Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nr4z6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-13T00:50:31.525Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Education, British Colonialism, and a Plural Society in West Malaysia: The Development of Education in the British Settlements along the Straits of Malacca, 1786–1874

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Peter Wicks
Peter Wicks*
Affiliation:
Academic Services at Darling Downs Institute of Advanced Education, Toowoomba, Australia
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the modern history of West Malaysia, people from four of the world's major cultural traditions—Malay, Chinese, Indian, and British—have met, settled, clashed and sought to co-exist. Although the British who came as colonizers have now gone, the complex relationship between the formal educational system of the colonial era and the divisive pluralism of contemporary West Malaysian society continues to attract considerable academic and political attention. Recently published monographic studies on aspects of West Malaysian educational history have focused on the period following British “Intervention” in the Peninsular Malay States of Perak and Selangor in 1874, and one of these studies explicitly attributes the “seeds of separatism” in contemporary West Malaysian society to the educational policies implemented under British colonial auspices during the period between 1874 and 1940. Since this article is concerned with an earlier period than the recent monographic studies, it cannot be employed to test or disprove the arguments of these works. The article does, however, examine the origins of West Malaysia's cultural pluralism in the century prior to 1874 and portrays this pluralism as the consequence of a multiplicity of circumstances, not merely British educational policies.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 20 , Issue 2 , Summer 1980 , pp. 163 - 187
Copyright
Copyright © 1980 by History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 The relationship is discussed from varying scholarly perspectives in the following recent works:- Chan, Chai Hon, Planning Education for a Plural Society. (Paris, 1971); Koh, E.K., “Education for Unity in Malaya—Problems and Prospects,” Unpublished paper presented at the Comparative Education Centre, University of Maryland, April, 1970; Chang, Paul M.P., Educational Development in a Plural Society: A Malaysian Case Study (Singapore, 1973); Seng, Philip Loh Fook, Seeds of Separatism: Educational Policy in Malaya, 1874–1940 (Lumpur, Kuala, 1975); Stevenson, Rex, Cultivators and Administrators; British Educational Policy towards the Malays, 1875–1906 ( Lumpur, Kuala, 1975); and Kee, Francis Wong Hoy, “Education, Society, and Development in Malaysia,” Asian Profile, 5, and 6 (December, 1977): 565–578. For more polemical viewpoints, see bin Mohamad, Mahathir, The Malay Dilemma (Singapore, 1970); and the Revised Report of the Royal Commission on the Teaching Services, West Malaysia (Lumpur, Kuala, 1971), Paras. 6.1 and 6.2, p. 24.Google Scholar

2 Loh, , Seeds of Separatism, p. 1.Google Scholar

3 Mary Turnbull, C., The Straits Settlements, 1826–1867: Indian Presidency to Crown Colony (London, 1972), p. 1.Google Scholar

4 Cameron, John, Our Tropical Possessions in Malayan India. (London, 1883). (reprinted, Lumpur, Kuala, 1967), p. 2.Google Scholar

5 Hahn, Emily, Raffles of Singapore (Lumpur, Kuala, 1968), p. 74.Google Scholar

6 Quoted in Maxwell, Sir William. “The Malay Peninsula: Its Resources and Prospects,” Proceedings of the Royal Colonial Institute, 23 (1891): 6.Google Scholar

7 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 14.Google Scholar

8 Cameron, , Our Tropical Possessions, p. 51.Google Scholar

9 Figures from Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, pp. 8, 23; and Mills, Lennox A. British Malaya, 1824–1867 (Kuala Lumpur, 1966), pp. 217–218.Google Scholar

10 Mills, , British Malaya, pp. 217–218.Google Scholar

11 For an excellent analysis of Malay responses to the urban atmosphere of Singapore during the nineteenth century, see Roff, William R., The Origins of Malay Nationalism (New Haven, 1967), Chapter 2.Google Scholar

12 Vaughan, J.D. The Manners and Customs of the Chinese of the Straits Settlements (Singapore, 1879). (reprinted, Kuala Lumpur, 1971), p. 1.Google Scholar

13 Wong, Ruth H.K. “Education and the Problems of Nationhood”, in Gungwu, Wang, (ed.), Malaysia: A Survey (New York, 1965), p. 199.Google Scholar

14 Early educational development in the Straits Settlements did, of course, run parallel to that of most other major commercial centres in Southern Asia during the nineteenth century, where groups of philanthropic Westerners, in difficult economic and social circumstances, sought to foster formal schooling amongst the local inhabitants.Google Scholar

15 Kee, Francis Wong Hoy and Gwee, Y.H., Perspectives: the Development of Education in Malaysia and Singapore (Kuala Lumpur, 1972), p. 6.Google Scholar

16 Quoted in Loh, , Seeds of Separatism, p. 2.Google Scholar

17 Straits Settlements; Original Correspondence with the Colonial Office, File 273, Vol. 25, No. 303. Mackay, James to Colonial Office, 20th February, 1868, p. 1 (henceforth cited as CO273).Google Scholar

18 Ibid. Google Scholar

19 Ibid. Google Scholar

20 Quoted in Wong, and Gwee, , Perspectives, p. 11. “Free” in this context meant “open to all races and classes”, not education without financial cost to parents.Google Scholar

21 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 223.Google Scholar

22 Kam, John, “Penang Perspective: Those good old days—in a great school,” New Straits Times (Malaysia) (10th October, 1977).Google Scholar

23 Mackay to Colonial Office, p. 2.Google Scholar

24 Ibid. Google Scholar

25 Turnbull, , The Staits Settlements, p. 223.Google Scholar

26 Mackay to Colonial Office, p.2.Google Scholar

27 Ibid. Google Scholar

28 Malcolm, Howard, Travels in South-Eastern Asia, embracing Hindustan, Malaya, Siam, and China. (2nd ed.) Vol. 2 (Boston, 1839), p. 94.Google Scholar

29 For a comprehensive discussion of the London Missionary Society and its activities in China and Malacca, see Harrison, Brian, “The Anglo-Chinese College at Malacca,” in Cowan, C.D. and Wolters, O.W. (eds.). Southeast Asian History and Historiography (Ithaca, N.Y., 1976), pp. 246–261.Google Scholar

30 Abdullah bin Abdul Kadir (trans. Hill, A. H.), The Hikayat Abdullah (Kuala Lumpur, 1970), p. 103.Google Scholar

31 Harrison, , “The Anglo-Chinese College:” 250.Google Scholar

32 Quoted in Ibid. Google Scholar

33 Newbold, Thomas J., Political and Statistical Account of the British Settlements in the Straits of Malacca, Vol. I (London, 1839) (reprinted, Kuala Lumpur, 1971), p.182.Google Scholar

34 Ibid., p. 183; also Begbie, Peter J., The Malayan Peninsula (Madras, 1834) (reprinted, Kuala Lumpur, 1967), p. 368.Google Scholar

35 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 103.Google Scholar

36 Ibid., p. 126.Google Scholar

37 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 184.Google Scholar

38 Begbie, , The Malayan Peninsula, p. 369.Google Scholar

39 Malcolm, , Travels in South-Eastern Asia, p. 98.Google Scholar

40 Begbie, , The Malayan Peninsual, p. 369.Google Scholar

41 Ibid. Google Scholar

42 Malcolm, , Travels in South-Eastern Asia, p. 98.Google Scholar

43 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 126.Google Scholar

44 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 184.Google Scholar

45 Harrison, , “The Anglo-Chinese College:” 254.Google Scholar

46 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 126.Google Scholar

47 Malcolm, , Travels in South-Eastern Asia, p. 96.Google Scholar

48 Bird, Isabella, The Golden Chersonese and the Way Thither (London, 1883) (reprinted, Kuala Lumpur, 1967), p. 20.Google Scholar

49 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 93.Google Scholar

50 Malcolm, , Travels in South-Eastern Asia, p. 109.Google Scholar

51 Quoted in Loh, , Seeds of Separatism, p. 125.Google Scholar

52 Quoted in ibid. Google Scholar

53 Roff, William R. (ed.), The Wandering Thoughts of a Dying Man: The Life and Times of Haji Abdul Majid bin Zainuddin (Kuala Lumpur, 1978), p. 22.Google Scholar

54 Quoted in Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 223.Google Scholar

55 Hough, G. G., “Notes on the Educational Policy of Sir Stamford Raffles,” Malaysian Branch Royal Asiatic Society Reprint No. 1. (Singapore, 1973), p. 174. In fact Morrison, and Raffles, had extensive discussions prior to the setting-up of the Singapore Institution. It was even contemplated that the Anglo-Chinese College at Malacca might eventually amalgamate with the Singapore Institution, but this merger never eventuated.Google Scholar

56 Quoted in ibid. Google Scholar

57 Ibid., p. 175 ff.Google Scholar

58 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 180.Google Scholar

59 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 181.Google Scholar

60 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, pp. 180–181; and Mary Turnbull, C., A History of Singapore, 1819–1975 (Kuala Lumpur, 1977), p. 26.Google Scholar

61 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 225.Google Scholar

62 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 289.Google Scholar

63 Hough, , “Notes:” 178.Google Scholar

64 Crawfurd's views are presented at greater length in Wijeysingha, E., A History of Raffles Institution, 1823#1963 (Singapore, 1963), Chapter 2.Google Scholar

65 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 225.Google Scholar

66 Ibid.; also see CO273, Vol. 51, No. 308. Colonel A.E.H. Anson to the Earl of Kimberley, 21st November, 1871.Google Scholar

67 Turnbull, , A History of Singapore, p. 61.Google Scholar

68 Malcolm, , Travels in South-Eastern Asia, p. 93.Google Scholar

69 Winstedt, Richard Sir, Start from Alif: Count from One (Kuala Lumpur, 1969), p. 66.Google Scholar

70 Abdullah, , The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 53.Google Scholar

71 Winstedt, , Start from Alif, p. 66.Google Scholar

72 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, pp. 87–90, 171–172; Begbie, The Malayan Peninsula, p. 369; Cameron, , Our Tropical Possessions, p. 135 Abdullah gives a horrendous glimpse at the punishments meted out in the Koranic schools in The Hikayat Abdullah, p. 40.Google Scholar

73 Vaughan, , The Manners and Customs of the Chinese, p. 89.Google Scholar

74 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 172.Google Scholar

75 Ibid., pp. 174–176.Google Scholar

76 Arasaratnam, Sinappah, Indians in Malaysia and Singapore (Kuala Lumpur, 1970), p. 178.Google Scholar

77 Newbold, , Political and Statistical Account, p. 180.Google Scholar

78 Turnbull, , A History of Singapore, p. 62.Google Scholar

79 Ibid., p. 63.Google Scholar

80 Turnbull, , The Straits Settlements, p. 232.Google Scholar

81 Thut, I. N. and Adams, Don, Educational Patterns in Contemporary Societies (New York, 1964), p. 397.Google Scholar

82 Seng, Philip Loh Fook, The Malay States, 1877–1896 (Kuala Lumpur, 1969), p. 160.Google Scholar

83 Ibid., p. 161.Google Scholar

84 Sweeney, Amin and Phillips, Nigel (ed.), The Voyages of Mohamed Ibrahim Munshi (Kuala Lumpur, 1975), p. 29.Google Scholar

85 Mackay to Colonial Office, pp. 1–3.Google Scholar

86 CO 273, Vol. 25, No. 309. Internal Minute to Rogers, F. Sir, 9th April, 1968.Google Scholar

87 Mackay to Colonial Office, No. 304, p. 3.Google Scholar

88 Ibid. Google Scholar

89 CO 273, Vol. 51, Nos. 301, 308. Anson, Colonel to Kimberley, Lord, 21st November, 1871.Google Scholar

90 Mackay to Colonial Office, p. 4.Google Scholar

91 There was more than simple ethnocentricity in Mackay's views on the virtues of the English language. His remarks also reflected a fundamental tenet of Victorian educational theory, namely that the learning of another language would promote mental discipline and capacity for logical thought.Google Scholar

92 CO 273, Vol. 62, No. 247. Dr. Little as recorded in the Minutes of the Straits Legislative Council, Singapore, 15th October, 1872, p. 165.Google Scholar

93 CO 273, Vol. 25, No. 313. Minute 161 from Colonial Office to Ord, H. Sir, 14th August, 1868; also Anson, to Kimberley, .Google Scholar

94 Anson, to Kimberley, , No. 304, Paras. 7–8.Google Scholar

95 Ibid. Google Scholar

96 CO 273, Vol. 64, No. 247. Meade to Secretary, 21st January, 1872.Google Scholar

97 A small Malay teachers' training college was opened in Taipang, Perak, in 1898, and closed two years' later. A larger training establishment opened in Malacca with 24 Malay students in December, 1900.Google Scholar

98 CO 273, Vol. 64, No. 243. Ord, to Kimbeley, , 17th January, 1873.Google Scholar

99 Ibid. Google Scholar

100 Minutes of Straits Legislative Council, p. 164.Google Scholar

101 Ord, to Kimberley, .Google Scholar

102 CO273, Vol. 62, No. 250, Kimberley, to Ord, , 18th February, 1873.Google Scholar

103 Minutes of Straits Legislative Council, p. 166.Google Scholar