No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
The Nationalist Credentials of Christian Indonesians and the Legacy of Colonial Racism1
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 June 2011
Extract
The Dutch civil servants, missionaries, business people, and others living and working in the Dutch East Indies during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries looked homeward to a society in process of being ‘pillarized’ into socio-religious blocks. Some scholars have observed how the new nation that arose from that colony, Indonesia, developed a similar kind of structure called aliran (literally, currents or streams) best known to scholars, perhaps, through Geertz's classic ethnography, Religion of Java. There is surely some ontogenetic relationship between Dutch ‘pillarization’ and Indonesian aliranisation. Drawing on ideals about a public church embedded organically in a particular society and culture, a volkskerk, Protestant missionaries brought a different theological version of Christianity compared to their Catholic competitor, but also like that competitor, church-affiliated schools, hospitals and social services. Modernist Muslim organisations such as Muhammadiya copied these religiously based services and institutions, thus ‘pillarizing’ Islam in response to the Christian presence. It is not surprising, then, that when Indonesians were first able to form political parties, some of these were also defined along sectarian lines – Catholic, Protestant, traditionalist and modernist Muslim.
- Type
- Conference: ‘An Apartheid of Souls’
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 2003
References
Notes
2 Toer, Pramoedya Ananta, This Earth of Mankind (New York 1996) 145Google Scholar.
3 Geertz, Clifford, The Religion of Java (New York 1960)Google Scholar.
4 Schlegel, Stuart A., ‘Technocrats in a Muslim Society: Symbolic Community in Aceh’ in: Davis, Gloria ed., What is Modem Indonesian Culture? (Athens, Ohio 1979) 232–247Google Scholar.
5 E.g. Kipp, Rita Smith, Dissociated Identities: Ethnicity, Religion, and Class in an Indonesian Society (Ann Arbor 1993) 91–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schrauwers, Albert, Colonial ‘Reformation’ in the High-lands of Central Sulawesi, Indonesia, 1892-1995 (Toronto 2000) 214–224CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 Stoler, Ann Laura, ‘Rethinking Colonial Categories: European Communities and the Boundaries of Rule’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 31 (1989) 134–138CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Gouda, Frances, Dutch Culture Overseas: Colonial Practice in the Netherlands Indies 1900-1942 (Amsterdam 1995) 28–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
8 Ibid., 249, n. 80 for various estimates of the number of Europeans in the Indies.
9 The equation of Native with Muslim is clear from the fact that the colonial Office of Native Affairs (Kantoor voor lnlandse Zaken) was concerned almost exclusively with monitoring Islam. It is the bureaucratic predecessor of Indonesia's Department of Religion.
10 Lijphart, Arend, The Politics of Accommodation: Pluralism and Democracy in the Netherlands (Berkeley 1975)Google Scholar.
11 Goudsblom, Johan, Dutch Society (New York 1966) 124Google Scholar.
12 Mehden, Fred R. von der, Religion and Nationalism in Southeast Asia (Madison 1963) 171, 182; (Han 1967: 52)Google Scholar.
13 Anderson, Benedict R. O'G., Mythology and the Tolerance of the Javanese (Ithaca 1996) 14Google Scholar.
14 On Africa see for example Ayandele, Emmanuel A., The Missionary Impact on Modern Nigeria, 1842-1914 (London 1971)Google Scholar; Majeke, Nosipho, The Role of Missionaries in Conquest (Johannesburg 1952)Google Scholar; on Burma see Mehden, , Religion and Nationalism.Google Scholar
15 Ngelow, Zakaria, Kekristenan dan Nasionalisme. Perjumpaan Umat Kristen Protestan dengan Pergerakan Nasional Indonesia (Jakarta 1996)Google Scholar; Muskens, M.P.M. ed., Sejarah Cereja Katolik (Indonesia 1972-1974)Google Scholar; Sidjabat, W.B. ed., Partisipasi Kristen dalam Nation Building di Indonesia (Jakarta 1968)Google Scholar.
16 Billig, Michael, Banal Nationalism (London 1995)Google Scholar; Chatterjee, Partha, The Nation and its Fragments (Princeton 1993)Google Scholar; Dirks, Nicholas, ‘History as a Sign of the Modern’, Public Culture 2 (1990) 25–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 Milner, Anthony, The Invention of Politics in Colonial Malaya: Contesting Nationalism and the Expansion of the Public Sphere (Cambridge 1994) 282Google Scholar.
18 Reid, Anthony, ‘Entrepreneurial Minorities, Nationalism, and the State’ in: Chirot, Daniel and Reid, Anthony eds, Essential Outsiders (Seattle 1997) 38Google Scholar.
19 Henley, David E.F., Nationalism and Regionalism in a Colonial Context: Minahassa in the Dutch East Indies (Leiden 1996)Google Scholar.
20 Shiraishi, Takashi, Age in Motion: Popular Radicalism in Java, 1912-1926 (Ithaca 1990)Google Scholar.
21 Ngelow, , KekristenanGoogle Scholar; Verdoorn, J.A., De lending en net Indonesisch Nationalisme (Amsterdam 1945)Google Scholar.
22 Mobini-Kesheh, Natalie, The Hadrami Awakening: Community and Identity in the Netherlands East Indies, 1900-1942 (Ithaca, N.Y. 1999) 15Google Scholar.
23 Cf. Randwijck, S.C. Graaf van, Handelen en denken in dienst der zending (The Hague 1981) Vol. 1, 336–337Google Scholar.
24 Mackie, J.A.C., ‘Anti-Chinese Outbreaks in Indonesia, 1959-68’ in: Mackie, J.A.C. ed., The Chinese in Indonesia (Honolulu 1976) 75–138Google Scholar.
25 The question in brackets is mine. Schmutzer, Eduard J.M., Dutch Colonial Policy and the Search for Identity in Indonesia, 1920-31 (Leiden 1977) 85Google Scholar.
26 Simtupang, Tahi Bonar, The Fallacy of a Myth (Jakarta 1996) 37Google Scholar.
27 Kipp, , Dissociated Identities, 24–32Google Scholar.
28 Simtupang, Tahi Bonar, Report from Banararv Experiences During the People's War (Ithaca, N.Y. 1972) 89Google Scholar.
29 Simtupang, , The Fallacy, 167Google Scholar.
30 Ibid, 26.
31 Feith, Herbert, ‘Indonesia’ in: Kahin, George ed., Government and Politics of Southeast Asia (Ithaca 1964) 193Google Scholar.
32 Taylor, Jean Gelman, The Social World of Batavia: European and Eurasian in Dutch Asia (Madison 1983) 47Google Scholar; See also Mastenbroek, William Edward van, De Historische Ontwikkeling van de Staatrechtelijke Indeeling der Bevolking van Nederlandsch-lndie (Wageningen 1934) 5Google Scholar.
33 Mastenbroek, , Historische Ontwikkeling, 21Google Scholar; Blussé, Leonard, Strange Company: Chinese Settlers, Mestizo Women and the Dutch in VOC Batavia (Leiden 1988)Google Scholar.
34 Taylor, , Social World of Batavia, 28Google Scholar.
35 Mastenbroek, , Historische Ontwikkeling, 45Google Scholar.
36 Taylor, , Social World of Batauia, 67Google Scholar.
37 Ibid., 76, 85.
38 Mastenbroek, , Historische Ontwikkeling, 48Google Scholar.
39 Taylor, , Social World of Batavia, 118Google Scholar.
40 Berg, L.W.C. van den, ‘De Rechtstoestand der Inlandsche Christenen in Nederlandsch-lndie en de Bezwaren daaruit voor de Zending Voortvloeiende’, Orgaan NZV 39 (1899) 85–100Google Scholar.
41 R.r. Article 109, cited inMastenbroek, , Historische Ontwikkeling, 107Google Scholar.
42 Porte, André de la, Recht en Rechtsbedeeling in Nederlandsch-lndië (The Hague 1926)Google Scholar.
43 Coppel, Charles A., ‘The Indonesian Chinese as “Foreign Orientals” in the Netherlands Indies’ in: Lindsey, Timothy ed., Indonesia: Law and Society (Sydney 1999) 35Google Scholar.
44 Mastenbroek, , Historische Ontwikkeling, 49, 54–55Google Scholar.
45 Randwijck, , Handelen en Denken, vol. 1 271Google Scholar.
46 Copple, , ‘Indonesian Chinese’, 33Google Scholar; Voilenhoven, Cornellis van, ‘Geen Juristenrecht voor den Inlander’, Het Adatrect van Indie 3 (1933) 31Google Scholar.
47 Mahadi, , ‘Islam and Law in Indonesia’ in: Kipp, Rita Smith and Rodgers, Susan eds, Indonesian Religions in Transition (Tuscon 1987) 213Google Scholar.
48 Voilenhoven, Cornelis van, Staatsrecht Overzee (Leiden 1934) 96; J.F. Hollema ed., Van Voilenhoven on Indonesian Adat Law: Selections from Het Adatrecht van Nederlandschlndie (The Hague 1981) 8-15Google Scholar.
49 Tagliacozzo, Eric, ‘Kettle on a Slow Boil: Batavia's Threat Perceptions in the Indies’ Outer Islands, 1870-1910’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 31 (2000) 94CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
50 Nordholt, Henk Schulte, ‘Localizing Modernity in Colonial Bali during the 1930s’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 31 (2000) 103CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
51 Ellen, Roy F., ‘The Development of Anthropology and Colonial Policy in the Netherlands: 1800-1960’, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 12 (1976) 3183.0.CO;2-D>CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Gouda, , Dutch Culture, 62Google Scholar; Mahadi, , ‘Islam and Law’, 215Google Scholar.
52 Prins, W.F., ‘De Bevolkingsgroepen in het Nederlandsch-lndische Recht’, Kolonial Studien 17/2 (1933) 679Google Scholar.
53 Mobini-Kesheh, , The Hadrami Awakening, 44Google Scholar.
54 Shiraishi, , Age in Motion, 188Google Scholar.
55 Schijf, H. and B.A.M. ‘The Chinese Doctors in the Dutch East Indies: Social Mobility among an Ethnic Trading Minority in Colonial Society’, Indonesia 53 (1992) 36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
56 Kleintjes, Ph., Staatsinstellingen van Nederlandsch-lndie (Amsterdam 1927) 102Google Scholar.
57 Louter, Jan de, Handleldlng tot de Kennis van de Staats- en Administratief Recht van Nederlands-lndië (The Hague 1904) 102, 126Google Scholar.
58 Mobini-Kesheh, , The Hadrami Awakening, 44Google Scholar.
59 Kleintjes, , Staatsintellingen, 101–102Google Scholar.
60 Schijf, and The, ‘Chinese Doctors’, 36Google Scholar.
61 Fasseur, C., ‘Cornerstone and Stumbling Block: Racial Classification and the Late Colonial State in Indonesia’ in: Cribb, Robert ed., The Late Colonial State in Indonesia: Political and Economic Foundations of the Netherlands Indies 1880-1942 (The Hague 1994) 42Google Scholar.
62 Louter, , Handleiding, 124Google Scholar.
63 Legge, J.D., Indonesia (Englewood Cliffs 1964) 84–85Google Scholar; van der Kroef, Justus M., The Dialectic of Colonial Indonesian History (Amsterdam 1963)Google Scholar; Schmutzer, , Dutch Colonial Policy.Google Scholar
64 Randwijck, , Handelen en Denken, 271Google Scholar.
65 Other colonial rulers faced the same conundrum. The British in India did not resort to adat law for the Natives as the Dutch had done, but fell back instead on the criterion of converts’ former religion as a basis for their legal positions. Thus, Christian converts were protected from the civil death that would have made them non-persons and ineligible to hold property according to local custom, but by the same stroke had to follow Hindu laws in matters of family law and inheritance when, by reason of education and experience, they would often have preferred British laws; see viswnathan, Gauri, Outside the Fold: Conversion, Modernity, and Belief (Princeton 1998).Google Scholar Their conversion, then, placed them ‘outside the fold’, so to speak, neither fully ‘Hindu’ anymore in the eyes of their communities, nor ever fully equal to the British.
66 Gouda, , Dutch Culture, 25Google Scholar.
67 For the full text of the oath, translated into English, Ingleson, John, Road to Exile: The Indonesian nationalist Movement, 1927-1934 (Singapore 1979) 66Google Scholar.
68 Ingleson describes this event as one of the ‘best remembered’ in the nationalist struggle, but it is often remembered inaccurately. As Hans van Miert points out, this conference did not immediately spell the end of all divisiveness in the student movement, especially with regard to Islamic groups. Miert, J.J. van, Een koel hoofd en een warm hart: nationalisme, javanisme enjeugdbeweging in Nederlands-lndie, 1918-1930 (Amsterdam 1995).Google Scholar On the same point see also Suryadinta, Leo, ‘Indonesian Nationalism and the Pre-war Youth Movement: A Reexamination’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 9 (1978) 99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
69 Ricklefs, M.C., A History of Modem Indonesia since c. 1300 (Stanford 1993) 186CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
70 Suryadinta, Leo, Dilema Minoritas Tionghoa (Jakarta 1982) 5, n. 5Google Scholar.
71 Kenangan, J. Leimena Panitia Buku, Kewarganegaraan yang Bertanggungjawab (Jakarta 1995) 10Google Scholar.
72 Tan, Liok Ee, The Rhetoric of Bangsa and Minzu: Community and Nation in Tension, the Malay Peninsula, 1900-1955 (Australia 1988) 16Google Scholar; Omar, Ariffin, Bangsa Melayu: Malay Concepts of Democracy and Community 1945-1950 (Kuala Lumpur, Oxford 1993) 176–177Google Scholar.
73 Milner, Invention of Politics.
74 Tan, , Rhetoric of Bangsa, 9Google Scholar.
75 These usages in Malay may have also been affected by the English discourse around race in this period and the rise of ‘scientific’ racism. For purposes of taking censuses, the British shifted from counting members of various ‘nationalities’ to counting those of different ‘races’. Hirschman, Charles, ‘The Meaning and Measurement of Ethnicity in Malaysia: An Analysis of Census Classifications’, The Journal of Asian Studies 46 (1987) 555–581CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
76 Milner, , Invention of PoliticsGoogle Scholar; Omar, , Bangsa Melayu, 55Google Scholar.
77 Omar, , Bangsa Melayu, 64.Google Scholar See also Reid, , ‘Entrepreneurial Minorities’Google Scholar.
78 Omar, , Bangsa Melayu, 62Google Scholar.
79 Siddique, Sharon and Suryadinata, Leo, ‘Bumiputera and Pribumi: Economic Nationalism (Indigenism) in Malaysia and Indonesia’, Pacific Affairs 54 (1981-1982) 665CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
80 Suryadinata, Leo, ‘Pre-war Indonesian Nationalism and the Peranakan Chinese’, Indonesia 11 (1971) 84–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
81 Ibid., 668.
82 Reid, , ‘Entrepreneurial Minorities’, 57Google Scholar.
83 Shiraishi, Takashi, ‘Anti-Sinicsm in Java's New Order’ in: Reid, , Essential Outsiders, 191Google Scholar.
84 Mobini-Kesheh, , The Hadrami Awakening, 45Google Scholar.
85 Ibid., 139.
86 Mackie, J.A.C. and Coppel, Charles A., ‘A Preliminary Survey’ in: Mackie, J.A.C. ed., The Chinese in Indonesia (Honolulu 1976) 10Google Scholar.
87 Suryadinta, Leo, Pnbumi Indonesians, the Chinese Minority and China: A Study of Perceptions and Policies (Singapore 1986) 3Google Scholar.
88 Blumberger, J.Th. Petrus, De Indo-Europeesche Beweging in Nederlandsche-lndie (Haarlem 1939) 7Google Scholar.
89 van der Veur, Paul W., ‘The Eurasians of Indonesia: Castaways of Colonialism’, Pacific Affairs 27 (1954) 133CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
90 van der Veur, Paul W., ‘Eurasian Dilemma in Indonesia’, Journal of Asian Studies 20 (1960) 58–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
91 Ibid., 53.
92 Ngelow, , KekristenanGoogle Scholar; Tan, Tiat Han, The Attitude of Dutch Protestant Missions Toward Indonesian Nationalism, 1945-49 (PhD thesis Princeton 1967)Google Scholar; Verdoorn, J. A., De tending en net Indonesisch nationalisme (Amsterdam 1945)Google Scholar.
93 Mehden, , Religion and Nationalism, 170Google Scholar.
94 For a similar assessment of Malaysia see Milner, , The Invention of Politics in Colonial Malaya, 83Google Scholar.
95 Klinken, Geert Arend van, Migrant Moralities: Christians and Nationalist Politics in Emerging Indonesia: A Biographical Approach (PhD thesis Griffith University, Brisbane 1996) 371Google Scholar; Bank, Jan, Katholieken en de Indonesische Revolutie (Baam 1983)Google Scholar.
96 Mehden, , Religion and Nationalism, 182Google Scholar.
97 Randwijck, , Handelen en Denken, 341–342Google Scholar; See also Verdoorn, , lending, 11Google Scholar.
98 Randwijck, , Handelen en Denken, 341Google Scholar.
99 Bank, , Katholieken, 50Google Scholar.
100 Simatupang, Tahi Bonar, ‘Partisipasi Kristen Dalam Revolusi Dibidang Politik’ in: Sidjabat, W.B. ed., Partisipasi Kristen Dalam Nation Building di Indonesia (Jakarta 1968) 7–35Google Scholar.
101 See Gellner, Ernest, Nations and Nationalism (Ithaca 1983) 33–34Google Scholar.
102 Cote, this volume.
103 Anderson, Benedict R.O'G., Imagined Communities (London 1991)Google Scholar; Kahin, George McTuman, Nationalism and Revolution in Indonesia (Ithaca 1952)Google Scholar.
104 Leeuwen, Arend Theodoor van, Christianity in World History: The Meeting of Faiths East and West (New York 1964)Google Scholar.
105 Miller, Elmer, ‘The Christian Missionary, Agent of Secularization’, Anthropological Quarterly 43 (1970) 14–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
106 Mary Huber's ethnography of a Catholic mission in New Guinea also deals with this. Huber, Mary Taylor, ‘Constituting the Church: Catholic Missionaries on the Sepik Frontier’, American Ethnologist 14 (1987) 107–125CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
107 Comaroff, Jean and Comaroff, John, Of Revelation and Revolution 1 (Chicago 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
108 Muga, Erasto, African Responses to Western Christian Religion: A Sociological Analysis of African Separatist Religions and Political Movements in East Africa (Nairobi 1975) 128Google Scholar.
109 Kraemer, Hendrik, ‘Het Rassen Probleem en de Zending’, De Opuiekker 73 (1928) 273Google Scholar.
110 Leimena, Johannes, ‘De Ontmoeting der Rassen in de Kerk’, De Opwekker (1941) 630–631Google Scholar.
111 Stoler, , ‘Rethinking Colonial Categories’, 137Google Scholar.
112 Christophers, Brett, Positioning the Missionary: John Booth Good and the Colonial Confluence of Cultures (Vancouver 1998) 42Google Scholar.
113 Pels, Peter, ‘The Anthropology of Colonialism: Culture, History, and the Emergence of Western Governmentality’, Annual Review of Anthropology 26 (1997) 172CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
114 Castelli, Elizabeth A., Imitating Paul: A Discourse of Power (Louisville 1991)Google Scholar.
115 Thomas, Nicolas, Colonialism's Culture: Anthropology, Travel and Government (Princeton 1994) 142Google Scholar.
116 Castles, Lance, The Political Life of a Sumatran Residency: Tapanuli 1915-1940 (PhD thesis Yale 1972)Google Scholar; Kipp, Rita Smith, The Early Years of a Dutch Colonial Mission: The Karo Field (Ann Arbor 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
117 For example, when four Batak leaders wrote the Governor General in 1917 protesting plantation leases to Europeans, and when workers clearing the land for the plantation expansion had to be put under armed guard to prevent attacks from local people, the government suspected the missionaries of helping to incite the protest; Castles, Political Life of a Sumatran, 120.
118 Kipp, , Dissociated Identities, 50–55Google Scholar.
119 Castles, , Political Life of a Sumatran, 70Google Scholar.
120 Neumann, J.H., ‘De Perhoedamdam in Deli’, Mededelingen NZG 62 (1918) 185–189Google Scholar.
121 Hirosue, Masashi, ‘The Batak Millenarian Response to the Colonial Order’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 25 (1994) 331–343CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
122 Castles, , Political Life of a Sumatran, 90Google Scholar.
123 Ibid., 170.
124 Pedersen, Paul B., Batak Blood and Protestant Soul: The Development of National Batak Churches in North Sumatra (Grand Rapids 1970) 150Google Scholar.
125 Castles, , Political Life of a Sumatran, 152–153Google Scholar.
126 Hutauruk, J.R., Kemandirian Gereja: Penelitian Historis-Sistematis tentang Gerakan Kemandirian Gereja de Sumatera Utara dalam Kancah Pergolakan Kolonialisme dan Gerakan Kebangsaan de Indonesia, 1899-1942 (Jakarta 1993)Google Scholar; Pedersen, , Batak Blood, 151Google Scholar.
127 Kraemer, Hendrik, Van Godsdiensten en Menschen: Reisindntkken van een Tambaramganger (Nijkerk 1940) 127Google Scholar; Pedersen, , Batak Blood, 101Google Scholar.
128 This figure is from Castles, Political Life of a Sumatran. The Mission Statistics of the Zendingsconsulaat, published in De Opwekker 1938, putthe number at 58.
129 Castles, , Political Life of a Sumatran, 138–139Google Scholar.
130 Meerwaldt, J.H., ‘Muloschool in Tapanoeli’, De Banier 18, 6 (1926) 42–44Google Scholar.
131 Mulia, Gunung, ‘Muloschool in Tapanoeli’, De Banier 18, 11 (1926) 84–85Google Scholar.
132 Kraemer, Hendrik, From Mission Field to Independent Church: Report on a Decisive Decade in the Growth of Independent Churches in Indonesia (London 1958)Google Scholar.
133 Joustra, M., ‘Verslag van de Zending onder de Karo-Bataks over 1899’, Mededelingen NZG 43 (1901) 1–16Google Scholar.
134 Neumann, J.H., ‘Goeroe Djamaaf’, Mededelingen NZG 66 (1922) 131Google Scholar.
135 Ibid., 136.
136 Author's interview with Pdt. Julianos Berahmana, Kabanjahe, 26 July 1983.
137 Rae, Simon, Breath Becomes the Wind: Old and New in Karo Religion (Dunedin, New Zealand 1994) 104Google Scholar.
138 Reid, Anthony, The Blood of the People: Revolution and the End of Traditional Rule in Northern Sumatra (Kuala Lumpur 1979) 57Google Scholar.
139 Cooley, Frank, Benih Yang Tumbuh IV. Suatu Survey Mengenai Gereja Batak Karo Protestan (Jakarta 1976)Google Scholar.
140 Rae, , Breath Becomes, 116–117Google Scholar.
141 Kipp, Rita Smith, ‘Conversion by Affiliation: The History of the Karo Batak Protestant Church’, American Ethnologist 22 (1995) 1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
142 Henley, , Nationalism and Regionalism, 41Google Scholar.
143 Probowinoto, B., cited in Ngelow, Kekristenan, 184Google Scholar.
144 Ibid., 137.