Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The Politics of Nationalism and Status in Puerto Rico

  • André Lecours (a1) and Valérie Vézina (a2)

Abstract

Over the last several decades, nationalist movements in liberal democracies have challenged their community's relationship with the state. One such case that has drawn relatively little attention is Puerto Rico. A peculiar feature of Puerto Rican politics is that powerful nationalism coexists with several distinct status options: a reform of the current Commonwealth, statehood (becoming an American state), free association and independence. This article examines the various sources for Puerto Rican nationalism and discusses the relationship between nationalism and each of the status options. It also explains why none of the options has succeeded in gathering majority support amongst Puerto Ricans and why, therefore, the constitutional status quo has so far remained on the island.

Plusieurs démocraties occidentales ont eu à composer avec des mouvements nationalistes au cours des dernières décennies. Un cas de mouvement nationaliste qui a peu retenu l'attention est Porto Rico. Le nationalisme porto ricain a la particularité de venir avec plusieurs options quant au statut politique de l’île : une réforme du statut existant (Estado Libre Asociado, ELA), l'indépendance, devenir un état des États-Unis et un arrangement de souveraineté-association avec les États-Unis. Cet article examine les différentes sources du nationalisme porto ricain et sa relation avec chacune de ces options politiques. L'article explique pourquoi aucune de ces options n'a jusqu’à maintenant obtenu une majorité réelle d'appui et donc pourquoi le statu quo constitutionnel demeure.

Copyright

Corresponding author

School of Political Studies, University of Ottawa, 120 University, Ottawa ON, K1N 6N5, email: alecours@uottawa.ca
Department of Political Science, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's NL, A1B 3X9, email: valerie.vezina@mun.ca

References

Hide All
Anderson, Robert W. 1965. Party Politics in Puerto Rico. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press.
Baldacchino, Godfrey. 2006. “Islands, Island Studies, Island Studies Journal.” Island Studies Journal 1: 318.
Baldacchino, Godfrey. 2007. A World of Islands: An Island Studies Reader. Charlottetown PEI: Island Studies Press.
Barreto, Amílcar Antonio. 1998. Language, Elites, and the State: Nationalism in Puerto Rico and Quebec. Westport CT: Praeger.
Barreto, Amílcar Antonio. 2001. “Constructing Identities: Ethnic Boundaries and Elite Preferences in Puerto Rico.” Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 7: 2140.
Berríos Martínez, Rubén. 1977. “Independence for Puerto Rico: The Only Solution.” Foreign Affairs 55: 561–83.
Berríos Martínez, Rubén. 1997. “Puerto Rico's Decolonization.” Foreign Affairs 76:100–14.
Brass, Paul. 1991. Nationalism and Ethnicity: Theory and Comparison. London: Sage.
Bosque-Pérez, Ramón and Colón Morera, José Javier, eds. 2006. Puerto Rico under Colonial Rule: Political Persecution and the Quest for Human Rights. Albany NY: State University of New York.
Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2013. Economy at a Glance—Puerto Rico. http://www.bls.gov/eag/eag.pr.htm (May 3, 2016).
Carrión, Juan Manuel. 2006. “The War of the Flags: Conflicting National Loyalties in a Modern Colonial Situation.” Centro Journal 28: 101–23.
Carroll, Henry K. 1975 [1899]. Report on the Island of Porto Rico. New York: Arno Press.
Colino, César and Hombrado, Angustias. 2015. “Besieged and paralyzed? The Spanish State facing the secessionist challenge in Catalonia and coping with the Reform imperative.” In Jahrbuch des Föderalismus, ed. Tübingen, Forschung. Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlag, Europäisches Zentrum für Föderalismus.
Collazo, Sonia G., Ryan, Camille L. and Bauman, Kurt J.. 2010. Profile of the Puerto Rican Population in the United States and Puerto Rico: 2008. Census Bureau Report, Washington DC: US Census Bureau.
Comisión estatal de elecciones. 2017. “Plebiscito para la decolonizatión inmediata de Puerto Rico.” http://resultados2017.ceepur.org/Noche_del_Evento_78/index.html#es/default/CONSULTA_DESCOLONIZACION_Resumen.xml (June 16, 2017).
Conkling, Philip. 2007. “On Islanders and Islandness.” The Geographical Review 97: 191201.
Connor, Walker. 1984. “Eco- or Ethno-nationalism?Ethnic and Racial Studies 7: 342–59.
Cox Alomar, Rafael. 2015. “In search of a Puerto Rico strategy,” The Hill, November 5, 2015. http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/economy-budget/259165-in-search-of-a-puerto-rico-strategy (May 4, 2016).
Denis, Nelson A. 2015. War against All Puerto Ricans. Revolution and Terror in America's Colony. New York: Nation Books.
Duffy Burnett, Christina and Marshall, Burke. 2001. Foreign in a Domestic Sense: Puerto Rico, American Expansion, and the Constitution. Durham NC: Duke University Press.
Fazi, André. 2012. “Insularity and Autonomy: From a Misleading Equation to a New Typology.” In Political Autonomy and Divided Societies: Imagining Democratic Alternatives in Complex Settings, ed. Gagnon, Alain-G. and Keating, Michael. Houndmills UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Fernandez, Ronald. 1992. The Disenchanted Island. Puerto Rico and the United States in the Twentieth Century. New York: Praeger.
Guibernau, Montserrat and Hutchinson, John, eds. 2004. History and National Destiny. Ethnosymbolism and its Critics. Hoboken NJ: Wiley-Blackwell.
Hay, Peter. 2006. “A Phenomenology of Islands.” Island Studies Journal 1: 1942.
Hearing before the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources of the United States Senate. 2013. Washington: US Government Printing Office.
Hepburn, Eve. 2010. “A Comparative Analysis of Island Region Autonomy.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association, Montreal.
Hepburn, Eve. 2012. “Recrafting Sovereignty: Lessons from Small Island Autonomies?” In Political Autonomy and Divided Societies: Imagining Democratic Alternatives in Complex Settings, ed. Gagnon, Alain-G. and Keating, Michael. Basingstoke UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hernández Cólon, Rafael. 2013. “Misguided Policy on Puerto Rico.” The Hill, December 13.
Hutchinson, John. 1987. The Dynamics of Cultural Nationalism: Gaelic Revival and the Creation of the Irish Nation State. London: Allen & Unwin.
Keating, Michael. 2002. Nations against the State: The New Politics of Nationalism in Québec, Catalonia and Scotland. 2nd ed. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Keating, Michael. 2001. Plurinational Democracy: Stateless Nations in a Post-Sovereign Era. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lawson, Gary and Sloane, Robert D.. 2009. “The Constitutionality of Decolonization by Associated Statehood: Puerto Rico's Legal Status Reconsidered.” Boston College Law Review 4: 1123–93.
Lecours, André. 2000. “Ethnonationalism in the West: A Theoretical Exploration.” Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 6: 103–24.
Lewis, Gordon K. 1963. Puerto Rico: Freedom and power in the Caribbean. London: Merlin.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1960. Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics. New York: Doubleday.
Lluch, Jaime. 2011. “Autonomism and federalism.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 42: 134–61.
Lluch, Jaime. 2014. “Varieties of Territorial Pluralism: Prospects for the Political and Constitutional Accommodation of Puerto Rico within the USA.” In Constitutionalism and the Politics of Accommodation in Multinational Societies, ed. Lluch, Jaime. London: Palgrave MacMillan.
McCall, Grant. 1994. “Nissology: A Proposal for Consideration.” Journal of the Pacific Society 17: 93106.
Mooney, Gerry and Scott, Gill. 2015. “The 2014 Scottish independence debate: Questions of social welfare and social justice.” Journal of Poverty and Social Justice 23: 516.
Morris, Nancy. 1995. Puerto Rico: culture, politics and identity. Westport CT: Praeger.
Murillo, Mario. 2001. Islands of Resistance: Puerto Rico, Vieques and US Policy. New York: Seven Stories Press.
Passalacqua, Juan M. Garcia. 1994. “The 1993 Plebiscite in Puerto Rico: A First Step to Decolonization?Current History 93: 103–07.
Pantojas-García, Emilio. 2005. “The Puerto Rican Paradox: Colonialism Revisited.” Latin American Research Review 40: 163–76.
Pantojas-García, Emilio. 2013. “The Puerto Rico status question: can the stalemate be broken?Caribbean Journal of International Relations & Diplomacy 1: 4152.
Pantojas-García, Emilio. 2015. Crónicas Del Colapso: Economia, Politica Y Sociedad De Puerto Rico En El Siglo Veintiuno. Ediciones Callejon: San Juan.
Pérez, Marvette. 2002. “The Political ‘Flying Bus’: Nationalism, Identity, Status, Citizenship and Puerto Ricans.” Critique of Anthropology 22: 305–22.
“Puerto Rico: Greece in the Caribbean.” 2013. The Economist. October 26. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21588374-stuck-real-debt-crisis-its-back-yard-america-can-learn-europes-aegean (January 2, 2016).
Prensa Asociada. 2009. “¿Se discrimina al usar el inglés en algunos tribunales de Puerto Rico?Daily News, Latino (New York), February 24.
Ramos Méndez, Mario. 2007. Posesión del Ayer: La nacionalidad cultural en la estadidad. San Juan: Isla Negra Editores.
Ramos Méndez, Mario. 2016. Fuera del laberinto: La estadidad como igualdad y soberanía. San Juan: Publicaciones Gaviota.
Report of the President's Task Force on Puerto Rico's Status, Washington: the White House, 2011 https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/uploads/Puerto_Rico_Task_Force_Report.pdf (June 16, 2017).
Rivera-Batiz, Francisco and Santiago, Carlos. 1996. Island Paradox: Puerto Rico in the 1990s. New York: Russell Sage.
Rivera-Ramos, Efrén. 2013. “Puerto Rico. Autonomy or Colonial Subordination?” In Practising Self-Government. A Comparative Study of Autonomous Regions, ed. Ghai, Yash and Woodman, Sophia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Romero-Barceló, Carlos. 1978. Statehood is for the Poor. San Juan: Romero-Barcelo.
Safa, Helen. 2011. “The Transformation of Puerto Rico: The Impact of Modernization Ideology.” Transforming Ideology 19 (1): 4649.
Scarano, Francisco A. 2000. Puerto Rico: Cinco Siglos de Historia. 2nd ed. Mexico: McGraw-Hill.
US Census Bureau. 2011a. Household Income for States: 2009 and 2010. American Community Survey Briefs. Washington DC: US Census Bureau.
US Census Bureau. 2011b. Poverty: 2009 and 2010. American Community Survey Briefs. Washington DC: US Census Bureau.
US Congress. 2016. Congressional Task Force on Economic Growth in Puerto Rico. Report to the House and Senate.
US Department of Justice. 2016. Brief for the United States as Amicus Curiae Supporting Respondents. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico vs Luis M. Sánchez Valle.
Wells, Henry. 1969. The Modernization of Puerto Rico. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Wyden, Ron and Murkowski, Lisa. 2013. United States Senate, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, December 13.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed