No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
From Roadside Stops to the Courthouse Stairs: Defendant Race and the Attorney’s Role in Routine Cases
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 March 2023
Abstract
Latinos, especially those who recently immigrated, face many obstacles in navigating the political and judicial environment in the United States. While prior scholarship suggests that racial minorities are more likely to be stopped by law enforcement for traffic violations and face harsher penalties for major crimes, little research has explored whether a defendant’s characteristics are influential in routine traffic court cases. Using an original database, this paper examines disparate treatment in speeding ticket reductions. The results indicate that Latino defendants are less likely to receive meaningful reductions to their charges. However, attorney representation greatly lessens the likelihood of disparate treatment for Latino drivers. As traffic court proceedings often represent the only interaction most people have with the judicial system, these findings have significant implications for racial equality, the administration of justice, attorney representation, and public opinion of the judiciary.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Law and Courts Organized Section of the American Political Science Association
References
Alvarez-Rivera, Lorna L., Nobles, Matt R., and Lersch, Kim M.. 2014. “Latino Immigrant Acculturation and Crime.” American Journal of Criminal Justice 39: 315–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Andersen, Kristi. 2010. New Immigrant Communities: Finding a Place in Local Politics. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barclay, Scott and Chomsky, Daniel. 2014. “How Do Cause Lawyers Decide When and Where to Litigate on behalf of Their Cause?” Law and Society Review 48:595–620.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Behrens, Angela, Uggen, Christopher, and Manza, Jeff. 2003. “Ballot Manipulation and the ‘Menace of Negro Domination’: Racial Threat and the Felon Disenfranchisement in the United States, 1850–2002.” American Journal of Sociology 109:559–605.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beltrán, Cristina. 2010. The Trouble with Unity: Latino Politics and the Creation of Identity. Oxford University Press on Demand.Google Scholar
Berdejo, Carlos. 2018. “Criminalizing Race: Racial Disparities in Plea-Bargaining.” Boston College Law Review 59(4): 1187–1250.Google Scholar
Birch, Traci. 2015. “Skin Color and the Criminal Justice System: Beyond Black-White Disparities in Sentencing.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 12:395–420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bleakley, Hoyt, and Chin, Aimee. 2010. “Age at Arrival, English Proficiency, and Social Assimilation among US Immigrants.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 2 (1): 165–92.Google Scholar
Blumer, Herbert. 1958. “Race Prejudice as a Sense of Group Position.” Pacific Sociological Review 1: 3–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bobo, Lawrence and Hutchings, Vincent L.. 1996. “Perceptions of Racial Group Coopetition: Extending Blumer’s Theory of Group Position to a Multiracial Social Context.” American Sociological Review 61: 915–972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borgida, Eugene, and Miller, Andrea. 2013. “Implicit and explicit measurement approaches to research on policy implementation: The case of race-based disparities in criminal justice.” PS: Political Science & Politics 46: 532–536.Google Scholar
Boyd, Christina L., and Hoffman, David A.. 2013. “Litigating Toward Settlement.” Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 29:898–929.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brayne, Sarah. 2014. “Surveillance and System Avoidance: Criminal Justice Contact and Institutional Attachment.” American Sociological Review 79(3): 367–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, Karin and Coulter, Philip B.. 1983. “Subjective and Objective Measures of Police Service Delivery.” Public Administration Review 43: 50–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burden, Barry C., and Neiheisel, Jacob R.. 2013. “Election Administration and the Pure Effect of Voter Registration on Turnout.” Political Research Quarterly 66: 77–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carlos, Roberto F. 2021. “The Politics of the Mundane.” American Political Science Review 115(3): 775–789.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, Tom S., Cohen, Elisha, Glynn, Adam, Owens, Michael Leo, Gunderson, Anna, and Schiff, Kaylyn Jackson. 2020. “Are Police Racially Biased in the Decision to Shoot?” Working Paper. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58d3d264893fc0bdd12db507 5 (2020): 1591117221040.Google Scholar
Collins, Todd, Moyer, Laura, and Dumas, Tao. 2017. “Being Part of the ‘Home Team’: Perceptions of Professional Interactions with Outsider Attorneys.” Journal of Law and Courts 5: 141–171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Croyle, James L. 1983. “Measuring and Explaining Disparities in Felony Sentences: Courtroom Work Group Factors and Race, Sex, and Socioeconomic Influences on Sentencing Severity.” Political Behavior 5(1): 135–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Curry, Theodore R., and Corral-Camacho, Guadalupe. 2008. “Sentencing Young Minority Males for Drug Offenses: Testing for Conditional Effects Between Race/Ethnicity, Gender and Age During the US War on Drugs.” Punishment & Society 10: 253–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Doerner, Jill K., and Demuth, Stephen. 2010. “The Independent and Joint Effects of Race/Ethnicity, Gender, and Age on Sentencing Outcomes in US Federal Courts.” Justice Quarterly 27: 1–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dumas, Tao L., Haynie, Stacia L., and Daboval, Dorothy. 2015. “Does Size Matter? The Influence of Law Firm Size on Litigant Success Rates.” Justice System Journal 36: 341–354.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Durose, Matthew R., Farole, Donald, and Rosenmerkle, Sean P. Jr. 2009. “Felony Sentences in State Courts, 2006 – Statistical Tables.” Bureau of Justice Statistics 1–45. Available at www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fssc06st.pdf.Google Scholar
Epstein, Lee, Landes, William M., and Posner, Ricard A.. 2013. The Behavior of Federal Judges: A Theoretical and Empirical Study of Rational Choice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Farrell, Amy. 2015. “Explaining Leniency: Organizational Predictors of the Differential Treatment of Men and Women in Traffic Stops.” Crime and Delinquency: 61: 509–537.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Farrell, Amy, McDevitt, Jack, Bailey, Lisa, Andresen, Carsten, and Pierce, Erica. 2004. “Massachusetts racial and gender profiling study.” Northeastern University, Institute on Race and Justice. http://www.mass.gov/Eeops/docs/eops/Racial_and_Gender_Profiling_Study.pdf.Google Scholar
de Figueiredo, Luiz F. Poli, Rasslan, Samir, Burscagin, Vicgo, Cruz, Ruy Jr. and Rocha e Silva, Mauricio. 2001. “Increases in Fines and Driver License Withdrawal.” Injury 32: 91–94.Google Scholar
Feeley, Malcolm M. The Process is the Punishment: Handling Cases in a Lower Criminal Court. Russell Sage Foundation, 1979.Google Scholar
Fischman, Joshua B., and Schanzenbach, Max M.. 2011. “Do Standards of Review Matter? The Case of Federal Criminal Sentencing.” Journal of Legal Studies 40: 405–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Friedrich, Robert J. 1982. “In Defense of Multiplicative Terms in Multiple Regression Equations.” American Journal of Political Science 26: 797–833.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galanter, Marc. 1974. “Why the “Haves” Come Out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change.” Law and Society Review 9(1): 95–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galanter, Marc. 2004. “The Vanishing Trial: An Examination of Trials and Related Matters in Federal and State Courts.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 1: 459–570.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giles, Micheal W., and Hertz, Kaenan. 1994. “Racial Threat and Partisan Identification.” American Political Science Review 88: 317–326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gordon, Sanford C., and Huber, Gregory A.. 2002. “Citizen Oversight and the Electoral Incentives of Criminal Prosecutors.” American Journal of Political Science 46: 334–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, David A. 1999. “Stories, the Statistics, and the Law: Why Driving While Black Matters.” Minnesota Law Review 84: 265–326.Google Scholar
Haynie, Stacia L., and Sill, Kaitlyn L.. 2007. “Experienced Advocates and Litigation Outcomes Repeat Players in the South African Supreme Court of Appeal.” Political Research Quarterly 60: 443–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hazelton, Morgan L.W., Montgomery, Jacob M., and Nyhan, Brendan. 2016. “Does Public Financing Affect Judicial Behavior? Evidence from the North Carolina Supreme Court.” American Politics Research 44: 587–617.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hingson, Ralph W., Howland, Jonathan, and Levenson, Suzette. 1988. “Effects of Legislative Reform to Reduce Drunken Driving and Alcohol-related Traffic Fatalities.” Public Health Reports 103: 659–667.Google ScholarPubMed
Johnson, Brian D. 2003. “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Sentencing Departures Across Modes of Conviction.” Criminology 41: 449–490.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kam, Cindy D., and Franzese, J. Jr. 2007. Modeling and Interpreting Hypotheses in Regression Analysis. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Kastellec, Jonathan P., and Lax, Jeffrey R.. 2008. “Case Selection and the Study of Judicial Politics.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 5: 407–446.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kautt, Paula M. 2002. “Location, Location, Location: Interdistrict and Intercircuit Variation in Sentencing Outcomes for Federal Drug-Trafficking Offenses.” Justice Quarterly 19: 633–671.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Key, V.O. Jr. [1949] 2001. Southern Politics in State and Nation. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press.Google Scholar
Kim, Pauline T., Schlanger, Margo, Boyd, Christina L., and Martin, Andrew D.. 2009. “How Should We Study District Judge Decision-Making?” Washington University Journal of Law & Policy 29: 83–112.Google Scholar
King, Ryan D., and Wheelock, Darren. 2007. “Group Threat and Social Control: Race, Perceptions of Minorities and the Desire to Punish.” Social Forces 85: 1255–1280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knowles, John, Persico, Nicola, and Todd, Petra. 2001. “Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence.” Journal of Political Economy 109(1): 203–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knox, Dean, Lowe, Will, and Mummolo, Jonathan. 2020. “Administrative Records Mask Racially Biased Policing.” American Political Science Review 114(3): 619–637.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kritzer, Herbert M. 1990. The Justice Broker: Lawyers and Ordinary Litigation. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kritzer, Herbert M. 1991. Let’s Make a Deal: Understanding the Negotiation Process in Ordinary Litigation. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Kritzer, Herbert M 2012. “Understanding Trial Courts Means Understanding Lawyers.” Law and Courts Newsletter 22(Summer): 8–15. Available at http://lawcourts.org/pubs/newsletter/index.html.Google Scholar
Kutateladze, Beski Luka, Andiloro, Nancy R. and Johnson, Brian D.. 2016. “Opening Pandora’s Box: How Does Defendant Race Influence Plea Bargaining?” Justice Quarterly 33:398–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
LaFountain, R, Schauffler, R, Holt, K., and Lewis, K.. 2016. “Court Statistics Project Dataviewer.” www.courtstatics.orgGoogle Scholar
Lum, Terry Y., and Vanderaa, Juliane P.. 2010. “Health Disparities Among Immigrant and Non-immigrant Elders.” Immigrant Minority Health 12: 743–753.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lundman, Richard J. 1979. “Organizational Norms and Police Discretion.” Criminology 17: 159–171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lynch, Mona and Omori, Maris. 2014. “Legal Change and Sentencing Norms in the Wake of Booker: The Impact of Time and Place on Drug Trafficking Cases in Federal Court.” Law and Society Review 48: 411–445.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maas, Cora J.M., and Hox, Joop J.. 2005. “Sufficient Sample Sizes for Multilevel Modeling.” Methodology 1: 86–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Makowsky, Michael D., and Stratmann, Thomas. 2009. “Political Economy at Any Speed: What Determines Traffic Citations?” The American Economic Review 99: 509–527.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Massie, Dawn L., Campbell, Kenneth L., and Williams, Allan F.. 1995. “Traffic Accidents Involvement Rates Driver Age and Gender.” Accident, Analysis and Prevention. 27: 73–87.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Matsubayashi, Tetsua, and Ueda, Michiko. 2011. “Political Knowledge and the Use of Candidate Race as a Voting Cue.” American Politics Research 39: 380–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McAtee, Andrea, and McGuire, Kevin T. 2007. “Lawyers, Justices, and Issue Salience: When and How Do Legal Arguments Affect the U.S. Supreme Court?” Law & Society Review 41(2): 259–278.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McClain, Paula D., Carew, Jessica D. Johnson, Walton, Eugene Jr. and Watts, Candis S.. 2009. “Group Membership, Group Identity, and Group Consciousness: Measures of Racial Identity in American Politics?” Annual Review of Political Science 12: 471–485.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metcalfe, Christi. 2016. “The Role of Courtroom Workgroups in Felony Case Dispositions: An Analysis of Workgroup Familiarity and Similarity.” Law & Society Review 50: 637–673.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michelson, Melissa R. 2003. “The Corrosive Effect of Acculturation: How Mexican Americans Lose Political Trust.” Social Science Quarterly 84: 918–933.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morenoff, Jeffrey D., and Astor, Avraham. 2006. “Immigrant Assimilation and Crime: Generational Differences in Youth Violence in Chicago.” In Immigration and Crime, edited by Martinez, Ramiro Jr. and Valenzuela, Abel Jr. New York: New York University Press, 36–64.Google Scholar
Mucchetti, Anthony E. 2005. “Driving While Brown: A Proposal for Ending Racial Profiling in Emerging Latino Communities.” Harvard Latino Law Review 8: 1–183.Google Scholar
Mustard, David B. 2001. “Race, Ethnic, Gender Disparities in Sentencing: Evidence from the US Federal Courts.” Journal of Law and Economics 44: 285–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muthen, Bengt. 1997. “Latent Variable Modeling of Longitudinal and Multilevel Data.” Sociological Methodology 27: 453–480.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Natapoff, Alexandra. Punishment Without Crime: How Our Massive Misdemeanor System Traps the Innocent and Makes America More Unequal. Hachette UK, 2018.Google Scholar
Nicholson-Crotty, Sean, and Meier, Kenneth J.. 2002. “Size Doesn’t Matter: In Defense of Single-State Studies.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 2: 411–422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Novak, Kenneth J. 2004. “Disparity and Racial Profiling in Traffic Enforcement.” Police Quarterly 7: 65–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
O’Neil, Michael Edmund. 2003. “When Prosecutors Don’t: Trends in Federal Prosecutorial Declinations.” Notre Dame Law Review 79: 221–290.Google Scholar
Overby, L. Marvin, Brown, Robert D., Bruce, John M., Smith, Charles E. Jr., and Winkle, John W. III. 2005. “Race, Political Empowerment, and Minority Perceptions of Judicial Fairness.” Social Science Quarterly 86: 444–462.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ostrom, Brian L., Strickland, Shauna M., and Hannaford-Agor, Paula L.. 2004. “Examining Trial Trends in State Courts: 1976-2002.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 1: 755–782.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pickerill, J. Mitchell, Mosher, Clayton, and Pratt, Travis. 2009. “Search and Seizure, Racial Profiling, and Traffic Stops: A Disparate Impact Framework.” Law and Policy 31: 1–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Priest, George L., and Klein, Benjamin. 1984. “The Selection of Disputes for Litigation.” The Journal of Legal Studies 13: 1–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rahel, Kate O. 2013. “Why the Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel Includes an Out-of-Court Interpreter." Iowa Law Review 99(5): 2299–2344.Google Scholar
Rehavi, M. Marit, and Starr, Sonja B.. 2014. “Racial Disparity in Federal Criminal Sentences.” Journal of Political Economy 122(6): 1320–1354.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rocha, Rene R., and Espino, Rodolfo. 2009. “Racial Threat, Residential Segregation, and the Policy Attitudes of Anglos.” Political Research Quarterly 62:415–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodriguez, Clara E. 2000. Changing Race: Latinos, the Census, and the History of Ethnicity in the United States. New York University Press.Google Scholar
Rodriguez, S. Fernando, Curry, Theodore R., and Lee, Gang. 2006. “Sentencing: Do Effects Vary Across Violent, Property, and Drug Offenses?” Social Science Quarterly 87: 318–339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rojeck, Jeff, Rosenfeld, Richard, and Decker, Scott. 2012. “Police Race: The Racial Stratification of Searches in Police Traffic Stops.” Criminology 50: 992–1024.Google Scholar
Romano, Eduardo, Tippetts, Scott, Blackman, Kenneth, and Voas, Robert 2005. “Acculturation, Income, Education, Safety Belt Use, and Fatal Motor Vehicle Crashes in California.” Prevention Science 6: 139–148.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rosenstone, Steven J., and Hansen, John Mark. 1993. Mobilization, Participation, and Democracy in America. London: Longman Publishing Group.Google Scholar
Rowland, Charles K., and Carp, Robert A.. 1996. Politics and Judgment in Federal District Courts. Lawrence, KS: University of Kansas Press.Google Scholar
Schanzenbach, Max M. and Tiller, Emerson. 2007. “Strategic Judging under the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines: Positive Political Theory and Evidence.” .Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization 23: 24–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scherer, Nancy, and Curry, Brett. 2010. “Does Descriptive Race Representation Enhance Institutional Legitimacy? The Case of the U.S. Courts.” The Journal of Politics 72(1): 90–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sidanius, Jim, Pratto, Felicia, van Laar, Colette, and Levin, Shana. 2004. “Social Dominance Theory: Its Agenda and Method.” Political Psychology 25:845–880.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Alisa and Maddan, Sean. 2022. “The Interaction between Legal Representation and Extralegal Factors on Nonviolent Misdemeanor Case Outcomes.” Justice System Journal 43(1): 102–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Solis, Julia M., Marks, Gary, Garcia, Melinda, and Shelton, David. 1990. “Acculturation, access to care, and use of preventive services by Hispanics: Findings from HHANES 1982–84.” American Journal of Public Health 80: 11–19.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sommers, Ira, Goldstein, Johnathan, and Baskin, Deborah. 2014. “The Intersection of Victims’ and Offenders’ Sex and Race/Ethnicity on Prosecutorial Decisions for Violent Crimes.” Justice System Journal 35: 178–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Starr, Sonja B. “Estimating Gender Disparities in Federal Criminal Cases.” 2015. American Law and Economic Review 17: 127–159.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ulmer, Jeffrey T. 2005. “The Localized Uses of Federal Sentencing Guidelines in Four U.S. District Courts: Evidence of Processual Order.” Symbolic Interaction 28: 255–279.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ulmer, Jeffrey T., Light, Michael T., and Kramer, John H.. 2011. “Racial Disparity in the Wake of the Booker/Fanfan Decision.” Criminology and Public Policy 10: 1077–1118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Unah, Issac. 2011. “Empirical Analysis of Race and the Process of Capital Punishment in North Carolina.” Michigan State Law Review 2011: 609–658.Google Scholar
United States Census Bureau. 2020. QuickFacts – North Carolina. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/NCGoogle Scholar
Valention, Nicholas A., Hutchings, Vincent L., and White, Ismail K.. 2002. “Cues that Matter: How Political Ads Prime Racial Attitudes During Campaigns.” American Political Science Review 96: 75–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Warren, Patricia, Tomaskovic-Devey, Donald, Smith, William, Zingraff, Matthew, and Mason, Marcinda. 2006. “Driving While Black: Bias Processes and Racial Disparity in Police Stops.” Criminology 44: 709–738.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, Ismail. 2007. “When Race Matters and When It Doesn’t: Racial Group Differences in Response to Racial Cues.” American Political Science Review 101: 339–354.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yang, Crystal S. 2014. “Have Interjudge Sentencing Disparities Increased in an Advisory Guidelines Regime-Evidence from Booker.” New York University Law Review 89: 1268–1342.Google Scholar
Xu, Jun. 2005. “Why Do Minorities Participate Less? The Effects of Immigration, Education, and Electoral Process on Asian American Voter Registration and Turnout.” Social Science Research 34: 682–702.CrossRefGoogle Scholar