Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

A Tale of Two Liberalisms? Attitudes toward Minority Religious Symbols in Quebec and Canada

  • Luc Turgeon (a1), Antoine Bilodeau (a2), Stephen E. White (a3) and Ailsa Henderson (a4)

Abstract

Proponents of restrictions on the wearing of religious symbols in public institutions in Quebec have often framed their support in the language of liberalism, with references to “gender equality”, “state neutrality” and “freedom of conscience”. However, efforts to account for support for restrictions on minority religious symbols rarely mention liberalism. In this article, we test the hypothesis that holding liberal values might have different attitudinal consequences in Quebec and the rest of Canada. Our findings demonstrate that holding liberal values is associated with support for restrictions on the wearing of minority religious symbols in Quebec, but it is associated with opposition to such restrictions in the rest of Canada. Moreover, this difference between Quebec and the rest of Canada in the relationship between liberal values and support for restrictions on minority religious symbols can explain Quebecers' greater support for restrictions.

Les partisans de restrictions au port de symboles religieux dans les institutions publiques du Québec ont souvent formulé leur appui dans le langage du libéralisme, par des références à « l’égalité des sexes », « la neutralité de l’État » et « la liberté de conscience ». Toutefois, les recherches visant à expliquer les motivations des partisans de ces restrictions examinent rarement le rôle du libéralisme. Dans cet article, nous vérifions l’hypothèse selon laquelle l’adhésion aux valeurs libérales pourrait avoir des conséquences comportementales différentes au Québec et dans le reste du Canada. Nos résultats démontrent que le fait d’exprimer des valeurs libérales est associé à un plus fort appui aux restrictions au port de symboles religieux minoritaires au Québec, mais à une plus forte opposition à de telles restrictions dans le reste du Canada. De plus, cette différence entre le Québec et le reste du Canada dans la relation entre les valeurs libérales et l’appui aux restrictions sur les symboles religieux minoritaires peut expliquer pourquoi les Québécois appuient davantage de telles restrictions.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. E-mail: lturgeon@uottawa.ca

Footnotes

Hide All

We would like to thank Benjamin Ferland for his very thoughtful comments and suggestions on an earlier draft of this article, as well as the journal's anonymous reviewers. We want to acknowledge the financial support of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. The survey used in this study was made possible thanks to the financial support of the following organizations: the Secrétariat aux affaires intergouvernementales canadiennes of the Quebec government; the Institute for Research on Public Policy; the Canadian Network for Research on Terrorism, Security and Society; the Chaire de recherche du Canada en études québécoises et canadiennes de l'Université du Québec à Montréal; and Concordia University. The authors remain solely responsible for the interpretation of the data.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Angus Reid Global. 2013. “Quebecers, Canadians Split on Proposed Charter of Values.” http://angusreid.org/quebecers-canadians-split-on-proposed-charter-of-values/ (December 16, 2018)
Bakali, Naved. 2015. “Contextualising the Quebec Charter of Values: How the Muslim ‘Other’ Is Conceptualised in Quebec.” Culture and Religion 16 (4): 412–29.
Baubérot, Jean. 2009. “L’évolution de la laïcité en France : entre deux religions civiles.” Diversité urbaine 9 (1): 925.
Berry, J. W. and Kalin, Rudolf. 1995. “Multicultural and Ethnic Attitudes in Canada: An Overview of the 1991 Survey.” Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science 27 (3): 301–20.
Betz, Hantz-Georg and Meret, Susi. 2009. “Revisiting Lepanto: The Political Mobilization Against Islam in Contemporary Western Europe.” Patterns of Prejudice 43 (3/4): 313–34.
Bilodeau, Antoine, Turgeon, Luc and Karakoç, Ekrem. 2012. “Small Worlds of Diversity: Views toward Immigration and Racial Minorities in Canadian Provinces.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 45 (3): 579605.
Bilodeau, Antoine, Turgeon, Luc, White, Stephen and Henderson, Ailsa. 2018. “Strange Bedfellows? Attitudes toward Majority and Minority Religious Symbols in the Public Sphere.” Politics and Religion 11 (2): 309–33.
Billiet, Jaak, Maddens, Bart and Berteen, Roeland. 2003. “National Identity and Attitude toward Foreigners in a Multinational State: A Replication.” Political Psychology 24 (2): 241–57.
Blumer, Herbert. 1958. “Race Prejudice as a Sense of Group Position.” Pacific Sociological Review 1 (1): 37.
Bowen, John R. 2006. Why the French Don't Like the Headscarves: Islam, the State, and the Public Space. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Burchardt, Marian. 2016. “Recalling Modernity: How Nationalist Memories Shape Religious Diversity in Quebec and Catalonia.” Nations and Nationalism 23 (3): 599619.
Canadian Institute of Public Opinion (CIPO). 1990. Gallup Poll, April 1990, #004_1 [Canada]. [public-use microdata file]. Toronto: Gallup Canada.
Cardinal, François. 2017 “Sale multiculturaliste!” La Presse, February 19. http://www.lapresse.ca/debats/editoriaux/francois-cardinal/201702/18/01-5071010-sale-multiculturaliste-.php (May 16, 2018).
Carmines, Edward G. and D'Amico, Nicholas J.. 2015. “The New Look in Political Ideology Research.” Annual Review of Political Science 18: 205–16.
Ceobanu, Alin M. and Escandell, Xavier. 2008. “East Is West? National Feelings and Anti-Immigrant Sentiment in Europe.” Social Science Research 37 (4): 1147–70.
Citrin, Jack, Johnston, Richard and Wright, Matthew. 2012. “Do Patriotism and Multiculturalism Collide? Competing Perspectives from Canada and the United States.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 45 (3): 531–52.
Clements, Ben. 2013. “Explaining Public Attitudes towards the Integration of Muslims in British Society: The ‘Solidarity of the Religious’?Journal of Contemporary Religion 28 (1): 4965.
Commission de réflexion sur l'application du principe de lacïté dans la République. 2003. Rapport au Président de la République. http://www.ladocumentationfrancaise.fr/var/storage/rapports-publics/034000725.pdf (May 16, 2018).
Dufresne, Yannick, Kilibarda, Anja, Blais, André and Bibeau, Alexis. 2018. “Religiosity or Racism? The Bases of Opposition to Religious Accommodation in Quebec.” Nations and Nationalism. https://doi.org/10.1111/nana.12429.
Eagle, David E. 2011. “Changing Patterns of Attendance at Religious Services in Canada, 1986–2008.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 50 (1): 187200.
Ferland, Benjamin. 2018. “L'impact des minorités visibles sur l'appui à la Charte des valeurs et l'interdiction des symboles religieux.” Revue canadienne de science politique 51 (1): 2359.
Galston, William. 1995. “Two Concepts of Liberalism.” Ethics 105 (3): 516–34.
Gionnavetti, Justin. 2013. “Five Key Consequences of Quebec's Planned Charter of Values.” The Globe and Mail, September 13. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/five-key-consequences-of-quebecs-planned-charter-of-values/article14239113/ (December 16, 2018).
Gray, John. 2000. Two Faces of Liberalism. London: Polity.
Gustavsson, Gina, van der Noll, Jolanda and Sundberg, Ralph. 2016. “Opposing the Veil in the Name of Liberalism: Popular Attitudes to Liberalism and Muslim Veiling in the Netherlands.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 39 (10): 1719–37.
Helbling, Marc. 2014. “Opposing Muslims and the Muslim Headscarf in Western Europe.” European Sociological Review 30 (2): 242–57.
Iacovino, Raffaele. 2015. “Contextualizing the Charter of Values: Belonging without Citizenship in Quebec.” Canadian Ethnic Studies 47 (1): 4160.
Inglehart, Ronald and Welzel, Christian. 2005. Modernization, Cultural Change, and Democracy: The Human Development Sequence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Joppke, Christian. 2009. Veil: Mirror of Identity. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Journet, Paul. 2013. “La laïcité française, une “inspiration” pour Marois.” La Presse, December 13. http://www.lapresse.ca/actualites/politique/politique-quebecoise/201312/13/01-4720644-la-laicite-francaise-une-inspiration-pour-marois.php (May 16, 2018).
Kinder, Donald D. and Sears, David O.. 1981. “Prejudice and Politics: Symbolic Racism versus Racial Threats to the Good Life.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 40 (3): 44–31.
Koussens, David and Amiraux, Valérie. 2014. “Du mauvais usage de la laïcité française dans le débat public québécois.” In Penser la laïcité québécoise: fondements et défense d'une laïcité ouverte au Québec, ed. Lévesque, Sébastien. Québec: Presses de l'Université Laval.
Labelle, Micheline. 2008. “Les intellectuels québécois face au multiculturalisme : hétérogénéité des approches et des projets politiques.” Canadian Ethnic Studies 40 (1): 3356.
Lamy, Guillaume. 2015. Laïcité et valeurs québécoises. Les sources d'une controverse. Montreal: Québec-Amérique.
Levine, Robert A. and Campbell, Donald T.. 1972. Ethnocentrism: Theories of Conflict, Ethnic Attitudes, and Group Behaviour. Oxford: John Wiley & Sons.
Mayer, Nonna. 2013. “From Jean-Marie to Marine Le Pen: Electoral Change on the Far Right.” Parliamentary Affairs 66 (1): 160–78.
Meunier, E.-Martin and Wilkins-Laflamme, Sarah. 2011. “Sécularisation, catholicisme et transformation du régime de religiosité au Québec. Étude comparative avec le catholicisme au Canada (1968–2007).” Recherches sociographiques 52 (3): 683729.
Modood, Tariq. 1994. “Establishment, Multiculturalism and British Citizenship.” Political Quarterly 65 (1): 5373.
O'Neill, Brenda, Gidengill, Elisabeth, Côté, Catherine and Young, Lisa. 2015. “Freedom of Religion, Women's Agency and Banning the Face Veil: The Role of Feminist Beliefs in Shaping Women's Opinion.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 38 (11): 18861901.
Saharso, Sawitri. 2013. “Conclusion: The Veil as a Case of Value Diversity and European Values.” In Politics, Religion and Gender: Framing and Regulating the Veil, ed. Rosenberger, Sieglinde and Sauer, Birgit. London: Routledge.
Saroglou, Vassilis, Lamkaddem, Bahija, Van Pachterbeke, Matthieu and Buxant, Coralie. 2009. “Host Society's Dislike of the Islamic Veil: The Role of Subtle Prejudice, Values, and Religion.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations 33 (5): 419–28.
Schwartz, Shalom H. 1994. “Are There Universal Aspects in the Structure and Content of Human Values?Journal of Social Issues 50 (4): 1945.
Siddiqui, Haroon. 2013. “Faulty Rationalizations for Quebec's Official Bigotry.” The Star (Toronto), September 18. https://www.thestar.com/opinion/columnists/2013/09/18/faulty_rationalizations_for_quebecs_official_bigotry_siddiqui.html (December 16, 2018).
Stasiulus, Daiva. 2013. “Worrier Nation: Quebec's Value of Codes for Immigrants.” Politikon 40 (1): 183209.
Taylor, Charles. 1994. “The Politics of Recognition.” In Multiculturalism : Examining the Politics of Recognition, ed. Amy Gutmann. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tessier, Charles and Montigny, Éric. 2016. “Untangling Myths and Facts: Who Supported the Quebec Charter of Values?French Politics 14 (2): 272–85.
Triadafilopoulos, Triadafilos. 2011. “Illiberal Means to Liberal Ends? Understanding Recent Immigrant Integrations Policies in Europe.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 37 (6): 861–80.
Van der Noll, Jolanda. 2010. “Public Support for a Ban on Headscarves: A Cross-National Perspective.” International Journal of Conflict and Violence 4 (2): 191204.
Van der Noll, Jolanda and Saroglou, Vassilis. 2015. “Anti-Islam or Anti-Religion? Understanding Objection against Islamic Education.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41: 219–38.
Van Schuur, Wijbrandt H. 2003. “Mokken Scale Analysis: Between the Guttman Scale and Parametric Item Response Theory.” Political Analysis 11 (2): 139–63.
Velasco González, Karina, Verkuyten, Maykel, Weesie, Jeroen and Poppe, Edwin. 2008. “Prejudice towards Muslims in the Netherlands: Testing Integrated Threat Theory.” British Journal of Social Psychology 47 (4): 667–85.
Weinstock, Daniel. 2007. “La crise des accommodements au Québec: hypothèses explicatives.” Éthique publique 9 (1): 2026.
Winter, Elke. 2011. Us, Them, and Others: Pluralism and National Identity in Diverse Societies. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Winter, Stephen. 2014. “Cultural Politics Pathology: The Charter of Québec Values.” Politics, Groups, and Identities 2 (4): 681–88.
Wright, Matthew, Johnston, Richard, Citrin, Jack and Soroka, Stuart. 2017. “Multiculturalism and Muslim Accommodation: Policy and Predisposition across Three Political Contexts.” Comparative Political Studies 50 (1): 102–32.

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed