C. (2005). Role of premorbid factors in predicting safe return to driving after severe TBI. Brain Injury, 19, 197211.
Ponsford, J.L., Downing, M.G., Olver, J., Ponsford, M., Acher, R., Carty, M., & Spitz, G. (2014). Longitudinal follow-up of patients with traumatic brain injury: Outcome at two, five, and ten years post-injury. Journal of Neurotrauma, 31(1), 6477.
Preece, M.H.W., Horswill, M.S., & Geffen, G.M. (2010). Driving after concussion: The acute effect of mild traumatic brain injury on drivers’ hazard perception. Neuropsychology, 24, 493503.
Radford, K.A., Lincoln, N.B., & Murray-Leslie, C. (2004). Validation of the stroke drivers screening assessment for people with traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury : [BI], 18, 775786.
Schmidt, J., Hoffman, N., Ranchet, M., Miller, L., Tomporowski, P., Akinwuntan, A., & Devos, H. (2017). Driving after concussion: Is it safe to drive after symptoms resolve? Journal of Neurotrauma, 34, 15711578.
Schneider, J.J., & Gouvier, W.D. (2005). Utility of the UFOV test with mild traumatic brain injury. Applied Neuropsychology, 12, 138142.
Smith, A. (1982). Symbol Digit Modalities Test (SDMT). Manual (Revised). Los Angeles: Western Psychological Services.
Sommer, M., Heidinger, C., Arendasy, M., Schauer, S., Schmitz-Gielsdorf, J., & Hausler, J. (2010). Cognitive and personality determinants of post-injury driving fitness. Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology : The Official Journal of the National Academy of Neuropsychologists, 25, 99117.
Sosin, D.M., Sacks, J.J., & Smith, S.M. (1989). Head injury-associated deaths in the United States from 1979 to 1986. JAMA, 262(16), 22512255.
Spinnler, H. & Tognoni, G. (1987). Standardizzazione e taratura italiana di test neuropsicologici. Italian Journal of Neuroscience, 6, 4446.
Stroop, J. (1935). Studies of interference in serial verbal reactions. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 18, 643662.
Wechsler, D. (1997). WAIS-III administration and scoring manual. San Antonio, TX: Pearson.
Wechsler, D. (2008). WAIS-IV technical and interpretive manual. San Antonio, TX: Pearson.
Wechsler, D. (2009). WMS-IV administration and scoring manual. San Antonio, TX: Pearson Education.
Werner, C. & Engelhard, K. (2007). Pathophysiology of traumatic brain injury. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 99(1), 49.

Keywords

Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary materials

Egeto et al. supplementary material
Egeto et al. supplementary material 1

 Word (15 KB)
15 KB

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed